News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by onedev on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:03AM (#7087678)
Do I complain about not being able to afford living in Manhattan? No. It's historically one of the most important areas in one of the most important cities in the world.

In the same way, why are people constantly complaining about not being able to afford living in San Francisco? It's one of the hottest cities on the planet right now. I don't get where this entitlement is coming from that people feel that they SHOULD be able to live there without paying the price?

I'm not saying there aren't real societal issues in San Francisco, but I think the entitlement from the people who can't afford to live there doesn't make sense to me.

Yes, we should try to make San Fran affordable as possible. Yes, more housing should be built, etc, etc. However, the entitled way in which the less fortunate approach this situation is what baffles me.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by Jormundir on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:51AM (#7088107)
The entitlement argument is completely stupid, and really is only made from a perspective of entitlement. This is a matter of history and establishment.

Back before the tech boom we see today, these people, who are now facing eviction, were just moving into their neighborhoods in the city. At this time, they did not face a choice of whether to rent or buy, as some stupid people on HN may be arguing. They only could afford to rent, and rent they did for decades. But these people didn't just park themselves in a bed at night, they established themselves in the neighborhood, building a vibrant community and culture. They opened businesses and started sports leagues and cultural preservation groups. They had kids here, who are now in the local schools. They gave the neighborhoods the very soul that is now so attractive to us tech workers.

Fast-forward to present day, and they are facing challenges from all sides and are fighting to defend the roots that they've planted and communities they've worked hard to establish over the decades, it really has nothing to do with entitlement at all. This isn't a fight over whether someone gets to keep land, regardless of whether they own it or are renting, this is a fight to defend what they've worked for. Really I see the other side as the entitlement fight. We techies think we're entitled to the communities these people established only by paying higher rent. With this attitude, soon enough these very neighborhood we talk about will have no culture, and won't be as desirable.

Really the only solution to this is to build more, so go yell at the people blocking new construction. Screaming entitlement is just making you look like a moron.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by ahomescu1 on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:32AM (#7088206)
> This isn't a fight over whether someone gets to keep land, regardless of whether they own it or are renting, this is a fight to defend what they've worked for.

This sounds ridiculous. If they (the renters) don't own it, the owner decides who lives there (that's the essence of property). Why should renters get a say in what happens to someone else's property?

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by Jormundir on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @02:42AM (#7093953)
Well now we can have a more productive debate.

The "essence of property" as you state it of having absolute authority of what an individual can do with their property doesn't exist legally -- zoning laws are the first example I can think of that refutes the claim or ideal.

So there's already a legal basis for us as a society having say in what people do with their property. Quite frankly I think a lot of these laws are overstepping their bounds and encroaching on personal freedom. BUT I think there's a perfectly legitimate line to draw when it comes to using your property to provide housing for other people.

When you decide to use your property to make money by renting it out to other people, you are essentially taking on a huge amount of power over their livelihood, and this cannot be stated lightly. So to me this is where we as individuals and as a society need to decide how to govern this territory in a way that's fair for both parties involved, as it is certainly not fair to widely restrict the amount of money someone can make from their property, and it is certainly detrimental to people and communities to upheave members from their homes and established roots. This is where striking a balance makes the most sense for the strength of the community, and the individual stakeholders, and will produce a strong society as a whole.

To me, making the claim of absolute property rights is simply weak. I don't want to deride the most important point, as stated above, but absolute property rights don't really make logical sense to me either, as property is often a hugely restricting resource, and one completely established by precedence rather than contribution per se.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by supersystem on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:06AM (#7087693)
I don't see how the "money should trump everything" argument is less entitled. Of course I'll think this will change if the fortunate side becomes reserved for the very fortunate, like has happened in some other cities.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lambdaphage on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:37AM (#7087777)
What criterion do you suggest to determine who lives in SF, besides "let people come to mutually beneficial arrangements among themselves"? Keep in mind that the most common alternative policy, rent control, is widely acknowledged (http://www.nytimes.com/2000/06/07/opinion/reckonings-a-rent-...) to turn rental markets into basket cases.

There are currently a host of policies that keep people from doing what they would otherwise very much like to do, which is building new higher-density housing and living in it. That would result in net gains, whereas arguing about who gets to live in SF is pretty much zero-sum. Yet people really seem to like to argue over the latter, and are weirdly quiet about the former.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by supersystem on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:48AM (#7087951)
I don't have time to do this largr discussion justice, but if you can't tell I think value associated with stable, and preferably cheap, housing is important enough to protect. Regardless if it's preventing a housing market crash, having rent control or forcing increased development.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lambdaphage on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:45AM (#7088097)
Sure, and the question is how you achieve those aims. If you can read an op-ed by one of the most highly respected progressive economists in the world, whose message is:

> Rent control in SF has had perverse consequences for tenants. Don't go in for rent control.

and your conclusion is

> Maybe we should go in for rent control.

I'm not sure what else to say.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by supersystem on Monday January 20, 2014 @05:21AM (#7088699)
Rent control is one of the tools, I've never said anything about it in relation to SF. I'd like to see anyone argue that rent control doesn't work as a price ceiling for the rent controlled units.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lambdaphage on Monday January 20, 2014 @05:55AM (#7088820)
Well, that really depends on what you consider a price: if a law prevents a landlord from renting to the tenant offering them the most money, they have to decide on the basis of some other criterion. In SF, you apparently had people showing up to open houses offering to pay the (legally stipulated) rent a year in advance. (http://www.lrb.co.uk/v35/n03/rebecca-solnit/diary NB: the author is apparently sympathetic to rent control) Moving a year's worth of future rent up to the present costs money in the form of interest rates, and is a cost. Landlords in rent-controlled units are notorious for dragging their feet on repairs, since the tenant is unlikely to look elsewhere and even if so, another occupant will always be ready to take over the lease. Just searching for a place in a rent-controlled district takes more time. All of these are costs, arising from the fundamental fact that if you make it illegal to allocate a resource on the basis of price, you still have to allocate it some other way.

You shouldn't be worried about rent control failing to function as a price ceiling-- you should be worried about it functioning exactly as a price ceiling.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lolwutf on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:19AM (#7087730)
You used the word 'important' for 'expensive'. That, in my opinion, is a fallacy.

It is expensive. That's different from important.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by onedev on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:31AM (#7087764)
But don't you agree that the reason an area would increase in value (which often converts to the monetary type) to a lot of people is because it holds some sort of importance to them?

Whether it be intellectual importance, industrial importance, creative importance, etc

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lolwutf on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:00AM (#7087981)
To wrap the varied values of an area up into a single word - 'importance' - is a gross oversimplification to the extent that it can even be considered incorrect.

It is, however, and undeniably, expensive.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by ok_craig on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:41AM (#7088085)
No reason it can't be both. One usually leads to the other.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by IvyMike on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:48AM (#7088103)
> why are people constantly complaining about not being able to afford living in San Francisco?

Think of someone like a cook who has lived in SF for years. They came to the city, honed and practiced their skills, and in their own small way helped make SF one of the best food cities in the world. And their reward is "MOVE OUT", or at least live in a crappy situation. And that change happened really fast.

It is human nature that someone in this situation would complain.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by malandrew on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:12PM (#7090906)
It didn't happen really fast. It's been ignored for several decades, probably since that person moved into the city.

I honestly see little difference in the human mentality that lead to the national housing crisis that and the SF housing availability crisis. Yeah, you can say the national housing crisis started very quickly in 2008 and got bad fast, but the truth is that the seeds that lead to that unstable situation were planted long long ago. The same is true for SF's housing crisis.

Rent control is a prime suspect in all this. In the case of NYC, rent control probably makes sense because it's largely hit the limit of how high a city can be built (it's easy to remove a 1-3 residence building in place of a 15 residence building, but hard to remove a 15 residence building for a 30 residence one.) It's easy to argue for 5x increases in housing for a given plot of land, but much harder to argue for 2-3x increases.

Economists generally all agree that rent control fucks up housing markets and reduces the quantity and quality of housing [0]. Most importantly for SF, it removes entire swathes of the existing middle class from demanding more and more housing over the years as the city grows. When you build up your life around 1994 rents, you ignore the housing problem in SF and hunker down in the home you happened upon in 1994. If for whatever reason you're rooted up 15+ years later, the rental rates have changed so much that you can't even afford to stick around and lobby for a solution like making more affordable housing available by eliminating building restrictions and rent control. Worse yet, you're likely to make the market even more distorted by arguing for more tenant protection laws. Had you been participant to the problem since 1994 because you had no rent control, you would have also been participant in the debate asking for more housing to be built each year. This is the exact same mentality that causes banking crises: introduce some extreme distorting policy that disproportionately benefits you in the short term and ignore what is going to happen when the chickens come home to roost in 10-15 years time.

[0] http://www.nytimes.com/2000/06/07/opinion/reckonings-a-rent-...

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by buro9 on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:15AM (#7088162)
As an outsider (London, UK based) I keep wondering why SF isn't building skywards?

By which, rent prices reflect supply and demand (and some other things, but mostly basic supply and demand), there is water on three sides and a park to the South.

The only thing to relieve pressure on prices will be more floor space for residential, and the only space for that is above the existing floor space.

For a long while there will be a lot of profit in supplying the additional demand, so I don't get why profiteering by developers hasn't led to enormous swathes of existing housing being knocked down and 8+ story buildings being laid in their place. And if this is happening, why it doesn't happen at a far more rapid pace.

Is there something preventing developers from doing this?

Are there local NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard!) groups who resist the building of additional residential units?

Are there city disincentives to doing this?

Or is this more a case of waiting for the "big one" and starting over when that happens?

To an outsider, can the question be answered: Why not build up?

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by potatolicious on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:36AM (#7088228)
Because San Francisco greatly perceives itself, and desperately wants to remain, as a small friendly hamlet of sorts. It wants to have its cake and eat it too: the prestige and economy of a world city, and the friendliness and pleasantness of a small town.

Because also San Francisco perceives itself as radical - this is true both in SF tech and outside of it - and perceives mass urbanization as symptom of all that is stodgy, traditional, and old (see: Chicago, New York City, London, etc).

"Manhattanization" is a pejorative with no defense in the city - "being like New York" is anathema to a large number of people, and suggesting that SF should be like other skyward cities is immediately painting a giant bulls-eye on your own head and a guarantee that you'll never be a meaningful participant in civic discourse.

In simple words, SF hates skyward-building because its worst fear is becoming New York City.

To answer your questions more directly:

- The city government, in response to voter demand, opposes most development outside of the downtown core, where there are actually plenty of tall buildings (almost entirely commercial). As a (shitty) compromise they've marked out a section of previously underdeveloped light industry just south of downtown for active development. This is where most of the action is. It's also not connected to mass transit, and there's currently an expensive project underway to build a brand new subway line to connect this area of town. This, despite other parts of SF being underdeveloped and already accessible to transit.

- The population of San Francisco, and this includes the techies, loudly opposes dense developments. San Francisco is well known for its picturesque neighborhoods of colorful old Victorian houses. The long-time residents are loathe to see this disappear in favor of mid-rises or high-rises, and the wealthy newcomers are loathe to lose what is an aesthetic gain. Neither side seems willing to admit that the price of their aesthetic preference comes directly out of their pocket book. Proposals to knock these houses down in favor of denser housing are opposed across the board and across the wealth spectrum.

All of this is official policy: http://www.sf-planning.org/ftp/General_Plan/index.htm - specifically this one: "That existing housing and neighborhood character be conserved and protected in order to preserve the cultural and economic diversity of our neighborhoods;"

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by buro9 on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:03AM (#7088351)
But yet there are great examples of cities that allow building, have increased the heights of buildings, and maintain the character of the city. Paris springs to mind, as does Edinburgh.

So long as "character" isn't defined as "3 stories", it should be possible to build to 6 stories whilst maintaining façades, retail space, etc and yet doubling available space and improving the standard of housing that exists (oh man, that dodgy wiring in every place in Mission I've ever stayed).

Do the residents realise the connection between scarcity and price, and that they are able to do something about it?

From the stuff that appears on here, it seems that there is a lot of anger against large companies but little reflection that the root imbalance in supply is caused by policies set by the population (or at least, in their name).

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by timr on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:01AM (#7088836)
"Do the residents realise the connection between scarcity and price, and that they are able to do something about it?"

There's some truth to the parent comment (I've said parts of it myself), but it's also misleading. Yes, the city could stand to build up in places, but the people in the tech world are also totally delusional when it comes to choosing where to live and work. Everyone is trying to cram into the same three hipster neighborhoods, and ignoring all of the cheaper parts of town. Price sensitivity is almost completely absent.

Notably, when people here talk about "bungalows" and "three-story buildings", what they're really talking about is the western half of the city (the part west of Mount Sutro). It's true that those neighborhoods are really low density, but it's also true that rents there are already much lower than in SOMA or the Mission. You can move to the Richmond and save hundreds of dollars a month in rent, but nobody wants to do that.

There are good reasons for all of this, of course (transit, weather, etc.), but the point is that it isn't just "zoning laws" that are causing prices to spike here. There's good deal of irrationality on the demand side, too. You'd be surprised at the number of tech people who have never even visited neighborhoods like West Portal, even though they're on major transit lines. If it's not hip in San Francisco, it doesn't exist.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by malandrew on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:55PM (#7090796)

    "Everyone is trying to cram into the same three hipster 
    neighborhoods, and ignoring all of the cheaper parts of 
    town."
Those three hipster neighborhoods are probably the way they are because of their great access to public transit not only for traveling within the city but getting out of it via BART. No one ones to move to SF and live in a neighborhood with a suburban lifestyle that requires a car to maximize life's experiences.

Living in places like the Richmond and the Sunset for example are more isolating than living in Oakland. Living at the top of most of San Francisco's hills is relatively isolating as well. Furthermore, hills aren't conducive to human-powered transportation like biking and skateboarding. Being able to quickly move around via the power of your own two feet via walking, pedaling or pushing is one of the draws of all cities. Every relatively flat neighborhood with great transportation is destined to gentrify.

If you put a BART line under the Geary and California bus routes, all the neighborhoods in the far west would "hipsterfy" as well

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by timr on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:00PM (#7091163)
Yes, as I said, there are reasons that these neighborhoods are popular. Another reason is the weather: the Mission and SOMA tend to be sunnier than the rest of the city. These features, in a rational world, demand a certain price premium. But the outer neighborhoods have nice features, too (e.g. they have less filth and crime, and more nature), so there's a trade-off.

That said, complaints about being "isolated" in the Sunset is mostly a lot of butthurt. The entire city of San Francisco is seven miles wide. There is literally no part of this city that could be considered "isolated", unless your definition of "the city" begins and ends in the Mission. And I say that as someone who lives without a car -- there are rail lines that run to the Sunset, West Portal, Glen Park, Ocean View and so on. You're maybe 30 minutes away from downtown, at most. Still, ask a 20-something coder to consider living in the Inner Sunset, and you'd think you'd asked him to move to North Dakota.

No, the real problem is that most of the people flooding into SF are wealthy 20-somethings who will pay nearly any price to live right in the middle of the hippest entertainment districts in the city. They don't want to live near icky married people and children, they don't want to travel more than ten minutes to meet their friends for a drink, and they definitely don't want to go up or down any hills to get anywhere. There are basically two neighborhoods in the city that meet these constraints, and in both, rents are skyrocketing.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:55AM (#7089767)
> the people in the tech world are also totally delusional when it comes to choosing where to live and work. Everyone is trying to cram into the same three hipster neighborhoods

What's delusional about deciding a particular neighborhood is nice enough to merit its higher rent? Just because you have a different opinion from the people who live there regarding what they should spend their money on doesn't mean they're delusional.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by timr on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:39PM (#7091055)
It's delusional because the demand for real estate in these neighborhoods appears to be almost perfectly inelastic. People don't even think about moving anywhere else in the city, even when the cost/benefit equation tips in favor of living in another location.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:54PM (#7091140)
The equation is different for each person. It sounds like it's tipped for you, but not them.

Therefore, just because you make different decisions than they do, it doesn't mean either of you is deciding irrationally.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by xster on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @07:37PM (#7099777)
Argument's kinda extensible to say Huston is both cheap and well equipped as a city but neither them or you or I are in Huston. It's a bit of a stretch to say to wanting to live in areas with desirable weather is delusional.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:36AM (#7089682)
The key differences between Paris and SF in this regard are:

1. In Paris, nobody has a chip on their shoulder about a nearby larger city. In SF, sour grapes about all the attention NY and LA get led long ago to our population pretending they don't want to be a big city. (Even though now it's actually within our reach)

2. In SF, a large number of people drive everywhere but live in garageless houses -- or they have single-car garages but own multiple cars. They resist building because they don't want to compete for existing parking spaces.

3. SF lacks a decent underground train system, so anything that puts more cars on the road is hotly resisted, and people believe that a garageless building next to a train station will be filled with new car owners.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by zimpenfish on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:03AM (#7088844)
Budapest is a good example - lots of 5/6 story apartment blocks right in the centre with (what seem to be) huge numbers of apartments and they look ok.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:10AM (#7089535)
> The population of San Francisco, and this includes the techies, loudly opposes dense developments.

Not the techies I know. In my experience, the vast majority of SF techies want high-density housing near excellent transit.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by malandrew on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:58PM (#7090818)
I was thinking the same. I can't think of one techie that thinks this way to be honest. The only ones that come close to thinking this way aren't anti-urbanization, but sit right in between both sides because they just don't care since they've made enough money to buy property and be insulated from the problems.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:27AM (#7089641)
When the American West was growing up, the trendy thing to do was enshrine laws into one's constitution or city charter allowing for direct democracy via ballot proposition: every election day, there's a bizarre slate of proposals to consider, and any that receive 50+% become the law of the land. This even overrides the decisions of the legislature or courts.

One result of this system is that in California, the needs of the few, or the one, outweigh the needs of the many. Don't want to pay high property taxes? Pass a proposition locking in all existing homeowners', and let the future generations get screwed. Do you live in a tall building next to a parking lot, and you're afraid someone will build there and block your view? Pass a proposition forbidding it! Worried that lack of tax revenue will keep you from getting a raise at your government job? Pass a proposition mandating a certain level of spending on your special interest.

Everything is arranged to prop up the established ones. Seniority is the most important thing you can have -- most statements at public hearings begin with, "I've been living in this city for 34 years, and I think..."

For other examples of status-quo-preserving red tape, google [CEQA] and [SF discretionary review].

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by pavpanchekha on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:20AM (#7088179)
I believe (so don't quote me) that city ordinances ban buildings higher than 3 floors. I'm sure it makes the city look nice.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by hessenwolf on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:03AM (#7088347)
It's possibly the same problem as other places: Zoning laws. The politicians and voting age population typically are in the age bracket where they own property... There was a good article on it in FT alphaville about a year and a half back.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by nerfhammer on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:33AM (#7088209)
Anti-development attitudes are endemic to the Bay Area.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by asveikau on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:26AM (#7087751)
What I dislike the most about the anti-techie rhetoric is how they seem to think every 22 year old kid who takes an offer from Google is basically a clone of Larry Ellison. This group may have a wage above the average but is still middle class. That guy's boss's boss's boss's boss is who they should be more worried about. (But he probably lives in the south bay.)

Then again, I was walking around SoMa with my family one day not too long ago and found myself stuck on the sidewalk in a large crowd of fratboy types who might as well have been straight out of the caricatures in a bunch of these articles... They were talking about working in the south bay and speculating on real estate. Really annoying kids. I get irritated too.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by ryanobjc on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:52AM (#7088114)
I find it interesting how the SF's rent control seems to not be well understood by many.

For example, people quote the ellis act as a frequent way in which people are evicted, and hold it up as proof that long time renters have no security.

But that's not exactly 100% of the truth. Sure Ellis act can be used to do a owner-move-in (for a new owner of a rented house for example), and in theory can be used for condo conversion, BUT San Francisco strictly regulates condo conversions. Specifically buildings with > 6 units cannot be converted to condos:

http://www.andysirkin.com/HTMLArticle.cfm?Article=2

Which means that, for all intents and purposes, renters in a larger building, are just as secure as any property owner.

There are guys in my building who have lived here since the moon landing. One was telling me he had to buy a black-and-white TV to watch it! In our building!

Amazing history here in SF.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by dnr on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:07AM (#7088367)
No, not really. Buildings larger than six units can still be Ellis-ed and turned into TICs. Even if those TICs can never convert to condos, it's still often profitable to do that.

(Btw, owner-move-in evictions have nothing to do with the Ellis Act. Separate laws.)

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by Tossrock on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:58AM (#7087831)
" I don’t have any answers to how to make it better. I’m not even sure it can be made better. "

Sorry, but isn't the answer just to change the zoning laws preventing residential buildings over 3 stories from being built in most neighborhoods? This seems pretty straightforward.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by dredmorbius on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:53AM (#7088294)
There are ultimately other constraints on density. For California, as with much of the West, water is an ultimate limit. Though the argument that San Francisco cannot increase housing densities on account of water access is ... even in this drought year ... likely invalid. Largely as the housing is being constructed elsewhere within the same larger watershed.

There are other constraints. San Francisco traffic, parking, and transit are all fairly strained as it is, particularly in the the denser core of the City (downtown, SOMA, Mission). Access from the outer neighborhoods to the core can be as long or longer than suburban commutes, though bicycles offer a pretty good year-round alternative.

For San Francisco, biting the bullet and allowing additional housing to be built, yes, even housing that is primarily marketed to the nouveau riche and upscale, would likely relieve much of the pressure for the rest of the community.

Another solution, of course, would be to provide more housing and more attractive housing throughout the rest of the region. As Geoffrey Nunberg recently commented icily, Palo Alto is a wonderful place to raise a car (and PA is positively urban compared to much of the greater, or should I say, worser, Silicon Valley). While much of SF is limited to heights of 3 stories, the Valley is, with very, very few scattered exceptions, one. Accepting that it is in fact part of a larger megapolis and acting like it would be a net benefit.

Too would be for employers to locate to other locations accessible via transit. Oakland, Berkeley, Emeryville, and other stops along BART have the benefit of a commute system with high levels of service and a broad collection region. And yet the bulk of tech jobs continue to be located either along the 101 corridor (a hellhole), in the South Bay, or, increasingly, in San Francisco. With the exception of the last, transit is a barely viable option, and even within SF, unless you're in the dense cores (again: downtown, SOMA, Mission), access to what transit there is down the Peninsula is highly limited. The dedicated company shuttles are an extremely appropriate response to the situation, and the outrage against them wholly misplaced.

Is this a bubble? Probably. Are some of the new arrivals annoying and socially maladroit? Quite. Does that change any of my commentary? No.

San Francisco isn't the only region faced with high housing costs: New York, London, and Mumbai all have similar (and arguably worse) challenges. There are many parts of the world, and numerous of those within the US, which would love to have these problems. Addressing the situation rationally, unfortunately, seems difficult to impossible, and sadly many of the tantrum-throwing children (on all sides of the issue) draw the most attention. Shame on the media for that.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lambdaphage on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:54PM (#7087655)
I'm pretty confused about how shuttle buses became the preferred metonymy for corporate evil. As if replacing each bus with twenty cars would make SF a better place for anyone?
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by patio11 on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:31AM (#7088064)
My theory for this is that Google is essentially a functioning welfare state which is geographically co-located with a dysfunctioning welfare state. If it weren't the Google bus it would be the Google food kitchens, the Google social insurance, the Google healthcare, the Google subsidized apartments, the Google free education, etc etc.

Nothing so frustrating to hear that your dream polity has been realized in your town and you're not invited.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by ahomescu1 on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:35AM (#7088222)
I'm not sure I'd call Google a "welfare state". They're not really tolerant of slackers, if you stop pulling your weight then you're out in the street.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by patio11 on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:46AM (#7088262)
Among the type of people who think "'welfare state' describes the kind of society I wish to live in", welfare state does not mean "we pay people to be slackers", it means "we have fairly robust systems for preventing the vagaries of life from materially impacting our citizens."

n.b. Not to infringe upon the HN politics rule but, for avoidance of doubt, the above does not describe my personal politics.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by shalmanese on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:02AM (#7087984)
I'm pretty confused about how shuttle buses became the object of ire given that, from my perspective, it seems like most of the growth is being driven by startups now preferring SF as their home base of operation rather than bussed employees to south bay companies.

AirBNB, Dropbox, Twitter, Uber etc are all thousand people companies and almost all of the employees live in SF.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by wmf on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:00AM (#7087672)
The theory is that without buses Silicon Valley employees would stay in the valley, causing less competition for housing. Of course, this theory ignores all the tech companies with offices in San Francisco.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lambdaphage on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:12AM (#7087704)
Not to mention the 70% of Silicon Valley workers in the linked study (http://www.sfbg.com/politics/2014/01/15/study-30-percent-tec...) [note: figure comes from self-reports] who would stay and presumably commute by car.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by supersystem on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:25AM (#7087749)
I'm not sure that's the core of the issue so much as disappointment over the tech companies preserving the status quo making it easy for those in power to avoid the issues.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by gruseom on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:56PM (#7087658)
Perhaps because there's such a clear symmetry with public transport.

Symbolism has its own logic, and the thing that becomes emblematic usually is not the most important one physically or rationally.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by bluekeybox on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:56PM (#7087660)
You are using logic. Stop where you are.
[deleted]
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lambdaphage on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:15AM (#7087713)
If you believe an argument to be unsound, you can point out the error. That is one of many advantages arguments have over rhetorical questions.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by supersystem on Monday January 20, 2014 @05:32AM (#7088739)
I did.

"replacing each bus with twenty cars"

You assume that either is this solution or no solution, which isn't necessarily true. In fact I would argue that this proprietary solution makes other solutions less viable. Both from a political and economic standpoint, with less pressure on the government and less usage for any public solution.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lambdaphage on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:06AM (#7088851)
I anticipate this reply here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7088378
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by IvyMike on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:39AM (#7088083)
There is an argument that "shared pain" is the foundation of community within a city.

And by avoiding the pain of commuting, the shuttle riders raise the ire of everyone who does have that pain.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by batbomb on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:50AM (#7088106)
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lambdaphage on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:09AM (#7088378)
I appreciate this link. I read it through, but I'm afraid it doesn't really present much of a case for... whatever it is Solnit wants to do about housing policy in SF, besides sneer at tech workers. I found the piece frustratingly long on vague innuendo and ressentiment, and short on arguments about what we ought to value, and how we ought to achieve it.

Many of her arguments, such as they are, seem to follow backwards from the desired conclusion that tech workers are awful and their employers, even worse. For example, consider:

> The Google Bus means so many things. It means that the minions of the non-petroleum company most bent on world domination can live in San Francisco but work in Silicon Valley without going through a hair-raising commute by car ... the corporations of Silicon Valley aren’t much interested in improving public transport, and in fact the many corporations providing private transport are undermining the financial basis for the commuter train.

Of course, if the companies didn't organize shuttle buses, then they'd be accused of ruining the environment by letting their employees drive nine hours every day. "How come the most powerful corporations in the world can't shell out for a shuttle bus", you can just imagine the author asking. Furthermore, suppose Google et al. did lobby California for a fifty mile commuter rail project from SF to SV that serves practically no one but... Google et al.'s employees. Headline: Greedy Corporations Buy Off Transit Authority for Tech Nerd Express, Shift Costs to Public. In general, I'm a big fan of public transit because I think it's a situation where collective action can often improve efficiency. But arguing that Google is destroying civil society by not 'heightening the contradictions' in order to get the transit authority to build a railway to nowhere is kind of rich.

Solnit's discussion of rent control is also pretty amazing. She punctuates her (completely understandable) complaints about the rental market with astonishment that the textbook unintended consequences of rent control persist despite rent control, never considering that they might be due to rent control. Prospective tenants supplicating to landlords, live-in couples occupying two units just to lock in tenancy, landlords dis-preferring long-term tenants, the overall lack of response in the housing supply to demand; these are classic symptoms which noted conservative Paul Krugman diagnoses in the article I linked elsewhere in this thread. If someone wants to write a piece in LRB defending rent control in SF, I'd sincerely like to read it. But you have to argue for it, not simply assume the desirability of a policy which is practically unanimously opposed by the people who study it professionally.

Finally, although I'm of mixed mind about whether I even want to indulge this line of thought, I find it pretty stunning that someone with Solnit's pedigree (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebecca_Solnit#Early_life_and_e...) presumes to speak for the poor and downtrodden, those "more frail", in a first-person piece called "Diary". It's the same sort of tenor you find on flyers like this one (http://25.media.tumblr.com/3fd37355541474385f8db330e58ebb0f/...). The author, who fancies themselves immersed in "poverty, homelessness and death..violence and degradation", makes it painfully obvious that they have at least one liberal arts degree.

From what I've read so far, it seems to me like the "opponents"* of tech workers in the bay area are basically the cultural ancien regime, upset about losing their cool digs and relative status to a bunch of nerds (Solnit is pretty explicit about this). If that's what this is about, I wish they'd just say it. And if they're genuinely concerned about the legitimately poor,* they should recommend serious proposals, and would probably have the support of many of the "technocrats" Solnit so despises. But mixing and matching leaves me short on both pathos and policy.

---

* I use scare quotes because I still don't understand what they want to do about tech workers in SF, except disdain them so hard. Which, have at it...

* * A group that, by the way, has practically zero intersection with the set of people to whom it would occur to hand out passive-aggressive, Flesch-Kincaided-out typeset essays concluding with "GET THE FUCK OUT OF OAKLAND"

* * * I also suspect I am less outraged than Solnit is that a man cannot make a living as the almost-Poet-Laureate of San Francisco, and must find a cheaper place. I'm not making this up.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by batbomb on Monday January 20, 2014 @11:30AM (#7090288)
Oh, I agree completely. I largely mentioned her and that piece because, AFAIK, she was the actual progenitor of this idea that the busses are The symbol of disparity, suggesting even that they should be protested against. I mean, the busses aren't anything new. At best, they've been really annoying, but this whole outrage thing was born in 2013, not 2012 or even 2010.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by cllns on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:42AM (#7088088)
> It is a free country, right? People are still free to live anywhere they can pay the rent, right?

That's true, if you're white.

http://www.propublica.org/series/living-apart

http://www.urban.org/publications/410821.html

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by mooreds on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:06AM (#7087692)
Cached version for those who are getting a database connection error: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:S1lWjQ6...
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by ps4fanboy on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:58AM (#7088607)
As a foreigner rent control seems like a bizarre concept in a capitalist country even more bizarre that its america.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by Semiapies on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:02AM (#7087676)
Maybe tech companies don't have to live in overpriced, overhyped coastal cities.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lolwutf on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:21AM (#7087738)
Fun fact: San Francisco is one of the few places where it's cheaper to live near the ocean, than it is to live inland!

That is, 'coastal' is irrelevant to your point.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by Semiapies on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:20AM (#7087884)
Not going by any of the prices I can find for San Fran.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by bmelton on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:48AM (#7088271)
http://www.trulia.com/for_sale/San_Francisco,CA/37.719154916...

Looking at that, the adage seems to hold true -- prices appear to fall off as you radiate away from the heart of the city. There's even a 1BR/1BA near the ocean by the USS San Francisco Memorial for $425k.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by Semiapies on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:38PM (#7091367)
So we're pretending moving a few miles inland is not living on the two major US coasts.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by lolwutf on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @02:14AM (#7093886)
Based on the urban layout and population distribution within the city, yes, those are two distinct regions.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by asveikau on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:07AM (#7087696)
When the non-coastal cities have the same job prospects, the same thing will happen to them.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by Semiapies on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:40PM (#7091378)
No, there's far too much cachet to living on the East or West coasts.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by aspensmonster on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:37AM (#7087933)
Edit: In the time it has taken to write this up, this article is now ranked 51 and is well on its way to the third page. Mods, go fuck yourselves.

> Maybe tech companies don't have to live in overpriced, overhyped coastal cities.

It's the tech companies that made those cities overpriced. The same problems will crop up in any city that attracts a sizable enough contingent of high-paid work. Hell, it's happening to my hometown of Austin as we speak. Throngs of transplants, eager for high-paying work at whatever tech or energy company is calling, take a look at the cost of living reports for Austin and think they've found a match from heaven. They pack up their bags and move, thinking that somehow, Austin won't succumb to the maladies of its predecessors.

But property investors aren't stupid. They start buying up real estate left and right for ten percent over the asking price. Sellers are ecstatic. Owners give considerable thought to joining the sellers and renting elsewhere off of the proceeds. Everyone along the financial chain sees the bandwagon and rents and mortgages rise. The investors and sellers know the money is out there for the taking. And that's all well and good for those with the money. Moving from expensive San Francisco or NYC to Austin leaves you sitting pretty in Austin's (historically) lower costs of living, even if the house you purchase would have gone for 15 or 20 percent less 5 years ago.

But everyone else gets squeezed. Slowly of course. Rent rises like it does every year, but since it's a seller's market, there's no apartment complex to hit up for the same rent you were paying. If you're leasing, your landlord is giving serious thought to adding three or four or five or six hundred dollars a month to his bank account. It doesn't matter that you can't pay; there's a waiting list of interested parties that can. It doesn't matter that you want to stay in a neighborhood with decent schools so your children can have a shot at a better life; the people on the list want that too and have no problem outpricing you. Your paycheck hasn't really risen. The two percent COL raise might have broken even before but it sure doesn't now (assuming you were fortunate enough to even have a COL raise). Traffic has always sucked, but now it's sucking like it's trying to get a golf ball through a garden hose.

The tech and energy workers don't see these problems. They can afford whatever price increases come their way. It's the supermajority of citizens that don't work in office buildings off 360 or MoPac that have to deal with these problems. And when they rightfully insist on nipping this gentrification in the bud, when they fight to prevent Austin from cannibalizing itself into the next Silicon Valley, they get told with a straight face that they aren't "entitled" to their homeland and must step aside so the affluent can have their fun.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by blazespin on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:59AM (#7088132)
" They’re just individual people that learned a very boring but high-paying skill," Wait, what?
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by jasonkester on Monday January 20, 2014 @07:41AM (#7089172)
Other people finding your dream job to be boring is benefit.

The less people who choose to compete for the ludicrously overpaid, relatively straightforward knowledge work that is so much in demand at the moment, the more of it you and me get to break off for ourselves, and the more people will be willing to pay us to do so.

Good thing we can stand the boredom, but it's a living, eh?

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by ahomescu1 on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:33AM (#7088211)
Programming probably seems boring to the author; it's sad he/she generalizes like this (the article link didn't work for me, so I don't know who wrote it).
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by peferron on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:42AM (#7088540)
From the sidebar: "ALEX CASTLE is a writer, musician, filmmaker, editor, husband, father, and hand model based in Brooklyn."

Given his profile I'm not suprised he's not interested in programming, but the jump to suggesting that the activity itself is inherently boring is hilarious.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by imsofuture on Monday January 20, 2014 @10:26AM (#7089918)
This whole debate sounds as if they'd just invented gentrification. I'm having a hard time mustering outrage for anyone involved.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by aspensmonster on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:06AM (#7088364)
And now we are at #111 on page four. Slow clap.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by calcsam on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:23PM (#7087557)
1400 for a 2br in Glen Park? Good luck getting that for 2000 today...
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:53PM (#7087651)
Glen Park doesn't really have apartments; 99% of its residential buildings are houses.

If someone's advertising an apartment as "Glen Park" it's almost certainly going to turn out to actually be in Sunnyside or Diamond Heights.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by kchoudhu on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:32AM (#7087916)
2K for a 2 bedroom. Man, maybe I should move from NY to SF.