News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:43PM (#8455312)
Hmmm...that's a curious definition of both "unsolicited" and "spam". If you post a profile on a dating site, are you not soliciting responses? As for spam, if someone contacts me for the very purpose which I have solicited responses for (in this case, finding someone to date) I would hardly call that spam.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:00PM (#8455416)
are you not soliciting responses?

Yeah, from a prospective date, not a matchmaker.

A similar situation: posting a job ad and having a recruiter reply to it trying to sell you their services, rather than a prospective employee. If you've ever been in that situation you'd know that it isn't a comparable response, and is just irritating spam that results in an instant delete.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:30PM (#8455945)
I'm getting tons of downvotes but I have karma to spare so I really don't care and will continue to express my opinion. Those two things are not remotely close to the same. The recruiter is a nuisance; someone that moves you closer to what it is that YOU WERE SOLICITING for in the first place would be a welcome response. In fact given that people are shy, someone acting as a middleman would add value to the experience.

The downvote button is to the left....fire away.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:49PM (#8456027)
The recruiter is a nuisance; someone that moves you closer to what it is that YOU WERE SOLICITING for in the first place would be a welcome response.

That's exactly what a recruiter does, though.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:03PM (#8456070)
No it's not. The recruiter hasn't matched you with a specific job at the time they send you the message....they're just spamming you. A matchmaker would have already done this and is bringing you precisely what you were asking for. Gigantic difference.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by jschwartzi on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @11:45PM (#8457076)
If you're a prospective employee a good recruiter will act much as a matchmaker by talking with you and establishing that you might be a good fit for the position they're advertising for.

There are plenty of international recruiting firms that just spam short to mid length contract jobs in places nobody wants to move to at hourly rates nobody would take. Those are the ones you want to ignore.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:19PM (#8456133)
I'm talking about a recruiter approaching an employer. Sometimes they will e-mail with a specific candidate, sometimes they won't. In either case, they won't show you until you agree to pay them.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by minimaxir on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:52PM (#8455362)
You're soliciting responses from OKCupid, not from a direct competitor.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:59PM (#8455407)
You're soliciting responses for a date. If someone responds with "we have someone we want to set you up with"....that gets me to my goal of finding a date. I don't think real users looking for dates make the distinction that you are.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:55PM (#8455381)
@Minimaxr - Calling us a direct competitor is a HUGE compliment. Thank you! I've talked to people at OkC and they could care less about us now. We're peanuts compared to them. Also, they have really good spam filters etc, so they can (and do) kick us off whenever they want.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by prawn on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:06PM (#8455457)
Someone from OKC posted above and asked you to stop. Why make them do it with spam filters!? Just honour their request.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:09PM (#8456558)
Exactly. Playing fair and showing friendliness can go a long way. Isn't that what YC teaches, by the way?