...an AI summary, where you have to check by reading all the sources anyway, because once you get into more niche topics, it turns out that the source of the AI overview is often a comment from a random Redditor without any supporting evidence (and often just wrong).
Of course, many people just take whatever AI overview says at face value without any very verification.
Scary stuff...
This is a wide-scale erosion of truth, and people are not thinking about the far reaching long term consequences.
(Queue comments saying, "you think it was good before? Internet pages were already full of junk." Yes, but this is fundamentally worse.)
Yeah, great point! I was trying to find some information about what is actually in the EPI Wero requirements (due to some banks now requiring Play Integrity for Wero payments). And AI overview often completely made up statements, where the stated did not occur in the sources.
This is analogous to how it can make basic apps and websites, so people think it can make everything.
The people who are working with interesting info that AI can't answer or making interesting programs that AI can't write know that it is smoke and mirrors.
But this is the typical big tech modus operandi. If it destroys democracy, incites hate, or whatever, it's always the user fault for misusing/misunderstanding value-neutral tech. "Guns don't kill, people kill", yet in all countries that have gun control, gun deaths are much lower.
Besides that, in AI overviews reputable sources (e.g. good news papers) get mixed up with random Reddit comments, etc. In pure search, people develop an intuition to assign a confidence score to sources. (E.g. Wikipedia > some random Reddit comment or Tweet.)
I can then access the exact sources used for that.
Regular search is flooded with clickbait spam that won't get me to quality sources.
> But this is the typical big tech modus operandi. If it destroys democracy, incites hate, or whatever, it's always the user fault for misusing/misunderstanding value-neutral tech.
What alternative do you have to current status quo?
These days, Reddit just isn't the same anymore. The talk aspect is drying up, and it is clear there's a lot of AI involvement in discussions - I'm not talking 'user has had AI rephrase their own thoughts', but 'user is an ai'. Eventually, Reddit will dry up.
I also admit, I welcome it. Maybe we can stop using the web as a money-generating venture and go back to a more private web. Fewer users, but more connection.
I think this is selling allaboutberlin.com short. There is e.g. a tax calculator (I just had a cursory look, but it seems to get the basics right). It seems to be actively curated and much better organized as a whole bunch of threads with statements of facts intermingled with opinions and rumors you'd find at a social media site.
I created that website in direct response to all the incorrect information on Reddit and in Facebook groups. In the absence of official information, you are bound to find a lot of rumours. I used to be pretty active on the /r/berlin subreddit and boy oh boy were they wrong about a lot of things.
When I travel, I have a similar experience with more obscure border crossings. The information about them is generally incorrect, and you end up with a dozen websites parroting the same incorrect source. Curation involves checking the information.
[0] https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/immigration-office/wait-ti...
It is interesting to think about whether we will lose some key sources of information if AIs snipe all the easy queries that can be answered from multiple sources, leaving not enough traffic for the people who were generating the data to live off (because they were cross-subsidising the hard work with traffic to their easily reproducible work). I guess one option is more paywalling for the stuff that requires hard work (i.e. the way news/blogs went, and also the way this used to work, when people would buy a book to guide them on a move to a new city).
I don't know the details of how Google AI Overview tracks data provenance, but I don't think they have an accurate way of tracing the provenance of data in their model weights.
Not to say of course models appropriate and resell information that just one person ever wrote about.
Trying to find answers today means wading through oceans of garbage websites instead of meaningful ones. Only to maybe find honest sites. That choice is by design, as search engines can shape the internet the way they see fit. They now seem to cut out the good results and make everyone pay more. “Neutral” answers where every tech bro tries to game the results for more cash.
AI answers have removed that enormous friction and constant source of frustration, also at the cost of the few good sites that are left.
Allegedly only to repeat this enshittyfication process once again. Tangentially we currently might be living in the best iteration of AI. Sure the answers can be sometimes awful and wrong, but they are mostly honest, direct, undiluted and try to be truthful.
I might be okay with it.
People here complain about SEO infested, low quality sites but these are exactly what gets into the context of the ai summaries.
[1] https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/best-bank-germany