Make sure, in doing so, you make her aware of the advantages that she has been given, so that she's aware that, as hard as she's worked, it is not merely her hard work that gets her to where she is, and those that don't make it didn't just not make it because they didn't put in the effort.
So very true.
I think of this as the 'Black President Dismissal'.
I draw that from a certain set that will immediately raise the 2008 election as 'proof' that discrimination and inequality is an excuse and relic of the past.
You see the same with successful immigrants - who have already self-selected for drive, determination, ability and likely a certain amount of luck in getting here - who are wielded the same way, held up as 'proof' that anyone can make it America.
Sure.
Problem is, it takes a basic notion of statistics to grok a statement like that. That's something which, in the US at least, I perceive to be largely absent.
What's said. / What it actually means. / What people hear.
* Anyone can make it. / Anyone can make it with widely varying degrees of likelihood. / Anyone who doesn't make it is a lazy freeloader, except for me and people like me.
* A are more likely than B to have a criminal record. / Though A are 25% more likely to have a criminal record, 75% of A have no criminal record. / A are all criminals.
* On average, C are more intelligent than D. / The topic remains highly debatable, but some research has shown 1 standard deviation difference in IQ between C and D. Whether any observed differences are a matter of genetics or environmental factors is the interesting question. / All C are smarter than all D, period, look it up stupid.
On the other hand immigrants from Mexico and Central America are mostly from rural places, poor, barely literate in Spanish and with lower average IQ than general population of their country. Adverse selection in action - it does not make sense for well educated person from Mexico to move to US illegally so only poor and uneducated cross the border. Illegal immigrants from those countries are not really equipped to succeed in American in either first or second generation and this leads to higher crime, gangs, and other negatives. I do not think education system is capable of fixing it.
Asian American (mostly first or second generation immigrants) have average household income 14k higher than White Americans (mostly native). It's a pretty good indicator of education and class level of immigrants. Also Asians are famous for their work ethics and respect for eduction. Even if first generation is poor and work blue collar job, the second generation is much more likely to get college degree (~5x more likely than second generation Mexican).
Even in the case of an immigrant with a low level of education from a poor background, there needs to be a group willing to make him/her cross the ocean. So from the start (s)he will be have been selected as worth the cost of the plane ticket, and will be integrated in a community/somewhere as soon as (s)he lands in the country to make up for the initial cost.
Maybe something got lost in translation but your inclusion of this one word "unfair" depresses me.
That depends on precisely how you go about it.
By way of example, a farmer teaching their children how crop rotation works will enable their children to get more crops than other farmers who do not use the technique, even though they work the same acreage. This in turn implies more reward for the same effort. Advances like this are how we build a society of abundance where people have the freedom to devote themselves to music, art, or science without worrying about starving.
The idea that this family's success somehow diminishes the accomplishments of other farmers does not make much sense to me.
Now this is sometimes the case in the real world, for sure. And it's even more often the case that if one farmer starts doing something that works, astute neighboring farmers will observe the improved yields and copy the first one.
However what this model overlooks is the situation where one farmer has complex knowledge that is not obvious to others, and parlays that into an economic advantage. If the more informed farmer leverages the advantage long enough, s/he can end up buying the land off the others as they fall farther and farther behind. Economically efficient in the aggregate, but but far from ideal for those farmers who end up as sharecroppers on the land they used to own, or taking up some other line of work in which they have no special skills.
Even this outcome is not so bad where the advantage is based on actual innovation, but in many contexts economic advantage is derived through political maneuvering or similar, and increased yields often reflect an extraction of economic rents rather than profitable innovation. If you're economically-minded, being a rentier is a shameful position to be in.
Start a business and employ some people.
Something doesn't quite add up here.
[1] I had "effort and intelligence" here, but I don't think "intelligence" belongs. Our human capital is the hours of life that we are given here on this earth. Free will is what we choose to do with those hours. Getting a better outcome from the same hours of labor, just because of the composition of your parents' DNA, isn't fair. It might be natural and inevitable, but that doesn't mean it's fair.
Personally, I don't find the Harrison Bergeron definition of 'fair' to be particularly useful. It seems to be questioning things for the mere sake of questioning things. Yes, in the cosmic sense, everything is unfair, but what's your point? Society wasn't made to give everyone equal "cosmic fairness". This is how you create a society where the gifts of peoples' talents and circumstance go unused. By contrast, the people who are disagreeing with you are interested in maximizing the usefulness of these gifts. Improving peoples' circumstances is part of this, but only one part.
Toiling away for 16 hour days in a factory with no AC isn't necessarily as valuable to others as working from home on computer problems that have huge impact.
And I say this as someone who has done both of those things personally.
And yet, oddly enough, doing the one helped me get the other job. Not many come out of a factory job with a letter of commendation from the company president, after all.
I think it is true that we don't all have equal access to opportunity, and that extent I do think it unfair. My solution to that is to use my advantages to create more opportunities for those who lack the same and I have done this where I was able.
Again, its not. Unless you are stuck in a war zone or in some remote corner of Africa.
Most people in developed and developing nations today have the freedom to make decisions that decide how they are going live their lives. For centuries we've fought and asked for these rights, Now we have them. The fact is most people have fewer reasons to blame for their failures these days. Sooner or later you have to face the fact, you are what you are because of your decisions.
Even the person who works 16 hours at a factory has a choice. It might be a difficult choice, but the person still has some remote chance. The question is do you want to the same work another 15 years from now, or can you do something in your spare time and change that.
There are always going to be some people in that factory who won't be doing the same job 15 years from now, and there are always going to be people who will the same job 15 years from now.
What spare time? Have you tried laboring for long periods of time in very unpleasant conditions? The majority of humanity is engaged in a daily struggle for survival (in fact, for most of them our original state as hunter-gatherers would probably be an improvement). For the majority this condition is not a choice, but mostly a circumstance of the birth lottery.
I actually ended up using all of my vacation time to take a class that helped me churn out some projects that really impressed them on my interview for a much better job.
If it is inevitable but unfair then fairness is not a relevant consideration. Nothing can be done to make a situation more fair if it is inevitable.
They don't 'just' have money. Its not like some fairy shows up on one particular night drops a suitcase full of money outside their doorstep.
Life is full of choices and actions we take.
If a parent slogs all their life to ensure their kids have a good future and another parent doesn't. Then I'm very sorry that's exactly the future these people chose for themselves.
Ironically these are the same people who keep talking of work life balance, quitting jobs and taking care of kids and all that. While somebody else builds a financial empire. In the real life a parent who is always busy but can provide financially is vastly more preferable to kids than some who isn't but stays at home just to take care of them.
Learn to live with your choices and decisions.
How many billionaires exist in the world? Say X000? How does this compare with the world population? You seem to arguing that Y is a failure in life, because X was born to a rich guy.
I wouldn't go to an extent to argue that your initial conditions in life don't have a effect on your future. But at some point of time as you age, that argument just dies.
>> In the end money has no moral weight.
You can either say that and not make money, or go out and earn money. At the end having money would have solved most of your problems and may be even your kids's problem.
The more I see in life, the more I question how valid a concept "free will" really is, and to what extent we really "choose what to do with those hours." I'm not prepared to say there's no such thing as free will, but just the way people's behavior changes under the influence of chemicals, or in response to brain damage, suggests that we don't have a satisfying theory of why people make the choices they do.
I keep meaning to re-read John Rawls's A Theory of Justice. What he said about making social policy from behind "the veil of ignorance" makes so much more sense to me now than it did when I read it in law school. (Back then I was much more conservative, and a fan of Robert Nozick's response, Anarchy, State, and Utopia.)
How would you resolve this?
Just stuff like that. Different people need different amounts of things. It's not a particularly controversial statement.
Actually thinking this way will leave the person where they are. There is absolutely no doubt that luck exists. But what sort of logic is this to justify your failure with some one else's luck.
Whatever it is, it's not "simple."
I could describe snatching old ladies' purses as 'simply trying to provide for my children', but that's a deceptive, self-justifying rationalization that begs the question.
If it's "simple", it's not worth thinking about. If it's not, and could possibly be "unfair", then it's shameful to not have thought about it.
Not only that, but they have a great shot at ending up there even if they make big mistakes, including things like rape and even murder. This is the total opposite of the under-privileged, whose lives can be ruined after a small mistake, such as carrying a few ounces of weed on their person.
Yes, it's true that your kid might want to be an astronaut, but not get selected. Or the President, and not get elected. That's ok--when they get to that point in their life, they will understand what's going on. As a kid, they don't understand, so it's better to give them license to dream.
Also, maybe they won't want to be President. My brother always wanted to be a musician; now he's living a hard, low-salary life as a professional musician. He gave up a lot typical "upper class" success metrics like house, family, manager job, nice car, etc.--but he's really happy.
So, telling your kid they can be who they want to be can give them license to be someone who's a bit outside the social norms of success. Heck maybe they will grow to be someone who wants to work to improve education and social mobility.
Human beings are genetically and socially wired to do this.
Many people would objectively agree "Private tuition for entrance exams distorts the intake by income not ability". Very few would then refuse to give their children that edge going in to the exam. Similar examples exist for things like inheritance.
Personally, I'm wouldn't try and argue that people should not act in their own (and their children's) best interest. Because there is no chance that takes root. The need is for systemic limits to be in place on the impact this natural/rational behaviour can have.
When I think of my future parent self, I want to try to walk the thin line of granting advantages to my kids without coddling them. It's easy to fall into this trap, where the kid seems to think only the nice things in life are worthwhile. I think most people would end up more resilient if they didn't think this way. However, I know how the world works, and it loves to reward those whom have already been given much. So, the goal is to have shiny things so you can get more.
It's disgusting, really. I hate that I'm complicit in it all. Really just want to quit all the stupidity.
I know that was said in passing, but I want to point out that it's not true: Economic mobility exists, and the amount of economic mobility can and does change.
Economic mobility has decreased recently in the U.S., but let's not accept that as a fact of life. We can do better, and we can innovate ways to do better than ever (e.g., by providing quality education to disadvantaged children).
What are you supposed to tell her? That having a defeatist attitude is the best way to go through life? I sincerely doubt that's how those 33/800 children moved from the low income bracket to the high income bracket.
edit: unless you meant that she can be whatever she wants to be without working hard. Then you should have her aim a little higher. :)
Hmm... that actually may not be as ridiculous as it sounds at first blush. Not "stupid" though, more like "unreasonable". I'm reminded of the George Bernard Shaw quote "The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man."
Maybe the most important thing is exactly being unreasonable enough to shoot for vistas that are seemingly unreachable?
I don't know, but personally, I think "work ethic" is one of the most important things one can glean from your family environment growing up. I grew up in a single parent household through a chunk of my childhood, and a poor, rural "white trash" sort of environment through the majority of my childhood, but if I learned one thing from my dad, it was drive and work ethic. And to the extent that I've been successful in life, I'd credit that (and a boatload of perseverance) more than anything else.
I'd be curious to know if those factors are actually largely attributable to genetic factors, or if they're more "learned behavior". shrug
So you say to your kids, work hard at school, et cetera, but what's the backing? "Didn't you work hard, Daddy?". "Well yes, but greedy bankers gambled and lost and caused a recession that made our company fail and we lost everything ...".
If a child's primary example contradicts a lesson then it's a lot harder to justify that lesson for them.
Seems to me you're saying pretty much the same thing as the post I replied to earlier. The point, as I see it, is that while what you say is true, it is still the case that some kids who see evidence which would seem to support a conclusion of "you will fail" still manage to go on to greater success than their parents.
The question in my mind, then, is "why"? What results in the "unreasonable" kids who say "screw the odds, screw fate, I'm doing this anyway", despite the evidence?
As far as looking at it from a parent's perspective... I don't have kids, so I haven't thought about it much from that angle. But I think if I ever have kids, I'll want to teach them a lot of the same basic lessons my parents taught me, including "work hard and you can achieve anything you want". Note, of course, that "can" != "will". But I think kids are smart enough to understand that sometimes bad/unexpected things can happen, and that sometimes even when you "do everything right" external factors can knock you off the rails. The important thing there, IMO, is the attitude of "it's not how many times you get knocked down, it's how many times you get back up".
This is the crux though. You can't achieve anything you want, it might happen and your effort can help. As I see it the original comment was saying if the only tangible example is the parent telling you this and they haven't achieved anything like what they wanted - like are out of work, no money, living on benefits despite working hard, etc. - then how do you carry off that suggestion that it's better to work hard.
"It didn't work for you .."
"Well, no, but .." [what goes here?]
Technically true for a certain level of pedantry, but I still find that a useful overall mindset in general. shrug
then how do you carry off that suggestion that it's better to work hard.
I don't know exactly how you do it, at least not in a consistently reproducible way. What I'm saying is, we know some kids do take that lesson to heart, despite the lack of obvious evidence.
[what goes here?]
"... but you're smarter than we are, and you'll have the benefit of learning from the mistakes we made ..."
Or something like that. Again, I think kids are smart enough to understand the distinction between saying something is possible and saying that it's guaranteed.
I suspect that the scope of possibilities they're aware of, things that they can be if they work hard, is simply different.
Ex: if 0.04125 (33/800) people are "high income bracket" then no foul. People growing up in low income families have the same chance of getting rich as the average of the populace.
Only 33 children moved from birth families in the low-income bracket to the high-income bracket as young adults; if family had no bearing on children's mobility prospects, almost 70 would be expected. And of those who started out well off, only 19 dropped to the low-income bracket, a fourth of the number expected.
He compares some of the other stats too.
Tables/data from it is available: https://www.russellsage.org/sites/all/files/Alexander_Tables...
Edit: Google books: http://books.google.com/books?isbn=1610448235
A very poignant observation. This is exactly where the root of improving the human condition lies. The HN crowd doesn't seem to care much for ideas and critiques from a Marxist perspective, but there's some seriously important truth about this state of affairs that are always under the Marxist microscope, so to speak. To quote from a recent article on "Karl Marx's Guiding Idea"[1]:
> "One of the strangest features of human existence is that we are oppressed by things that we have created; but anything that is created by humans can ultimately be transformed by us, once we see through its apparently alien character and recognize it as a human creation, so as to be liberating rather than oppressive."
Marx followed and extended a rather lengthy philosophical tradition that was directly critiquing the bizarre notion--which seems to always remain near-universal across different societies--that the material conditions in which people live and either thrive or wither are the product of socioeconomic laws that most believe and argue are as immutable as the laws of nature. Social notions before and since Marx's time have remained replete with this widespread assumption that things are the way they are for reasons that are not our fault and, ultimately, beyond our ability to control--as if we're all just born into material conditions that are like those which govern the entire universe. It's what makes revolutions in history such lightning rod events--until they settle down and back into a new veneer that's just a bit different from that which came before. It's what leads people to resign themselves to the notion that, generation after generation, "the poor will always be with us".
Yeah, for as long as we allow them to be.
We create much of our material conditions and surroundings, and all of the socioeconomic systems we build around them. Then we treat them as if they are unchangeable. We persist in this regard for generations, relegating the greatest number of the masses to increasingly inferior conditions, while a tinier majority increases their material conditions exponentially. When we recognize this, we tell ourselves that it's unavoidable, natural, unalterable, etc. That a bit more hard work from everybody, a killer idea for a new startup and some successful pitches to VCs later, and you're gonna be on your way up, too, free of the need to worry about the problematic shit around you ever again.
This is unjustifiable foolishness.
You and I likely don't agree on perspectives (so please forgive the intrusion and know I'm not trying to convert you or trigger a philosophical debate that completely loses sight of the target here), but we do agree at least on your core point--this is not rational. We made everything around us. We can recognize it as a human creation, and then change it. And I don't mean sitting around waiting for the next election. That's not going to change a thing. All the hope and change so many voters expected to see in the last 6 years has gone ... where? Incremental alterations to things that, sure, matter in some way, but do nothing toward fixing what is fundamentally broken. We are closer than ever to equalizing marriage for all adults; we sit idly by as people continue to slide into deeper poverty and fewer real opportunities for improving their material lives. Such progress. Such hope. Such change.
In the meantime, people do exactly as you point out--identify outliers to avoid dealing with the norms and recognizing things are actually broken. Use anecdotal stories about someone who did something surprising (given his or her original material conditions), and allow themselves to be content with the idea that "if so-and-so did it, then so can everyone else".
As a parent (and a Marxist), I, too, am constantly battling a palpable sense of unfairness and guilt when I examine the ways in which I work as hard as I can to make sure my sons have an unfair advantage. I want them to have a better education, better life, better opportunity, better options, increased chances of avoiding all the shit I was not equipped to avoid by my parents and learned the hard way. I attempt to balance this by raising my kids to be aware and mindful of their advantages and, above all, of the complexity of everything around them--the need to avoid at all costs allowing themselves to look at others and relegate them to simplistic explanations that they're lazy, unmotivated, or whatever. I try to help them recognize the ways others try to boil things that arrest their attention into simplistic (and often polarizing) viewpoints that delete all the nuance of life, allowing an erroneous worldview to plant itself in their minds that they're any different from anyone else. And yet I feel guilty knowing that--because of the structural problems in our society that we've both created and continue to allow to remain in place--they actually will find they are different from others. Experiences that will be known by others because of their material conditions and limitations will be foreign to them (statistically speaking, at least, both poorer and richer included). It's not easy raising kids in a broken society that seems to only be concerned with incremental changes that give people the illusion of hope and change, while resigning itself to doing nothing at all about things that would rapidly and significantly ameliorate a host of social problems.
What do I really want to be part of providing them? A better world. Oscar Wilde wrote the following in The Soul of Man Under Socialism:
> "“A map of the world that does not include Utopia is not worth even glancing at, for it leaves out the one country at which Humanity is always landing. And when Humanity lands there, it looks out, and, seeing a better country, sets sail. Progress is the realisation of Utopias.”
I think it's time we stopped dismissing Utopia as a fool's errand, and start sailing toward it as humanity's destination. We need Utopia. It's how we plot our course. We've been severely off-course for long enough now. We could use a bit of fixing our eyes on it to see which direction we should move for the benefit of as many as we can fit on the ship.
[1]: http://www.3quarksdaily.com/3quarksdaily/2014/08/karl-marxs-...
> Just 33 children — out of nearly 800 — moved from the low-income to high-income bracket. And a similarly small number born into low-income families had college degrees by the time they turned 28.
What bothers me is not that the poor stay poor and the rich stay rich. That's pretty much the history of the world, and it's unlikely to change any time soon.[1] What bothers me is how people rationalize the very imperfect world we live in. A great example of this is how often people point to outliers in discussing the structural barriers holding back poor kids. It's not rational. Obviously the relevant question is the plight of those with median-ish determination and drive, born into different circumstances.
I've worked a little bit with inner city students, and what just kills me is meeting kids who are like 90th percentile of determination and drive. Not the 99.9th percentile kids that will go to Harvard on a free ride despite growing up in the ghetto, but the kids who are a notch below. Those kids are one wrong step away from never making it out of the ghetto. Their counter-parts, born into well-off families, on the other hand, have a great shot at ending up at the upper end of the income spectrum.
[1] One of the things that really messes with my brain is how hard I'm trying to make sure my daughter has an unfair advantage in life. Not just in terms of education, etc, but even in terms of expectations and aspirations. How do you tell your kid to work hard so they can be anything they want to be, when you your own circumstances belie that assertion?