Not so gullible so as to take to heart what you're saying, considering that you created your account solely to deride her. Here we are, 70 days after your account was created, and yet you've only posted 1 comment that wasn't negatively criticizing her? And your only argument is a copy/paste of your original complaint from 70 days ago, all based off of source-control introspection?
I don't care if what you're saying is true or not, I think your behavior (an apparent personal vendetta) is the only sad thing here.
However, everything they brought up was already addressed 70 days ago. To be honest, petea raises a valid concern, and I certainly don't want to be party to shills or other types of fraudulent or deceptive activities, but considering that petea didn't even put forth the effort to further refine or follow-up on their original argument (especially given 70 additional data points [sites] with which to draw evidence from), then that signals to me that they have motivations beyond what meets the eye.
My biggest issue is stuff like this. Take a look at the JS from day 1-8, then look at day 9.
Day 8: http://jenniferdewalt.com/more_drop_shadow.html
Day 9: http://jenniferdewalt.com/bouncing_ball.html
That's a pretty massive jump in coding proficiency in a delta of one day.
This has nothing to do with marginalizing skill, it just seems like there was some outside help here, and that should probably be credited.
edit: I see a lot of different indent patterns on the JS as well. That kind of points me towards n different coders with at least two different text editor configs, or a good deal of copy->paste from SO.
This is pretty much a given. The delta from days 8 and 9 is "learned how to use named functions, learned that jQuery has plugins". That's not that much of a leap, but of course any student is going to be using external resources. You might notice that her goal was "make websites", not "hand-code everything".
This is how everyone learns. Copy-paste some code in without understanding it, watch it break, figure out how to fix it, repeat.
I don't think it's helpful to speculate as to whether she had someone in particular helping her throughout the lifetime of her project.
I suspect that if a similar project were done by a male, no one would question if it was a solo venture or not. I think the fact that Jennifer is a woman makes people suspicious enough to inspect the code and say things like, "it just seems like there was some outside help".
Maybe there was, maybe there wasn't. It's as disprovable as it would be if Jennifer was a man instead of a woman, yet only a woman would get called out on it.
TL;DR: there's no red flag here.
So that alone doesn't suggest to me anything deceptive afoot.
I doubt my indentation patterns were very consistent at first either. :-) Especially if I was learning from one book on one day and another book on another day.
Maybe this is all part of the soft marketing for YCombinator backed companies so they get technology "mind-share".
The 42Floors blogposts are generally good quality too, so nobody has any reason to flag them, and they're generally on topic and somewhat interesting, like this one.
I'm pretty sure any company featured on HN (eg RethinkDB or any other) would send a link to the comments on HN if their product was being discussed here, and most employees would then upvote it.
It is a voting ring, but it's probably not done maliciously and it's just how HN works, I guess.
I suspect the "friendly upvote effect" has a lot to do with getting to the front page (which admittedly is important), but that doesn't make up for low quality content.
What next? Send out internal emails saying "Hey, the company has just posted a new blog, but you don't need the actual link, instead just use the HackerNews one, or maybe this Reddit one..."
For example "lets check with the (boys|girls)" is a pretty common usage casual usage of the term for adults, especially in the 18-35 age bracket. The term boy is actually very common in uniformed occupations (military, police, etc).
Depending on the context using "women" implies a level of formality and abstraction that some could find more offensive. So whatever word gets chosen carries some risk of offence, but it's best not to get hung up on subtitles especially when so many people are non-native english speakers.
How about the tech industry? When's the last time you got called a boy? I'd be baffled to be called a boy by someone I didn't know.
> Depending on the context using "women" implies a level of formality and abstraction that some could find more offensive.
I suspect you'd have a hard time finding someone who'd have been offended by replacing "girl" with "woman" in the original post.
Well done on your journey, very impressive! It's an inspiration for many of us.
You replied about the use of "girl" (and I agree, "person" would be best here), but why not reply to petea's original comment where he criticizes you? Every time your blog makes it to front page on HN, I notice you're active in the comment thread but you don't reply to the criticism. Why not? It would quickly put an end to these type of comments. I think ignoring the criticism does more harm than the truth about whether or not you received help from others or you started the challenge with some basic knowledge.
Well, that's a novel theory on Internet commenting.
The question keeps appearing every time Jennifer's story makes the front page. If it was answered, the answer can be easily linked to any time the question pops up in the future.
While her accomplishment is very inspirational, it can also act as a disincentive to many who feel discouraged or stupid after having failed on much simpler beginner tasks. This can change depending on her answer to the criticism.
BTW this project is now a significant part of her life. It got a lot of attention and most people will know her because of the accomplishment. It'll be difficult to quickly move on from it - I'm sure the project will pop up in conversation with her, years from now, along with the same questions.
Whether she responds to the criticism or not, it's been exciting seeing her make progress and complete her goal. I wish her all the best.
I'm working through the same tutorial myself, so I see no reason to doubt that it is entirely possible to set up a rails dev environment and get started in a single day.
I would also argue she is in fact disclosing how "someone else" helped her -- "...sites like Stack Overflow, MDN, CSS Tricks, blogs and demos. I also used some great online tutorials". Using these resources is to me no different than having your experienced developer friend sit next to you. Probably better, in some cases.
I don't think its controversial or argumentative to say its probably faked to a degree.
I think that's the insinuation here.
Not that it would be that tough to figure out - the name kinda invites googling, where the first few results will tell you what you need to know.
The fact it's not true doesn't really matter.
If a man had done the exact same project, no one would care. So, well done her for being a woman.
Like you said, "If you post some idiotic comment, and 1,000 people agree with you, that's quite a powerful feedback loop."
Jayenkai's "Game A Week" project (male dev) has also attracted quite a bit of press.
One sentence; how'd I do?
---
So let's see her repository (https://github.com/jendewalt/jennifer_dewalt).
This girl not only became a competent front end developer in 100 days, but looking at the Gemfile, she knows how to use capistrano, redis, capistrano, paperclip, omniauth and devise?
She knows the best practices for Rails perfectly. She not only grasped to use MVC perfectly, but also organized asset codes perfectly in like 50 days.
I forgot to mention that she knew Rails from like day 1.
Additionally, she knew better to hide sensitive information about secret tokens for maybe AWS in the config folder and other Rails environment info.
Really? Is Hacker News this gullible? If you really want to see what actual beginner struggle with for 10 hours a day, go take a look at StackOverflow. Beginners are struggling for hours to create hoverover effects and persistent footer.
---
Edit 1.
While rereading this blog post, I found that she made the first simple Rails app on day 69. So who was it that set up all the Rails dev environment for her starting day 1. I don't understand why she still wouldn't disclose how someone else helped her.