Google has this pattern of all or nothing approach.
Maps refuses to show your *current* location if you don't enable location accuracy i.e. if you won't allow it to spy on your WiFi or Bluetooth it refuses to show your current location at all.
We can disable notifications and even phone access but physical activity is the one permission that cannot be disabled for play services !?
Google apps have a lot of WTFs!
I found out later that Goog411 was created to primarily train on the voice prompts from the users of the service. Left a really bad taste.
I know this idea is over the head of probably 75% of people, so forgive me if this is too dense to understand, but "full payment" is the sum of all forms of payment (usually a combo of data, ads, and money). The seller of a product/service is the one who determines the payment component ratios, and the buyers decide if they want it or not. This applies to everything from streaming services, to app subscriptions, to TV sales.
So while true that you are giving money to Google, it is also true that you are paying the rest of the "full payment" with your data.
Google offers the option to pay the "full payment" with only money too. But often companies do not, and only offer other ratios of "full payment".
Don't feel bad for not grasping this, seemingly everyone else is unable to get it without having it spelled out.
Create an API key linked to your billing info
There are though some more privacy friendly alternatives that I remember from playing with GrapheneOS settings.
And on phones. In my experience, a hot start fix (with up to date ephemeris) shouldn't take more than a couple seconds. Maybe you have a bad antenna.
There's no reason they can't have a mix of "this is popular in general" and "your subs and likes suggest you'd like this" on the front page - they just don't want people to disable watch history. They are required to offer that as an option, but they'll never stop pestering you about it.
That one I do like. YouTube’s homepage (at least with history off) is a cesspool of uninteresting clickbait garbage so I’m glad to have it off. I do agree with you they seem to think of it as some kind of punishment¹, which makes it all the more satisfying that it works as I want it.
¹ It’s now entirely blank for me, but I remember when they started doing this (it wasn’t always the case) they showed a message that suggested not having a homepage was undesirable.
Imagine if you go to Google.com to do a web search, and it is a page full of recommendations on sites to visit. Would you want that?
Call it what it is, please. User-hostile behaviour that compels you to turn their tracking on if you want to use any of the practically helpful services.
I'm a super privacy conscious person, and even I end up keeping many of these things on simply because I want to use for eg google assistant.
Sandboxed Play Services works on Grapheneos without physical activity so it's definitely not actually required by their services.
But I think they showed the best example of that behavior just recently: no AI, no Google search for students because search is "too integrated" with AI (https://www.forbes.com/sites/maryroeloffs/2026/11/03/google-...)
Then again, anon YouTube no longer showing recommendations on the start page is what waned me off the website.
Thanks for the reminder OP!
They are not transparent about it either. Anything you link to it to enable basic functionality you had on device before gets them the ability to use it for not just training but ads and measurement.
I had it switched off:
"Hey Google, remind me at 7pm <something>"
"OK, your reminder is set for 7pm"
Next day:
"Hey Google, why didn't you remind me at 7pm"
"I can't do anything with your phone unless you enable chat history."
WTAF!