News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by moralestapia on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:01PM (#50064766)
To expand, we might find out the hard way that having an expiration date was a feature of our species, not a flaw.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by kees99 on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:07PM (#50064804)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck%27s_principle

...which in a somewhat blunt rephrasing is quoted as: "Science progresses one funeral at a time"

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by LoganDark on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:18PM (#50064900)
Indeed; the biggest reason is surely cancer.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by dyauspitr on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:34PM (#50065020)
That’s a coping mechanism because we can’t change it.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by hootz on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:45PM (#50065107)
Wasn't death a requirement for us to reach this current stage of human evolution? I don't think it is a good idea to stop it entirely.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by jeremyjh on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:49PM (#50065145)
Evolution of humans by natural selection is already over with - or at least proceeding at time scales irrelevant to our civilization.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by card_zero on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:23PM (#50065385)
"Contrary to popular belief," https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recent_human_evolution

I don't think it matters, mind you.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by snk on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:56PM (#50065610)
If it doesn't matter then it is not evolution, right?
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by card_zero on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:10PM (#50065729)
So it's things like: some people died because there was a famine and they didn't have lactose tolerance (and thus didn't have any cows, or they'd just eat the cows, a detail). Some people died due to having unnecessarily large and sturdy jaws in the era of cooked food. (Not sure how this would cause death, perhaps due to greater surface area for tooth trouble? It's always the teeth.) Then, their offspring - wait, I mean other people's offspring - are more adapted and less vulnerable.

Well sure, we should become less vulnerable, including biologically. But there are better ways to accomplish this than having people killed.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by pestatije on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:18AM (#50068890)
that's plain wrong... selection continues to this day through ability to reproduce, not longevity
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by bravoetch on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:21PM (#50065371)
Not sure about death being required. It's more that life after reproductive success is not required.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by robwwilliams on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:01PM (#50065648)
…that longer life after reproductive exhaustion is not under selection.”
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by idle_zealot on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:22PM (#50065379)
Curing aging doesn't stop death entirely. There's still the attrition of living in the physical world. Some portion of the population will trip and break their necks every year.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by suslik on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:00PM (#50065213)
Of course it's a feature; it still doesn't mean it cannot be stopped or considerably postponed.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by TedDoesntTalk on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:06PM (#50065256)
I’m always fascinated by people who think death can be “stopped” (not postponed, but eliminated). Fascinating.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by suslik on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:08PM (#50065274)
Is there a reason why it can't possibly be stopped?
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by TedDoesntTalk on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:32PM (#50065450)
Everything we have witnessed that arises also passes away. Every living thing, every dead thing - even stars and planets - arise and pass away.

I feel it’s the ultimate hubris to think we can cheat death.

Moreover, why would you want immortality?

Many books of fiction and poetry discuss the curse of immortality.

Here are a few:

The Immortal, Jorge Luis Borges (1947)

A man discovers a source of immortality, but eternity eventually destroys the significance of individual experiences. When everything can happen infinitely, nothing feels particularly important.

The Mortal Immortal — Mary Shelley (1833) - also wrote Frankenstein

A man drinks an elixir and lives for centuries without substantially aging. He watches his wife grow old and die, and becomes increasingly alienated from humanity. Shelley focuses on loneliness and the psychological weight of endless time.

All Men Are Mortal — Simone de Beauvoir (1946)

An immortal man lives through centuries of history, relationships, and political upheaval. Gradually he discovers that even extraordinary achievements seem meaningless when time is unlimited.

The Makropulos Affair — Karel Čapek (1922)

A woman lives more than 300 years through an elixir. She retains her youth but becomes emotionally exhausted, cynical, and incapable of finding pleasure.

—

There are more. Sure, these are fiction. But use your imagination. Why would you want immortality, even if you could retain perfect health indefinitely?

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by RuslanL on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @12:12AM (#50066604)
Or perhaps these authors could not imagine what being 100+ years of healthspan person would actually be like.

Imagine a civilization where death from biological aging would've happened at the age of 12. Would authors from such civilization be able to predict how a 45 year old would function? Or just extrapolate their (maximum 12) years old experience and come to the conclusion that being past 40 is so psychologically damaging that it would've been better to keep things the default way?

Note that I have just used my imagination, and came to different conclusions, so we are on the equal terms with said authors.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by TedDoesntTalk on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:24AM (#50070568)
Yes, you used your imagination. But only 45/12 =3.75 times. That puts our projectiok at approximately 100*3.75=375 years. That’s quite different than living several million years or indefinitely.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by RuslanL on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @02:57AM (#50083490)
I just demonstrated the principle. Equating something novel that neither us nor said authors could realistically imagine with something unquestionably bad is a logical fallacy (appeal to ignorance).
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by ryuuseijin on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:53PM (#50065982)
Great list. Also, Anne Rice's Vampire stories.

I like Alan Watt's view on death: "it's absurd to worry about death because when you're dead, you've got nothing to worry about, so you'll be alright".

And Neil deGrasse Tyson, I think in reference to life after death: "it's the same as before you were born". Kind of mindblowing perspective - you've already experienced the state of not existing, it's the same as before you were born.

This brings it home that really it's the now you should learn to live and appreciate to the fullest instead, not some future you have no control over. Still struggling how that translates into worrying about my future health, but I suppose there is still the now of the future to worry about.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by rootusrootus on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @12:31AM (#50066749)
> it's the same as before you were born.

That's how I've long viewed it. As a practical matter we live "forever." Still makes me a tad nervous if I find myself thinking about it in the dark at 2am, but during the day it is a satisfactory explanation.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by compton on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @09:00AM (#50070998)
> Kind of mindblowing perspective - you've already experienced the state of not existing, it's the same as before you were born.

Your consciousness might have existed before, in another body, and it might do so again after your death.

The fact is you don't know what happens after you die. Maybe you'll cease to exist and will never again come into existence, even over all the hundreds of trillions of years yet to come in this universe, and even in any of the who-knows-how-many other universes that will ever exist.

Or maybe the physical requirements to create your specific consciousness will reoccur again and again and again.

You just don't know. Nor does Neil deGrass Tyson. Nor does, for that matter, the pope or the Dalai Lama.

You may want certainty. You may crave it, even need it. But that's too bad, as you'll never have it.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by ryuuseijin on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:40AM (#50082456)
What's interesting to me here is what consciousess even means. I experience it in the moment, that I am sure of. But what about the past consciousness I only have memories of, or a future consciousness I care about to preserve? Lets admit the rules of physics in so far as they explain our observations, how does consciousness fit into this? Take away the meat of my brain (i.e. death), does consciousness still exist? Is there only one consciousness in the universe, except it's experienced only by entities that have chemical processes that translate into things like memory and feeling? What about AI, is there a consciousness in the matrix multiplications? Does a stone have a consciousness?

Wild things to ponder, I wonder if we will ever get a handle on this question.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by orangecat on Monday October 12, 2026 @11:38PM (#50066331)
I feel it’s the ultimate hubris to think we can cheat death.

And if we were meant to fly we'd have wings, and diseases are the gods punishing us for our sins.

Moreover, why would you want immortality?

I don't know about immortality, but I'd definitely like more than 80 years, and I'd like to be in good health for as long as I am alive.

Many books of fiction and poetry discuss the curse of immortality.

Yes, and those are almost entirely cope.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by TedDoesntTalk on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:26AM (#50070590)
> don't know about immortality, but I'd definitely like more than 80 years

You’re changing the subject; this is about immortality. I’d also like to live more than 80 years, and no book can convince me otherwise. But forever? No thanks.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by snk on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:54PM (#50065598)
Not everything; only 93% of humans have died, for example. Past != future.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by pestatije on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:08AM (#50068790)
...existing...
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by ribosometronome on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:23PM (#50065792)
Why would someone want to live 100 years? 80? 60? 40? 20? Were ultimately just saying we like living and would like to keep living until we decide we don’t want to anymore. The thought that people might like living longer than they get is pretty well supported by every dying person who doesn’t want to die rather than just some speculative fiction.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by Nursie on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:57PM (#50065628)
Because one lifetime is not enough to experience everything the world has to offer.

If one doesn't have to watch ones spouse, friends and family grow old and die, because it is available widely, that removes some of your objections.

Personally I don't subscribe to the idea that things lose meaning in a longer life, I find it a 'just so' story of self comfort in the face of the inevitable.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by card_zero on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:48PM (#50065561)
That is a really wanky, lazy, cliched, annoying trope - to a longevity advocate, of course. For the many people who inexplicably think death is friendly and wonderful, these tired old storylines are utterly insightful. (see also: Doctor Who, they did stories about immortality-seeking villains a few times.)
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by RuslanL on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @12:14AM (#50066620)
> Doctor Who

This is a bit ironic, considering the lifespan of Time Lords in that universe.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by jojobas on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:41PM (#50065509)
Well if one can live to the heat death of the universe I'll count it as prevented, not postponed, death.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by suslik on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @02:55AM (#50067778)
> Everything we have witnessed that arises also passes away. Every living thing, every dead thing - even stars and planets - arise and pass away.

The context was if biological aging and age-related death can be stopped / prevented / reversed, and I don't see in what you wrote an argument against that. Those are a set of biochemical processes, and if there exist a scientific principle which would prevent modulating them successfully, you didn't name it.

> Moreover, why would you want immortality?

First, this is an orthogonal question. Whether I don't want something to happen, doesn't mean it can't, or won't: I never wanted to be replaced by LLMs, but those got invented anyway. Anyhow, the immortality we're talking about isn't of the kind where you are unable to die no matter what, it's just you don't age. You are permanently 22 - but so is everyone around you. I don't know, maybe it gets boring after 300 years, maybe after 300.000 - but I'd rather try and take myself out when I feel like it than die feeling there's so much more to experience (which is almost certainly going to be the case).

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by TedDoesntTalk on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:21AM (#50070529)
> if there exist a scientific principle which would prevent modulating them successfully, you didn't name it.

Why does such a “ scientific principle “ need to exist? So that you could finally point to a clear reason that it’s impossible?

Did Newton’s laws of motion exist before they were described by Newton?

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by card_zero on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:28PM (#50065426)
Well, accidents. Inconveniently close supernovas. Something is likely to get you eventually, some few millennia later.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by moralestapia on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:29PM (#50078238)
I'm alway fascinated by people who think 80 years of life is the same thing as 1,000 years of life. Fascinating.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by card_zero on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:16PM (#50065334)
Walk me through it: in order to get dictators killed, because they defend themselves very effectively, we should put everybody on the planet under a biological death sentence, which will get the dictators too.

No, I cannot endorse this.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by setr on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:30PM (#50065434)
Science moves forward one death at a time

So at least two systems run better with the implicit time limit.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by card_zero on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:33PM (#50065460)
We should kill the dictators deliberately, improve our biology deliberately, and get stuffy old people like me to change their minds deliberately. No stupid use of death as a proxy, it's a horribly blunt instrument. "Let your ideas die in your place".

Besides, maybe it's the young people who are the most dogmatic. Studies are inconclusive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck%27s_principle#Rebuttal If we're going to go around killing people for having rigid ideas, perhaps concentrate on the young ones, for statistical reasons.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by idiotsecant on Monday October 12, 2026 @11:54PM (#50066453)
Humans who get old and comfortable often become quite terrible people.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by card_zero on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @12:48AM (#50066856)
That's a perception. Do they, though? If so, why? "I hope I die before I get old", sang The Who. Roger Daltrey is 82. Trump (slightly younger) was one of His Generation, although I expect he probably wasn't a mod. But what I mean is, the coercive oppression visited upon you by your elders is coming from the youth of yesterday, who had it lurking in them latently, waiting to gain status and money and influence. Those things arrive gradually (if at all) along with age, and I guess they make a person complacently comfortable, but the driving cause is that the person is a coercive dogmatist with a drive to oppress inferiors, and always was in most cases, because we don't usually learn to be wronger,* only how to express our terrible attitudes. So age isn't doing this, it's just revealing it.

* Undoubtedly sometimes the spark of malevolence develops into more coherent and sophisticated badness, I have to admit, so an old person has had more time to mature into being truly terrible. But this is against the pressure of rationality.

Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by shrubble on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:32PM (#50065455)
All it would take would be one billionaire who invested in long term bonds, à la Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy…
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by robwwilliams on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:55PM (#50065603)
Definitely a feature: Disposable soma theory of Kirkwood. Your germline is the real “you”.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by bloqs on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:55PM (#50065605)
Neurogenesis slows for a similar reason
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by mullingitover on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:10PM (#50065727)
It's a feature of every species that evolves. You can't evolve if you're striving to outcompete your offspring. You quickly game out that not having offspring is the winning chess move there. Now you're not having offspring, and thus you're not evolving. Then the environment changes and you, being unable to adapt in any way, go extinct.
Re:Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with... by c22 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @03:00AM (#50067816)
Cheating senescence is kind of the ultimate adaptation. If we can crack this then I'd expect designing other artificial adaptations to be quite tractable in the future.