Turns out that's not a thing. https://duckduckgo.com/?q="proto+feral+cats"
Looks like neutered pet cats are just that.
Not all pet cats are neutered, those that aren't breed.
Where do you think feral cats come from then? They were not native to Australia (for example) until pet cats were bought over.
* https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-10-17/research-project-ding...
* https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-10-07/malupirti-springs-cam...
Neutered? Good.
Abandoned, not neutered? - Not Good, and heading toward a feral life.
A pet cat wandering free is not in the latter category.
Quick question, do you actually live under a rock, have you never spoke to rescue workers at Cat Haven, are you fully clueless about the numbers of "pet cats" that end up as not pets?
And the vast majority of pets cats are neutered so they still don't go into the second category even if they get abandoned.
All un-neutered outdoor cats absolutely are potential feral cats.
Not all turn feral, not all abandoned - but all have the potential.
On this point I have actual life experience and have worked with town rangers and native conservationists who prefer their bilbies et al over the cats and foxes that kill them.
Introduced species left to run wild are an actual problem - although you appear to struggle to acknowledge that as fact.
Your reading of it is suspect.
All pet cats are potential feral cats - ones that are neutered will only prey on wildlife until they die without offspring. Cats that can breed will litter out wild cats if allowed to run wild.
It's pretty straight forward.
> All un-neutered outdoor cats absolutely are potential feral cats.
These are very different statements, are they not? And the main difference is the neutering.
Neutered cats that lose their house don't usually become properly feral and even when they do it's not a big percent of feral cats as far as I can tell. It's a rare thing, outdoor cats are not "proto feral" as a whole.
Abandoned cats either wander about looking for new owners or turn wild.
You and I disagree.
Especially given that earlier crack about me "struggling to acknowledge" the idea of introduced species. You mentioned cats as an introduced species to someone else, not to me! And even then, a probably-deliberate release of cats 240 years ago into a cat-free land is very very different from modern pets in a land that already has lots of cats.
A number of abandoned cats do turn feral.
We know this, here in Australia, as most pet cats are chipped and when cats are captured rangers can test if they have been chipped (and whether the registered owners are still about).
So, is it deliberate that this is indistinguishable from making outside cats illegal? Otherwise how the heck are owners supposed to ensure cats stay on their property?
Sounds like that's their problem to figure out, and I think that's right. I would 1000 times rather have more birds at my feeders than the neighbor's cat pooping in my yard, hunting birds and bothering my dog.
Let them put in a good fence, electric collar, leash with one of those zip line things - whatever they have to do.
At bird feeders the percentage of individual visitors that are non-native is often much higher. The non-natives tend to be more generalist eaters, whereas the native specifies tend to stick more to their native diet which isn't as well served by most feeders.
By drawing in these generalist non-natives feeders tend to actually displace native birds from the surrounding area.
That's why when I was feeding birds I didn't really worry about cats getting into my yard. I couldn't think of a way to make a good argument that the line of how much harm it is OK to do to the native environment for your enjoyment is somewhere between the harm feeding non-native birds does and the harm the neighborhood cats do (especially since I've never seen a cat catch a bird in my yard).
you know how crazy you sound?
read the exchange in which i told someone they sounded crazy. understand it in context, and try to be less eager to blurt out your first reaction. god damn.
I have an electric fence; cats sense it and avoid it. 20+ years without a cat getting off the property.
If you'd like that pleasure, you're welcome to it. You just don't get to inflict your particular masochist tendencies on your neighbors.
The irony of "control your animals" while referring to wild birds as "yours" is ... interesting.
> In Faith's case, Wissner said, the neighbor apparently didn't realize the fence line and property line weren't the same
It’s weird because it’s like a series of well meaning people that dropped the ball on what was the most obvious action to take.
The concept of being on ranch property gets a bit nebulous in Wyoming when you realize much private land is checkerboarded with blm land and the ranchers have long term blm grazing leases. The dog being outside the rancher's private property doesn't mean it's not out doing its job.
I don’t know the full story here, but have you tried talking to your neighbor? Like, really tried in a way that takes their perspective seriously? Because what you’ve described here is essentially guaranteed to make the relationship worse and likely to cause other problems down the road. Heaven forbid you ever truly need this person’s help, you’re going to be in a tough spot.
Wording could be taken either way, and I could be wrong, but it almost sounds like the dog was not on the property of its owner, and was over the fence in the neighbours property?
We have a huge problem with pet cats that stray from their properties and eat birds/fish/etc in neighbouring properties... if one turns up on my property, I trap it and send it to the shelter specifically so the owner gets fined, even though I know who owns it. It's what our local council/government recommend we do considering the owners already know it's illegal for pet cats to be off their property here (or even outside of their house after dark, which is almost always when we trap them in our yard).