News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by devsda on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:44AM (#50364788)
This was the case with Google Assistant too.

Google has this pattern of all or nothing approach.

Maps refuses to show your *current* location if you don't enable location accuracy i.e. if you won't allow it to spy on your WiFi or Bluetooth it refuses to show your current location at all.

We can disable notifications and even phone access but physical activity is the one permission that cannot be disabled for play services !?

Google apps have a lot of WTFs!

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by bonoboTP on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:16AM (#50365118)
It's no wtf. Google is an ad company so they want all your data to target ads at you.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by amelius on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:25AM (#50365956)
Yes, it's almost like a fairy tail where children are offered candy but then very bad things happen. Hansel und Gretel, etc. We should have known all along!
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by wingmanjd on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:48AM (#50366282)
Continuing with your Hansel and Gretel metaphor, the first time the candy turned sour for me was Goog-411. It was a service (at least over here in the US) that allowed you to look up local businesses via voice prompts over a phone call. When the service was still active, calling 411 via a mobile phone had a per-call cost, so a free lookup service seemed great.

I found out later that Goog411 was created to primarily train on the voice prompts from the users of the service. Left a really bad taste.

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by WarmWash on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:55AM (#50366402)
People use Google everyday, block all ads, get extremely angry about Google's grubby advertising hands, and then when you tell them their are paid services like Kagi and Proton...."pay for this stuff? Nah, I have a right to it for free!"
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by bonoboTP on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:38AM (#50367128)
Payment doesn't guarantee anything tho. We are right now in a thread about a paid product by Google still spying.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by WarmWash on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:01AM (#50367502)
Payment is a compound of inputs.

I know this idea is over the head of probably 75% of people, so forgive me if this is too dense to understand, but "full payment" is the sum of all forms of payment (usually a combo of data, ads, and money). The seller of a product/service is the one who determines the payment component ratios, and the buyers decide if they want it or not. This applies to everything from streaming services, to app subscriptions, to TV sales.

So while true that you are giving money to Google, it is also true that you are paying the rest of the "full payment" with your data.

Google offers the option to pay the "full payment" with only money too. But often companies do not, and only offer other ratios of "full payment".

Don't feel bad for not grasping this, seemingly everyone else is unable to get it without having it spelled out.

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by bonoboTP on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:12PM (#50371593)
How do I pay Google for Gemini without spying?
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by WarmWash on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:55PM (#50374102)
https://aistudio.google.com/docs

Create an API key linked to your billing info

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by WmWsjA6B29B4nfk on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:41AM (#50365381)
I've just turned off location accuracy, google maps displayed a popup said results will be better if I turn it on, and after dismissing the popup it did use GPS to localize me with no issues.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by franktankbank on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:52AM (#50365524)
A/B testing rules
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by indigo945 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:14AM (#50365825)
This will only work for a few weeks, after which the location will be missing entirely. (Which just makes it more obvious that this is an intended feature, not a bug.)
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by WmWsjA6B29B4nfk on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:53AM (#50366358)
If true, what you described makes it sound exactly like a bug, not an intended feature.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by wafflemaker on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:36PM (#50372449)
GPS only navigation is really bad. Takes ages to get a lock, especially in bad weather.

There are though some more privacy friendly alternatives that I remember from playing with GrapheneOS settings.

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by dTal on Thursday November 05, 2026 @09:41AM (#50379665)
Funny, it works just fine for cruise missiles.

And on phones. In my experience, a hot start fix (with up to date ephemeris) shouldn't take more than a couple seconds. Maybe you have a bad antenna.

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by wafflemaker on Thursday November 05, 2026 @04:17PM (#50384577)
I'm comparing 0 GPS assist with full assist. Takes a few seconds and another few for a proper lock. With assist it's kind of instant. But I'm close to Polar Circle, maybe it's less sats over the North Pole?
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by BoppreH on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:51AM (#50366314)
And the YouTube home page is blank if you have Watch History off. The recommendation algorithm still runs on the side bar of any video you watch, but the home page refuses to even show your subscriptions.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by ACCount39 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:57AM (#50366416)
Yeah, this is just Google punishing people for not enabling their data harvesting.

There's no reason they can't have a mix of "this is popular in general" and "your subs and likes suggest you'd like this" on the front page - they just don't want people to disable watch history. They are required to offer that as an option, but they'll never stop pestering you about it.

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by OvervCW on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:32AM (#50367034)
I'm surprised they don't just store your watch history anyway , with the toggle option being "don't show me or people looking over my shoulder my watch history".
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by TingPing on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:36AM (#50368080)
My watch history is set to 3 months. It used to constantly show things I had already seen. However eventually (years ago) I just don’t get repeats.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by SoftTalker on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:58AM (#50366450)
That could be seen as a feature.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by latexr on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:38AM (#50367113)
> And the YouTube home page is blank if you have Watch History off.

That one I do like. YouTube’s homepage (at least with history off) is a cesspool of uninteresting clickbait garbage so I’m glad to have it off. I do agree with you they seem to think of it as some kind of punishment¹, which makes it all the more satisfying that it works as I want it.

¹ It’s now entirely blank for me, but I remember when they started doing this (it wasn’t always the case) they showed a message that suggested not having a homepage was undesirable.

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by BoppreH on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:55AM (#50368355)
Agree, but it should at least show recent uploads from my subscription. It's stupid that I can visit "www.youtube.com" and not see a single video.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by rolosa on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:49PM (#50369064)
That's actually a plus.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by BeetleB on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:20PM (#50370270)
I have to say - I actually like this.

Imagine if you go to Google.com to do a web search, and it is a page full of recommendations on sites to visit. Would you want that?

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by BoppreH on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:08PM (#50371546)
The difference is that I'm subscribed to a variety of channels on YouTube. Yes, I do want to see their videos on the front page. That's what the Subscriptions page is doing anyway.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by BeetleB on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:11PM (#50371579)
Yes, but what algorithm will it use to show videos from the channels you're subscribed to? Will you and everyone else agree with that choice of algorithm? The only one that makes sense is chronological. Anything else leads to similar problems as in the past.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by BoppreH on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:26PM (#50371802)
Yes, chronological from my subscriptions. I'm logged in, it's just my Watch History that off. Like the Reddit homepage showing the most popular posts from the communities I've joined. What's the problem with that?
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by BeetleB on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:03PM (#50373166)
I agree, but most people do not. A quite common complaint of Mastodon - even here on HN - is that chronological makes discovery difficult.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by Timon3 on Thursday November 05, 2026 @04:58AM (#50377302)
I find it hard to believe anyone prefers "no results" to "chronological results".
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by dTal on Thursday November 05, 2026 @09:37AM (#50379614)
You know what makes discovery difficult? A blank page
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by aquentinn on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:18PM (#50373301)
Welcome to monopoly where they get the free videos from the sheep and still order you around. Why has Youtube not been disrupted btw, everyone gave up or did VCs order it?
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by syshyk on Thursday November 05, 2026 @03:08AM (#50376484)
I have a whole add-on just to default/redirect me to my subscriptions page.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by user_7832 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:54AM (#50366382)
> Google has this pattern of all or nothing approach.

Call it what it is, please. User-hostile behaviour that compels you to turn their tracking on if you want to use any of the practically helpful services.

I'm a super privacy conscious person, and even I end up keeping many of these things on simply because I want to use for eg google assistant.

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by marcosdumay on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:13PM (#50368563)
Last time I tried, Maps also refused to show a map at all, from anywhere if you didn't enable your location.
Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by Sayrus on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:47PM (#50373032)
> We can disable notifications and even phone access but physical activity is the one permission that cannot be disabled for play services !?

Sandboxed Play Services works on Grapheneos without physical activity so it's definitely not actually required by their services.

But I think they showed the best example of that behavior just recently: no AI, no Google search for students because search is "too integrated" with AI (https://www.forbes.com/sites/maryroeloffs/2026/11/03/google-...)

Re:Tell HN: Gemini trains on chat history, even for subscrib... by gherkinnn on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:54PM (#50373097)
Surely that approach is implemented to force people in to the all group.

Then again, anon YouTube no longer showing recommendations on the start page is what waned me off the website.