News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by potatolicious on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:36AM (#7088228)
Because San Francisco greatly perceives itself, and desperately wants to remain, as a small friendly hamlet of sorts. It wants to have its cake and eat it too: the prestige and economy of a world city, and the friendliness and pleasantness of a small town.

Because also San Francisco perceives itself as radical - this is true both in SF tech and outside of it - and perceives mass urbanization as symptom of all that is stodgy, traditional, and old (see: Chicago, New York City, London, etc).

"Manhattanization" is a pejorative with no defense in the city - "being like New York" is anathema to a large number of people, and suggesting that SF should be like other skyward cities is immediately painting a giant bulls-eye on your own head and a guarantee that you'll never be a meaningful participant in civic discourse.

In simple words, SF hates skyward-building because its worst fear is becoming New York City.

To answer your questions more directly:

- The city government, in response to voter demand, opposes most development outside of the downtown core, where there are actually plenty of tall buildings (almost entirely commercial). As a (shitty) compromise they've marked out a section of previously underdeveloped light industry just south of downtown for active development. This is where most of the action is. It's also not connected to mass transit, and there's currently an expensive project underway to build a brand new subway line to connect this area of town. This, despite other parts of SF being underdeveloped and already accessible to transit.

- The population of San Francisco, and this includes the techies, loudly opposes dense developments. San Francisco is well known for its picturesque neighborhoods of colorful old Victorian houses. The long-time residents are loathe to see this disappear in favor of mid-rises or high-rises, and the wealthy newcomers are loathe to lose what is an aesthetic gain. Neither side seems willing to admit that the price of their aesthetic preference comes directly out of their pocket book. Proposals to knock these houses down in favor of denser housing are opposed across the board and across the wealth spectrum.

All of this is official policy: http://www.sf-planning.org/ftp/General_Plan/index.htm - specifically this one: "That existing housing and neighborhood character be conserved and protected in order to preserve the cultural and economic diversity of our neighborhoods;"

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by buro9 on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:03AM (#7088351)
But yet there are great examples of cities that allow building, have increased the heights of buildings, and maintain the character of the city. Paris springs to mind, as does Edinburgh.

So long as "character" isn't defined as "3 stories", it should be possible to build to 6 stories whilst maintaining façades, retail space, etc and yet doubling available space and improving the standard of housing that exists (oh man, that dodgy wiring in every place in Mission I've ever stayed).

Do the residents realise the connection between scarcity and price, and that they are able to do something about it?

From the stuff that appears on here, it seems that there is a lot of anger against large companies but little reflection that the root imbalance in supply is caused by policies set by the population (or at least, in their name).

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by timr on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:01AM (#7088836)
"Do the residents realise the connection between scarcity and price, and that they are able to do something about it?"

There's some truth to the parent comment (I've said parts of it myself), but it's also misleading. Yes, the city could stand to build up in places, but the people in the tech world are also totally delusional when it comes to choosing where to live and work. Everyone is trying to cram into the same three hipster neighborhoods, and ignoring all of the cheaper parts of town. Price sensitivity is almost completely absent.

Notably, when people here talk about "bungalows" and "three-story buildings", what they're really talking about is the western half of the city (the part west of Mount Sutro). It's true that those neighborhoods are really low density, but it's also true that rents there are already much lower than in SOMA or the Mission. You can move to the Richmond and save hundreds of dollars a month in rent, but nobody wants to do that.

There are good reasons for all of this, of course (transit, weather, etc.), but the point is that it isn't just "zoning laws" that are causing prices to spike here. There's good deal of irrationality on the demand side, too. You'd be surprised at the number of tech people who have never even visited neighborhoods like West Portal, even though they're on major transit lines. If it's not hip in San Francisco, it doesn't exist.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by malandrew on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:55PM (#7090796)

    "Everyone is trying to cram into the same three hipster 
    neighborhoods, and ignoring all of the cheaper parts of 
    town."
Those three hipster neighborhoods are probably the way they are because of their great access to public transit not only for traveling within the city but getting out of it via BART. No one ones to move to SF and live in a neighborhood with a suburban lifestyle that requires a car to maximize life's experiences.

Living in places like the Richmond and the Sunset for example are more isolating than living in Oakland. Living at the top of most of San Francisco's hills is relatively isolating as well. Furthermore, hills aren't conducive to human-powered transportation like biking and skateboarding. Being able to quickly move around via the power of your own two feet via walking, pedaling or pushing is one of the draws of all cities. Every relatively flat neighborhood with great transportation is destined to gentrify.

If you put a BART line under the Geary and California bus routes, all the neighborhoods in the far west would "hipsterfy" as well

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by timr on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:00PM (#7091163)
Yes, as I said, there are reasons that these neighborhoods are popular. Another reason is the weather: the Mission and SOMA tend to be sunnier than the rest of the city. These features, in a rational world, demand a certain price premium. But the outer neighborhoods have nice features, too (e.g. they have less filth and crime, and more nature), so there's a trade-off.

That said, complaints about being "isolated" in the Sunset is mostly a lot of butthurt. The entire city of San Francisco is seven miles wide. There is literally no part of this city that could be considered "isolated", unless your definition of "the city" begins and ends in the Mission. And I say that as someone who lives without a car -- there are rail lines that run to the Sunset, West Portal, Glen Park, Ocean View and so on. You're maybe 30 minutes away from downtown, at most. Still, ask a 20-something coder to consider living in the Inner Sunset, and you'd think you'd asked him to move to North Dakota.

No, the real problem is that most of the people flooding into SF are wealthy 20-somethings who will pay nearly any price to live right in the middle of the hippest entertainment districts in the city. They don't want to live near icky married people and children, they don't want to travel more than ten minutes to meet their friends for a drink, and they definitely don't want to go up or down any hills to get anywhere. There are basically two neighborhoods in the city that meet these constraints, and in both, rents are skyrocketing.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:55AM (#7089767)
> the people in the tech world are also totally delusional when it comes to choosing where to live and work. Everyone is trying to cram into the same three hipster neighborhoods

What's delusional about deciding a particular neighborhood is nice enough to merit its higher rent? Just because you have a different opinion from the people who live there regarding what they should spend their money on doesn't mean they're delusional.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by timr on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:39PM (#7091055)
It's delusional because the demand for real estate in these neighborhoods appears to be almost perfectly inelastic. People don't even think about moving anywhere else in the city, even when the cost/benefit equation tips in favor of living in another location.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:54PM (#7091140)
The equation is different for each person. It sounds like it's tipped for you, but not them.

Therefore, just because you make different decisions than they do, it doesn't mean either of you is deciding irrationally.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by xster on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @07:37PM (#7099777)
Argument's kinda extensible to say Huston is both cheap and well equipped as a city but neither them or you or I are in Huston. It's a bit of a stretch to say to wanting to live in areas with desirable weather is delusional.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:36AM (#7089682)
The key differences between Paris and SF in this regard are:

1. In Paris, nobody has a chip on their shoulder about a nearby larger city. In SF, sour grapes about all the attention NY and LA get led long ago to our population pretending they don't want to be a big city. (Even though now it's actually within our reach)

2. In SF, a large number of people drive everywhere but live in garageless houses -- or they have single-car garages but own multiple cars. They resist building because they don't want to compete for existing parking spaces.

3. SF lacks a decent underground train system, so anything that puts more cars on the road is hotly resisted, and people believe that a garageless building next to a train station will be filled with new car owners.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by zimpenfish on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:03AM (#7088844)
Budapest is a good example - lots of 5/6 story apartment blocks right in the centre with (what seem to be) huge numbers of apartments and they look ok.
Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by raldi on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:10AM (#7089535)
> The population of San Francisco, and this includes the techies, loudly opposes dense developments.

Not the techies I know. In my experience, the vast majority of SF techies want high-density housing near excellent transit.

Re:San Francisco Is Eating Itself by malandrew on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:58PM (#7090818)
I was thinking the same. I can't think of one techie that thinks this way to be honest. The only ones that come close to thinking this way aren't anti-urbanization, but sit right in between both sides because they just don't care since they've made enough money to buy property and be insulated from the problems.