So does Apple even need to create applications (that nowadays will get copied and opensourced in a day), or the hardware is the winning strategy in the end?
I think the more interesting question for Apple is the split between cloud and local. Economies of scale and aggregation vs privacy and ownership. I’d say so far it’s 2-1.
Who has? Google, Anthropic, OpenAI and Microsoft have spent hundreds of billions and produced nothing but chat apps that Apple could build in a few days, they’re all just interfaces to models that are available to Apple via an API. Hard to imagine Apple as anything but the winner of this era unless OpenAI or Anthropic pull something out of the bag.
You could spend it on free universal healthcare.
> they are being inactive because they don't have the skillsets
Rare to see an argument that Apple can't hire talent.
They need a significant team creating their own model, (the talent of which has already gone elsewhere) and they also need to be working towards the future of photonic computing for running those models with success long term, again which will require a huge hiring effort. Considering it's clear they are not putting in that hiring effort it's obvious what work they have been doing.
This is extremely revisionist. For ex with WiFi, ThinkPad + a Lucent WiFi card was standard issue for years before any Apple product had WiFi. Apple shipped integrated WiFi, which is wholly consistent with the notion of improving what the industry is doing.
Connectors? Yes, Apple has a history of improving connectors. Other computers have had connectors since forever. In this case, Firewire was Apple's semi-proprietary alternative to USB. USB, which Apple put into their computers years after others had shipped it.
> They need a significant team creating their own model
Your judgement. It's entirely reasonable at this point to license other models and look for a better/cheaper entry point. Apple tends to enter markets when it is possible to make profit. It is not clear yet that the business of creating and running advanced models is a profitable venture. By which I mean no company has yet demonstrated the ability to earn a positive ROI by developing and running an advanced model.
> working towards the future of photonic computing
Again, nothing in Apple's history would suggest that they would even aim to do this.
None of that stuff has worked right for several years now apart from maybe Gmail.
This isn’t true they’ve literally launched Apple Intelligence with multiple apps and surfaces three times now and it’s flopped each time so badly they regroup and pretend it wasn’t the real launch then launch it again at the next WWDC.
Siri just got AI-fied and it's worse and slower than ChatGPT in 2022. Also it doesn't work offline anymore.
I used to "describe a shortcut" maybe 5 times this week and today I was hit with "you reached the limit". Mind you I have a 17 Pro and spend $120/year on iCloud.
These are useful applications of AI - or would be if they actually worked.
But this is all based on marketing not facts. Apple is as privacy invasive as the next guy. Obviously this shtick will work as long as marketing continues do to good job.
Could be the winner, in your opinion. They are extremely well positioned with hardware, devices, ecosystem, privacy, brand value & trust, and a significant active base. So far, they have not yet delivered on any useful AI application. There are so many opportunities in both MacOS and iOS, I guess they just need a new software VP.