Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by pdx on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:14AM
(#5406991)
Things that annoy me on most forums are the clutter added by signatures, join date (which I always confuse with posting date), and the ubiquitous avatar.
I really enjoy that HN lacks these distractions, so the presence of the avatars at the posted site was a disappointment. Still, it was much better than most.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by pmelendez on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:41AM
(#5407167)
Well you are right when you say that's part of the appeal of HN. The thing is, that's part of the appeal for a hacker. I bet that for a JS professional, part of the appeal of this site is to have restrict the news just to that domain.
At the end, the success or failure of these kind of web sites tend to be more related to the community rather than the look or the features.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by akakey on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:34AM
(#5406809)
what's with JavaScript community to make everything end in "js"? You don't see Ruby guys ending every one of their product names in "rb" or Python guys in "py".
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by bazzargh on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:49AM
(#5406871)
The java equivalent was '4j'. It's mildly useful on a mixed community like HN, you've got some idea before you click through what the target developer audience is.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by petercooper on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:21AM
(#5407380)
JavaScript is rather long. This can be an issue with domain names, event names, Twitter handles, etc. "Ruby" is a lot more succinct which is why we tend to use it as-is.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by pqdbr on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:48AM
(#5406864)
I think it's a simple matter of focus. One could extend your logic and say 'Why don't you get your tech news from NY Times instead of Hacker News, since they have a tech section in their website ?'
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by shaneeb on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:00AM
(#5406920)
True, but making a NY Times-like website for tech news wouldn't work either. HN works for techies because its clean and simple, and the karma/upvote mechanism keep the content relevant. So there is a difference from NY Times.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by shaneeb on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:06AM
(#5406704)
I never said it claims to be better and it isn't. Let me rephrase the question: why would anyone want to be on echojs instead of HN, given that it's essentially an HN clone for JS and HN community is bigger at the moment? Why would you use it?
I am just trying to understand its value for myself.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by pcote on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:55AM
(#5406896)
The first thing this has me thinking is that it looks like a "subreddit" of HN. I'm surprised to not have seen or heard of a Reddit style site with HN voting rules on it.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by untog on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:30AM
(#5407088)
Not quite, no. You can't downvote stories (only comments, when you reach an appropriate karma level) and the algorithms for story/comment decay seem to be wildly different.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by untog on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:40AM
(#5407159)
Hacker News isn't really that different- people flag the article instead of downvoting it, so it takes even fewer people to bury a story. It's happened more times than I can count.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by vaidik on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:40AM
(#5407497)
+1 for the effort. But there is already a project like that which you could have used for this purpose if your purpose was not to build something like HN but build something like HN for only JS: https://github.com/SachaG/Telescope
This would have saved a lot of programming effort.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by resu_nimda on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:48AM
(#5407572)
There is a 'source code' link at the bottom that leads to https://github.com/antirez/lamernews, which looks mostly the same with a different stylesheet, so I think they did save that effort ;)
And FWIW, Telescope may preserve the functionality of HN, but I like the design a lot less (though the Echo design could use some work).
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by sktrdie on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:21AM
(#5406585)
It's horrible: big fonts, 100% wide and awful spacing of elements. Gives me a headache just reading it. I like the topic though. Hope a designer can jump in and improve the overall experience.
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by btipling on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @02:43PM
(#5409281)
I am a software engineer who writes a lot of JavaScript and I care about software engineering topics. I am not interested in the latest jQuery library or basic JavaScript howtos and I want more meaningful discussions about JavaScript libraries than "wow nice!"
Re:Echo JS - JavaScript News
by resu_nimda on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:10AM
(#5407313)
But those X's do exist, if only temporarily. At any given time, you probably are an X programmer, and a community around X is useful to you. People may drop in and out, but it's still a (potentially) valuable resource.
I really enjoy that HN lacks these distractions, so the presence of the avatars at the posted site was a disappointment. Still, it was much better than most.
Part of the appeal of HN is I get interesting stuff from all over (#) not just my niche.
TO do an HN, but have it on one niche seems missing the point.
(#) less of it now, these kids today, back when I were a lad ... shoebox .. motorway.
At the end, the success or failure of these kind of web sites tend to be more related to the community rather than the look or the features.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5399879
My question then remains, what is different?
>>Why not just use HN to follow topics you like (JS in this case)?
It's a very subjective question. One answer can be why there's HN or why there's StackOverflow or why there's both.
It's actually good to have a dedicated JS forum, even if there are already many out there. Besides, on HN everything is posted - everything. People participating here are https://twitter.com/thejayfields/status/235074734163898368
I am just trying to understand its value for myself.
For example, anyone that dislikes {lang} will just downvote any {lang} article
vs
Reading the {lang} article and downvoting it if it's just linkspam
This would have saved a lot of programming effort.
And FWIW, Telescope may preserve the functionality of HN, but I like the design a lot less (though the Echo design could use some work).
Indubitably!
Need coffee....