Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by smspence on Thursday August 07, 2014 @05:04PM
(#8150123)
Extreme liberals do not want "equal opportunity". What they actually want is "equal outcome in all circumstances", which is obviously never going to happen, not even under socialism/communism.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by the_af on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:11PM
(#8150982)
Who are these "extreme liberals"? Note that socialism and communism do not propose an "equal outcome in all circumstances".
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by Natsu on Thursday August 07, 2014 @10:41PM
(#8151184)
Mao certainly attempted something like this with land reform. But you have a good point that it was never really equal, as he was living it up in the Forbidden City while the poor were starving.
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by the_af on Friday August 08, 2014 @12:21PM
(#8153591)
No, I meant that socialism/communism do not state, in their list of goals, "an equal outcome in all circumstances". This is not about hypocrisy, but about misrepresenting socialism and communism.
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by wmoxam on Thursday August 07, 2014 @11:37PM
(#8151350)
No one has lived in the Forbidden City since 1924.
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by Natsu on Friday August 08, 2014 @12:39AM
(#8151493)
Oops, you're right, I was confusing that with Zhongnanhai for some reason.
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by steveklabnik on Thursday August 07, 2014 @10:57PM
(#8151226)
The maxim "to each according to his need" is diametrically opposed to "equal outcome in all circumstances."
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by Natsu on Friday August 08, 2014 @02:06AM
(#8151699)
This would appear to imply that our needs are somehow 'diametrically' unequal. My experience has been that everyone needs roughly the same basic necessities.
How would you resolve this?
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by steveklabnik on Friday August 08, 2014 @01:13PM
(#8153922)
An 85 year old woman with a serious illness has very different needs than a 22 year old man who's healthy.
Just stuff like that. Different people need different amounts of things. It's not a particularly controversial statement.
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by ch4s3 on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:25PM
(#8151016)
This is a straw-man argument and not valid.
Re:Rich Kid, Poor Kid: For 30 Years, Baltimore Study Tracked...
by MartinCron on Thursday August 07, 2014 @10:33PM
(#8151166)
I would go so far as to call it an extreme straw-man.