News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by adamio on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:30PM (#8455246)
"Our Premium Matchmakers will contact someone if they have someone they want to set them up on a date with."

This is unsolicited spam. And likely against OkCupid's terms of use.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by Meekro on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:39PM (#8455291)
Spam is in the eye of the receiver. Someone with an empty OkCupid inbox would probably be glad to get a "I know someone you'd be perfect for!" message. Maybe that's still against OkCupid's ToS, I don't know, but if I was the recipient I wouldn't really care.

If it was just generic "come sign up for our new dating service!" messages, I'd agree with you, but that's not what they were doing.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by shostack on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:43PM (#8455690)
The problem with this is that every dating site out there looking to grow their user base might see that as a viable strategy.

If it were to become more common (not sure how common it is actually...probably very), that could result in an overall poor experience for OKCupid users who would associate using the service with receiving spam that never netted out to anything.

There is nothing wrong with OKCupid drawing the line on another service trying to get "free" marketing on its dime and at the expense of its user experience.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by Meekro on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:11PM (#8455852)
I agree with your last paragraph. If I were OkCupid, I would try to prevent people from doing this. If I were Dating Ring, I would try to do this. And if I were an OkCupid user, I would feel gratitude towards anyone who arranged a date for me, Terms of Service be damned.

That said, if it never amounted to anything -- as in, I got Dating Ring spam promising dates that never materialized, I would be pretty pissed.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by shostack on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:25PM (#8455925)
If it did amount to something, sure, users would be happy.

However my point was that it is not exclusively Dating Ring doing this. It is important to consider the overall signal to noise ratio when you factor in the messages from Dating Ring and any other company out there trying to use OKCupid's platform to promote themselves.

OkCupid, barring the creation of a program/partnership specific to this case, has decided that overall, it is worth filtering out. If they thought it added value based on the data they had, they would try to partner with Dating Ring. Heck, it would likely have been fine if Dating Ring purchased ad inventory on their site. As it stands, it seems they view this approach as spam per the OP. If it is against their terms, Dating Ring doesn't have much leg to stand on as that would make it a pretty black and white situation.

Part of me wonders if a Cease & Desist is en route to Dating Ring's office.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @07:59PM (#8456523)
> However my point was that it is not exclusively Dating Ring doing this. It is important to consider the overall signal to noise ratio when you factor in the messages from Dating Ring and any other company out there trying to use OKCupid's platform to promote themselves.

Such situations are exactly the kind where Kant's categorical imperative applies. If something is clearly wrong when everyone does it, it should not be OK for a particular company to do.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by adamio on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:52PM (#8455363)
It would not be spam if this startup was only giving it's customers links to great matching OkCupid profiles
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @09:23PM (#8456770)
Why would you want to date anybody with an empty okcupid inbox.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by DaFranker on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:57PM (#8460873)
Edge case 1: You're the first to send them a message! Edge case 2: They just deleted everything in their inbox. Edge case 3: They have a particularly polarizing outlier property (e.g.: a very intense fetish for something most people would find disgusting). Edge case 4: Some quirk (or maybe even a bug!) of OKCupid's matching algorithm is pushing that user far far down in most people's priority / match % lists. Edge case 5: OKCupid's matching algorithms are functioning well, but the person is just that peculiar of an outlier in that algorithm that there's just very few active users who are going to be matched well with them.

Just off the top of my head. And then consider that, by the context, they probably meant anyone who hasn't had a new message in a while. Yeah.

TL;DR: Lots of good reasons.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by zdean on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:37PM (#8455278)
There's an entire ecosystem (though possibly not very robust) around providing services to people on dating services like helping with writing their profile. I've heard from a few people that it would be awesome to have someone just manage their dating profile for them. This service seems in some ways to add to that ecosystem and fill the need. I would think that OKC, etc. would in the end benefit from their contribution.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by railsdude on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:44PM (#8455315)
> I would think that OKC, etc. would in the end benefit from their contribution.

That's BS and you know it. If that were the case, OP's startup should've bought ads on OKC and OKC would be glad to sell ad space. I really doubt that OKC or its parent company will sell ads to a competitor dating site.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by jonathanjaeger on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:58PM (#8455403)
OkCupid does have big ads for PlentyOfFish on their logout screen. They do allow ads, but of course, PlentyOfFish is paying for that ad space. Many niche or competitor dating sites advertise on other dating sites, but since it's paid advertising, the benefits outweigh the possible loss of users (think of it as shared users?).
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by zdean on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:03PM (#8455443)
Ignoring the fact that you're calling me dishonest for a moment, here's how I see it:

1. OKC is a listing of profiles where the lister is expected to manage the transaction 2. The management of the transaction is a huge friction and pain point for a significant number of people (as is writing a profile, taking pics, etc...for which there are also people that help). 3. this service reduces/removes that friction/pain point for okc. 4. this service is NOT a listing of profiles (as far as I can tell) 5. this service does NOT discourage people from signing up for OKC, Match, POF, etc...in my view it encourages participation in those services (whether implicitly or explicitly).

If I'm missing the mark on any of the above, feel free to correct me.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:05PM (#8456548)
> 5. this service does NOT discourage people from signing up for OKC, Match, POF, etc...in my view it encourages participation in those services (whether implicitly or explicitly).

As far as I understand it from the copy on Dating Ring's web page, their service is meant to replace all those dating sites. It's a fire-and-forget product that frees you from the need of maintaining an on-line profile and visiting a dating site - discouraging people from singing up for OKC is exactly what it is meant to do.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by weixiyen on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:52PM (#8456035)
Paid advertising rarely works. I think the growth hack is pretty clever. Perhaps they should pay to be allowed to growth hack.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:36PM (#8456643)
Did you seriously just say that "paid advertising rarely works?" Really? You believe that the entire 50 $billion Internet advertising industry is just wasting its money?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by weixiyen on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:53AM (#8457535)
I could have been more specific, but paying for advertising on OKCupid for this startup in particular is just not going to work. It's not cost effective and very few people will be clicking through on those ads.

I guess the better way to put it is that if your startup has to resort to paid advertising as the main user acquisition funnel, you probably already lost unless you have ridiculous conversion and LTV on each user.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @09:03PM (#8456712)
I think that "paid advertising rarely works" is actually true and yes, the whole (Internet or not) advertising industry is really wasting tons of money - and more importantly, fuel and labor.

The thing is, marketing is mostly zero-sum game; people are stuck in a negative feedback loop of throwing more and more money to one-up their competitors at attracting customers from the same limited pool. It's an unlimited resource sink, but it's a) what you have to do lest you get outcompeted by others, and b) profitable for those who facilitate advertising.

Weixiyen is also right that this "growth hack" is effective, but remember that "growth hacking" is mostly a fancy term for spamming / abusing trust. Every new way to trick people into buying something will work for a while, until everyone else starts doing the same and the ROI drops to zero.

Once upon a time, a pop-up banner was the clever growth hacking trick. As HN's idlewords tells the story,

"One of the first banner ads had a click-through rate of 78%. That's mind-boggling. Do you know what two words were on that banner ad?

"Shop Naked!" CLICK!

But banner ads turned out to be like poison ivy. People clicked them once, and learned never to touch them again. The industry collapsed in a flurry of pop-overs, pop-unders, and shame."

http://idlewords.com/bt14.htm

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:43PM (#8455312)
Hmmm...that's a curious definition of both "unsolicited" and "spam". If you post a profile on a dating site, are you not soliciting responses? As for spam, if someone contacts me for the very purpose which I have solicited responses for (in this case, finding someone to date) I would hardly call that spam.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:00PM (#8455416)
are you not soliciting responses?

Yeah, from a prospective date, not a matchmaker.

A similar situation: posting a job ad and having a recruiter reply to it trying to sell you their services, rather than a prospective employee. If you've ever been in that situation you'd know that it isn't a comparable response, and is just irritating spam that results in an instant delete.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:30PM (#8455945)
I'm getting tons of downvotes but I have karma to spare so I really don't care and will continue to express my opinion. Those two things are not remotely close to the same. The recruiter is a nuisance; someone that moves you closer to what it is that YOU WERE SOLICITING for in the first place would be a welcome response. In fact given that people are shy, someone acting as a middleman would add value to the experience.

The downvote button is to the left....fire away.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:49PM (#8456027)
The recruiter is a nuisance; someone that moves you closer to what it is that YOU WERE SOLICITING for in the first place would be a welcome response.

That's exactly what a recruiter does, though.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:03PM (#8456070)
No it's not. The recruiter hasn't matched you with a specific job at the time they send you the message....they're just spamming you. A matchmaker would have already done this and is bringing you precisely what you were asking for. Gigantic difference.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by jschwartzi on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @11:45PM (#8457076)
If you're a prospective employee a good recruiter will act much as a matchmaker by talking with you and establishing that you might be a good fit for the position they're advertising for.

There are plenty of international recruiting firms that just spam short to mid length contract jobs in places nobody wants to move to at hourly rates nobody would take. Those are the ones you want to ignore.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by untog on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:19PM (#8456133)
I'm talking about a recruiter approaching an employer. Sometimes they will e-mail with a specific candidate, sometimes they won't. In either case, they won't show you until you agree to pay them.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by minimaxir on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:52PM (#8455362)
You're soliciting responses from OKCupid, not from a direct competitor.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by downandout on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:59PM (#8455407)
You're soliciting responses for a date. If someone responds with "we have someone we want to set you up with"....that gets me to my goal of finding a date. I don't think real users looking for dates make the distinction that you are.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:55PM (#8455381)
@Minimaxr - Calling us a direct competitor is a HUGE compliment. Thank you! I've talked to people at OkC and they could care less about us now. We're peanuts compared to them. Also, they have really good spam filters etc, so they can (and do) kick us off whenever they want.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by prawn on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:06PM (#8455457)
Someone from OKC posted above and asked you to stop. Why make them do it with spam filters!? Just honour their request.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:09PM (#8456558)
Exactly. Playing fair and showing friendliness can go a long way. Isn't that what YC teaches, by the way?