News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by card_zero on Friday October 09, 2026 @02:40PM (#50024933)
But lots of things are mostly water. Fresh fruit juice, wine, meat, humans. They're just not made by adding water. Beer is though. I don't think it should be labelled "water".
Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by WarmWash on Friday October 09, 2026 @03:10PM (#50025299)
"From concentrate" pretty much means all the water was taken out, and then they decided how much to put back in. It also allows them to make incredibly sugary drinks while also advertising "No added sugar".

I suppose to be fair, whole pressed juices are incredibly expensive. But I think they should be forced to be more upfront about what these "juices" actually are - mostly apple juice powder with a few other fruit powders sprinkled in and then mixed with water to the desired sweetness level.

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by card_zero on Friday October 09, 2026 @03:22PM (#50025454)
The wool thing is mysterious, because I keep hearing about sheep farmers losing money on shearing sheep because the raw wool price is too low, and then I went round a fabric shop the other day and it was all polyester, I don't get why.
Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by killingtime74 on Friday October 09, 2026 @09:53PM (#50028731)
There's many grades of wool and the coarse ones really are very cheap. So cheap as to be used for carpet in government schools (in NZ/Australia).
Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by dylan604 on Friday October 09, 2026 @10:05PM (#50028800)
Polyester can be made 24/7 365 while wool comes in batches. Also, regardless of how low wool prices are, it will be more expensive than polyester components as the sheep require being fed and what not. Maybe polyester prices are affected by Hormuz closing????
Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by ahi on Saturday October 10, 2026 @12:16AM (#50029503)
Polyester ~$1000/MT, wool ~$15,000/MT. Polyester is cheap, barely more than it's feedstocks.
Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by woolion on Saturday October 10, 2026 @03:42AM (#50030640)
It's all processing. Wool is a free by-product, sheep have to be sheared. More than 20 years ago, it was a pretty lump sum for someone who would shear 10K sheep a year. Still not much compared to the shearing price, but that helps sheep get more meat, reduce disease problems, and also reduce their size to the feeding stations. So a win for everybody.

Then, everything closed and the only thing left was to send it to China. Priced dropped entirely, to the point where it would mostly be considered a net negative. You have to store it before you can send a batch, and that takes a lot space. Not only that, but it has to stay dry. Then, consider you want to have a basic sort already done, because you don't want the whole batch to be paid little because it would be considered the lowest grade. So Bags should be consistent; they also have to be dense enough to avoid taking too much space (typical bags are around 1 cubic meter / 100kg). Most of these operation require quite a lot of very tiring human labor, which also require some skills, a problem pervasive with the sheep industry.

So yes, in the end it's too cheap to produce but too expensive to buy.

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by swiftcoder on Saturday October 10, 2026 @06:25AM (#50031454)
> Wool is a free by-product, sheep have to be sheared

One of the problem here is that while yes, you have to shear sheep raised for meat, the wool is going to be of an exceptionally low quality, because (a) you generally aren't raising a wool breed for meat, and (b) you aren't keeping your sheep in a manner that minimised damage to the wool.

We receive a fair bit of free by-product wool from meat herds, the processing cost is roughly double that of wool from a proper wool herd, and the end result is inferior.

The best use of by-product wool is often quality-insensitive bulk applications, like wool pellets for roof insulation, at which point there is very little money in the whole value chain

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by defrost on Saturday October 10, 2026 @06:31AM (#50031488)
> sheep have to be sheared

Not sheep raised for meat, bred to be low wool volume producers, and regularly (two or three times a year) run through a defoliating spray.

See, for example: https://farmtable.com.au/ag-library/ag-business-resources/se...

FWiW, in the actual sheep for wool trade there's still a high demand in China for ultrafine low micron merino wool for modern high end breathable suits. So:

> Then, everything closed and the only thing left was to send it to China.

really depends on the grade and quality of the wool - a lot is low grade rag fibre for stuffing and insulation, some (many tonnes per annum) is for quality tailoring.

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by cucumber3732842 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @08:25AM (#50032234)
Timber is the same way. Trees are free-sih It's what you do to them (basically converting diesel into a different commodity) after you cut them down that adds money.

Being too bulky to engage in overseas shipping shenanigans probably helps it.

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by akoboldfrying on Saturday October 10, 2026 @08:47AM (#50032413)
> It's all processing. Wool is a free by-product, sheep have to be sheared. More than 20 years ago, it was a pretty lump sum for someone who would shear 10K sheep a year.

50 years ago, the wool sold for more than the meat.

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by abanana on Saturday October 10, 2026 @09:48AM (#50032959)
> Wool is a free by-product

I can't believe how common this erroneous view is. Sheep reared for wool were bred specifically for the quality of their wool. Those that produce the best wool are not used for their meat. Wool is not a free by-product of anything, it is the product.

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by woolion on Sunday October 11, 2026 @05:08AM (#50041180)
If we look at breeds or volume, wool breeds accounted for roughly a third. If you look at meat breeds that account for the majority of sheep, the majority has medium quality wool. For such breeds, shearing is a necessity. So that carries the weight that it is a free by-product, in general.

>Those that produce the best wool are not used for their meat

You can eat delicious merinos. If anything, you could see their meat as a free by-product. Same caveat applies, meat processing is not cheap.

I think the erroneous view is just how things work unless you look at luxury/high grade market, which obey fundamentally different economics.

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by matkoniecz on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:51AM (#50030006)
> It also allows them to make incredibly sugary drinks while also advertising "No added sugar"

you can do this also without any concentrate using regular apple juice

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by TheScaryOne on Saturday October 10, 2026 @04:26AM (#50030870)
Every juice cocktail I've ever drank has been upfront about the juices inside.

Your hangup on dehydrated juice is weird. Like, yea, they removed all the water from the juice so all you need to do is add water and it ships better and keeps longer....

Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by seemaze on Saturday October 10, 2026 @02:20AM (#50030196)
I don't know, if beer were labelled ‘water’ i’d be less productive, but also less anxious..
Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by croisillon on Saturday October 10, 2026 @04:18AM (#50030832)
they're made out of water?
Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by psd1 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @05:03AM (#50031032)
Re:Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredien... by washadjeffmad on Saturday October 10, 2026 @09:00AM (#50032513)
I know I've seen American beer alongside the water in at least one German market.