News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by waterTanuki on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:50PM (#50512186)
SpaceX has received more than $22B in subsidies from taxpayer money. They were built off of public funding as much as NASA was. At this point, they are not entitled to keep rocket designs and experiment results secret (except where national security is a concern) from other U.S. competitors. Any company that can obtain a security clearance and demonstrate ability to build should be able to receive these designs from the Federal Government. It's extremely inefficient to keep destroying rockets all so one man can keep his circular financing scheme going.

Armchair scientists who come along and say "Look what they did that NASA couldn't do" don't understand A) SpaceX wouldn't exist at all if not for 6 decades of innovations from NASA & JPL and B) NASA ACTUALLY does space exploration unlike SpaceX, and their budget has to support rovers on other planets, launches, the ISS, astronaut training, weather and climate research (which SpaceX and Blue Origin also benefit from).

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by lukeify on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:53PM (#50512213)
Your comment won't appeal to the capitalism-oriented audience of HN but you're right; so right in fact I believe a lot of this is already done.

Usually there is sharing between NASA and all private launch companies when it comes to failures, because they have a vested interest in the outcome of the rockets due to flying payloads on them (someone name me a US rocket that NASA _hasn't_ flown a payload on).

I don't disagree that I think the information sharing could be amped up little, though.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by WorkingDead on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:54PM (#50512224)
And Boeing-Lockheed hasnt recievend subsidies?
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by ceejayoz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:09PM (#50512798)
SpaceX is an example of how effective subsidies can be.

Boeing/Lockheed are examples of how ineffective they can be.

Both outcomes are possibilities.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by jryle70 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:56PM (#50512241)
Can you provide an example of subsidy for SpaceX? Who else got taxpayer money for space flights according to you?
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by ceejayoz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:34PM (#50512537)
> Who else got taxpayer money for space flights according to you?

All of them. That's OK! SpaceX was a phenomenal investment by the government. But it was undoubtedly one.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 16, 2026 @04:47AM (#50515793)
Total grants to SpaceX were well under a billion dollars. That isn’t nothing. And it’s returned phenomenally, including to the U.S. taxpayer. But it’s not some gargantuan commitment.

Tesla, on the other hand, has reeled it I.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by antonvs on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:36PM (#50512560)
Here's an example that answers both your questions:

https://www.gao.gov/assets/a586368.html

It includes $396 million for SpaceX and $288 million for Orbital Sciences to "develop and demonstrate commercial cargo transport capabilities." I.e., it was not a procurement contract for some deliverable for the government, it was a development subsidy.

Here's another one, which provided about $545 million to SpaceX: https://www.nasa.gov/humans-in-space/commercial-space/commer...

Those two total almost $1 billion for SpaceX. A lot of the other money to SpaceX has been in the form of procurement, such as cargo services to the ISS. There have also been mixed contracts which included both subsidies and procurement, such as the Commercial Crew Program. NASA describes it like this:

> "CCP has invested in multiple American companies that are designing and developing transportation capabilities to and from low-Earth orbit and the International Space Station. By supporting the development of human spaceflight capabilities, NASA is laying the foundation for future commercial transportation capabilities."

--https://www.nasa.gov/humans-in-space/commercial-space/commer...

SpaceX has received at least $2.6 billion from this program, but some of that is procurement.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by jryle70 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:05PM (#50513540)
First of all GP mentioned "SpaceX has received more than $22B in subsidies from taxpayer money". I wanted to know what they would include in that number. Do you think that's in the right ball pack?

Secondly, CCP includes two different kinds of agreements -- Space Act and Contracts. Only Space Act can more or less be considered subsidies. From your link:

When NASA decided to support the development of new U.S. human spaceflight capabilities to low-Earth orbit, it relied on its commercial partners to propose specifics, ranging from the design and capabilities to private investment ratio, milestone achievements, success criteria and timelines. Once an agreement was accepted, CCP and its expert teams worked closely with each company to provide technical support and determine when milestones were met.

SpaceX got more than $500 million from that. The $2.6 billion number was not an investment but contract for the crew flights.

Nobody denies that SpaceX owned a lot of its success to NASA. I don't know what OP wanted to spin here. ULA got even more money than SpaceX from the government (NASA and DOD). See where they are?

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by antonvs on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:28AM (#50514363)
You asked for an example, I gave you some.

> Secondly, CCP includes two different kinds of agreements -- Space Act and Contracts. Only Space Act can more or less be considered subsidies.

Yes, I addressed this. Perhaps reread my comment.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by chipsa on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:28PM (#50512496)
Contracts for services rendered are subsidies. I see.
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by ceejayoz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:34PM (#50512542)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subsidy

> Subsidies take various forms, such as direct government expenditures, tax incentives, soft loans, price support, and government provision of goods and services.

So, yes.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:38PM (#50512577)
SpaceX has a functioning "subsidized" manned space vehicle. Boeing has burned through a much larger subsidy for a competing system with nothing to show for it.
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by ceejayoz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:38PM (#50512581)
Yes. Not every investment pays off; that doesn't make them not investments.
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by AngryData on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:20AM (#50514331)
It is when they could have spent that money to do it themselves as they very clearly could through NASA.
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by andrewla on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:39PM (#50512582)
By "received more than $22B in subsidies from taxpayer money" do you mean "the government has spend more than $22B on services from SpaceX" or do you mean "the government has given money to SpaceX for which it receives no specific benefit"?

The Washington Post reporting on this is specifically about government contracts, that is, SpaceX is being paid to provide a service to the government. I don't think I would consider this a subsidy under any reasonable definition.

They have gotten actual subsidies for rural broadband and arguably the incentive tax breaks they've gotten are subsidies; this combines to about $2B or so of true subsidies.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by ceejayoz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:40PM (#50512592)
> do you mean "the government has given money to SpaceX for which it receives no specific benefit"?

That was a potential outcome, yes. The Commercial Crew/Cargo programs paid out in milestones; as Boeing has demonstrated, those payments don't depend on a completed product.

That SpaceX was successful is great, and a successful example of why we subsidize risky ventures.

As a more recent example, SpaceX gets paid for the in-development HLS, $2.9B so far for something that does not yet exist. https://www.usaspending.gov/award/CONT_AWD_80MSFC20C0034_800...

They get to keep it if the project fails or is canceled; we may not get anything out of it. But I'm inclined to consider it a good investment.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by skissane on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:53PM (#50512691)
> They get to keep it if the project fails or is canceled

I don't think milestone payments which you keep even if the project gets cancelled count as a "subsidy".

The same thing happens in the private sector – if a big company hires a contractor to work on a project, and then decides to cancel the project, the contractor usually gets to keep the payment for the work they performed, even though it turned out to be pointless in the long-run – but who would call that a "subsidy"?

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by ceejayoz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:55PM (#50512713)
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1361983/000119312513...

> 4.1 Down Payment. The Parties acknowledge that [*…*] of the aggregate [*…*] in payments made by Customer to SpaceX pursuant to the Falcon 1e Agreement shall be applied as a down payment under this Agreement, to be equally between the first Launch Service and the second Launch Service (individually or together, as applicable, the “Down Payment”), as reflected below, against the aggregate Forty-Two Million, Six Hundred Thousand U.S. dollars ($42,600,000) payable under this Agreement. The Parties further acknowledge and agree that, by virtue of execution of this Agreement, any claim, obligation, or liability, or refund that may be owed, under the Falcon 1e Agreement is waived or terminated, as applicable.

They threw money at a risky investment. It paid off, and that's great; it was a very cost-effective use of subsidies.

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by oskarkk on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:13PM (#50513205)
This is a contract between SpaceX and Orbcomm, concerning the launch of some commercial communication satellites. The initial contract was for a launch on Falcon 1e (cancelled rocket), this is a new contract for the launch of the same satellites on Falcon 9. The paragraph you cited declares the previous contract null and void, and says that the money Orbcomm paid for it is transferred to the new contract. So I'm failing to see the relevance here, certainly it's not an example of subsidy or of keeping money for work not done.
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by bryanlarsen on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:46PM (#50512647)
The article is about Lockheed/Boeing/ULA, who received far more in subsidies than SpaceX ever did. For example, back when ULA had a launch monopoly, they received $1B a year for "launch readiness". IOW, money for nothing.
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by IAmNotACellist on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:48PM (#50512652)
"Armchair scientists who come along and say..."

So, yourself?

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by grosswait on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:58PM (#50513121)
You sound like the subject of Paul Graham's response. https://x.com/paulg/status/2122033524857589799?a=gCWeSGmkpXf...
Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by DoesntMatter22 on Monday November 16, 2026 @03:08AM (#50515219)
Nearly everything said in this comment is either wrong or completely ridiculous.

ULA and others have received far more money. And space X just makes good products. That's the secret

Re:Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails mid-flight, destroys payload... by anon7000 on Monday November 16, 2026 @03:20AM (#50515278)
Hmm. I think you’re suggesting that if the Falcon 9 design was publicly accessible, all other companies should be able to use it.

Honestly, I think a lot of the basics of the design are kinda out there, right? People generally know how the engines work, what propellant it uses, etc.

The hard part is integrating it, testing it, and operating it over time. No one did that before SpaceX. Unless you’re suggesting SpaceX also provide a complete design for the factories and complete operations too?

But at that point, what incentive does SpaceX have to keep innovating on rockets? SpaceX is very obviously an example of a company that is both innovating on a technological level, and trying very hard to innovate even further. In a field that has really struggled with innovation for decades.

In my view, we shouldn’t disrupt that process while it’s working and benefiting people. (Cheapest launch systems ever made, only reusable orbital launch system on the planet, etc etc etc.) We should go after monopolistic companies which are not innovating any more, and just jack prices and make products worse. We should go after SpaceX if they start doing that.

Also, just making it open doesn’t mean NASA could, say, build and operate Starship for cheaper if only they had the designs. They don’t need to have an assembly line of rockets, and without that they’ll never have the economies of scale to make it cheaper. NASA wants to pay someone else so they don’t have to worry about it, they want to run science missions and explore, not build a car. SpaceX wants to mass manufacture. Very different goals.