The minimum-wage debate is more about politics
than economics
Not for those 3.3 million people, it's not.3.3 million is about 2% of the workforce of the US. The point I'm making, is that the economic cost of the price increase (which is the argument made against minimum wage increases) is far less than the tangible quality-of-life benefits to those 3.3 million workers.
I'm for raising the minimum wage BTW. Because the pros (better life for those workers) far outweigh the cons, especially from an economic standpoint.
Another issue I thought of is this. If min wage workers all suddenly have wage increases by law, then businesses like fast food chains might just replace many them with machines. I mean, you already know your McDonald's burger is disgusting, so probably wont mind if it gets pooped out of a dispenser like pudding. So, this policy may simply lead to layoffs.
Like McDonald's is currently piloting in France where you order your food from a touch-screen kiosk instead of a cashier.[1]
[1] http://www.cnet.com/news/mcdonalds-hires-7000-touch-screen-c...
The issue isn't that owners will fare worse, but that raising the min wage while it makes us feel good won't necessarily help lower income workers. Doubling the salary of an entry level position will only reduce the number of entry level positions. And as I'm sure your experience in fast food illustrated, there's some people who aren't even worth paying min wage. Except for a few management folks, it shouldn't be a long term job or career.
I used to love flying flight sims back in the Falcon 4.0 days, and I expected flight sims to progress as hardware advanced. Nowadays the flight sim market is DOA, despite my demand.
Sounds like you just worked for an asshole. Also sounds like you guys eventually adapted to the wage hikes (I'm assuming he's still in business?).
Of course no one's happy when things become more expensive. Here they just announced a new tax on gas (making it as expensive as before the price of oil went to shit), and a new tax on booze. Guess what - people still drive, and drink beer (hopefully not at same time).
Also, he had a lot of longer term employees who were making more than min wage, but still would benefit if it was raised. So it became more economical to let them go, despite the loss of their higher productivity.
Also, you can't just think in terms of the hourly rate. Increases in the hourly rate also affect worker's comp rates, Social Security contributions, etc. So an $8 increase would probably be at least a $10 cost increase to the owner.
Outside of that though, raising prices immediately hurts sales, but worse customer service due to the restaurant being chronically short-staffed takes longer to hurt sales. Being chronically short-staffed also makes for a worse working environment which leads to employee turnover, which is more costly in the long run, but when you're struggling to make rent this month, the long term costs may not be as apparent.
Finally, if it's a small restaurant where the owner also helps with the day-to-day operations of restaurant (maybe they're even the chef), it mean's they'll have to work even harder. The owner may just find it worth the cost to have an extra employee and be able to work just a little bit less.
So if you increase his labor costs from 20% to 30%, you just wiped out his return. If you double it to 40% like a $15 increase would do, then he's got to either automate or cut to the bone.
And yes I realize I'm conflating figures from the 80s to today, but the percentages still hold.
I'd generally expect a restaurant to do twice as much in sales (or more) in a year compared to the initial cost, and be able to recuperate the initial investment in 5-10 years (one of the more recent restaurateurs I worked for paid back his investors in 3 years, and has a second location 5 years in).
But even using his sub-par numbers, $750K a year since the 80's means he's already recuperated his costs and made some serious profits since. What more does he expect? He could close them all tomorrow and be ahead. If anything, this anecdote does show just how greedy some people are.
Different countries handle the issue of high minimum wage differently. Some countries have very thorough enforcement and drive the cost of everything through the roof, but end up with a more egalitarian society (I think Norway, where a beer costs as much as a large meal in neighbouring countries, counts). Singapore chooses not to have a minimum wage and to make it easy to import manual labour legally, and affords these labourers the same legal protection afforded any other resident. China uses the hukou system [2] to regulate the influx of unskilled labourers into more prosperous regions.
The US simply turns a blind eye to the rule of law when it comes to unqualified labour, which allows businesses to keep their costs low, and politicians to save face and pretend they did something "for the workers", whilst a side effect is increasing the stress on the legal unskilled residents which might even be a positive for politicians as they love a good crisis.
Conclusion: legal unskilled workers should fight for the law to be enforced, not for minimum wage to be legally increased. It would both remove competition and drive up demand for their unskilled work, and since there is no population explosion in the United States and legal immigration is incredibly regulated, should result in a natural rise of wages matching the higher cost of living in locations like Seattle.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_immigrant_population_of...
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hukou_system
[3] http://poverty.ucdavis.edu/faq/what-are-characteristics-mini...
I do enjoy travelling down there to Montana - ski tickets are cheaper, gas is cheaper, and good beer is much, much cheaper (I seriously love the micro-brew scene in the US. Canada has a good micro-brewing scene too, but not to the same degree).
I'd guess the much smaller market (35m inhabitants vs 320m - Australia has 22m), the weather, the distance from production centres and major ports, and so on would impact prices as well.
As for beer it might be taxes, which Wikipedia says are amongst the highest in the world.
It was a little tongue-in-cheek, however I still am surprised that there are so many illegal immigrants in the US...
No, I'm more surprised that the US is so bad at dealing with illegal immigration. Do they tacitly accept it?
I thought the (excellent) movie "Act of Valor" pointed out the other way this issue could be resolved. In the movie, terrorists use the people smuggling networks to allow suicide bombers into the US, targeting a few stadiums in Southern cities. This is not the first time enemies of the US try to smuggle people in illegally - the Soviets and the Cubans especially sent many agents that way, as well as infiltrating US criminal organisations (see for example Oleg Kalugin's biography [1] which explores the links between the Soviets and the Italian mafia).
In the real world, no criminal organisation would be mad enough to let that happen (much as gangs in Mexico try to avoid killing gringos) because it would mean a promotion from "criminal organisation" to "effective terrorist organisation" and we saw after 9/11 how the American public reacts to that. So long as you're "just" smuggling drugs and people, it's "just" the DEA and ATF and the odd border agent.
If they did facilitate terrorist attacks, you can bet there'd be an enormous appropriation and militarization of the border, coupled with a systematic destruction of virtually all smuggling networks on Mexican soil and maybe temporary occupation of the territory south of the border. Panama was invaded for less.
But this is not going to happen just because a few people go on strike, especially when the majority of manual labour (11m vs 3m) appears to be illegal already without much outcry from the public which tacitly understands that this is key to cheap food and service.
[1] http://www.amazon.com/First-Directorate-Intelligence-Espiona...
Some industry players benefit from having low-skilled workers that are demotivated to complain to government of labor violations, etc., so there is some of that.
OTOH, a bigger issue is that, while most people would agree that illegal immigration, per se, is bad, there is no census on how to deal with the issue.
There are groups that oppose not only illegal immigration, but are strongly concerned with controlling the level of immigration (and often with managing its origin), so that they see the solution in enforcement measures (though even groups in this category often don't agree on which enforcement measures.)
Then there are groups that are less concerned with the level of immigration than with illegality itself, and so would favor new avenues of legal immigration, or increased quotas within existing avenues, etc.
And there are additional disagreements over approaches to dealing with the existing population that is present without proper immigration status beyond the different views on "going forward" policy.
Many will simply eat the cost, actually. The minimum-wage debate is more about politics than economics. There's not as many minimum wage workers as people think, so for very little economic cost, you can increase the quality of life for the lowest paid workers in our society.
A few businesses may be forced to change, but those are the ones that run razor-thin margins.
> What happens if you make $9 now, make $15 tomorrow, but tomorrow the prices of everything you buy suddenly doubled?"
Nothing will double in price. Given the amount of minimum wage workers that actually exist in the US, prices shouldn't increase by more than 5%. Anything more would just be opportunistic gouging.