News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by goodside on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:10PM (#8455138)
Please tell your employees to stop creating fake profiles on OkCupid and spamming our users. Behaving like that doesn't inspire much confidence in your service.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by railsdude on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:19PM (#8455184)
It's not "spamming", it's Growth Hacking ™.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:08PM (#8455467)
From the same outfit that brought you that weird crowdfunding campaign to send women from New York over to woman-starved Silicon Valley: https://www.tilt.com/campaigns/working-on-it

Another solid YC investment at work.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by 7Figures2Commas on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:11PM (#8456100)
> Another solid YC investment at work.

I actually think this is an interesting example of YC's investments, but not for the reason you seem to suggest.

YC's public persona is all about "hyper-growth" and building "very large" companies[1]. But if you go through the list of companies it has funded, a good number would have a very difficult time making a prima facie case that they fit the profile of a business that can achieve significant growth and scale. Dating Ring is the perfect example of that.

There are numerous challenges associated with breaking into the online dating space generally. First, the costs of customer acquisition are typically quite high because there's so much competition. That makes it very difficult for new services to gain traction without significant investment in advertising. Second, there's an additional level of churn built in to this market because when a dating service works, it loses customers. That produces a constant need for investment in the aforementioned user acquisition which is so costly.

More specifically, Dating Ring seems to be positioned in no man's land (no pun intended). It can't compete with the quantity and immediate gratification of online services that cost nothing or roughly the same, and it can't compete with the quality and exclusivity of matchmaking services which generally have costs signaling much higher value.

If the OP's comment is true, Dating Ring would ironically appear to be offering the worst of both worlds by trying to package users from the former as part of a service masquerading as the latter. Even with adjustments to its model, the odds that this company ever achieves "hyper-growth" or becomes a very large business are next to nil.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBYhVcO4WgI

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:16PM (#8455519)
Nothing about that campaign itself was sexist. But mix women and dating, and you get a ton of outcry from the media that the women are prostitutes. As a feminist company, that wasn't fun for us to be associated with, but there was little we could do about that. The trip was mostly a joke, and also because we honestly thought a few people may end up having a good time. And one woman ended up falling in love and is now moving to SF.

So, I'd hold off on insulting YC based on some publicity we've received. And .. all press is good press for growth for an early stage startup.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by mwhite on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:31PM (#8456189)
What is a feminist company?

Given that 'feminist' and 'feminism' are used by many people to mean many different things, it would be nice to specify what being a feminist company means.

Is it just a company run by people who self-identify as feminists, maybe one that only hires other people who self-identify as feminists? If so, how do you enforce this? Or is the company's feminism defined by specific policies that are based in a specific meaning of 'feminism', and if so, what are they?

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by cowsandmilk on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:26PM (#8456617)
Women constantly get harassed on okcupid. Their goal is to do online dating where the women won't get harassed.

Being against the harassment of women is pretty fundamentally feminist.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by dubfan on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:52PM (#8456684)
I always thought it was about "not being a bad person", a concept which predates feminism by a few millennia.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by scott_s on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @09:33AM (#8458289)
I feel you are being disingenuous in your disagreement - that you're deliberately trying to be combative as opposed to engaging in honest discussion.

Clearly, goals can belong in several umbrella categories at the same time. Most people would agree that "not harassing women" falls under "not being a bad person." But, at the same time, it is also a major goal of most feminists.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @09:20PM (#8456764)
The presence of "harassing women" has not traditionally been in the category of "things a good person does not do".
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by alttab on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:40AM (#8457197)
Yes but the problem can be addressed without addressing sex.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Thursday October 16, 2014 @08:34AM (#8464542)
In some universe of pure forms, sure, but on the other hand: material reality.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by _tlf7 on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @09:30PM (#8456787)
our company is a feminist company- it just means that feminist values are a part of the company culture.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @09:44PM (#8456815)
This is not a response to

> Given that 'feminist' and 'feminism' are used by many people to mean many different things, it would be nice to specify what being a feminist company means.

Which feminist values?

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by _tlf7 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:35PM (#8467508)
feminism = social political and economical equality between women and men. A company culture with feminist values means equal maternity and paternity policies, thoughtful consideration for hiring 50/50 men and women, providing health care that covers birth control, etc. Just thinking about equality in every business decision.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by king_jester on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:43PM (#8455681)
> As a feminist company, that wasn't fun for us to be associated with, but there was little we could do about that.

I don't see how your company could describe itself and feminist while also making a campaign that relies on some of the structural sexism of the Valley and tech. How did that campaign challenge the existing power structures and stereotypes/mythology of tech?

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by atom-morgan on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:30PM (#8455944)
> How did that campaign challenge the existing power structures and stereotypes/mythology of tech?

That wasn't her goal with the campaign.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by king_jester on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:43PM (#8455997)
So what was the goal then? It seemed like a legit campaign that was raising actual money. How does one reconcile their company as feminist with how that campaigned operated?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by mblevin on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:50PM (#8456257)
The goal was free marketing via the press who zeroed in on what appeared to be an ongoing SV story - Bubble 2.0 + gender imbalance + hapless engineer stereotypes.

And by any measure, it was outrageously successful.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by atom-morgan on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:58PM (#8456698)
> How does one reconcile their company as feminist with how that campaigned operated?

By accepting those women as adults who are free and intelligent enough to make decisions that may not necessarily line up with the common branch of feminism popularized by the media.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by peterwwillis on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:05PM (#8456316)
You don't have to spend every waking moment of your life, nor every resource or effort of an organization you belong to, to prove that you're worthy of associating with an ideal like feminism. If they identify with the feminist cause and support it, they don't need to prove it to you or justify how their campaign is or isn't feminist. It wasn't intended to be a feminist campaign, and it doesn't invalidate the rest of who they are or what they identify with.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by king_jester on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:25PM (#8456400)
I'm not saying that they have to constantly spend time justifying themselves, but it is important to look critically at the work a company does when it claims to be feminist. In regards to the tilt campaign, I don't see how that campaign challenges the status quo and pushes for women's rights. I do see how it could be viewed as promoting or exploiting the mythology of male culture the Valley to raise money, which to some may be anti-feminist in nature.

> If they identify with the feminist cause and support it, they don't need to prove it to you or justify how their campaign is or isn't feminist.

We've seen that many times organizations that claim feminism or feminist principles often don't act in a way that is supporting of women, so being critical is fully warranted when an organization says one thing but does something that seems to do nothing but perpetuate existing stereotypes and problems. Moreover, they made the claim, not me, so asking "why is what you are doing feminist" is important.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:45PM (#8456468)
> I do see how it could be viewed as promoting or exploiting the mythology of male culture the Valley to raise money, which to some may be anti-feminist in nature.

Is it a mythology if it is based on hard facts? I.e. this sounds a bit like saying that heat engine works on mythology of lower energy levels in a heat sink. Also note that just like heat engine equalizes energy levels between source and sink, such campaing seeks to equalize gender inbalance. Which I guess is as feminist as you can get.

I think it is actually beneficial for a person or an organization working toward women's right to disassociate themselves from the feminism movements and related labels lest they actually do end up spending all their time constantly justifying themselves.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by dubfan on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:57PM (#8456695)
You can't compare a physical phenomenon to a social one, especially when the existence and magnitude of the latter is heavily contested by people with agendas that rely on the phenomenon's existence and magnitude.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @09:08PM (#8456724)
Just like the utility of heat engines is heavily contested by us making sure heat sink never averages with the heat source. That's why you have a radiator in your car.

My point is, that a) that campaign didn't foster a myth, it used a real, existing potential gradient and b) it is very much pro-feminist as long as they're letting things equalize and not actively trying to maintain that gender gradient.

ETA: of course I can compare a physical phenomenon to a social one, mathematical models don't differentiate between those. Still, I chose that example only to highlight that calling facts a "mythology" is weird.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:18PM (#8455535)
...I never said it was sexist?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by pocketheyman on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:59PM (#8455411)
I'm going to write a Grease monkey script to prevent the word "hacking" from ever being displayed on my screen.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:50PM (#8456485)
Do a version replacing "growth hacking" with "spamming" and "marketing" with "lying", and I'll very happily install it (and wire you two beers worth of money, if you have a donate button or sth.).
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by jacalata on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:11PM (#8455486)
what are you going to replace it with? "butt" is already taken and wouldn't fit grammatically anyway. [https://github.com/panicsteve/cloud-to-butt]
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by philsnow on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:19PM (#8455538)
s/Hacking/Jacking/g
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by Fuzzwah on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:13PM (#8456110)
s/hacking/licking/g

would be my pick

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by prawn on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:51PM (#8456262)
Snacking?

Growth snacking? Snacking on some code?

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by reinhardt on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @09:18PM (#8456748)
I vote for fumbling.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by lalos on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:44PM (#8456001)
hack -> buzz, hacking -> buzzing
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by hderms on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:21PM (#8455899)
my sentiments exactly. HN comment of the month.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by eegilbert on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:28PM (#8455234)
Reminiscent of folklore surrounding Airbnb's Craigslist campaign: http://davegooden.com/2011/05/how-airbnb-became-a-billion-do...
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by nostromo on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:30PM (#8455598)
Airbnb was spamming, but they weren't being dishonest. To me, dishonesty is worse.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by nether on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:55PM (#8455379)
I think MyTwinPlace is currently doing such a campaign.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by samstave on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:06PM (#8455456)
Everyone did this, Tagged did the same thing as well, so did HI5. (create fake users that is - not doing it on OKCupid)

(Then tagged and HI5 took the user base's email addresses and turned them into mailing lists for their spam email side companies...)

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by ilamparithi on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:48PM (#8455339)
Its AirBnB all over again.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by 7Figures2Commas on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:15PM (#8456116)
For every company that successfully uses gray and black hat techniques to spur growth there are literally hundreds that don't achieve the desired result.

YC companies that think they're being clever and are more likely to employ these techniques successfully "Because AirBnB" shouldn't be disappointed when they fail.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:51PM (#8456493)
> For every company that successfully uses gray and black hat techniques to spur growth there are literally hundreds that don't achieve the desired result.

Exactly. But every such campaign contributes to the erosion of trust on the Internet and generally makes the world suck more.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:54PM (#8455375)
Nicest comment ever. Marry me?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by ilamparithi on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:55AM (#8457429)
Sorry. My comment was not positive. I love YC and what they are doing. But the fact that they are turning a blind eye to these kind of practices has been a sore point for me. First AirBnB, then Rapgenius(now genius) with their black hat SEO and now you. I though YC was about helping geeks succeed without making compromises to their moral principles.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by sauere on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:32PM (#8456425)
Oh boi. This is going to be good.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:26PM (#8455219)
Also, to clarify, while I did personally message a ton of people during our early days (CEO in her pajamas at 3am doing anything to get a site off the ground) - this is not at all what we do now. Our Premium Matchmakers will contact someone if they have someone they want to set them up on a date with. You're on OkCupid for dates, right? So we're trying to help :)
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by adamio on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:30PM (#8455246)
"Our Premium Matchmakers will contact someone if they have someone they want to set them up on a date with."

This is unsolicited spam. And likely against OkCupid's terms of use.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by Meekro on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:39PM (#8455291)
Spam is in the eye of the receiver. Someone with an empty OkCupid inbox would probably be glad to get a "I know someone you'd be perfect for!" message. Maybe that's still against OkCupid's ToS, I don't know, but if I was the recipient I wouldn't really care.

If it was just generic "come sign up for our new dating service!" messages, I'd agree with you, but that's not what they were doing.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by shostack on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:43PM (#8455690)
The problem with this is that every dating site out there looking to grow their user base might see that as a viable strategy.

If it were to become more common (not sure how common it is actually...probably very), that could result in an overall poor experience for OKCupid users who would associate using the service with receiving spam that never netted out to anything.

There is nothing wrong with OKCupid drawing the line on another service trying to get "free" marketing on its dime and at the expense of its user experience.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by Meekro on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:11PM (#8455852)
I agree with your last paragraph. If I were OkCupid, I would try to prevent people from doing this. If I were Dating Ring, I would try to do this. And if I were an OkCupid user, I would feel gratitude towards anyone who arranged a date for me, Terms of Service be damned.

That said, if it never amounted to anything -- as in, I got Dating Ring spam promising dates that never materialized, I would be pretty pissed.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by shostack on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:25PM (#8455925)
If it did amount to something, sure, users would be happy.

However my point was that it is not exclusively Dating Ring doing this. It is important to consider the overall signal to noise ratio when you factor in the messages from Dating Ring and any other company out there trying to use OKCupid's platform to promote themselves.

OkCupid, barring the creation of a program/partnership specific to this case, has decided that overall, it is worth filtering out. If they thought it added value based on the data they had, they would try to partner with Dating Ring. Heck, it would likely have been fine if Dating Ring purchased ad inventory on their site. As it stands, it seems they view this approach as spam per the OP. If it is against their terms, Dating Ring doesn't have much leg to stand on as that would make it a pretty black and white situation.

Part of me wonders if a Cease & Desist is en route to Dating Ring's office.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:59PM (#8456523)
> However my point was that it is not exclusively Dating Ring doing this. It is important to consider the overall signal to noise ratio when you factor in the messages from Dating Ring and any other company out there trying to use OKCupid's platform to promote themselves.

Such situations are exactly the kind where Kant's categorical imperative applies. If something is clearly wrong when everyone does it, it should not be OK for a particular company to do.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by adamio on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:52PM (#8455363)
It would not be spam if this startup was only giving it's customers links to great matching OkCupid profiles
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @09:23PM (#8456770)
Why would you want to date anybody with an empty okcupid inbox.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by DaFranker on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:57PM (#8460873)
Edge case 1: You're the first to send them a message! Edge case 2: They just deleted everything in their inbox. Edge case 3: They have a particularly polarizing outlier property (e.g.: a very intense fetish for something most people would find disgusting). Edge case 4: Some quirk (or maybe even a bug!) of OKCupid's matching algorithm is pushing that user far far down in most people's priority / match % lists. Edge case 5: OKCupid's matching algorithms are functioning well, but the person is just that peculiar of an outlier in that algorithm that there's just very few active users who are going to be matched well with them.

Just off the top of my head. And then consider that, by the context, they probably meant anyone who hasn't had a new message in a while. Yeah.

TL;DR: Lots of good reasons.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by zdean on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:37PM (#8455278)
There's an entire ecosystem (though possibly not very robust) around providing services to people on dating services like helping with writing their profile. I've heard from a few people that it would be awesome to have someone just manage their dating profile for them. This service seems in some ways to add to that ecosystem and fill the need. I would think that OKC, etc. would in the end benefit from their contribution.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by railsdude on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:44PM (#8455315)
> I would think that OKC, etc. would in the end benefit from their contribution.

That's BS and you know it. If that were the case, OP's startup should've bought ads on OKC and OKC would be glad to sell ad space. I really doubt that OKC or its parent company will sell ads to a competitor dating site.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by jonathanjaeger on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:58PM (#8455403)
OkCupid does have big ads for PlentyOfFish on their logout screen. They do allow ads, but of course, PlentyOfFish is paying for that ad space. Many niche or competitor dating sites advertise on other dating sites, but since it's paid advertising, the benefits outweigh the possible loss of users (think of it as shared users?).
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by zdean on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:03PM (#8455443)
Ignoring the fact that you're calling me dishonest for a moment, here's how I see it:

1. OKC is a listing of profiles where the lister is expected to manage the transaction 2. The management of the transaction is a huge friction and pain point for a significant number of people (as is writing a profile, taking pics, etc...for which there are also people that help). 3. this service reduces/removes that friction/pain point for okc. 4. this service is NOT a listing of profiles (as far as I can tell) 5. this service does NOT discourage people from signing up for OKC, Match, POF, etc...in my view it encourages participation in those services (whether implicitly or explicitly).

If I'm missing the mark on any of the above, feel free to correct me.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:05PM (#8456548)
> 5. this service does NOT discourage people from signing up for OKC, Match, POF, etc...in my view it encourages participation in those services (whether implicitly or explicitly).

As far as I understand it from the copy on Dating Ring's web page, their service is meant to replace all those dating sites. It's a fire-and-forget product that frees you from the need of maintaining an on-line profile and visiting a dating site - discouraging people from singing up for OKC is exactly what it is meant to do.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by weixiyen on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:52PM (#8456035)
Paid advertising rarely works. I think the growth hack is pretty clever. Perhaps they should pay to be allowed to growth hack.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:36PM (#8456643)
Did you seriously just say that "paid advertising rarely works?" Really? You believe that the entire 50 $billion Internet advertising industry is just wasting its money?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by weixiyen on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:53AM (#8457535)
I could have been more specific, but paying for advertising on OKCupid for this startup in particular is just not going to work. It's not cost effective and very few people will be clicking through on those ads.

I guess the better way to put it is that if your startup has to resort to paid advertising as the main user acquisition funnel, you probably already lost unless you have ridiculous conversion and LTV on each user.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @09:03PM (#8456712)
I think that "paid advertising rarely works" is actually true and yes, the whole (Internet or not) advertising industry is really wasting tons of money - and more importantly, fuel and labor.

The thing is, marketing is mostly zero-sum game; people are stuck in a negative feedback loop of throwing more and more money to one-up their competitors at attracting customers from the same limited pool. It's an unlimited resource sink, but it's a) what you have to do lest you get outcompeted by others, and b) profitable for those who facilitate advertising.

Weixiyen is also right that this "growth hack" is effective, but remember that "growth hacking" is mostly a fancy term for spamming / abusing trust. Every new way to trick people into buying something will work for a while, until everyone else starts doing the same and the ROI drops to zero.

Once upon a time, a pop-up banner was the clever growth hacking trick. As HN's idlewords tells the story,

"One of the first banner ads had a click-through rate of 78%. That's mind-boggling. Do you know what two words were on that banner ad?

"Shop Naked!" CLICK!

But banner ads turned out to be like poison ivy. People clicked them once, and learned never to touch them again. The industry collapsed in a flurry of pop-overs, pop-unders, and shame."

http://idlewords.com/bt14.htm

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:43PM (#8455312)
Hmmm...that's a curious definition of both "unsolicited" and "spam". If you post a profile on a dating site, are you not soliciting responses? As for spam, if someone contacts me for the very purpose which I have solicited responses for (in this case, finding someone to date) I would hardly call that spam.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:00PM (#8455416)
are you not soliciting responses?

Yeah, from a prospective date, not a matchmaker.

A similar situation: posting a job ad and having a recruiter reply to it trying to sell you their services, rather than a prospective employee. If you've ever been in that situation you'd know that it isn't a comparable response, and is just irritating spam that results in an instant delete.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:30PM (#8455945)
I'm getting tons of downvotes but I have karma to spare so I really don't care and will continue to express my opinion. Those two things are not remotely close to the same. The recruiter is a nuisance; someone that moves you closer to what it is that YOU WERE SOLICITING for in the first place would be a welcome response. In fact given that people are shy, someone acting as a middleman would add value to the experience.

The downvote button is to the left....fire away.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:49PM (#8456027)
The recruiter is a nuisance; someone that moves you closer to what it is that YOU WERE SOLICITING for in the first place would be a welcome response.

That's exactly what a recruiter does, though.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:03PM (#8456070)
No it's not. The recruiter hasn't matched you with a specific job at the time they send you the message....they're just spamming you. A matchmaker would have already done this and is bringing you precisely what you were asking for. Gigantic difference.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by jschwartzi on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @11:45PM (#8457076)
If you're a prospective employee a good recruiter will act much as a matchmaker by talking with you and establishing that you might be a good fit for the position they're advertising for.

There are plenty of international recruiting firms that just spam short to mid length contract jobs in places nobody wants to move to at hourly rates nobody would take. Those are the ones you want to ignore.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:19PM (#8456133)
I'm talking about a recruiter approaching an employer. Sometimes they will e-mail with a specific candidate, sometimes they won't. In either case, they won't show you until you agree to pay them.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by minimaxir on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:52PM (#8455362)
You're soliciting responses from OKCupid, not from a direct competitor.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:59PM (#8455407)
You're soliciting responses for a date. If someone responds with "we have someone we want to set you up with"....that gets me to my goal of finding a date. I don't think real users looking for dates make the distinction that you are.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:55PM (#8455381)
@Minimaxr - Calling us a direct competitor is a HUGE compliment. Thank you! I've talked to people at OkC and they could care less about us now. We're peanuts compared to them. Also, they have really good spam filters etc, so they can (and do) kick us off whenever they want.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by prawn on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:06PM (#8455457)
Someone from OKC posted above and asked you to stop. Why make them do it with spam filters!? Just honour their request.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:09PM (#8456558)
Exactly. Playing fair and showing friendliness can go a long way. Isn't that what YC teaches, by the way?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by tempestn on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:42PM (#8456656)
I think part of the problem here is that there isn't a lot of information on exactly what you're offering the people you contact. Given that goodside referred to it as spam, the default assumption is going to be ... it's spam. And indeed, asking for some "slack" isn't going to get you any sympathy on HN, nor should it honestly. However, what might help is to explain in more detail exactly what you're doing, and be open to suggestions on how to improve it, while hopefully still maintaining some marketing benefit.

For example, if you contact someone with a message along the lines of, "Hi, we're _____, and we've got someone who's perfect for you. Just sign up for our service at _______ to get started!" that's definitely spam. No question about it.

On the other hand, if the message is more like, "Hi, we're _____. We think one our clients, ________ would be a great match for you. You both enjoy _______, and in particular, he(she) like that you mentioned _________. Here's a link to his(her) profile. You can contact him(her) at _______." that doesn't look like spam to me at all. Effectively you're just acting as a proxy in that situation. The OKC user is indeed getting exactly what they're looking for.

So I guess my point is, it all depends on the message. If you make them sign up for your service, spam. If your message is generic, spam. But if you give them information about a real person, and a way to contact them - ie exactly what they would expect to get in a message directly from another user - that seems fine from the user's perspective.

Of course, OKC would likely still not appreciate your use of their service to facilitate competition. In that case, a better model might be to strictly act as the agent of your user; search OKC for them, and if you find a good match, help them create an account and message the user directly. Obviously this might require tweaking your model a bit.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by minimaxir on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:34PM (#8455264)
That's not being altruistic, that's poaching.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by prawn on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:44PM (#8456230)
When I receive spam or people abuse services I run, I don't care what position they hold within a company or what time of morning it is. Play fair or don't play.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by mikeash on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:59PM (#8456521)
"You're on OkCupid for dates, right? So we're trying to help"

I hope you realize that this is almost word-for-word what any telemarketer or spammer will say about what they do. They're just trying to help you!

I've never used it, but I'm guessing that people don't sign up for OkCupid because they want messages from Premium Matchmakers. You're spamming them. It doesn't matter how much you think you're helping.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:24PM (#8455206)
Our employees don't have fake profiles on OkCupid, although the Premium Matchmakers do occasionally use their real profiles if they find someone that is exceptionally good for one of their clients. This is a pretty common practice overall in the matchmaking industry - do whatever it takes to find a good match for clients who are paying you a good amount of money for the search.

We do our best to not spam and inspire trust by being available 24/7 to answer questions and personally interact with users. At the same time, we're constantly trying to grow so that we can provide the best matches. It's hard! Cut us some slack? No? Because it's HackerNews? Yea, I guess that's okay then.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by otterley on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:38PM (#8455285)
> Premium Matchmakers do occasionally use their real profiles

Unless they're on OKC to look for dates, they have no business being there. The only messages that they could legitimately send on OKC would be to ask someone on a date.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by bravura on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:56PM (#8455387)
I have a friend in NYC who is a old-school matchmaker (sole proprietor). If she told me that she was doing a search for a client and looking on dating sites for prospects, I wouldn't blink. I guess that I trust she is trying to act in the best interests of the two people in the potential match.

Is this substantially different?

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by otterley on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:14PM (#8455509)
The interests of the clients are irrelevant. If you owned a business and your competitor used your business's facilities to promote his to your detriment, you'd understandably be upset. That's precisely what the poster is being accused of.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by patmcc on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:45PM (#8456470)
I think it depends - would your friend message the prospects on okcupid/POF, or tell her client "here are some great profiles, you should message these people"? Those are very different; I suspect dating sites would have a problem with the former and not the latter.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by heyheyhey on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:58PM (#8455402)
> Unless they're on OKC to look for dates, they have no business being there.

This isn't true. Some look for companionship on OKC. Why they use OKC for it, I have no idea but 100% of the user base isn't strictly for dates/hooking up.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by csharpminor on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:32PM (#8455613)
I think you're arguing semantics here (or trolling). The point is that users shouldn't be sending messages as a proxy.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by lostsock on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:41AM (#8457199)
Exactly!

The right way to go about helping out their clients without potentially spamming OKC users would be to message their client on their own site that they have found someone for them on OkCupid. They could then ask their client to sign up to OkCupid to view the account and message the user.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by UrMomReadsHN on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:38PM (#8455982)
Some people look for friends on OKC. While I wouldn't say they have no businesses being there - they definitely shouldn't spam users.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by lazyant on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:21PM (#8455556)
> Premium Matchmakers do occasionally use their real profiles if they find someone that is exceptionally good for one of their clients

This is bait and switch and also poaching, same as if a realtor goes to another realtor's web site to find prospects and start soliciting them, plus using false pretenses in your case.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by mzs on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:37PM (#8455979)
How about you have your employees contact their clients saying that they have found a good match on OKC and send the profile with that message. Then if the client is interested, that client can reach out on OKC personally, making an OKC account if necessary.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by klipt on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:35AM (#8463960)
How this would go 90% of the time...

"So I went through the effort of making a profile and messaging them and they never replied. Now what?"

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by fubu on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:24PM (#8455209)
Off topic life advice: When you tell someone to stop doing something, don't start out with the word "Please". It doesn't really make any sense as it's a pleading word used as an order. It comes off passive aggressive and abrasive. Same thing with "I'd really appreciate it if" and "Would you mind". If it really is a simple request, then by all means, but when it's an order or a direct request, just say it without the weird prefix.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by DanBC on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:09PM (#8455838)
The phrase "Please tell your employees to stop creating fake profiles on OkCupid and spamming our users." is standard English. There is nothing wrong with the please in that sentence. Your advice is weird and wrong. Please is just a word used to convey politeness and civility with a request.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by Joeboy on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:34PM (#8455269)
As a native, English, English speaker, I don't see anything at all wrong with goodside's phrasing. I think they successfully expressed what they were trying to express, succinctly and with appropriate tone.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by tedks on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:21PM (#8455905)
As a native English speaker I agree with the comment parent. "Please x" is just passive-aggressive. You see it a lot on hacker news because people want to be "civil" without actually being so.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:13PM (#8456580)
Please tell me (pun intended) how the hell you're supposed to be civil if being civil leads to you being accused of pretending to be civil for ultelior motives? This is stupid.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by tedks on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @11:58AM (#8459110)
I don't think that's a pun.

It's not civil to say "Please stop spamming." That's like saying "Please stop beating your wife." It contains an accusation, which is never a civil thing to say. There is no civil way to bring up how your conversational partner is beating their wife or spamming OkCupid.

Adding a "Please" is pretending to be civil.

There are just some conversations that cannot be had "civilly". If you think this is stupid ....I can't really help you. Try to go have a civil conversation about someone's weight gain with them.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:09PM (#8459202)
> There are just some conversations that cannot be had "civilly"

I think here lies our disagreement. I do believe that you can talk about anything in a civil manner. Being polite is completely orthogonal to the topic discussed. In this case, "please stop spamming" is just a more polite way of saying "stop spamming", period. The difference is in tone, not context, and this is how the word "please" is supposed to be used. Also, what goodside said was not "please stop spamming", but "please tell your employees to stop creating fake profiles (...) and spamming our users". Which is a request, not an order.

Accusations have nothing to do with civility. Telling me "please stop beating your wife" when I'm beating my wife is valid, just like saying "please stop spamming" is valid here because they're spamming. If you believe goodside is dishonest about Dating Ring's employees spamming OKCupid, address that.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by fubu on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:40PM (#8455302)
Then I have a question.

> Tell your employees to stop creating fake profiles on OkCupid and spamming our users.

Seems to be what the poster really means.

>Please tell your employees to stop creating fake profiles on OkCupid and spamming our users.

That means the poster is begging the person stop? Does that really make sense? It sounds like someone is directly telling someone something, but is adding "Please" to get themselves off the hook for being seen as directly telling someone something.

As a native English speaker, I cannot remember anyone, except maybe an old person at dinner saying "Please pass the salt", say the world "Please" at the start of a phrase where it wasn't an aggressively postured order. Like this obviously was.

Serious question: Could you tell me what I'm missing with that?

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by Joeboy on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:09PM (#8455474)
The idea that "Please" means "I beg you" is archaic. It's a prefix added to convey civility. It is not contradictory to use it while also being firm or even abrasive.

I sometimes find the English language to be quirky or frustrating, and I have some sympathy with efforts to change it for the better. I think in this instance you are tilting at windmills, and not offering sensible or sincere "life advice".

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by kazinator on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:33PM (#8456636)
When you add "Please" to a request, it makes that request less of an order. The word is there because part of being civil is not ordering people around abruptly. (Even if you have the authority to give them tasks.) So in fact, when it is used for civility, it does mean "I beg you". Or at least, "I softly order you".

So in fact it doesn't make sense in some circumstances (though those circumstances are narrower and fewer than fubu seems to think).

For instance, "please" is clearly out of place in "please put the gun down on the pavement, or I will shoot!".

The civility-conveying meaning of the word is out of place in abrasive speech; for instance it is out of place in "please get off the f___ing road!" In abrasive language, if "please" appears, its presence is ironic. For instance, in a sentence like "please don't start with that bullshit again!", "please" doesn't have any connection to being civil; it doesn't function that way. Other such politeness words are also ironic in abrasive speech. "Kindly keep your mutt off my lawn!"

(There is even the usage of the word "please" by itself, or nearly so: "Oh, please!" or its variant "Puh-lease!" which expresses disagreement or disapproval.)

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:55PM (#8456691)
You made a very accurate description, though I'd argue that depending on situation and culture, "please" in "please put the gun down on the pavement, or I will shoot!" might not be that much out of place.

It conveys friendliness, the concept of "we're all friends here and we don't want anyone to get hurt, so let us sort this out without a mess"[0]. On the other hand one could argue that abrasive speech is very effective at bypasing various psychological bareers and delivering message straight to the target - after all, that's the reason for so much shouting and insults in the military. So there's a trade-off.

[0] - I guess I might have been watching too much Star Trek in my childhood, which gave me a deeply ingraned attitude that we can all see the bigger picture if we try hard enough.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:02PM (#8455432)
Context? If you're at dinner with friends you don't say "would you mind passing me the salt". With a stranger you met for the first time you certainly might.

"Please" is not a pleading word, it's a polite word. If you're going to give life advice, make sure it's right.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by jacalata on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:13PM (#8455500)
Really? I would say that at dinner with friends. Why reserve civility and politeness for people you don't know?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:16PM (#8455516)
True - I was using an extreme example to make a point.

It would be more accurate to say that I don't have to, and that I sometimes don't. I'd be more likely to say "Can you pass me the salt?" or "pass the salt, will you?", which strikes me as a middle ground between "Please can you pass me the salt" and "Pass me the salt."

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by Hoozt on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:30PM (#8455252)
On Topic death advice: when giving someone advice, don't start your sentence with "Off topic life advice", as you will drop 30% of your readers* when vision hit the "off topic" part.

*No scientific evidence behind this statement, but this is the internet, so it's true.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by fubu on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:37PM (#8455279)
It's okay. If only one person reads it and stops the passive aggressive, office speak?, whatever that bizarre stuff is, I've done the rest of the normal sane people a favor. I'll take plenty downvotes to save just one person from having to listen to that weirdness even once.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by enraged_camel on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:46PM (#8455325)
>>I'll take plenty downvotes to save just one person from having to listen to that weirdness even once.

You are such a martyr! Your parents must be proud.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:16PM (#8456590)
If it takes a lot of karma to save a soul, maybe we can pool our collective scores to save more?