News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Saturday October 03, 2026 @11:08PM (#49950238)
But that math cant run without massive GPU clusters. We don't have to allow openai or anthropic access to those anymore than we have to allow a company to operate nuclear power or a bank.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by 01100011 on Saturday October 03, 2026 @11:49PM (#49950429)
So you are contending that individuals cannot run advanced models? What brought you to that conclusion?

Secondly, are you contending that progress in model efficiency and hardware just stops at whatever level you think is sufficient to prevent individuals or organizations from acquiring sufficient resources to run advanced models?

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by daveguy on Sunday October 04, 2026 @12:23AM (#49950611)
I think it's more the noise, power consumption, local water consumption, and wholesale theft of creative works.

..."government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth." -Lincoln, Gettysburg Adress

Unfortunately for AI, it still is. People still get to decide things at the city, town, village level.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:08AM (#49950823)
No. And that’s not necessary for my position. I have 4 Mac studios. I run large models and am building propelcompute.com to let people self manage clusters of their own hardware or combine hardware to run models. It’s not the models that are the problem. It’s that the people building them are shielded from the consequences of what they are building. I would say if you self host a model and it takes down a power grid you are personally liable for the consequences. I believe in broad distribution of AI and advancing its capabilities but not in a manner that socializes the harms and privatizes the gains which is what we have now.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by hobo123 on Sunday October 04, 2026 @10:10AM (#49954071)
Absolutely. Any AI could have a "legal team" (or conscience) that checks if any output and performed actions are permitted according to local (server location and client location) laws, so not violate human rights, Asimovs laws etc.

It's just that so far nobody cares about explicit checks because they cost resources or slow down the models.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by 01100011 on Sunday October 04, 2026 @11:09AM (#49954565)
Ok but this response has nothing to do with your other comment. What exactly were you trying to say?
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:02PM (#49955652)
Just because I can run near frontier level open weight models doesn’t mean I can continue to train models of equal or superior performance, doing that requires massively more hardware. And even if I did, that doesn’t mean I can serve those models to millions or billions of users.

My point is that I would rather have 1000 labs training and serving inference than 2 because that would distribute the wealth creation more broadly rather than allowing OpenAI and anthropic to capture all the value, it would drive more innovation as a broader set of experiments are pursued in parallel.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by 01100011 on Sunday October 04, 2026 @11:21PM (#49960341)
Again you're shifting your arguments and not addressing your initial response.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Monday October 05, 2026 @09:13AM (#49964419)
How am I shifting my argument. They are corollary arguments. Massive data processing is necessary for frontier model training and inference. If OpenAI and anthropic are behaving irresponsibly they we can limit their access the level of compute to train and serve models. That doesn’t imply individuals can’t run frontier level models or should be prohibited from doing so. That’s a coherent position across a spectrum of possible scenarios: I look at the behavior of the people running the model and would limit their ability to train and run models if they act in unsafe ways.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by nradov on Sunday October 04, 2026 @12:22AM (#49950603)
Who is "we"? The GPUs and training algorithms get more efficient all the time. In a few years, creating effective LLMs isn't going to require massive GPU clusters.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:03AM (#49950804)
We is society through government via regulation. I don’t think GPUs or training will get that efficient that fast absent a distillation target provided by the easily accessible frontier lab APIs.

Further, even if you are right, so what. Is that a reason to just accept bad public policy? That’s like saying, anyone can learn how to make smallpox at home with a basic lab set up so we should just ignore any safety measures.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by eddythompson80 on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:40AM (#49951001)
> Is that a reason to just accept bad public policy?

Not necessarily, but it should probably inform that public policy. I think the problem is no one knows what the public policy should be assuming that scenario is true. Even if you, somehow, regulate away massive GPU cluster training making such future training impossible, existing models are already here. Further already training smaller models for things like images, speech, and other specialties is cheaper than the bigger models.

I agree that we need some regulations like everything else, but it’s not clear to me what the right policy should be. I think the European ai act is a fine start, but it’s clearly not enough nor does it necessarily limits the training portion just the application portion. Not to mention that the requirements there can be summarized into something like “you have to be careful, and show evidence you tried to be careful”.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by lukan on Sunday October 04, 2026 @03:58AM (#49951668)
“you have to be careful, and show evidence you tried to be careful”.

That sounds reasonable. If applied to OpenAI and their agents multiple times breaking out of bad secured sandboxes, it should be enough.

But limiting the training?

There really is china and they have a different approach I suppose. But it is possible to talk with them.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by eddythompson80 on Sunday October 04, 2026 @11:14AM (#49954606)
> That sounds reasonable. If applied to OpenAI and their agents multiple times breaking out of bad secured sandboxes, it should be enough.

Does it? To me it seems reasonable for OpenAI to argue they did try to be careful evident by the sandbox, they just made a mistake. Almost every 0day is categorized by something like that. We haven’t had a long history of establishing a negligence charge to security bugs. Could you be sued because you didn’t demonstrate “carefulness” and used Linux which is not written in a memory safe language and has had multiple CVEs before? How complicated should the chain of an exploit be to demonstrate “carefulness” to the courts?

> training

OP was the one suggesting that training could be controlled because massive gpu clusters could be regulated the way a nuclear power plant could. If you assume training costs won’t drop, then it’s feasible I guess. However, unlike a nuclear reactor, the final training result isn’t a radio active material, but rather an ordinary file that anyone can load and use for inference.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:08PM (#49955726)
It seems really clear at this point China has only been able to keep pace by distillation farms.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:07PM (#49955720)
My entire point is that we are currently on a path to a duopoly which isn’t just expected to cover training and serving models but the entire knowledge economy. That could be mitigated by limiting their train and inference capacity to a specific percentage of total available compute. That would ensure other operators could compete in the market. Instead we are letting OpenAI literally contract to buy all available ram to the point that Apple can’t buy ram and had to cut their hardware configurations.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by nradov on Sunday October 04, 2026 @02:55PM (#49956723)
Apple could have bid higher but chose not to. Most modern desktop software is extremely memory inefficient. Developers have largely ignored this in recent years because RAM was so cheap. But there's tremendous opportunity for improvement with a little optimization work.

We used to run Microsoft Word and other popular applications with 8 MB RAM and it worked fine.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @04:57PM (#49957770)
No. Once the contract is signed it will be breach of contract. It’s not always a bidding process.

I am working on reducing ram requirements to run models but the weights are already compressed to the edge of the Shannon entropy boundary and might resist further compression.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by nradov on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:38AM (#49950990)
What a silly comparison. LLMs have nothing to do with smallpox.

Computing always gets cheaper and faster over time. We can argue about the exact rate of improvement but the results are inevitable and uncontrollable.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by lukan on Sunday October 04, 2026 @03:47AM (#49951610)
Short reminder from the guidelines:

'When disagreeing, reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3." '

Also LLM's have something to do with smallpox as a unrestricted LLM will happily guide any wannabe terrorist in how to make them.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:11PM (#49955755)
But the amount of available compute has been contractual bought by the frontier labs such that you can’t get equivalent compute even if you had the money. That is market lock up and is a policy choice. Free markets require market access. Anticompetitive contracting destroys markets and innovation. We don’t allow that in any other commodity market and we shouldn’t allow it for GPUs. You are not allowed to legally corner the market for silver or soybean futures.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:20PM (#49955831)
I am reasoning from analogy. Smallpox is dangerous so we have regulations that limit who can do research and how they do it. If LLMs are similarly dangerous we could do the same. As the government did with mythos.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by nradov on Sunday October 04, 2026 @02:57PM (#49956741)
Nah. There is no actual evidence of such danger. Fears about Mythos were completely overblown.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by Razengan on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:12AM (#49950844)
> cant run without massive GPU clusters.

How far back into the history of computing do people who keep repeating shit like that know about? God.

Look at the thing in your fucking hand. Now go back just 20 years and see how things were.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:37AM (#49950983)
So we should just yolo speed run this because of Moores law? How about you recognize there is a set of rules outside of tech and we can decide how to define them.

Just because models and GPUs will be more advanced in the future doesn’t mean we need to let OpenAI and anthropic establish monopolies on the backs of stolen training data give unfettered access to the internet, the terminal and people’s file system while also allowing them to have limited liability protection behind the corporate veil. That’s a choice.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by buriram on Sunday October 04, 2026 @02:17AM (#49951163)
But who are "we"? The society, the government, the regulator, or the consumer?

I don't see any of such entity would solve that problem. The government and regulator are in OpenAI and Anthropic's pocket, and I don't trust them a single bit on coming up with regulations. The consumers don't care; they just need something smart and cheap. And the society doesn't work either: each person is too busy fighting for their own survival rather than changing the system.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:42PM (#49956034)
People thought the same in the guilded age: standard oil is too big, Edison and Westinghouse already have the electric market captured and have captured political power. It was a similar transformation in society. If all we do is follow the same playbook America did then we’d be in a better position that the current approach.

There are clear anti-trust mechanisms to prevent market capture and the emergence of asymmetric power. Go back and see how much nashing of teeth Lina Khan triggered in SV when she started to enforce antitrust law and then compare it to what the Pinkerton agency was doing in the transition from the guilded age to the progressive era.

There is a vocal segment of SV that wants the return of the guilded age. Marc Andreessen as said that explicitly. Those of us in SV that value free markets and recognize that the progressive era actually saved markets from their natural tendency to self destruct when winners capture markets and destroy competition that provides the incentive to innovate and drives the price setting function for efficiency.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by buriram on Sunday October 04, 2026 @05:32PM (#49958110)
But if you are an aspiring and ambitious founder in Silicon Valley, which side would you take? The Glided Age mentality, or the Progressive Age mentality? The VC playbook made it very clear that the role of startups, or at least the very successful startup, is explosive growth, expanding quickly, capturing a monopoly and its distribution. Even if you are thinking otherwise, soon you'll face the reality of Silicon Valley's VC growth machine.

In other words, the aspiring founders look at Google, Facebook, Tesla, etc. and think "how can I become one of them", not "how can I be different from them"? If you can find me examples of successful startups that think fundamentally different from those big techs, I'm very happy to be wrong and be corrected here.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by Razengan on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:43AM (#49951010)
> Just because models and GPUs will be more advanced in the future doesn’t mean we need to let OpenAI and anthropic establish monopolies

Exactly, again, look at what COMPUTERS THEMSELVES used to be in the 1960s/1970s.

What the "P" in the PC stood for and why it was such a big deal

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:43PM (#49956044)
Which is why I am building propelcompute.com to let people run and manage their own inference clusters and band together to create coops
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by CamelCaseName on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:14AM (#49950855)
For anyone else curious:

> In 2006, the mobile phone market was dominated by stylish flip phones, early music players, and physical keypads just one year before the iPhone changed the industry

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by shawn_w on Sunday October 04, 2026 @02:40AM (#49951288)
I miss phones with real keyboards so much.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by awill88 on Sunday October 04, 2026 @02:08AM (#49951128)
Oh my god, I feel so old lol
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:45PM (#49956070)
Just because monopolies die over time doesn’t mean they aren’t destroying value while they exist.
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by trhway on Sunday October 04, 2026 @03:40AM (#49951573)
> ...massive GPU clusters. We don't have to allow openai or anthropic access to those anymore

if anybody was looking for a good reason for datacenters in space.

Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by T-A on Sunday October 04, 2026 @08:03AM (#49953155)
Re:OpenAI safety leader quits, warning AI company's culture ... by digitaltrees on Sunday October 04, 2026 @01:22PM (#49955851)
You can block their use of domestic airspace.