News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by smacktoward on Friday March 14, 2014 @03:40PM (#7401265)
It is a terrific salespitch, especially in how it raises the subject of OTA updates while adroitly waltzing you past the obvious worry that a poorly tested OTA update will brick your car.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by peeters on Friday March 14, 2014 @03:46PM (#7401298)
How does the distribution mechanism in itself affect the quality? It's just a way of getting new software on the car. You can have the exact same standards of quality for an update installed over the air as one installed at a service centre.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by ssmoot on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:02PM (#7401443)
Except at a service center there's presumably the opportunity to replace the firmware chip or board if they brick it during the update whereas a bad OTA update leaves you little option.

OTOH I'd risk a bad OTA update 1% of the time if it meant avoiding the service center the other 99% of the time. And I'm sure a bad update is just a call and a tow away from a fix at a Tesla service center. Unless you're on a road-trip I guess.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by stcredzero on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:15PM (#7401518)
With the march of Moore's Law, it should currently be feasible for automobile controllers to actually run under a kind of hypervisor and keep a copy of the old system so that it can roll back. (Including by request of the owner.)
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by samstave on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:54PM (#7401798)
Yeah - I would not expect Mus to not have the foresight to do this...
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by onedev on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:32PM (#7402051)
I'm supposing that was sarcasm?
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by jotm on Friday March 14, 2014 @11:46PM (#7403397)
They could make the previous firmware easily restorable - like the BIOS on post-2008 computers - all of them have a shadow copy that can be restored if the new BIOS does not work. Hold two buttons and start the car or something :-)
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by cjfont on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:16PM (#7401532)
You might want to turn off updates during road trips.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by stcredzero on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:21PM (#7401554)
How about registering your "garage coordinates" with your car's computer so that it can detect when you're on a road trip and give you the option of installing an update or not? (When you are stopped and have parked the car, of course.)
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by samstave on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:56PM (#7401811)
Exactly. In the same way my computer remembers which monitor I plug into it (work, home office one, home office two, etc) and recalls the configuration of the second screen... the car should know when it is plugged into your home charge port. Various features should only be available when plugged into your home charge port.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by Tossrock on Friday March 14, 2014 @11:17PM (#7403335)
You don't really take Teslas for roadtrips(at the moment - when the supercharger network gets finished...maybe)
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by bmelton on Saturday March 15, 2014 @01:12AM (#7403638)
I feel like you've uncovered a horror movie plot from the future. Teen girls take off on a road trip in their Tesla Model Z, when an unfortunately timed OTA update leaves them stranded in a land of backwoods hillbillies... with secrets they'd rather stay secret.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by stcredzero on Saturday March 15, 2014 @01:33PM (#7405308)
Cue dueling banjos?
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by smackfu on Friday March 14, 2014 @03:53PM (#7401353)
The easier it is to update software, the less important that it is bug-free.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by npizzolato on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:01PM (#7401428)
Until that bug causes a car to drive unexpectedly into a wall in the interim time until you've sent out a patch. The importance of being bug-free is much more driven by the potential damage caused by a bug than how quickly you can update the software.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by zobzu on Saturday March 15, 2014 @01:41AM (#7403716)
do you think that the gasoline cars don't have software updates? their engine is nowadays all software controlled and theres a fw update plug, generally under your driving wheel.

and they'll update it when they service the car. how is that software any safer than the OTA?

its not.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by npizzolato on Saturday March 15, 2014 @11:50AM (#7404934)
I never said that. I was responding to "The easier it is to update software, the less important that it is bug-free."
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by GenerocUsername on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:40PM (#7401688)
Fear monger. What if what if what if... I'm not saying it couldn't happen, I'm just saying that possible new issues are no reason to persist the old issues
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by sukuriant on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:05PM (#7401871)
No. It's a car, and has the power to kill people on software malfunction, making it a critical system. Critical systems are tend to go through a much greater and more robust form of testing.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by stcredzero on Saturday March 15, 2014 @01:32PM (#7405305)
The destructive potential of a car exceeds that of a lot of handguns one can buy.

There have long been techniques for writing software as formal proofs of correctness. As far as I can tell, they haven't been popular with mainstream programmers because they are simply too different.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by sukuriant on Sunday March 16, 2014 @08:20PM (#7412098)
That is a really neat bit of fact; but, what does that have to do with what I was talking about? I really would like to know, it sounds like a really important insight, I'm just not sure what train of thought led to that.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by throwaway2048 on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:04PM (#7401865)
This is utter nonsense, "possible new issues" are every reason to carefully evaluate and weight new options.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by Fomite on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:13PM (#7401914)
No, but "Cars do uncomfortable things at high velocity" is not exactly an edge case.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by sliverstorm on Friday March 14, 2014 @08:48PM (#7402926)
Right. So, what happens when you are the one in that car, the car that teaches them better?
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by MartinCron on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:14PM (#7401514)
I would say that the easier it is to update software, the more likely it is to be bug free.

It's easier to test one change in isolation than to try to figure out which of these 20/200/2000 commits broke things.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by rst on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:16PM (#7401527)
For one thing, an OTA update mechanism is obviously more subject to third-party spoofing than an update delivered by physical ethernet from the dealership.

(BTW, do Teslas apply OTA updates while the car is underway, or store them up for application when parked? If the former, then applying even a correct update to a car in motion could have all sorts of nasty consequences if it resulted in a sudden change to, say, response characteristics of the suspension or brakes.)

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by GauntletWizard on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:27PM (#7401597)
I'm sorry, but no. No, most manufacturers update processes aren't actually secure in any meaningful way. Tesla's OTA process seems to use (I've not checked it myself) web standards, encryption, and signatures to verify that the OTA update is correct. The "Physical ethernet cable" that is used by traditional manufacturers can be done by any hobo on the street, in pretty much the same time. It's really only a matter of time before a script-kiddie-ready device that you plug-in and starts the car shows up; There's no security, no signature verification, etc. on the traditional manufacturers updates.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by oh_sigh on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:39PM (#7402473)
Source please regarding teslas OTA process.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by secabeen on Friday March 14, 2014 @07:01PM (#7402589)
Here's a pretty good summary from someone who sniffed the WiFi traffic from a Tesla doing an OTA update: http://www.teslamotorsclub.com/showthread.php/22294-Sniffing...
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by hrayr on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:40PM (#7401698)
"do Teslas apply OTA updates while the car is underway"

Even your cellphone doesn't update when it's 'under way', what makes you wonder a moving automobile will? If you hazard a guess as to how OTA's are applied to automobiles, I would guess it'll be in Parked, plugged in, and prompted to update by pressing an "Accept & Update" button.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by stcredzero on Saturday March 15, 2014 @01:44PM (#7405349)
There are realtime kernels that can update the apps, the OS, and install a new kernel without dropping a beat. VisualWorks Smalltalk had a system for loading code into a shadow of the running class hierarchy, then atomically committing the code changes. If you defined some functions for the transformation of existing objects, you could start a transaction in one version, then finish it in another.

We keep forgetting that lots of "advanced" features were actually invented decades ago.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by peeters on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:23PM (#7401575)
Is that true though? I mean, in my mind OTA makes it a given that the firmware is going to be fully signed and the channel will be fully authenticated. Whereas if a dealer is installing it, they could dismiss concerns with "we trust our service technicians." Seems the latter opens the door to a lot of social engineering possibilities.

But I was responding to a claim of the update being "poorly tested", not insecure. That's orthogonal to it being over the air. A poorly tested update delivered through a service center can also brick your car.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by mikecarlton on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:01PM (#7402271)
No, of course it does not apply the update while under way. When there's a firmware update available you get a nice big dialog box telling you so and button that says "would you like install tonight at [3 AM]". You can change the time or even cancel the update.

Furthermore, the message tells you it won't install unless the car is plugged in or has a certain level of charge.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by toomuchtodo on Friday March 14, 2014 @03:57PM (#7401393)
GM's latest recall (faulty ignition switch) killed 303 people and covers 1.6 millions vehicles; I think they'd love to have an OTA update method right now, even with the possibility of "bricking" the vehicle.

http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-autos-303-dea...

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by aceperry on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:33PM (#7402060)
Don't know if an OTA update would fix what is essentially a mechanical problem.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by lostlogin on Sunday March 16, 2014 @02:12AM (#7408104)
If it cut the ignition and effectively bricked the car the 303 dead and their family and friends would be pretty stoked right now.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by georgemcbay on Friday March 14, 2014 @03:48PM (#7401309)
> a poorly tested OTA update will brick your car

This is possibly true (though I'd be surprised if they didn't have serious precautions in place to prevent a total firmware brick, even fairly cheap electronics are difficult to really brick these days, with multistage/multipartition bootloaders and such).

However, given the amazingly large amount of costly meatspace work they would cause themselves by sending out an OTA that bricks cars, I'm sure they are well motivated to avoid that possibility.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by stcredzero on Friday March 14, 2014 @03:50PM (#7401324)
a poorly tested OTA update will brick your car

It should be possible now to have a rollback function built into engine controllers.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by lifeisstillgood on Friday March 14, 2014 @03:58PM (#7401404)
A poorly performed service at a dealers will brick your car too.

We trust the manufacturer to correctly service our cars, manually or OTA.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by marssaxman on Friday March 14, 2014 @03:53PM (#7401352)
Yeah. I am completely uninterested in owning a vehicle which is 0wned by the manufacturer.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by batoure on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:20PM (#7401550)
whats the difference? 20% of Americans lease their cars from manufacturers right now, when you lease something by its nature you don't own it. Another 60% make use of financing when they buy, in which case the bank owns your car.

If you are trying to make an argument about control then make it and maybe give us some more information than just the conclusion of your thoughts.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by marssaxman on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:45PM (#7401739)
Sorry if my reference was unclear - I meant "0wned" in the hacker sense, in that ultimate control rests not with you, the owner, but with the manufacturer, who in the case of Tesla can apparently just pump new code out which your car will install. That seems seriously creepy and weird to me. When I buy a car, its previous owner should have no further control over it. OTA updates for a car sound really wrong.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by sp332 on Friday March 14, 2014 @04:50PM (#7401770)
Here is the changelog: http://www.teslamotorsclub.com/showwiki.php?title=Model%20S%... These changes sound worthwhile to me, even if the mechanism is creepy.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by batoure on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:23PM (#7401984)
Also just think; how long did it take for the first iphone jailbreaks to come out, cydia for your car. Alternately replaceable ROM's for your car a la android. Where there is a closed eco system there are 100 people just staring at their computers until they figure out how to break it wide open.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by tmzt on Friday March 14, 2014 @11:39PM (#7403384)
If the separation between the UI and the backend electronics (the stuff that would be critical to safety) was strong enough, Tesla could even embrace a hackable UI portion of their system. It would be up to you if the Bluetooth phone worked, or if the climate controls worked, or if any other feature worked on the main display. (I assume the cluster display would be controlled by a different virtualized process.)

Of course Tesla would still supply a standard UI that the vast majority of people would use, but it could be forked on Github if you preferred. (I assume that third-party apps would be separated.)

For all the 'speculation' about Apple merging with Tesla, acquiring a significant portion of Blackberry/QNX would be a better choice. Detroit could end up buying their interactivity from a subsidiary of Tesla.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by jodrellblank on Saturday March 15, 2014 @10:02AM (#7404652)
cydia for your car.

Just what my car is missing, fifty thousand anime ringtones and a SNES emulator with all-you-can-eat ROMs.

Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by batoure on Saturday March 15, 2014 @02:15PM (#7405531)
Yeah definitely, the whole statement played alot more sarcastic if you were sitting with me in the office.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by mediaman on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:29PM (#7402026)
You always have the choice whether to install updates. If you don't want the update, just decline it.
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by MichaelGG on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:25PM (#7402410)
If you don't trust the manufacturer and their software, why would you think declining an update would prevent them from "0wning" you?
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by CamperBob2 on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:20PM (#7401963)
Enjoy your horse, then... but only if you're an atheist. :-P
Re:Elon Musk: To the People of New Jersey by marssaxman on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:28PM (#7402019)
I have an old car, which has a little bit of non-upgradeable firmware in its ECU, and a motorcycle, which has no electronics more complicated than the turn-signal flasher relay. Even an electric car doesn't have to be built with some crazy upgradeable touch-screen computer; it could just be a car.