I continue to be blown away by Hacker News' collective refusal to believe that NK is likely behind this hack. Do you all also doubt that they were behind the other hacks mentioned by the FBI (e.g. on South Korean banks and media outlets)? Is it 'incredibly dangerous' to accuse them of that as well?
I understand the post-Iraq mentality of demanding evidence before going to war with a country, but that's not what's going on here.
Also, given how mouthy North Korea is, nobody finds it telling that other than a single denial on December 7th, they've been quiet? That denial, by the way, consisted of bullshit like saying that there were “a great number of supporters and sympathizers” with North Korea “all over the world,” including “champions of peace” who might initiate more “righteous reaction” against the United States’ “evildoings.”
Skepticism is healthy and encourages discussion. I am not observing a "collective refusal" as you put it, but instead a strong skepticism from the tech community (a community who has a good basis to interpret this story with).
"Do you all also doubt that they were behind the other hacks mentioned by the FBI (e.g. on South Korean banks and media outlets)? Is it 'incredibly dangerous' to accuse them of that as well?"
The discussion is around a specific cybersecurity attack, not North Korea's capabilities, so that's a bit of a straw man argument.
"I understand the post-Iraq mentality of demanding evidence before going to war with a country, but that's not what's going on here."
No rational person is making a case for war over this, but the fact that you mention going to war over this demonstrates why it is incredibly dangerous to make these assumptions about North Korea without looking at all the available evidence.
"Also, given how mouthy North Korea is, nobody finds it telling that other than a single denial on December 7th, they've been quiet?"
Quite the opposite. I think it would fit the profile if North Korea was being mouthy at this point in time. Their silence would suggest this is a delicate situation for them politically and they don't know how to respond to it.
Actually, we don't really have a good basis to interpret the story. The evidence that the US government has used to verify that NK was involved is most likely classified. The most straightforward way to verify the NK government's involvement is a high-level NK spy, or a communications tap on NK's political leadership. If it captured a high-level meeting regarding the "progress of the Sony hack," for example, then that would be pretty strong evidence of NK's involvement. Yet there's no way that any press release could include such info without also compromising their sources.
The point of the US government saying "NK is involved" is to say "We have verified NK is involved," not to give hard proof. Such proof may exist, but it may not be possible to divulge without also causing other consequences, as I mentioned above. It's not a trial, and they're under no obligation to present any of their core evidence or reasoning. It's up to us whether we choose to believe them or not.
The tech community sometimes overestimates how informed it is. For example, consider how someone would be viewed by the tech community if they claimed that governments were writing BIOS malware, and they made that claim before 2013.
So it seems mistaken to believe that the tech community is any better suited to interpret the story than any other community. Various intelligence communities or politics communities might even be better suited than we are at figuring out reasons why the story shouldn't be taken at face value, if any such reasons even exist.
Has there been a poll or are you just making that up?
Most of human beings are "belief oriented” which is the result of hundreds of thousands of years’ evolution. It’s the cause of most conflicts in the world. The widely supported Iraq war is an example. That’s why it is dangerous to do so.
In hacker news community, there are more “evidence oriented” post-modern people. This makes a difference.
Any discussion about Uber, or the evils of traditional capitalism (especially HFT) on here is full of distinctly belief driven people.
HFT is the easiest, it provides liquidity, helps to keep spreads narrow, flash crashes are nasty, but so rare there have been only 2 (and the cost of those was minimal, a few failed margin calls, oh noes).
Uber is tricky, because it's run by assholes, but that's not really different from the taxi (cab) industry in most cities. Plus they skirt the law, which was largely instituted to protect the interests of the incumbent taxi companies. It arguably helps to make the taxi market healthier, thanks to its increased efficiency, lower prices (larger supply), which leads to a bigger overall market, which likely leads to better relative wage for drivers. The potential negative externality happens when demand dries up, drivers are forced out of the market pretty fast, due to the more efficient pricing they must apply (or lose market share). And of course, Uber has competition Lyft (in the US) and Wundercar (in Europe) comes to mind.
And on traditional capitalism, the simple truth is that it's inescapable. People are locally rational, they have limited information, and oftentimes they have utility function that are non-optimal even locally, but they are rational nonetheless, and again, people are price sensitive. So capitalism is just the machine of progress that seeks more efficient allocation of capital. And even if you do away with property ownership (and try to opt for a temporary property possession model) you'll find that other types of capital still remain, they just get more perversely important (human capital, who knows who's who, influence, reputation, use of force, and so on).
And you can see that for these inferences you need evidence, but these are not single instance based cases like the Sony hack. It's much more sound and safe to trust and act upon these aggregates, than upon a single FBI "post" and the resulting drama.
On a related note, I discovered that many Americans have no ideas of the tremendous role of Russia in WWII, it has been completely erased from US collective memory the only thing that's left in popular US memory is USSR, communism is bad (and I'm pretty sure the details of why are blurry), and Russia can only be evil.
They are now painting other targets that way, like Iran, NK, and they used the same propaganda against Iraq. I guess they don't know (and acknowledge and take part of the responsibility for) the role of the US in creating the current situation in Korea.
There is a real lack of a measured and intellectual discourse in US public space (and by radiating influence, it's crushing it in the rest of the world).
Maybe you're looking in the wrong place.
Honestly, yours is truly a superficial, fake-sophisticate straw man, devoid of facts or information and pandering to the most simplistic anti-American tropes. I was happy to ignore it, but this caught my eye:
> I guess they don't know (and acknowledge and take part of the responsibility for) the role of the US in creating the current situation in Korea.
I'm curious what you mean by that.
Oh we have. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_during_the_occupation_of...
I quote: "Female deaths in connection with rapes in Germany are estimated to 240,000". Stalin himself had to ask them to be more gentle, what an irony from such a horrible person.
Besides, Russia was on the side of Hitler until Hitler betrayed it. It's not like they chose to be on the same side as US and democracy and freedom for the last year of WWII, it was the definition of "coincidence".
If remembering and describing a country's past is only remembering the worst without any nuance, why would anyone remember the U.S. for any positive thing? Or maybe the torture by the CIA or the 100000 deaths in Iraq doesn't erase the helping others in WWII and we have to live in a complex world where nothing is really black or white. just try to remember salient Facts, not rewrite history. And some countries could benefit from learning to say: "we're sorry", more than to say:"we're awesome" (that's valid for the 2 bullies of the other 200 countries).
On the NK situation, crossing the 38th parallel during the counter attack without having the means for a complete military victory and occupation just helped polarize everything. And now we can link the 2: invading Germany and Japan was possible because Russia agreed, invading NK was not possible because russia was against it. And this whole idea of "checking with Russia first" runs contrary to the Cold War mindset.
Anecdotal here - my mother's mother (an Austrian of Jewish descent) had to dress up as an old woman to avoid being raped in the Russian quarter of Vienna.
Russians were notorious for this, so my father (an Englishman) was welcomed with relatively open arms, as the English were known to them as gentlemen less likely to brutalise women.
...who are pandering to a crowd, and based upon essentially no information at all, but just the same sort of "I think" gut feeling notions that we see on HN. While there should always be questions about government honesty, it's rather incredible how far people will reach to find to clutch onto something that backs whatever their initial knee-jerk opinion was, seen throughout the comments here.
Quite a few comments are among the "they're making this up to go to war", which is simply incredible: Are people so far out of the loop on world players or current events? The US in no universe will launch a military action against a rogue, shells-pointed-at-Seoul, nuclear armed nation because they hacked Sony. That premise alone is simply absurd.
Is the US trying to isolate North Korea? They're already completely isolated. I mean...do people understand the situation North Korea is in, and the complete lack of tools to deal with this? The US gains literally nothing pointing the finger at North Korea.
They want to point at a country that will say "damn straight we did it" even if they didn't (North Korea is perfect!)
There have been attacks on the US government IT infrastructure. Stolen designs and files from military contractors. Attacks on energy and distribution systems. Attacks on the banking system.
On the grand hierarchy of attacks, this is really, really low. I mean, given the severity and regularity of attacks against things that really, really matter, no the US certainly didn't need this to justify anything. The concern is very real, and significantly more important than some Sony Entertainment emails or movie leaks.
I agree that it is absurd, but Washington seems to be talking up that premise.
Obama Vows a Response To Cyberattack on Sony
WASHINGTON — President Obama said on Friday that the United States “will respond proportionally” against North Korea for its destructive cyberattacks on Sony Pictures, but he criticized the Hollywood studio for giving in to intimidation when it withdrew “The Interview,” the satirical movie that provoked the attacks, before it opened.
Deliberately avoiding specific discussion of what kind of steps he was planning against the reclusive nuclear-armed state, Mr. Obama said that the response would come “in a place and time and manner that we choose.” Speaking at a White House news conference before leaving for Hawaii for a two-week vacation, he said American officials “have been working up a range of options” that he said have not yet been presented to him.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/20/world/fbi-accuses-north-ko...
One thing I would like to know, is if this whole thing was perpetrated by the North Korean state because of the potential offence to North Korea from showing their leader being killed, why has the scene of their leader being killed been leaked by the hackers and is now posted all over reddit? That really makes very little sense.
It also loses nothing, which might be the case if Russia or China were behind the attacks.
They're more of an annoyance than anything else. The strategy so far seems to have been to wait it out and hope their crazy cult-regime finally collapses. I don't see any reason anyone would want to expedite this unless they thought there was a clear and present danger of NK escalating in both belligerence and power in the near future. I can imagine the former, but not the latter.
The Korean War was in many ways similar to a "more power" version of Ukraine today.
I obviously don't know the story behind this. The point is, there are plenty of opportunistic and self-serving domestic interests who probably don't either but can nevertheless turn this hack into a very beneficial event, regardless of who did it. From their perspective, NK being the source is actually the best-case scenario.
Plus their prison camp system, internal mass famines, brutal authoritarian dictatorship.
It's much easier to address public fears with an easy scapegoat than to owe up to the overall frailty of network-driven industry. Could you imagine the cost of creating "the TSA of networks belonging to important private entities?"
What is the equilibrium in a world where state funded actors can anonymously attack major companies / infrastructure components? I am not convinced that is possible for a Sony to secure itself to such a level that it will not be vulnerable to attacks by state actors.
Sounds like a huge bounty for whoever gets the contract.
It matters little because the big issue here is that a group of cyber terrorists have effectively shut down a major corporation and most western countries are just standing by. if that is not green lighting future copy catting nothing I don't know what is.
The President should screen the film at the White House and allow it to be distributed to the armed forces
References?
What I remember is a well-argued article pointing to many parts of the hack that would seem to disqualify North Korea - for example the use of a (South) Korean language locale which North Koreans would in fact not normally be able or likely to use, broken English with little relation to how North Koreans would speak, etc.
Now, North Korean could be making a careful effort to impersonate Western hackers making a crude effort to impersonate North Koreans. But that's kind of reaching and there's a bit more than no evidence.
That article was a classic case of "assume the end result, and then make everything you've heard...including indirect, second-hand rumors, fit the mold you've set". You probably saw that "analysis" on here, and it was quite soundly destroyed as being largely ignorant.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8766411
But it went with them because it fits the case.
Further the whole "that bad English doesn't fit how I think bad English should look" is...well it's preposterous. The article also uses a ridiculous email exchange which could be anyone as proof -- again, fitting the mold.
There is literally nothing in that, beyond some person's subjective take on how a person might mangle English (this is one of those classic claims that assumes some grand conspiracy...but that the conspirators were too dumb to get the basic stuff right), that is based upon legitimate analysis.
Most posters on hackers news, it seems, rejected the idea that the Sony hack was done by North Korea or any easily determined actor.
The US government now has an official conspiracy, that the attack was the work of the government of North Korea. Just because that is conspiracy theory doesn't make it wrong but I and many people still doubt it.
You are replying to an attack on the common dubiousness of many hn posters to the North Korea theory. The attack seems to involve the idea that doubting the US government conspiracy theory has to be, itself, some other kind of more dubious conspiracy theory, when it is actually the belief that there's no evidence in that direction and plenty of evidence away from that direction.
literally nobody has said that, all that most people have said is that if you're going to accuse another nation of an act of "cyberwar" at least provide proof. Is that too much to ask?
Literally quite literally doesn't mean what you apparently think it means.
And the general conspiratorial narrative is that the US is trying to blame a blameless North Korea to achieve...something. Not sure what.
To assume the US Government's PR team won't use anything/everything to reinforce, reiterate or bolster it's own agenda is just idiocy. There are far too many examples throughout history where it has.
Whether or not that means that this investigation is a farce, is another question.
Its not like the US has to manufacturer an excuse to complain about them. There is an abundance of genuine North Korean antics to choose from if they want to.
The people who comment on HN about politics are hilariously confused.
The US gains quite a lot by pointing fingers at a bad guy. This bad guy happens to be North Korea. Anything just to keep the public distracted and the media happy to report something else but CIA torture.
Is that your gut feeling? :p I understand it's backed by strong arguments but so were (some) security professionals opinion. They might give updates after the FBI's communiqué and are aware of the limitations of their argumentation. That being said I do share your opinion on the matter...
EDIT: elaborating... EDIT 2: Not sure why I'm getting downvoted. No matter how much I believe US won't go to war there is always a possibility I could be proven wrong. I don't think security professionals analysis was based on "no information at all" (think things we know about North Korea), no more than the analysis we have about US not going to war.
Even if it wasn't North Korea, the U.S. still gains nothing from this except for maybe making NK look even worse.
And the U.S. might make some stupid political decisions, but there's a difference "ill advised" decision and a flat-out stupid decision. Going to war with NK would mean South Korea getting attacked by NK. Would the U.S. risk that?
I honestly do not think so, because it'd signal the end of the U.S.' diminishing credibility in the global sphere. Nobody wants to be friends with a country who'd willingly throw a friend under the bus simply because another country (which has very few friends) hacked into one of millions of corporations in said country.
If the U.S. and USSR could go years without nuking each other, I believe the U.S. has enough restraint to not launch (enough of) an attack on NK that would provoke a NK response towards their southern neighbors.
My guess, there are some serious, institutional-shaking smoking gun emails between media execs, lobbyists, gov't.
Official PR response of all parties presently guilty is to make as much noise about anything that's not in the data dump.
Wouldn't those be released in the SPE exec. mail dumps?
Quite often the easiest way to identify a criminal is to look at who benefited most from the crime.
On the Internet nobody knows you're North Korea (if you're sophisticated enough).
Also, their main evidence seems to be that "they used the same hacking software as North Korea had used before - and can be found on the black market". So this is a little like some hackers buying forensics tools that can hack iPhones, the same ones the police are buying, and then saying the police hacked the celebrity nudes a few months ago.
Assuming the FBI have no reason to lie, the more interesting question is "why did the FBI make a statement mentioning North Korea at all?"
The FBI could have chosen to not name the suspect. The only reason I can come up with is that the US is trying to send a message to the world (perhaps China specifically?) that the US is irrational, and may do something crazy at any moment.
The historical precedent would be the game of brinksmanship that played out over the Cuban missile crisis. Obama just doesn't have that sheen of crazy that Eisenhower had.
I stand by the assertion that the US was trying to come off as a little crazy in the Cuban Missile Crisis.
Normally the FBI would want to see monetary loss of e.g. $50k (arbitrary number I just chose) before they start caring, so your credit card probably isn't going to cut it.
Details about who's attached to a project as a star/director, or senior technician are easily available through trade newspapers and industry newsletters. The 'packaging' of a film ('Seth Rogen to star in The Interview') is the first stage of the marketing, taking place as long as 2-3 years before release, sometimes longer. Basically the way you get a film made is this: Write the script; find some famous actors who like it; get them to sign (largely) non-binding 'letters of intent' to act in it if it manages to attract financing; call up investors (including studios) and say 'do you want to put up the money for this? It's a great script, and I've got letters of intent from Seth and James!'; proceed to the stage of writing more binding contracts once you have money in the bank.
Long story short, there has been plenty of time for NK to become aware of the film and get offended about it. By some accounts the idea was in development since the last decade but got shelved when Kim Jong-Il died.
My point is that this can't be a conspiracy by Sony, because they would never leak the extremely compromising information that has been leaked. A lot of the leaked information makes them look very bad.
If you are trying to say that the movie not being leaked means the movie never existed, that doesn't make sense. If North Korea did hack Sony, they would not leak the movie because they hate the movie and don't want anyone to see it. If a group of other hackers hacked Sony and are pretending to be North Korea (compiling code on computers with the Korean language), then they wouldn't leak the movie because North Korea wouldn't leak it and they are pretending to be North Korea.
I'm disappointed by the lack of evidence given by the FBI and other departments investigating the attack that directly tie the incident to a specific government or group of non-state actors. Many well-known security professionals have given opinions contrary of the FBI's findings, stating that it's not only difficult to determine the source of the attack but also incredibly dangerous to attribute the attack to a specific government given so little direct evidence.
There are so many aspects to this story that don't add up, but most strikingly, the press's push to point the finger squarely at North Korea for all this.