News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by hayksaakian on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:30PM (#5972182)
Its really quite ironic that this article was submitted by an account that is 33 days old and submits daily dot articles exclusively without ever commenting.

I pointed this out once before, the last time they wrote an article and submitted it, and that was about the same thing too.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by jmduke on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:40PM (#5972280)
The submitter is the Asst. Managing Editor of the Daily Dot.

That being said, I don't think there's anything particularly wrong with accounts that exist specifically to submit a given site's content (even programmatically), since that content must be still democratically approved by the user base. I think vote-brigading is a much more serious issue, and one that HN seems to deal with well.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by brokentone on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:15PM (#5972545)
Agreed, it sounded like the Atlantic guy banned eons ago was actually a good community member. At some point the Reddit restriction of "submit any content but your own" feels very artificial.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by davidw on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:13PM (#5973277)
I've always found that attitude of not promoting your own stuff annoying. If you took the time to write it and think about it, you should be proud of it! If you're just spamming, people will see it and vote accordingly.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by tptacek on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:04PM (#5973538)
Submitting your own stuff is fine. It's when you mechanically submit everything that appears on your site that we start having problems.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by davidw on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:05PM (#5973546)
Sure, and I think the difference is pretty clear to most reasonable people. What I take issue with is the idea that self-promotion is "bad".
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by diminoten on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:12AM (#5975784)
curious why, though. If it's good, it'll be pushed upwards. If it's not it won't be.

Why does it matter who does the submitting?

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by benologist on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:47AM (#5975889)
It matters heaps - links submitted by community members with no affiliation to the source have been judged worthy for submission based purely on the content's merit.

Dailydot, extremetech, pcmag, geek, macobserver, betabeat, itworld, bostinno etc have collectively operated dozens of acounts to spam their own stuff, none of which met an actual community member's standards for submitting a story.

Individuals submitting their own blog posts and especially with success are usually so low volume they're not even noticeable unless they overdo it and inevitably get called out for it.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by yuhong on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @02:36AM (#5976195)
>Dailydot, extremetech, pcmag, geek, macobserver, betabeat, itworld, bostinno etc have

I prefer to say "could" instead of "have" unless you have definite evidence.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by benologist on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @03:08AM (#5976268)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5567427

Plus dailydot are just getting started with the OP + 'sexyalterego'.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by diminoten on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @01:01AM (#5975929)
What do you mean "judged worthy of submission"?
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by benologist on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @01:03AM (#5975936)
A submission from a real user implies one of us thought the rest of us might like this. They judged it worth submitting.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by diminoten on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @11:46AM (#5978588)
So a one person difference?
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by benologist on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @03:24PM (#5980162)
Think about everything you see online and don't submit. It matters.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by speeder on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:01PM (#5974271)
Except HN blocks that I guess...

At least I try to always make good submissions, and usually HN only let me submit twice every month...

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by dfc on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:44PM (#5975692)
I'm curious about the submission throttling that you have experienced. You have 4 submissions from the last month (last 30 days) and 9 submissions for the two previous months. What is being throttled?
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by speeder on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:29AM (#5975826)
I don't know, but I rarely can submit new stuff...

When I joined HN I submitted a lot, but suddenly I could not submit for two weeks, then sometimes I can submit twice or three times in a week, and then have to wait two weeks again...

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by ggchappell on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:27PM (#5972997)
I'd go further and say it's misguided. I'd like to think that a single account's submissions can be thought of as a "channel", as on YouTube.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by nonotthatone on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:28PM (#5972622)
> submit any content but your own

Plenty of people submit their own content. In fact, it's encouraged. You have reddit confused with digg, somehow.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by minimaxir on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:37PM (#5972677)
It's definitely not encouraged on Reddit, one of the old notes of Redditquite is "if more than 10% of what you submit is your personal content, then you're probably a spammer."

Once, someone submitted one of my blog posts about a rather interesting bug in a AAA game to /r/programming. Over 1,000 net score. Out of curiosity, I submitted the same post myself to /r/games. -7 score.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by skeletonjelly on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:26PM (#5974428)
Your last example could be bad timing and/or the r/games audience not caring about programming etc
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by minimaxir on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @04:08AM (#5976425)
True, although once a credible news source made a post with similar, it hit the front page of /r/games quickly.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by zevyoura on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:38PM (#5972680)
Actually, Reddit's FAQ[1] says:

> If over 10% of your submissions are your own site/content, you're almost certainly a spammer.

[1] http://www.reddit.com/wiki/faq#wiki_what_constitutes_spam.3F

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by Uperte on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:36PM (#5972661)
"Feel free to post links to your own content (within reason). But if that's all you ever post, and it always seems to get voted down, take a good hard look in the mirror — you just might be a spammer. A widely used rule of thumb is the 9:1 ratio, i.e. only 1 out of every 10 of your submissions should be your own content."

From reddiquette.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by alayne on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:54PM (#5972785)
Your own content != be a corporate shill / spammer.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by Pxtl on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:21PM (#5975617)
Exactly. A part of me was kind of sad that Digg's final phase of being a direct aggregator of news without "submission" but instead sucking the news straight from RSS feeds and pumping it into the hivemind upvote/downvote system... that this system tanked so badly and was so poorly done. Requiring that the "submitter" be some legitimate member of the community seems forced, as long as it's not high-frequency spam.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by anigbrowl on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:59PM (#5973207)
I don't mind that, but it should be posted transparently in the 'about' field of his HN profile, along with a link and contact. If you're on HN to promote your brand then journalistic ethics, as well as basic respect for other community members, suggests that disclosure of interest is appropriate.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by OTRAustin on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:56PM (#5972812)
Thanks for the comment. I’ve had extensive dialogue with Hacker News moderators about submitting Daily Dot stories. It’s something we do sparingly, with great caution, thought, and discussion. We take HN very seriously and want to ensure that we only contribute quality content that’s in line with the rules and standards. We value the community here, and we’ll make more of an effort moving forward to submit links from other parts of the Web.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by jerrya on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:51PM (#5973475)
I don't mind seeing an editor submitting links, but if you don't participate in the discussions, I would tend to think you are spamming HN.

You could add a lot of value to the discussions and to the DailyDot if you were to participate to some extent in the discussions.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by agravier on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:28PM (#5973004)
Don't hesitate to join the discussions too.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by anigbrowl on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:02PM (#5973222)
I'm fine with it, but you should put your affiliation in your profile for everyone else to see. Mods - this ought to be a requirement of using HN as a promotional outlet.

http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by OTRAustin on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:09PM (#5973261)
Adding it now. Good suggestion.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by benologist on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:17AM (#5975802)
And what will you do for this blatant spam account?

https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=sexyalterego

It's a shame the mods didn't shitlist your domain entirely, you're obviously here just to exploit HN.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by hayksaakian on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @01:52AM (#5976082)
I thought for a second that they might be changing, but this basically proves me wrong.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by yuhong on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @05:26AM (#5976637)
Well, we will see if they add the disclosure in the about field.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by yuhong on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @02:38AM (#5976204)
Do you have definite proof of who operate the account?
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by benologist on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @03:12AM (#5976275)
The number of people outside of dailydot that care about improving dailydot's mind/marketshare on HN is somewhere between 0 and delusional.

But I will concede it could be some random, unaffiliated person who just really, really, really, really wishes we would get our news from dailydot!

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by yuhong on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @04:33AM (#5976509)
Or just playing around or trolling for fun.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by benologist on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @04:43AM (#5976535)
For 7 months.

That definitely sounds more likely than spam on the internet.

He's most definitely not Jay Hathaway, AKA sexyalterego on reddit, currently "assigning editor at the Daily Dot".

https://www.google.com/search?num=100&site=&source=hp&q=You+...

I for one am shocked it wasn't some random unaffiliated person who just really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really wanted us to get our news from dailydot.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by sexyalterego on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @10:36AM (#5978040)
Point taken. I've updated my profile to reflect my affiliation. As Austin pointed out, it's not our intention to spam—we only submit stories that could actually be of interest to the community. We'll make sure those stories are coming from a variety of sources in the future, and also contribute to discussions.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by yuhong on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @02:53PM (#5979957)
Thanks.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by yuhong on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @05:13AM (#5976611)
To be honest, a reminder is definitely good. I was just worried about making definite claims without evidence. And just because one spam account can be explained like this don't mean it can be applied to all of them.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by anigbrowl on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:23PM (#5973342)
Thanks! I know HN is so minimal that it's easy to overlook.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by yuhong on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:51AM (#5975901)
The sad thing is that reddit don't even support it. I posted this on r/ideasfortheadmins to fix both problems: http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/xmsan/add...
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by ebbv on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:49PM (#5973138)
Link aggregating sites and social media are rampant with abuse and shilling. It's the name of the game. From celebrities trying to pass off obviously paid tweets as legitimate to every traffic driven/ad driven site engaging in shilling and upvote scamming.

It's pretty obivous to spot if you're a normal user of these types of sites.

But administrators usually have no incentive whatsoever to stop it unless the users actually get out the torches and pitchforks, and the administrators themselves are in danger of being called out as supporting this behavior. But in reality it's trivially easy for them to watch for it and stop it if they're interested in it.

I was in charge of a small, niche hobby forum that garnered about 20k visitors per day. Peanuts compared to anything larger, but even we had shills. I would spot it and stop it because I cared about the quality of the discussion far more than the number of posts or visitors.

Digg lost the number one spot because in its revision previously rather than stomping out shilling and vote scamming, Digg attempted to legitimize it and mainstream the sites that previously had engaged in nefarious acts to try to garner traffic.

Users are not innocent in this whole situation either; if they paid attention and reacted appropriately to shills and obvious voting abuse, the administrators would be forced to act responsibly. But users are apathetic most of the time, and often complicit in it.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by thedaveoflife on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:27PM (#5974023)
In the same vein, aren't most newspaper articles simply PR in some form or another? The key is to be a savvy enough user to spot it.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by hobs on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:38PM (#5974513)
Yep. Al Franken had a great piece he wrote about this when he was defending the claims of the liberal media and the like being biased against Bush. He went on to explain that most of the media is just an echo chamber, and repackaging a press release is much easier than actually doing work.

A !ton! of "news" is just reposting reposts.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by nwzpaperman on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:39AM (#5975861)
People have the opportunity to write news, but the will to write news isn't there, yet. With ~9 months of open-beta under our belts and no interference or incentivizing content of any stripe, people just don't cover what's in front of them. Fundamentally, I believe this is because people have a herding instinct and seek to be a member of a larger group. It's also possible that community-level(local) issues are "too close to home" for non-professionals to risk community reputation on.

Many people validate their positions--and themselves--by the quantity of people that agree with them which leads to holding popular positions.

At certain points in time altruism and necessity meet to overcome these social forces, but it's usually only when crisis forces everyone to the table.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by Tossrock on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @02:21AM (#5976158)
pg has an essay about this in fact:

www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by aspensmonster on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @02:40AM (#5976210)
>But administrators usually have no incentive whatsoever to stop it

Of course not. They're often the ones running the gig in the first place.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by anigbrowl on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:57PM (#5973187)
This post is full of teh drama, and pretty sophomoric, with the self-righteous conclusion...

The Miltz brothers learned the hard way that cheating Reddit doesn’t pay.

More like 'eventually stops paying.' If they were making $1.2m/month at the peak it seems reasonable to guess that they pulled in somewhere between $5 and $10 million over the two years of unhindered operation and resultant growth. Maybe more, but even if they only made $1 million that's a pretty nice payout for two people.

It's odd how the article totally ignores this in favor of the opportunity cost. To me it seems like gtwo8 and his brother made a small fortune without any incurring any legal problems, and learned enough to repeat the formula in some other context later.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by vermontdevil on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:49PM (#5973810)
But I wonder what are the costs to host all these images and traffic.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by umsm on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:59PM (#5974257)
Definitely no where near the reported millions of income. Data hosting is probably the lowest expense a website has.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by DanielBMarkham on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:07PM (#5972491)
I've had varied experiences with sites and banning. A couple of years ago, I made a funny picture site where I would collect some of these visual jokes. (plug: http://caption-of-the-day.com) I never submitted here, of course, but I also got zero traction on reddit. It always seemed weird to me that reddit was such a wasteland for that material, especially when there was so much of it on there.

Then this year, before the NSA story broke, I figured privacy and anonymity would be a big issue, one I was passionate about. So I created http://freedom-or-safety.com It's a mix of rewriting long stories into 3-5 paragraph summaries (with appropriate links back), and original commentary.

Since the majority of stuff on that site was technology/privacy related, and since many of my friends are here and like that kind of stuff, I submitted a lot of it on HN.

Then I got banned on HN. Beats me how. Still waiting to figure that one out. I asked to be reinstated and I was, but without knowing what I've done it makes it really difficult to avoid doing it again. I've stopped creating content over there while I figure out if it's worth getting another ban here because of who-knows-what. Sucks to have your work silenced due to forces outside your control and understanding. I really feel for all those other meme sites struggling away on reddit all that while. How many hundreds or thousands of hours of productivity were destroyed trying to honestly work with a system that was rigged all along?

We like to think of these aggregation sites as pristine, driven by the user voice, and automatically selecting and promoting good content. But after many years on several such sites, and after submitting my own stuff on several of them, I don't have such a charitable opinion. I like HN, and I really like the folks here, but in their effort to keep the site cleaned up, they've created an opaque and non-intuitive system. In many ways, this has the same effect on trust as having a crooked moderator. Things just don't make sense and don't feel right, but hell if you can put your finger on exactly what's going on.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by snowwrestler on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:16PM (#5972925)
> It's a mix of rewriting long stories into 3-5 paragraph summaries (with appropriate links back), and original commentary.

I never read your site so please take this with a grain of salt. But I assume the long stories were not your writing, right? You were taking other people's writing and condensing it down. That's not really that valuable or useful, and might have violated this part of the HN guidelines:

> Please submit the original source. If a blog post reports on something they found on another site, submit the latter.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by tzs on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:21PM (#5973323)
> Then I got banned on HN. Beats me how. Still waiting to figure that one out. I asked to be reinstated and I was, but without knowing what I've done it makes it really difficult to avoid doing it again.

HN bans often seem completely arbitrary. I recently turned on "showdead" to see what gets banned, and have come across some quite puzzling ones.

For instance, there is greenpizza13 [1]. His offense appears to have been posting a comment that called that "wat" video "hilarious".

Even more puzzling is luka1413 [2]. Just two comments. Neither particularly useful, but not offensive and certainly no more useless than many of the comments of regulars here.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=greenpizza13

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=luka1413

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by tptacek on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:58PM (#5973509)
There might be a voting ring detector thing happening here, too.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by Hovertruck on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:09PM (#5972016)
It really bothers me that the word "meme" has become a synonym for these Advice Animal style images.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by scrumper on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:37PM (#5972670)
Dawkins's concept of memes provides an interesting way to look at the nature of humanity, society, and civilizations. It's a simple concept, too: something graspable by any reasonably observant person. It's perhaps a little sad that something which represents naught but a shadow of the original idea has overtaken it in such a popular forum.

Is it possible that the meme of Dawkins's "meme" could itself die out, killed off by a parasitic invasive species that claimed its very name? Without that name, how do we talk about them?

Or, is the spread of the name 'meme' to mean 'image macros' instead indicative of the power of Dawkins's original idea? Here we are, looking at a community of a million teenagers, most of them utterly uninterested in thinking about the spread of ideas, taking a name from science and applying it to their own culture. The kids aren't even using the word incorrectly: image macros are a meme; individual examples are memes themselves, competing, reproducing, thriving, dying.

Fun to think about.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by qwertzlcoatl on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:35PM (#5974839)
Richard Dawkins laid down his own little twist on memes some weeks ago : http://youtu.be/GFn-ixX9edg?t=4m55s

Warning: Weirdness

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by bradleyland on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:30PM (#5972185)
Interestingly, this is one of the few news outlets that correctly identified them as "image macros". Pull quote:

His history on Reddit amounted to little more than link submissions to a relatively new site called Quickmeme, where users type bold-faced captions on popular memes like Scumbag Steve and Success Kid.

These are known as image macros.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by tome on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:21PM (#5972099)
That in itself is an example of the spread of a meme.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by heartbreak on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:17PM (#5972069)
You mean "image macros"
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by pyre on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:30PM (#5972191)
They were originally "image macros," but some image macros became memes unto themselves. Eventually people started referring to image macros as memes. Advice Animals started somewhere in the middle of all of this. Originally image macros didn't share a common picture, but a common phrase with a funny picture that was related or a specific image/phrase combination (e.g. "do not want", "no u", "get in the soup"[1]).

[1] http://endlesspicdump.com/original/shut%20the%20hell%20up%20...

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by kmfrk on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:29PM (#5972173)
You mean "demotivational posters".

Words change. "LOL" means something different than it used to. Such is the fluidity of language and the web.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by mehrzad on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:08PM (#5972890)
But they're not demotivationals.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by MostAwesomeDude on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:19PM (#5972947)
Image macros come from Japanese message boards; they are not really related to the faux motivational posters that are commonly known as "demotivationals".
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by astrange on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:01PM (#5973871)
Image macros came from SomethingAwful, although even then it was only a brief period where they were actual "macros".

Japanese sites don't even let you embed images. Everyone uses ASCII art (actually SJIS of course).

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by jere on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:08PM (#5973561)
Polysemy isn't something to get upset about. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyseme

Anyway, I'd say many people still understand the original meaning and distinguish between the two given enough context.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by dnautics on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:41PM (#5973078)
you're complaining that it has evolved out of its initial neologism?
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by Hovertruck on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:53PM (#5973159)
I'd call this the opposite. It's a devolution, equivalent to if we changed the meaning of the word soda to only apply to cola.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by dnautics on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:55PM (#5973495)
So, specialization, like how certain finches can now only eat nuts instead of nectar.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by dnautics on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:55PM (#5973499)
like how some finches can only eat nectar, others can only eat nuts.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by SeanDav on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:10PM (#5972019)
I would be quite fascinated to learn if the AdviceAnimals moderator that quashed the first investigation into gtw08 was receiving kickbacks from Quickmeme. The article does not go into that at all and it seems like an obvious point to address.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by minimaxir on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:42PM (#5972303)
Unfortunately, there's no evidence. (most of the article's information were from MwM and jokes_on_you themselves)

As mentioned with the article, Redditors shy away from conspiracy theories, because most of them sound too stupid to be true. Which, of course, makes actual conspiracies very effective.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by acgourley on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:16PM (#5972059)
The point that I make to people of your generation is that you can't lie to reddit. It's remarkable how many people try, but they don't understand that reddit's ability to detect bullshit is insanely high.

Gabe Newell Reflections of a Video Game Maker [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t8QEOBgLBQU

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by fnordfnordfnord on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:40PM (#5974523)
"The Miltz brothers learned the hard way that cheating Reddit doesn’t pay."

Looks like it paid handsomely for a year or more.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by redblacktree on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:58PM (#5974627)
Exactly my thought when I read that. I figured if I was them, I'd be saying, "Well, at least I've already got the yachts and vacation homes."
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by zalew on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:44PM (#5972309)
> The Miltz brothers learned the hard way that cheating Reddit doesn’t pay.

1.6 million dollars per month doesn't pay?

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by xanderstrike on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:25PM (#5972606)
Well that 80% drop in traffic is going to ensure that it doesn't pay any more. They've probably spent millions on infrastructure that will no longer be generating revenue, I imagine they'll see losses while they adjust.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by baggachipz on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:33PM (#5972647)
Still ~$320,000 per month... nothing to sneeze at there either. I somehow doubt their infrastructure costs anywhere near that.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by MichaelGG on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:19PM (#5972949)
This kinda thing seems perfect for elastic computing. They could scaleup the front-end on demand, and use S3 or whatever for actual storage, then aggressively delete older or less popular content. If their traffic drops, just scale down.

"Cloud" in this manner seems like a great hedge for sites that rely on somewhat fickle popularity.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by corresation on Monday July 01, 2013 @10:17PM (#5975364)
Did they grow on the back of cheating Reddit, however? If this was a more recent desperation tactic, then it did explode in their face rather spectacularly, seeing a much more dramatic decline than they would have likely seen with simple competition.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by rufugee on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:41PM (#5972708)
Quickmeme was now netting the brothers around $1.6 million a month

So...say I have an idea which would allow me to drive a lot of traffic to my site from Reddit. How does one begin to monetize this traffic? Where do you start? Where do you go to find advertisers? I've always had a vague understanding how it worked, but if I really had an idea with lots of traffic generation today, I lack the real world understanding re: how to turn that traffic into dollars now.

Also, /r/AdviceAnimals all seem to link directly to images...so where would the page views for quickmeme come from? Were they generating $1.6M simply by showing ads to the meme creators?

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by arn on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:25PM (#5973667)
The $1.6 million a month estimate is completely made up. They just used some web service that tries to estimate, based on pageviews. Not based on any actual knowledge. (That said, they probably did well - but not that well.)

According to the same site, HN makes $1.4 million a year.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by minimaxir on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:43PM (#5972716)
Quickmeme used the infamous transparent JPG trick to prevent direct linking of images, forcing links on /r/AdviceAnimals to link to the page with ads.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by mac1175 on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:42AM (#5977677)
Yeah, that was annoying to deal with when I posted because I would have to use Chrome's Dev tools to extract the image Url. For the average user, this wasn't so helpful if they didn't want ads.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by rufugee on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:54PM (#5972789)
Can you explain how this works or provide a link to an explanation? Thanks.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by minimaxir on Monday July 01, 2013 @02:58PM (#5972819)
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by jessaustin on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:21PM (#5972968)
So this means that there are a significant number of people "skilled" enough to right-click, but not skilled enough to view source. The mind boggles...
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by FireBeyond on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:34PM (#5973036)
The latest variations of this put the transparent JPG in the source code, then load in the image via JS with a lower Z layer. Now you move from "View Source", to "Developer Extension, watch assets, copy initial URL, paste, save".
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by icebraining on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:21PM (#5973964)
Nope, just Select All → View Source, which shows the current DOM state, at least on Firefox.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by skeletonjelly on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:30PM (#5974449)
Used to weird me out that Chrome performs a new GET request for page source but I guess I'm used to it now.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by andyhmltn on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:28PM (#5974438)
Well today I learned something new!
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by jonknee on Monday July 01, 2013 @05:42PM (#5973771)
How is that at all surprising? Right click is a really common thing for most non-Mac users. View source is something most people have only used by accident.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by ricardobeat on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:37PM (#5974105)
when was the last time you used a mac? right click has been omnipresent for the past half decade.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by jonknee on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:27PM (#5974794)
I use a Mac every day. I also watch other people use Macs and not only do they not use a contextual menu, but they by and large don't use keyboard shortcuts either. HN users are a pretty small subset of computer users.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by lesslaw on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:56PM (#5973178)
select text an address bar, ctrl-c

click somewhere else ctrl-v

and yes, view-source is beyond most people

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by bostonpete on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:09PM (#5972009)
What happened to the higher ranking mod who tried to intimidate ManWithoutModem to not look into the issue any further...?
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by makomk on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:54PM (#5972388)
He's still a moderator there and still hasn't reinstated ManWithoutModem as one. Apparently a large chunk of the Advice Animals moderation team also quit over it.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by zachlatta on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:49AM (#5971408)
No idea if anyone's interested, but I'm currently working on an open source Quickmeme alternative. I plan to deploy the MVP later this week. The Github repository is over at https://github.com/zachlatta/easymeme
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by billybob255 on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:23PM (#5975627)
It's a cool project, but HN doesn't seem like the sort of site that would be interested. Not that I'm criticizing you or your post.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by zachlatta on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:17AM (#5975799)
Yeah, absolutely. Honestly, I'm not the biggest fan of memes myself. The opportunity arose, so I asked myself why not.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by idupree on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @01:10AM (#5975962)
Don't forget to add a license file if you mean it to be open source (e.g. MIT/BSD, GPL).
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by zachlatta on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @11:02AM (#5978213)
Thanks! I forgot to do that! I looked into it and ended up going with the MIT license.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by benologist on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:16PM (#5973937)
Ironically the submitter is a dailydot spammer, the second submission they've successfully spammed about this site spamming reddit.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5927904

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by chiph on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:47PM (#5972338)
Between all the image macro sites, who holds copyright on the base images?

I imagine the owners of Grumpy Cat (the cat) are motivated to continue to allow photos of their pet to be used as Grumpy Cat (the meme), because they get exposure. But what about Overly Attached Girlfriend (apologies, don't remember her name IRL) -- the photos are of her, not a pet. I would think she has a stronger case in demanding ownership.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by icebraining on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:37PM (#5974109)
Copyright is hold by the person who took the photo, so they both have a case. That said, what can she do? As long as Reddit responds to DMCA takedown requests, they should be under safe harbor, so unless she planned on suing each submitter - and for nothing, since damages would be very hard to show -, there's really not much she can do.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by thereallurch on Monday July 01, 2013 @12:58PM (#5971921)
estimated $1.6 mil a month for > 12 months? For a meme generator? I'd say they had a good run.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by Uperte on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:31PM (#5972195)
Those numbers are from Worth of Web which is not reliable source. Were they making bank? Sure, but nowhere near $1m per month. CPM on websites like these is low.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by Puer on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:06PM (#5971982)
Are there any possible legal repercussions? I mean, yeah, if they made upwards of 12 million dollars from their site then banning it from reddit isn't exactly going to hurt them...
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by numbsafari on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:22PM (#5972102)
I guess Reddit could complain to the DA and press charges under CFAA, but the irony would probably cause the internet to implode.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by enraged_camel on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:23PM (#5972103)
Reddit users were a humongous part of their visitor-base, though. I don't know of many people outside of Reddit who have heard about them.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by MWil on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:23PM (#5972105)
I would love to see livememe bring a lawsuit, not because I'm trigger happy but because it sounds like they lost a ton of money which only had one direct cause.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by danielweber on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:00PM (#5972835)
I don't think you have a right to not have your stuff downvoted on a website.
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by MWil on Monday July 01, 2013 @04:04PM (#5973239)
I think you do have a right not to have your competitors engage in anticompetitive behavior
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by NanoWar on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @01:34AM (#5976023)
"The Miltz brothers learned the hard way that cheating Reddit doesn’t pay."

Well, actually...

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by _pmf_ on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @03:01AM (#5976250)
> The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire

... asylum ... inmates.

Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by pawrvx on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:23PM (#5973986)
Reddit needs to get rid of all moderators from the default sub-reddits if it want's to survive over the long term.
[deleted]
Re:The Reddit sleuths who brought down a meme empire by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @03:45PM (#5973113)
Unsubscribe from the subreddits that are for the sort of content that you are not interested in.