News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by DanBC on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @02:56PM (#6923492)
> Because while he was playing his little game, to "prove" that police profile people and to "prove" that getting arrested and jailed can be a violent and unfair experience, someone else was getting away with a purse snatching, or beating up an ex-girlfriend, or playing the knock-out game, or emptying a cash register.

You're missing the point that police profiling is already focusing attention on people not committing those crimes, or that plenty of people are getting away with the same behaviour but not facing any consequences for their actions.

Police stop and search someone because that person is black - they're missing the real crook.

Police don't take actions against white kids - they're missing real crooks.

> I found myself spending most of my time prosecuting people of color for things we white kids did with impunity growing up in the suburbs. As our office handed down arrest records and probation terms for riding dirt bikes in the street, cutting through a neighbor’s yard, hosting loud parties, fighting, or smoking weed – shenanigans that had rarely earned my own classmates anything more than raised eyebrows and scoldings

Whether these crimes deserve any police attention is something that could be discussed, but surely we can agree that prosecuting black kids but not white kids is something that drives inequality in society?

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:12PM (#6923599)
I agree with the general point, but "riding dirt bikes in the street" is possibly not as innocent as it may seem.

In rural areas riding dirt bikes on the street might conjure up images of a couple of brothers tearing around a few fields, generally making a mess but ultimately just doing it to have fun. In cities however there is often (by no means always, but often) something else going on.

At least in Philadelphia, gangs use dirt-bikes and 4-wheelers to 'patrol their turf' and flee the police (who are largely powerless to stop them, as they travel in groups of 10 or more, and all split the second a cop turns his lights on). In these instances it isn't harmless fun, they are basically neo-'biker gangs'. It is a big problem in north and west Philadelphia.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by stingraycharles on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:09PM (#6924331)
Over here in The Netherlands, about 10 years ago, there was a lot of commotion about a group of white supremacy-gangs wearing Lonsdale bomberjacks, and people wearing those were banned from certain clubs, etc.

According to your logic, in this case, everyone wearing a Lonsdale bomberjack would have to be arrested, and they would have to be banned by law? Isn't that outlawing the symptom, instead of outlawing the actual problem?

EDIT: Apparently this was not just an issue in The Netherlands, but more widespread: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/germany/147...

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:25PM (#6924423)
> "According to your logic, in this case, everyone wearing a Lonsdale bomberjack would have to be arrested, and they would have to be banned by law? Isn't that outlawing the symptom, instead of outlawing the actual problem?"

What? No. Just no.

It may be different in the Netherlands, but in the US riding dirtbikes on public streets is illegal. The bikes themselves are not street legal. The bikes don't have plates, turn signals, mirrors or horns. They are not registered with the DMV. In Pennsylvania they are wildly in violation of noise laws for motorcycles (they drown out conversations indoors when they pass on the streets). Totally unlicensed and almost certainly therefore uninsured (which is again illegal). Riding bikes of any sort in gangs is further illegal, breaking all sorts of traffic laws.

This going after dirt-bike riders is not about going after a symptom or superficial attribute of some other crime. It is the crime. It is the actual problem.

If I were saying "go after cars with spinney wheels" (which are perfectly legal) or "go after people wearing only red or blue" (which is perfectly legal) then your comparison would be apt, but that is not what is going on here.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by evan_ on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:37PM (#6924477)
You might want to just clarify since I could imagine it being a regional language issue- a "Dirt bike" is a type of off-road motorcycle, not a human-powered bicycle.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:46PM (#6924529)
Ah, good point. A dirt-bike is basically a stripped down off-road motorcycle. Fast, loud, and cheap.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by andybak on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:40PM (#6924795)
That clarifies it for me. I was imagining a bicycle.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by adestefan on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:54PM (#6924563)
A motocross bike would be a good term.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by vacri on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:29PM (#6924750)
The article's comment in context is that in his previous experience as a prosecutor, urban blacks were doing the same thing he was as a youth, yet the outcomes were different.

We don't have to invent scenarios to explain away the different results - they are his experience as a prosecutor and he has identified them as being identical. It's not an account from a newspaper where we don't know the details; it's cases he has personally worked on, and hence knows the intimate details we never hear of.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:35PM (#6924776)
This comment is essentially the same as another, this reply applies equally here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6924774

TL;DR: I think the writer is either somehow unaware of the issues with dirtbikes in cities (unlikely), or is banking on his audience being unaware of the problem. Either way, I think he is being disingenuous. I do not believe he actually got away with that sort of thing as a teenager.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by vacri on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:58PM (#6924878)
Because a blanket statement saying that "[non-criminal] riding dirtbikes in a city is clearly antisocial behaviour that needs to end" isn't being disingenuous?
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @07:48PM (#6925079)
There is no such thing as "[non-criminal] dirt-bike riding in cities". Riding dirt-bikes in cities in the US is illegal. People who do it are breaking numerous traffic and road laws.

Asserting that doing this is anti-social is hardly disingenuous.

Even if it were legal, the noise pollution alone would make it unquestionably anti-social as far as I am concerned. I'd rather have tractor trailers using jake brakes in my neighborhood, that's how unreasonably loud these bikes are.

(In case there is a misunderstanding here: dirt-bikes are stripped down light-weight motorcycles meant for off-road use only. They are not street legal. Similar I believe to a motocross bike.)

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by vacri on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @07:22PM (#6932042)
I guess my real problem was you calling the author disingenuous, when the author specifically identified 'riding dirt bikes on the streets in the suburbs' and you explained this away to actually being 'riding dirt bikes in paddocks in rural areas'. The author's point is that this was the same crime, but suburban whites were not pursued for it - and you're saying "it's not the same crime, the whites were riding around on farms, not streets".
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by DanBC on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @08:01AM (#6927264)
This bit of cultural knowledge is important.

I was thinking of dirtbikes as their UK equivalent. Here, youth ride scooters / mopeds and some of them are styled as like dirtbikes. And there are probably road legal dirt bikes of more than 125 cc.

The gang context is also really important.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by mtrimpe on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:25PM (#6923671)
That seems besides the point in this case though since the author himself describes these as 'shenanigans that had rarely earned my own classmates anything more than raised eyebrows and scoldings.'
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:37PM (#6923769)
To be clear, I don't think what I am saying detracts from the authors point, I just find it plausible that specifically the dirt-bike related arrests/fines/probations were legitimate.

The author probably was not in a dirt-bike biker gang when he was a kid, as far as I know that phenomenon is new.

(And honestly, I am surprised that the police were able to catch any of them in the first place. Chasing them down city streets would be extremely dangerous...)

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by lhc- on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:16PM (#6924675)
The writer was(is) a prosecutor. These aren't hypothetical cases, these are actual things he experience and actual cases he tried. If it were a bunch of kids in a gang riding bikes to terrorize a neighborhood, I think he is probably the person most likely to be aware of that and the differences from his youth. I'm not sure you can challenge his authority on the matter and argue he just doesn't know whats really going on considering his position as part of the criminal justice system.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:34PM (#6924774)
The writer is interested in pushing a narrative (one that I happen to support, just so that we are clear here). The dirt bike thing is slipped in with some other clearly unreasonable stuff, but I fear he is either stretching with the dirt bike example to pad out that section, or is aware of the problem but is giving those kids the benefit of the doubt an assuming that they had nothing to do with the dirt bike gangs.

Even if those kids had nothing to do with those gangs, riding dirt-bikes in a city is clearly anti-social behavior that needs to end. If there is a racial bias in the enforcement of those laws, that needs to end too, and the white kids need the book thrown at them too for it, but I really don't believe that the author use to get away with riding dirt bikes around in cities. That isn't standard teenager shenanigans.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by cullenking on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @07:34PM (#6925026)
This is the problem with black and white statements, there's always someone ready to jump in and prove there's middle ground. I am a well off white male and I've ridden a beaten up old dirt bike in the street plenty of times. Why? Because I like to ride off road, but you don't get to do that without tune ups, repairs etc. During riding season I am sure I annoyed neighbors with a weekly ten minute ride around a few blocks (and a large abandoned lot in my old city neighborhood). I even skip the helmet often during this so I can hear sounds as I diagnose a problem.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @07:51PM (#6925092)
If you were doing that in a city, I think it would be more than reasonable for cops throwing the book at you. In underpopulated areas the concept of there being a victim starts to disappear, but you still should not be doing that.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by cullenking on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @08:47PM (#6925379)
"throw the book at you" should be applied to non-victimless crimes, not things that you just don't like or agree with. Misdemeanor? Ridiculous. Moving violation with a fine? That's fine, I accept the consequences of my actions when they are proportionate to the action.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by DanBC on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:56PM (#6924579)
Yes, some youth riding dirt bikes will be gang members, and something needs to be done about that.

What the percentages are is up for discussion. The usefulness of taking a gang member and making it even harder for them to get employment is something that needs to be discussed.

Gangs are a symptom of other problems. Tackling gangs without tackling those other problems seems odd to me.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by sean-duffy on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:44PM (#6924509)
Not only this, but it's also very dangerous and intimidating. More than once here in the UK I've been faced with yobs riding dirt bikes at very high speeds in pedestrianised areas or on paths in public parks. The people who do it have no consideration for the safety of those around them, and often drive close by people on purpose just to scare them.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by adestefan on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:52PM (#6924554)
This was also an issue in Baltimore recently.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:55PM (#6924575)
Yeah, I've personally seen it in Philadelphia, and heard about it in Baltimore and NYC. I've yet to hear about anything like it in Seattle though.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by sitkack on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @08:34PM (#6925324)
Give me a cross street and I will burn some donuts in ur lawn.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by placeybordeaux on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @12:30AM (#6926073)
To put this into context there is a documentary coming out about dirt bikes and 4-wheelers in Baltimore.

http://12oclockboys.com/

I have personally gotten fairly close to hitting a 4 wheeler in ATL and see gangs of them roaming my neighborhood. It seemed to me like they were just having a good time, certainly disturbing the peace and creating dangerous road conditions though. Then again that isn't all too unusual in my neighborhood.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Yourfags on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:49PM (#6923848)
then how do you apply that law to everyone? only white people can ride dirt bikes? only people not in gangs can? the arrest should be for riding dirt bikes in a gang then, because part of the burden of the law is making it clear what it stands for
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Crito on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:57PM (#6923905)
Obviously everybody should be busted for riding dirt bikes in cities, particularly in gangs (riding in gangs inherently means that several other traffic laws are being broken as well, and when they scatter when police try to stop them you throw in all sorts of additional crimes...)

In unpopulated areas? I'm sure the local police have methlabs to worry about, but sure, arrest them too if they ride on the street or trespass.

I am not saying that a racial discrepancy in enforcement is acceptable. I am just saying that the police taking issue with somebody riding around the city on a dirt bike is not necessarily the police making a mountain out of a molehill. If they are arresting only black people that do this, then the problem is that they are not also arresting white people that do it.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by at-fates-hands on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:35PM (#6923745)
>>> Whether these crimes deserve any police attention is something that could be discussed, but surely we can agree that prosecuting black kids but not white kids is something that drives inequality in society?

Except when you take into account blacks commit far more crime than whites:

"According to the FBI Uniform Crime Reports, in the year 2008 black youths, who make up 16% of the youth population, accounted for 52% of juvenile violent crime arrests, including 58.5% of youth arrests for homicide and 67% for robbery."

Also keep in mind, these are usually not black on white crimes, but usually black on black crimes. It would foolish to think we should simply start prosecuting more white people simply because there is some form of perceived inequality in the justice system.

Perhaps instead of focusing on the fact more blacks end up in the system (when its already too late), maybe we should take a harder look at WHY they end up in the system and work on preventing them from ever getting there in the first place.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by reginaldjcooper on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:39PM (#6923784)
LOL your argument against black people being targeted for arrests is percent of arrests as proof of black people "committing more crimes"? Holy shit it's like an Onion article came to comment.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by blisterpeanuts on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @04:27PM (#6924093)
The reality is that for some types of crimes, African Americans, especially 18-39 year-old-males, are over represented. For example, roughly half the 32,000 gun homicides annually are committed by black males (see bjs.gov for the numbers). (Most of their victims are also black.) Most white gun deaths are from suicides. Latinos are also high up on this unfortunate list.

These numbers aren't made-up or based on biased arrest patterns; they're pretty much reality, sad but true.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by ThomPete on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @04:59PM (#6924263)
No but there are reasons why these numbers are high for them and they are as much to do with how society treats them and what their prospects with regards to making it are.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by bullseye on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:40PM (#6924493)
How is this argument any different than the absurd Affluenza argument that gained popularity this week? Successful/great people rise above all kinds of adversity and come from all sorts of backgrounds. Criminals likewise span every demographic in the U.S. The "poor" in our country live an order of magnitude better than many in the world and some of our most affluent groups have some of the highest suicide rates.

I don't even know what my point was anymore... I just get so tired of hearing everyone blame everyone else except themselves for the directions of their lives.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Guvante on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:19PM (#6924694)
> Successful/great people rise above all kinds of adversity and come from all sorts of backgrounds.

Bullshit, almost every rags to riches story has a "And I got lucky and _____" it isn't someone overcoming adversity, it is luck that got their talent noticed. I am not saying those who face hardship don't have talent, just saying it rarely gets noticed due to biases.

> Criminals likewise span every demographic in the U.S.

The poor are extremely more likely to commit crimes. You have to exclude economic factors or you cannot compare anything about crime, it is that large of an impact. Heck the "black problem" you list is 90% due to being poor much more often than other groups.

> The "poor" in our country live an order of magnitude better than many in the world

Pointless argument. Let me turn it around on you. The poor don't have to worry about starving to death nearly as much as elsewhere, but because of this they have a ton of spare time. How many things can you do that are illegal and are entertaining + cheap? I bet you can make a long list. This could just as easily be used to explain why being poor is a bigger problem in the US when using the level of logic this thread is using.

> I just get so tired of hearing everyone blame everyone else except themselves for the directions of their lives.

Are we talking about one singular person? Take the OP, he never claims he shouldn't have been treated as a criminal, his only complaints are that he should have been able to see his family, and he shouldn't have gotten 3 years parole for a non-violent offense.

Are we talking about a group, like poor blacks? You can't blame individual things like this for an entire population, it doesn't make sense. We aren't saying Johnny didn't go to college because he is poor, we are saying the poor on average go to college this much less, which for these reasons is because they are poor.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by encoderer on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @11:43PM (#6925955)
Regarding only your first point... I can't agree with that.

Aside from the lotto and other truly marginal edge cases, I'd say that hard work is not sufficient for success but it is required.

That is, if you take 100 successful people, you'll have 100 who needed some luck to get where they are. And of those, you'll have 99 who also had to work their ass off.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by ThomPete on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @08:37AM (#6927380)
Many people work hard and never make it.

Many people build great products and never make it.

Many people build a great business but it doesn't last.

Luck doesn't determine whether you are able to make it but it does often have a lot to do with whether you get the chance.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by WalterBright on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:12PM (#6931601)
If you don't work hard, don't build great products, and don't build a great business, you aren't giving luck much of a chance to help you.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by ThomPete on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @08:36PM (#6932339)
If you have a great business you are by definition successful so that makes no sense.

With regards to the other sure but none of them will guarantee you a great business.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by Guvante on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @01:21PM (#6929373)
My apologies, I did not at all mean to imply the opposite of that. Hard work is certainly required to succeed.

However most people talking about the American dream are talking about it being sufficient, which is what I was talking against.

Statistically you don't get lucky and get rich (guess what happens to lottery winners a year after they win most the time?) and you rarely work hard and get rich. You can get a little lucky and live a good life working hard, and you can get really lucky, work really hard, and get rich.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by ThomPete on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:25PM (#6924727)
Well that is your problem that you are sick and tired of it. It is pretty well established though that if you live in a poor black community your chances of making it to middle class are many times lower than making it to jail.

Make of that what you want. Perhaps black people are just lazy, stupid? Is that your point? In that case I don't think we will agree on much in life.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by CreakyParrot on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @09:52PM (#6932593)
> It is pretty well established though that if you live in a

> poor black community your chances of making it to middle

> class are many times lower than making it to jail.

To what cause or causes do you attribute that?

> Make of that what you want.

I'd rather not make of that what I want; I'd rather try to determine the cause(s).

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by ThomPete on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @07:19PM (#6924963)
Compared to where? Denmark? Sweden? Norway?

You seem to be forgetting that the US system is based around money first and foremost.

If you have money you will be able to attend the right university.

Of course their social status is not the only reason but it's a big part of it and especially the fact that it's very hard to get out of your social-economic status. Add to that an industry that actually makes money when people go to jail and you have the perfect spiral.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by blisterpeanuts on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:15PM (#6924369)
Can you expand on your point a little? Does any other group behave this way because of "how society treats them"?
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by datphp on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:42PM (#6924813)
I'm white, from Switzerland.

The only time I experienced racism was taking a vacation in Spain, in a place where there are a lot of french tourists. They get a lot of hate, and me speaking french got me treated like one of them.

I'm a very laid back, cool guy, and I'm usually the last one to get angry. But being at a restaurant and being made fun of randomly by the waiter, and then wondering if someone spat in my food, and having this impression that everyone hated me for now reason...

It was a terrible feeling. But I knew the only reason they were like that was because of a misunderstanding. All I had to do was mentioning I was Swiss or speak Spanish and it would stop instantly.

Now if I had been french, and I had no way to defuse the situation, I can imagine how frustrating it would have been.

Then I can see how things being like that your whole life must feel, specially when its something that stands out as much as your skin color.

I've been extremely frustrated on rare occasions in my life, and I've done things I would never thought I would. Karma is a thing. If people give you shit without a good reason, you'll do the exact same, probably to someone else, just to balance things.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by ThomPete on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:23PM (#6924412)
No because society doesn't treat them that way.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by CreakyParrot on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @09:57PM (#6932606)
So there's only one group of people society treats badly? What about other demographic sets of people with higher-than-average crime rates?
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by nitrogen on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:50PM (#6923855)
I think you're misreading the symptom as the cause. What's claimed is that black people are arrested more, even if they don't commit more crimes. Thus, the statistics will not necessarily reflect reality, but rather the alleged bias in arrest and prosecution.

I agree with your final paragraph, though. We as a society have an obligation to try to correct all forms of injustice, whether it's biased enforcement and prosecution, cultural isolation, or financial immobility.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by bitlord_219 on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:56PM (#6923899)
> "According to the FBI Uniform Crime Reports, in the year 2008 black youths, who make up 16% of the youth population, accounted for 52% of juvenile violent crime arrests, including 58.5% of youth arrests for homicide and 67% for robbery."

Arrests. Not convictions, and certainly not "crimes perpetrated."

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by DanBC on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:10PM (#6924649)
> Perhaps instead of focusing on the fact more blacks end up in the system

...institutionally racist police officers arrest them for minor offences, and that arrest and conviction fucks any chance of employment, meaning that gangs are the only employer left?

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by reginaldjcooper on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:37PM (#6923774)
Yes, what I got from it was that they were irritated by this journalist for wasting their time when they could have been wasting their time targeting other innocent people. At least this way we got some investigative journalism out of it.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by blisterpeanuts on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:04PM (#6923549)
>>Whether these crimes deserve any police attention is something that could be discussed, but surely we can agree that prosecuting black kids but not white kids is something that drives inequality in society?

Yes, we can agree on that.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by rayiner on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:10PM (#6923589)
> but surely we can agree that prosecuting black kids but not white kids is something that drives inequality in society?

Only if we're punishing them under the same circumstances, which I don't agree is necessarily the case. I think we should punish someone who marks graffiti in order to mark gang territory or intimidate others more harshly than someone who does it as a prank.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by nitrogen on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:54PM (#6923886)
> Only if we're punishing them under the same circumstances, which I don't agree is necessarily the case. I think we should punish someone who marks graffiti in order to mark gang territory or intimidate others more harshly than someone who does it as a prank.

This feels like it should make sense, but I think misses the forest for the trees. It's an example what I'd refer to as first-order thinking, or looking only at the immediate situation.

We need to be striving for higher order thinking. That is, we need to be looking at follow-on effects, which I'll analogize to looking at the second and later derivatives of a function, or looking at other elements in an interconnected feedback system (in the control theory sense).

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by tedunangst on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @04:44PM (#6924169)
What does this even mean?

Is not asking whether the graffiti was intended to intimidate somebody considering the follow-on effects?

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by nitrogen on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @07:38PM (#6925039)
It's considering an immediately adjacent effect, sure. But we can take one more step back and look at a still wider context: what led to the tagger to be in the habit of tagging to begin with? What will happen to the tagger and their community in the long run if all taggers are punished with the full force of the law? Is there some other course of action that would lead to a better outcome for both the individual tagger and the community as a whole?
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by tedunangst on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:44PM (#6925575)
Like an after school chess club? What if the tagger chooses not to go?
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:58PM (#6925624)
> Like an after school chess club?

Sort of. How about an after school "chess club" where the kids who attend get free dinner, and there are a variety of educational activities to choose from in addition to chess? How about a free camp where you bus all the kids out to the nearest wilderness every weekend to learn archery and play sports, and the kids who attend don't have to worry about not having food and shelter for two days out of the week?

> What if the tagger chooses not to go?

Not all of them have to go. You don't have to solve the entire problem at the same time. And if it doesn't work, you keep trying things until something sticks.

The key point is that you need to be willing to spend the resources keeping kids out of jail that you would spend keeping them in jail.

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by lotharbot on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @11:37PM (#6925936)
> "How about an after school "chess club" where the kids who attend get free dinner"

These sorts of clubs exist in some places, such as in my school [0]. They include everything from tutoring to other academic activities to free meals to summer programs.

[0] http://www.bgcmd.org/clubs/beacon-neighborhood-centers

Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @03:04AM (#6926398)
You're rambling about math but I think based on your second paragraph, you should change the first paragraph to just "This makes sense" instead forest/tree stuff.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by chetanahuja on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:03PM (#6925429)
That's almost akin to instituting thought-crime. Wouldn't one actually need to commit those acts of intimidation (or some other harmful consequence thereof) before you decide they need a harsher punishment? Until that happens, a prank is a prank.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @03:07AM (#6926408)
I think if you looked into this problem, it's hardly thought crime in the sense you mean it.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by likeclockwork on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:22AM (#6926982)
Because if you're black you're in a gang and if you're white you're just joshing around.
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by melling on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:03PM (#6923541)
What solution are you proposing?
Re:I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice ... by DanBC on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @03:11PM (#6923595)
Ideally, treat drugs as the health problem they are, not a crime problem.

Stop putting people in jail or prison for minor offences.

Stop including weird restrictions in parole orders.

Stop making community service being about "punishment" and move it towards "rehabilitation", of the offender and of their area.