News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by D9u on Thursday August 08, 2013 @04:54AM (#6177893)
"In such moments one feels pride with our country and regret over the course taken by United States -- a country betraying the principles it was once built on,"

Even Russians get it... Why don't more Americans get it?

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by melling on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:02AM (#6178044)
I really don't get how people can be so naive on HN. Let's talk about Snowden all day and wish we were more like Russia, where it's perfectly ok to say anything you want.

Sorry guys, but not every one really believes the NSA should be disbanded. They have a real job to do. Certainly there needs to be limits, which we could of course discuss for years on end, but I don't see the point of doing it in a forum that really isn't suitable for the topic.

Ok, back to the echo chamber. 4 downvotes and this message disappears. Well, I do need to try occasionally. HN used to be a great site.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by throwaway9848 on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:00AM (#6178342)
And it would be one thing if it were a country that had any sort of positive track record on privacy protection. The idea that Russia of all places should be used as an example of privacy protection vs. the US is _hilarious_.

I mean, off the top of my head: Gazprom/Rosneft, Anna Politkovskaya, Alexander Litvinenko... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_in_R...

And that's not to even just generally discuss the FSB, which is a proportionately larger and more corrupt version of the CIA and NSA combined. Just imagine if Bush or Obama were a former CIA officer, and had used a loophole in the Constitution to stay in power for more than a decade.

Russia's human rights and privacy rights are deplorable. Good for Snowden and his sense of realpolitik, but let's not pretend this is anything more than nation-state theater.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by sspiff on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:24AM (#6178088)
D9u said "even Russians get it", not "the Russians get it", "Russia gets it", or "the Russian government gets it", so I don't think D9u meant to say that the political and social climate in Russia is what we should aspire to.

Clearly, if he/she did, he would be poorly informed. Russia's crackdown on LGBT rights, their out-of-proportion prosecution of Pussy Riot and the oppression of opposition are recent markers of how free speech does not rule in Russia.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by speeder on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:13AM (#6178997)
Russians said US betrayed their own principles, not Russia principles.

Russians never had a free speech culture, and never cared about it, yes there is some minority that care, but pools there for example.revealed that 78% of the population is very happy with the ban of LGBT speech.

Also if Russian government allowed pussy riot on the street, someone would volunteer to kill them for profaning the church. Their issue is not with their message, but with how they did it.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by olalonde on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:39AM (#6178116)
> Ok, back to the echo chamber. 4 downvotes and this message disappears. Well, I do need to try occasionally. HN used to be a great site.

I'm sorry but this kind of comment is what makes HN worse. From the HN guidelines: "Please don't bait other users by inviting them to downmod you."

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by DanBC on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:22AM (#6178417)
Expressing frustration at a sudden bunch of downvotes on a post that shouldn't have been downvoted is understandable.

I'm in favour of down voting and I think people should be doing it a lot more on HN, but it is frustrating when reasonable posts are downvoted.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by hobs on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:23AM (#6178712)
Reasonable posts? I dont even have the power to downvote, but I would if I could, Why? Because first its patronizing, >I really don't get how people can be so naive on HN. Let's talk about Snowden all day and wish we were more like Russia, where it's perfectly ok to say anything you want.

No one said or implied this, simply that russian people were understanding there was something deeply wrong about the situation.

>Sorry guys, but not every one really believes the NSA should be disbanded. They have a real job to do. Certainly there needs to be limits, which we could of course discuss for years on end, but I don't see the point of doing it in a forum that really isn't suitable for the topic.

Nobody said this besides extreme and unthinking people and to suggest it is simply a strawman. Secondly, "I dont feel like talking about it", well then dont click the article and dont submit a comment.

>Ok, back to the echo chamber. 4 downvotes and this message disappears. Well, I do need to try occasionally. HN used to be a great site.

Asking for it.

I hope you can see where people would think this post adds very little to the discussion and in fact is inflammatory in some respects.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by DanBC on Thursday August 08, 2013 @04:38PM (#6181718)
> I hope you can see where people would think this post adds very little to the discussion

Yes, but it's a crap link so all the posts are worthless.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by adestefan on Thursday August 08, 2013 @07:22AM (#6178239)
Except they're correct. HN has always been an echo chamber and the groupthink here is thicker than most places.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by simias on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:10AM (#6178372)
It's been worse lately, I wish all political debates were banned in this place. IMO HN should be a technical forum first and foremost.

There are plenty of places on the internet do discuss politics, this doesn't need to be one of them.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by moocowduckquack on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:04AM (#6178953)
There is and always has been a massive overlap between technology and politics, especially computer technology.

To try and have a purely technical forum without any politics at all when dealing with the subject of computers, would be to ignore many of the main players and originators and also the motives that led to the existence of much of the technology.

The current news with the NSA is political, sure, but it is also as technical as it gets.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by lsc on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:02AM (#6178591)
Be the change you want to see.

I mean, I'm guilty of the same thing, too.

Really, I think the problem is that I (or you) click on these obvious political headlines. It's not like it's not obvious what they are from the headline, so they aren't hard to avoid. I'd compare this waste of time with being fat; the problem isn't the candy jar; the problem is that I /eat/ the candy in the candy jar.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by sanderjd on Thursday August 08, 2013 @11:20AM (#6179446)
Honestly, here's the thing for me - I agree with your comment in theory, but in practice, I'm not so sure. This forum was never meant for politics, and I think it's a real bummer that a potentially large faction of the readership here will forever have a tarnished view of the discussion here due to the strong political bent of the last few weeks. But in practice, I really don't know where else to go to see smart people discuss this topic. I know lots of places to find lots of people loudly agreeing with each other on one side of the debate or another, and I know some places where people debate it with the I'm-more-stubborn-and-louder-than-you methodology. Certainly the discussion here has been guilty of both of those sins at times, but I've yet to find a forum with more adversarial but civil discussion than this one.

Suggestions?

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by hboon on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:19AM (#6178402)
Let's just flag those posts that we think don't belong here.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by twoodfin on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:23AM (#6178424)
Careful, if you do this too often you'll lose flag privileges.

Besides, since pg has commented on a few of these posts approvingly, and since stories that would be [dead] within minutes previously now regularly top the front page, we have to assume he is OK with "Snowden News" at least for now.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by moocowduckquack on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:27AM (#6178733)
How about starting by not commenting on posts you aren't interested in.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by zxcdw on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:22AM (#6178416)
Except that the implications of Snowden and PRISM and whatnot are fisrt and foremost technical when it comes to running an online business, something HN is very focused on.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by DanBC on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:24AM (#6178426)
This submission has zero technical content. There is nothing in this discussion that is relevant to people running an online business in a world where PRISM exists.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by hermaj on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:44AM (#6178130)
Although I agree with you on many points I think you might be projecting onto D9u's comment. Nothing in the quote he posted suggests it is necessary to disband the NSA, nothing suggests Americans should wish they lived in a country like Russia. A 'course taken' implies a general direction, not a revolutionary change.

In the current situation Russians should be allowed to feel pride that it was their decrepit mafia state that opposed the United States on Snowden. That doesn't mean Russia did it for the right reasons, or that Russia is now a better place than it was before. A lot of Russians who feel pride in this action would probably still take the opportunity to live and work in the USA, the two are not mutually exclusive.

The problem I have with posts like yours is that they imply that because other places are a mess that exonerates the USA heading in that direction too.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by bazillion on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:18AM (#6178079)
Seeing this post made me very happy, actually. I've commented before about my perspective in the NSA and doing government work, but immediately get showered with downvotes because I have a point of view that differs from what other people have been rallying towards. I don't understand the motivation behind preventing discussion of actual facts or interesting points of view.

If 11 year old BBS-hacking NSA-conspiracy-fearing me had an opportunity to talk to and ask questions of former NSA analyst/programmer me, I would definitely have come up with a better discussion than the HN community.

At least my upvote will counter at least one close-minded person.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by k__ on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:23AM (#6178087)
What's the deal with everybody always taking sides?!

NSA AND Russia are bad.

There is nothing good in spying on people OR outlawing gays...

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by userulluipeste on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:40AM (#6178118)
Not only individual people take sides, organizations and governments take too. For how I see it, NSA is bashed because it took a side against the most of us. Russia on the other hand, gets its "hurray" because it opposes the one that is against us right now. It's not necessarily taking a side and sticking with it as a partisan, it is just condemning or recognizing one's merit when it's the case, simple.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by lotsofcows on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:37AM (#6178111)
Have a different opinion to you is not close-minded. Being unwilling to discuss ones opinion sensibly, eg labelling those whose opinions differ to yours as "close-minded", is close-minded.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by bazillion on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:47AM (#6178139)
Please re-read what I wrote and what I responded to. It was a post which was being downmodded because people didn't agree with his opinion, and I was opposing those who were suppressing his opinion. As in, those that were downmodding rather than supplying discussion content were close-minded.

This isn't supposed to be reddit, where people downmod something because it is an opinion that they don't agree with.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by dspillett on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:12AM (#6178648)
> and wish we were more like Russia

We are not saying we think the states should be more like Russia, well I aren't at least, we're pointing out the hypocrisy of the Powers That Be state-side.

They publicly chant "our way is better, what you are doing it wrong" but when their way doesn't work or otherwise becomes inconvenient they are perfectly happy to quietly use the techniques and policies they deride when others use them.

Russia doing many more bad things than the US is not justification for the US doing one thing we consider wrong.

I can't say I see anyone who is in the right in all this:

* I can see the national security argument having some validity so Snowden is culpable for releasing state secrets. He was trusted with information, he abused that trust (for reasons he and many others consider morally correct, but that morality issue does not mean it wasn't an abuse of trust).

* But what he released was details of the states doing something that they promised they were not doing, something that they deride oppressive states for. Whether Snowden's actions are right or wrong does not alter the fact the powers that be over there are both liars and hypocrites. They have abused the trust of their people.

* Russia is only taking part in this little game to wind up people it (or perhaps more specifically, Putin) feels the desire to wind up. They don't care one way or the other for Snowden specifically nor that the US is explicitly spying on its own people.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by weland on Thursday August 08, 2013 @05:37AM (#6177989)
This painfully reminds me of George Carlin, who referred to the original artisans of his country -- in jest -- as "a bunch of white slaveowners who wanted to be free".
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by dmix on Thursday August 08, 2013 @12:41PM (#6180056)
I understand this was in jest, but this comes up on HN often.

Slavery was introduced in America ~two centuries before the founding fathers had influence.

They were focused on the threat of authoritarianism/british rule, and failed to properly address their own complicit authoritarianism.

Very much like many people today who are all of a sudden concerned about the abuses of the "police state" aggressively targeting protesters and activists, when black communities have been harassed and targeted for decades (see the only domestic aerial bombing in US history targeting black activists in the 1980s [1] or recently "stop and frisk") with little public protest from white communities.

...or the difference in legal sentencing for crack cocaine vs powdered cocaine.

Racial hypocrisy is hardly a thing of the past in public discourse.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MOVE

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by Gonzih on Thursday August 08, 2013 @05:42AM (#6178000)
Believe me, Russian government is doing the same thing as NSA did. There are rumors about spying hardware installed in Russian ISPs. There are rumors about Russian organization that produces hardware for logging all internet traffic, decrypting on the fly encrypted data, filtering it and etc. Difference between this and NSA is than information about NSA is now public.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by praptak on Thursday August 08, 2013 @05:50AM (#6178022)
No contradiction to the point that GP made. Nobody said that Putin's Russia is more free than US. They just did the right thing in this particular case and made the "land of the free" look hypocritical as a result. This doesn't imply anything about how Russia citizens are treated by their own state.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by pathy on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:29AM (#6178096)
Snowden is nothing more than a political pawn for Russia. Once he landed in Moscow he had little power over his own destiny.

Snowden didn't get asylum in Russia out of the goodness of their hearts but rather Putin wanting to annoy USA and score anti-USA points on home turf. It has nothing to do with "doing the right thing" It is a political game, nothing else.

It is naive to believe anything else. It did, however, benefit Snowden, it is probably better to sit in a Russian quasi-house-arrest than a trip to an American prison.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by Gonzih on Thursday August 08, 2013 @05:58AM (#6178035)
I just don't understand how someone can be proud about modern Russia in any way.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by precisioncoder on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:19AM (#6178084)
Bad doesn't cancel out good, they exist side by side. I admire the US for it's amazing alternative culture (steampunk, goth, robots, anime, comic books, oh my). I admire it for it's incredible technological innovation. I have often weighed those things against the lack of support for it's citizens (No free healthcare, little to no vacation, often mandatory overtime, rich wins legal system, etc). I don't know as much about Russia and the US but I'm sure that it has a tremendous amount of good and bad living side by side. There's plenty to be proud of as well as ashamed of.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by Gonzih on Thursday August 08, 2013 @06:53AM (#6178155)
> I don't know as much about Russia...

Unfortunately I know about Russia too much. I totally agree with you, but from my point of view and with information that I'm getting about Russia I can't see how to look at that country from positive perspective.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by lvturner on Thursday August 08, 2013 @07:25AM (#6178246)
Go visit Russia, it's hard to evaluate any country based on information gleaned from the outside.

Edit: Actually, by visit, I mean go and live there for a while

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by Gonzih on Friday August 09, 2013 @11:21AM (#6186174)
I live in Belarus, so I think I can imagine what Russia is like (we have less issues in country, but most of negative aspects are same).
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by cpursley on Thursday August 08, 2013 @07:16AM (#6178225)
Well, you can be proud Russia has a very sane 13% flat national tax system while the US has incomprehensible tax code.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by drone on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:16AM (#6178676)
Even Russians get it... Why don't more Americans get it?

Get what?

A large group of the American people are upset that the NSA was spying on its own citizens. There's a healthy, and sometimes rancorous discussion going on over here. Lawmakers are trying to tighten up laws, the cabinet is defensive, and the populace is arguing amongst its self.

betraying the principles it was once built on...

No, "the country" is not. There seems to be this mythical belief that varies from country to country as to what it "means" to be the United States; even within the United States no one can agree as to what those principles actually are -- so how can someone outside of it be so sure? What have we learned in 200+ years of representative democracy? It hurts, it's hard, we can't always agree, we can't always make up our mind, we struggle to find balance, and when groups of people can make rules sometimes they make absolutely atrocious ones just like individuals do. Along the way, it will look terrible and horrible to outsiders who think they "see the obvious that no one inside of the system sees." Sorry, as an outsider you're not miraculously the only one aware of the truth - you're like that annoying other programmer who is always full of great ideas about how your code should be written, but always seems to gloss over the hard parts.

So, for those countries that romanticized about how utopian the United States must be for decades and decades of some other type of rule, and very recently have been given some semblance of democracy, it must be jarring to see there is no magic pill for the corruption and tyranny they may occasionally live under. But to think that "America has lost its way," it to act like a partisan here. I hear that every day from someone who is griping about some thing they don't like. It's trite at best.

The person who made the statement clearly has no idea as to what the principles of the United States actually are, and instead has idolized them into some inner picture of perfection that never existed.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by thuuuomas on Thursday August 08, 2013 @12:50PM (#6180122)
You speak as though you know "what the principles of the United Sates actually are", but much like the maligned "annoying other programmer", you don't mention what these principles might be.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by drone on Saturday August 10, 2013 @11:19AM (#6191347)
You speak as though you know "what the principles of the United Sates actually are", but much like the maligned "annoying other programmer", you don't mention what these principles might be

Quote: even within the United States no one can agree as to what those principles actually are -- so how can someone outside of it be so sure

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by dylangs1030 on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:30AM (#6178751)
You're ridiculous. This comment is a spectacular example of the faulty politicizing and black and white mentality being tossed about willy-nilly since the NSA scandal.

First of all - this is not indicative of Russia. This is just one Russian national giving him a job, and his stated reasons in the press may not be the real reasons why.

Second, Russia gave him asylum yes, but instead of echo chambering your preconceived beliefs about the NSA, why don't you apply the same critical skepticism to news coming out of Russia? Why don't you examine why Russia might want to grant asylum to an American refugee like Snowden instead of just saying, "Oh, they just get it man. They get it."

Third, there isn't anything concrete to get - the NSA isn't an evil, demonic institution sent here as a harbinger of the apocalypse. It's an institution whose abuses were wildly exaggerated and need to be corrected, not something to be burned to the ground. The country would not be better off without the agency in its entirety.

You're just applying this naive sense of cops and robbers to the entire dilemma and not critically examining all the evidence/stories. Your bias allows you to over-criticize one side and over-praise the other.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by danenania on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:35AM (#6178776)
Sorry, secretly storing and analyzing the private communications and browsing history of everyone on the planet absolutely is evil. Doesn't matter what the reason is.

If you don't understand this, there is something severely wrong with your moral compass.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by davvolun on Thursday August 08, 2013 @12:55PM (#6180161)
Didn't necessarily disagree with you until "If you don't understand this, there is something severely wrong with your moral compass." Personal attack and severe hyperbole wrapped into one, comments are about encouraging debate, so if you can't do that, just...shhhhh...
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by aurelius83 on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:51AM (#6178881)
What exactly is your definition of evil? This seems like such a hyperbolic statement.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by danenania on Thursday August 08, 2013 @11:05AM (#6179339)
"The moment someone keeps an eye on what we do, we involuntarily make allowances for that eye, and nothing we do is truthful. Having a public, keeping a public in mind, means living in lies."

-Milan Kundera

I think this form of societal corruption is one of the greatest and most insidious evils a government can undertake. You should read some accounts by people who have lived under similar monitoring regimes.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by dylangs1030 on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:50AM (#6178870)
This is one of the few times I've seen a genuine ad hominem on Hacker News...thank you for attacking my "moral compass" instead of the substance of my argument.

Now, to counter what you said - you're reaching by claiming the NSA "secretly stores and analyzes" the private communications of everyone on the planet. One interpretation of the materials originally leaked purports this, but there is also data contesting this view which is equally valid. Again - the echo chamber and bias allows you to just unilaterally suppose the NSA is capable of retrieving all data everywhere, but you're not examining counter evidence.

X-Keyscore allows email and web content surveillance, yes, but it isn't even practical to mine all data at once - it is much more practical (and probable) that this allows for finding and assembling an entry point to see where you should really begin looking in depth as an NSA analyst[1]. But, no, your traffic is not being viewed universally or entirely without someone at least believing there's a reason.

[1]: http://www.theguardian.com/world/interactive/2013/jul/31/nsa...

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by danenania on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:24AM (#6179072)
You are hand wringing over the details and completely missing the point. The most conservative possible interpretation of Snowden's leaks still leaves the NSA secretly spying on the private communications and online activity of hundreds of millions of innocent people. It is a starkly totalitarian measure that is unparalleled in human history.

If you find it difficult to see why this is morally abhorrent, I'm just not sure what to say you to you, as I think it would be quite apparent to the average 9 year old that deliberately spying on people who have done nothing to warrant suspicion is wrong.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by acomar on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:42AM (#6179185)
> It is a starkly totalitarian measure that is unparalleled in human history.

Really...? Come on now, that's totally unbacked by any analysis of history. I agree with you on the immorality, but hyperbole like that doesn't advance your case very well.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by abecedarius on Thursday August 08, 2013 @11:30AM (#6179508)
Let's see, is it hyperbole?

An unabashedly totalitarian regime would spy on all its subjects, all the time, through every available channel. It would keep the details of its spying as secret as it can, while letting everyone know they're being watched. It looks like we have most of this, minus 'unabashedly': they claim they drop particular cases where they learn the people they're spying on are citizens within the borders who don't fit a long list of exceptions (crypto, etc.); and they're trying to hide the extent of spying. (On the other hand I don't consider secret courts to weigh much against the label 'totalitarian': the Soviets had that kind of thing, too.)

It could be unparalleled in either nature or extent. In nature, automated data mining is pretty new; in extent, the previous paradigm case, the Stasi, falls laughably short in some ways, while still far ahead in others (informers).

I think the quote isn't unreasonable, though it's loose.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by danenania on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:55AM (#6179282)
Please point out any previous attempts to build ubiquitous international surveillance systems that intercept trillions of private communications.

I'll grant that if you include science fiction novels, there are a few contenders.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by fauigerzigerk on Thursday August 08, 2013 @02:48PM (#6180945)
I agree with you that this extent of surveillance is a characteristic element of totalitarian regimes. But the things that totalitarian regimes do with the data they collect is different from what happens in the US right now (as far as I can tell).

All totalitarian regimes used broad surveillance, but not all countries that have overly broad surveillance programs are totalitarian. What's missing is the desire for total control of many different aspects of life and political activity.

However, I think that there is a great danger that "total information awareness" leads to an ever greater desire for total control. That desire may even come from the people and have superficial democratic legitimacy. If everyone knows that the government knows everything, the people will demand control over many things that other people do.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by dylangs1030 on Thursday August 08, 2013 @01:25PM (#6180383)
Hundreds of millions is a bit more tolerable than an entire planet. I'd like to also point out I agree with you - none of my statements here should be interpreted as support for the NSA's excesses. Rather, my incentive is to:

1) Prevent people on the forum from using it as a buzzword to make points devoid of strong, reasoned arguments,

2) Prevent people from believing the NSA should be burned to the ground and disbanded entirely, when it does serve a very useful purpose.

Historically, there have been far worse totalitarian measures. To give one that is relevant to privacy and this particular issue: consider that in the KGB, the secret police could raid your home at any time without a warrant, and when you picked up the phone an operator immediately told you what you said would be recorded. Oh, sure you knew about it. That makes it so much better, I suppose, even though it was far more reaching than what the NSA is currently doing.

I want it very well understood that while the excesses of the agency should be corrected, and Americans should be entitled to privacy, we can't allow ourselves to just attack things passionately because the NSA scandal tells us to. That, and we should maintain a historical perspective so we understand how bad things are and we don't freak out as if it's the worst thing ever, when far worse things have happened in previous generations.

A level of outrage is appropriate - losing sensibility in debates is not.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by monsterix on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:59AM (#6178921)
Not to dissuade or disagree with your thoughts, but your opinion about evilness of this program will change over time. For example, when you get stuck (God forbid) in an unwarranted situation or a legal hassle and then the same NSA program you passively protect now is used to check back on your past data/behavior and then pull out useful subjective information and taint you with phrases like "infamous former contractor" and so on ... Have you thought about this?

Objectivity is a logical illusion.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by dylangs1030 on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:16AM (#6179010)
Well...I agree personal experience can be a powerful motivator for changing opinions. But what I'm saying is what I have found through researching it.

As to my feelings for whether or not the NSA should be preserved vs. destroyed entirely - yes, I could see how personal experience could skew this. I, thankfully, haven't had such interference in my life.

But I also want to point out I'm not protecting the NSA's PRISM et al. programs. I think they're too strong, and too obscured. But I do believe the NSA can replace them with more functional, transparent tools that will achieve the same goals. I also believe people are being swayed by big headlines and pathos arguments that prevent them from examining the NSA critically instead of passionately - I don't think it's as bad as everyone makes it seem.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by D9u on Friday August 09, 2013 @04:26AM (#6184368)
(Ad hominems?) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6178980

You're assuming that I haven't actually done my homework and am making an off-the-cuff statement based upon media exposure, when the facts of this matter are that I have done my homework on this topic.

(Obama on domestic surveillance, 2007) http://youtu.be/ZVUwUCe1e-A

(Why we don't trust the government) https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/08/restoring_tru...

(The Terrorism Delusion) http://politicalscience.osu.edu/faculty/jmueller/absisfin.pd...

As the facts are, and looking at the situation objectively, the sustained reaction to the 9/11 incident is uncalled for, especially when the US has gone through previous decades which had seen exponentially more terrorist (lots of bombs) activity on US soil than any time since, yet back then the government didn't overreact and implement such excessive measures as we see today, in commercial airports where passengers are treated like criminals in a prison, in our electronic communications, and our financial records.

I, personally, have never called for the abolition of the NSA, but rather would like to see less intrusive measures employed instead of what they're doing now.

Where is the probable cause for the interception, collection, and storage of my electronic communications? Where is the probable cause showing that I might be a terrorist?

There are conditions which are supposed to be met when the government wants to violate my 4th Amendment rights, and to add an exception for "National Security," where no exception exists, equates to denial of civil rights, so when it's done on as massive a scale as we see case now it's a gross breach of the public trust and people have a right to voice their displeasure with the actions of their government.

To simply sweep this under the rug would be the most unpatriotic thing you could do, and justifying this obviously unpopular program by citing terrorism is disingenuous when viewed from a chronological perspective.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by acomar on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:46AM (#6179226)
You're right on the details, and I agree with your analysis, but the moral question still stands. Do we as a society and nation have any right to do this? Why does our desire for security trump the rights of people at home and abroad? And why does having a conversation on this topic have to be so damn difficult -- all the details are kept secret, down to the interpretation of the laws that apparently allow for programs like these. There's something fundamentally messed up about all this.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by muyuu on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:10AM (#6178980)
SAYS "YOU'RE RIDICULOUS" TO A PREVIOUS POSTER FOR POINTING OUT THE OBVIOUS

WHINES ABOUT BEING THE TARGET OF AN AD HOMINEM ATTACK

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by aclevernickname on Thursday August 08, 2013 @02:34PM (#6180852)
Normally I disagree with the invocation of Scumbag Steve, but you, sir, are doing it right.

After reading the article on Crowdturfing [1], I can no longer assume that everyone posting here is acting in good faith.

[1] http://sdt.bz/61989

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by dylangs1030 on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:26AM (#6179094)
...Really? Please don't yell - it's not conductive to making your point.

I said "ridiculous" because it was a narrow, misinformed comment that failed to properly encapsulate the entire subject at hand. It wasn't representative of what's really going on in the political theater between Russia and the United States right now, e.g. no consideration of Russia's motives, positive impact of the NSA, how Russia would be hypocritical to endorse press freedom and citizen privacy, etc. etc. etc.

In fact, nothing about his comment was obvious - if you continue on through the thread, you can clearly see how my rebuttal dissects the entire view that Russia "gets" anything very sufficiently.

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by shpxnvz on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:46AM (#6179217)
When you said "you're ridiculous" you attacked the poster rather than the opinion, which made that part of your comment ad-hominem. That statement, juxtaposed with your complaint immediately following about being subject to the same sort of attack was indeed rather humorous.
Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by D9u on Friday August 09, 2013 @04:33AM (#6184399)
You defend your own ad hominems with more ad hominems? How do you know that I am misinformed? I've read everything that I can get my hands on regarding this subject.

Then you go on to confuse the sentiments of one Russian for the policies of an entire nation?

Who's being ridiculous here?

Re:Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job. by calibraxis on Thursday August 08, 2013 @05:57AM (#6178033)
I recall hearing about polls where like a third of US respondents believe that the US government was behind 9-11. Of course I don't believe it did, but clearly lots of us think we're run by a bunch of criminals. In comparison to graver problems (being the most incarceration-happy nation, mass international killings, etc), the Snowden thing is minor.

Durov's whole line about "betraying the principles it was once built on" is a reference to the usual quasi-religious nationalist founding mythologies.