News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by user_7832 on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:22AM (#49785789)
I... don't know how I feel about this. I mean, the concept, sure, good idea. Is it reliable? Perhaps. But... I get a "buy merch" popup the moment I open the page, and there seems to be a pro option for what seems to be a very much LLM-aided app? ...IDK, rubs off a bit wrong IMO. Just my personal opinion.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by hallway_monitor on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:02AM (#49786174)
The nearby glasses app linked in this thread seems to be a lovingly hand coded tool to detect Meta glasses.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by brettgo1 on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:18AM (#49786317)
Are you saying you don't want to show off a "Zuck Off" bucket cap?
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by bwnkl on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:25AM (#49785818)
I like the idea of this type of merch that normalizes anti big tech sentiment. But I personally would also opt for something more dramatic, possibly involving a guillotine...on the t shirt I mean
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by joenot443 on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:59AM (#49786151)
I think that'd be a pretty weird thing to wear, personally.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by GaryBluto on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:14AM (#49786287)
Social media has tuned people to be unable to think in non-hyperbolic ways. To these constantly wound-up people, every problem, no matter how big or small, can only be solved by brutal violence and savagery.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by ofjcihen on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:28AM (#49786417)
Honestly it sounds like I’m not inviting either of you to a party.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by mschuster91 on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:48AM (#49786624)
> To these constantly wound-up people, every problem, no matter how big or small, can only be solved by brutal violence and savagery.

well, the idea of democracy was to offer a viable path for people's discontent to be heard and remediated.

Unfortunately in most Western countries, dysfunctionality and corporatism have taken it over, and that is why you're seeing authoritarians on the rise across the world. They paint democracy and "legacy" figures as the scapegoat and themselves (plus handing them allllllll the power) as the only solution - just look at Milei and the chainsaw.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by jawilson2 on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:54AM (#49786684)
“The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants.”

-Thomas Jefferson

I personally think the tree of liberty is probably getting pretty thirsty.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by RobotToaster on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:05AM (#49787460)
"god forbid we should ever be 20 years without such a rebellion" Thomas Jefferson
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by p_j_w on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:35AM (#49787831)
It’s been over 150 years since we killed a bunch of tyrants here, and even then a lot of the tyrants got to live.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by stetrain on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:03AM (#49787438)
The longer people see issues that are not being solved via peaceful means, the more accepting they become of non-peaceful means.

I'm not advocating for those means, but I understand how people are feeling more helpless than ever to just "let the system work it out" when the system appears to be bought and paid for by a small concentration of corporations and people with an increasingly disproportionate share of wealth.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by bwnkl on Monday September 21, 2026 @03:29PM (#49792162)
I wouldn't see myself as constantly wound up, but I get your angle. I also was at most half serious, alluding to a time not long ago in a country not far away, where this instrument had its moment.

And in retrospect, the French revolution is not considered a dark episode of modern history, on the contrary.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by vitorfblima on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:44AM (#49786015)
Except any "solution" that involves AI is actually a win for big tech.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by UpsideDownRide on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:11AM (#49786253)
Is that true if we move to local models?
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by someonebaggy on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:13AM (#49786279)
Yes, big tech controls them.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by bigyabai on Monday September 21, 2026 @04:09PM (#49792686)
Unless you intend to run your inference on a potato battery, you're beholden to AMD/Apple/Nvidia/Intel.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by kdjdkcneixj on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:34AM (#49786477)
Doesn’t even have to involve AI. Any tech solution is a win for big tech. Simple as that. We’re way past the point of no return now.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by rob74 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:38AM (#49787139)
...except if it's certified organic open source?
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by idjcjdjdjskdj on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:56AM (#49787358)
Especially if it’s certified “organic” open source. To big tech open source is free labour.

It’s their game at this point, unfortunately. We hold very little say in how things go.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by BubbleRings on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:33AM (#49787803)
The following is 100% vibe coded by me, (except for the algorithm that actually makes the music recommendations, which is about 5 lines of code I wrote 30 years ago.)

I created it in two months using Claude Code. It would have taken me three years without it. I would have never done it.

What about this free service is a win for big tech?:

https://SimilaritiesEngine.com

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by rob74 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:37AM (#49787129)
Are you alluding to this t-shirt: https://tse3.mm.bing.net/th/id/OIP.WxWdam38N7Uxmwqa5dFTRQHaJ... ?

...which refers to the song https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Making_Plans_for_Nigel; the most well-known person called Nigel in the UK currently being https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nigel_Farage .

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @08:53AM (#49786676)
so what if it is "very much LLM-aided app"?

We are going to have the organic label soon on apps with this mindset..AI assisted development is evolving by the day and at the rate most apps will be built that way..

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by n4r9 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:06AM (#49786812)
I'd love a label like that which tells me when an app has had thought put into it
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:08AM (#49786828)
You can put a lot of thoughts while using LLMs.

You are equating manual coding with more thinking, which has proven to be not the case given that it is mostly automated.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by n4r9 on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:25AM (#49787002)
It's possible to code thoughtfully with LLMs, but the process strongly encourages superficial signing-off on its activities.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:32AM (#49787076)
It did make it easier to generate thoughtless apps, I agree.

But this process is new, and not every AI assisted app is thoughtless. In fact, I'd argue that if a person put more thoughts and amplify their abilities with AI assisted coding, then the total sum of mental labour exceed that of any manually coded app by huge margins.

I'm not sure about this particular app, haven't looked into it. But I was merely commenting about the mindset of the parent comment.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by alerighi on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:08AM (#49787502)
If one person knows how to code, they don't need an LLM. I've tried using all of them on my job, and I will give them a second chance time by time (to see if the claims made by these big tech hold up) and ALL of the time I've didn't noticed any speedup compared to coding manually.

If you are an experienced programmer (not someone that did an online course and calls like this) with YEARS of experience in coding in multiple languages really, the only real limitation is the speed at which you can type on the keyboard, that is usually way faster than what the even good LLM is able to emit tokens.

This not considering token expense: if we see at the point of view of the company, it's way cheaper an experienced programmer, that in my country costs you 4000 a month tax included, than the tokens that an LLM would use to do the same job.

On top of that there is the environmental impact of all of this, and why they are almost making me not use my car because it's euro 5 and now there is euro 6, these AI companies are emitting tons of CO2 to do stuff that human beings can do with 1/1000 the energy that these AI companies use.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @03:09PM (#49791874)
"if one person knows how to code, they don't need an LLM. I've tried using all of them on my job, and I will give them a second chance time by time (to see if the claims made by these big tech hold up) and ALL of the time I've didn't noticed any speedup compared to coding manually."

I mean, have you truly tried? do others thing this is true? I'm truly astonished if that is majority experience, I think we need to get surveys on this.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by n4r9 on Monday September 21, 2026 @03:20PM (#49792031)
Imo it depends on the type of change required. If it involves churning out 1000 line of new boilerplate, an LLM will win every time. If it means tracing a subtle edge-case bug and carefully planning a deep one-line change in a 100k codebase that leaves all other behaviour unaffected, I would still expect an experienced dev who's deeply familiar with the code to do it at least as fast and more correctly first time.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by krapp on Monday September 21, 2026 @03:17PM (#49791992)
The entire draw of coding with LLMs is that you can generate programs without knowing how to code. That's literally what "vibe coding" is. Why would it surprise you that people who do know how to code, and don't hate the process the way a lot of AI enthusiasts seem to, might not find them useful?

You'll find plenty of people on HN who have this experience,but they just tend to be ridiculed or told they just haven't used AI correctly or enough. Admitting you don't use LLMs for everything, or god forbid at all, is like telling Christians you don't want to be saved.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @03:59PM (#49792544)
Because they can easily get outcompeted by those who care about software/output and use the latest tools? might as well code in assembly and brag about it.

I'm not here condemning people who use or not use. We have a new tech, for anyone who have been in the field long enough, it is nothing short of magic was has been accomplished in the last few years.

I could turn around 10K lines of code per day (I know it's not the best measurement but it does capture size to some extent) when I was not able to pull more than a 100 LOC. Let us say that most of it work, and there are few rough edges, a senior programmer can follow the shape of the code, and understand where to tweak and where the LLM get stuck. So this is basically like having racing engine compared to running.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by krapp on Monday September 21, 2026 @04:18PM (#49792789)
Companies get outcompeted, individual coders don't. And not everyone wants to be the Thomas Kinkade of coding, just cranking product out as fast as possible. And products that "use the latest tools" don't always "outcompete" those that don't. Most of what gets vibe coded - as demonstrated by what gets posted to Show HN - is qualitatively worse than the equivalent human-written software. It certainly isn't better, and there's no indication that velocity to market leads to market dominance.

To metaquote a recent thread - where is the vibe-coded replacement for Photoshop that outcompetes it? or Word? Why aren't vibe-coded games dominating Steam?

The speed alone doesn't translate to productivity and productivity alone doesn't translate to quality.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @06:44PM (#49794452)
Sorry - I really don't think you know what you are taking about.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:26PM (#49794814)
Let me leave with something we agree on at least:

"The speed alone doesn't translate to productivity and productivity alone doesn't translate to quality."

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by krapp on Monday September 21, 2026 @06:53PM (#49794516)
And I don't think you know what you're talking about. Good day.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @07:17PM (#49794743)
you too :)
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by justacrow on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:27AM (#49787027)
If the developer can't be bothered to not make it look vibecoded I assume there's a minimal amount of thought and effort put into it. And in that case I'm not going to bother using it.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:36AM (#49787127)
Maybe this developer didn't bother I didn't even look frankly.

My point was that you can have very well designed and thoughted apps with LLMs. In fact, I'd argue you can go way further and deeper than any manual coded application paired with AI assistance.

But maybe this instance is not the case. But even if it turns out to be not the case, if the app does work and serves the utility you are after, then why not using it? People use many things in everyday life without thinking about what thought was put into it..in fact, most people don't think at all about what it took to build anything, and how it was built..

Do you really know or care if the shoes you wearing was handmade or built by a factory in china using robots? you probably don't know and don't care.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by stetrain on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:00AM (#49787405)
> My point was that you can have very well designed and thoughted apps with LLMs.

If that were the case here, then a user of the app probably would not come away with the impression that it was a "very much LLM-aided app."

You're talking about how LLMs can be used in such a way that they help production of an app but remain invisible to the end user. But the beginning of this thread was someone using the app and coming away with the impression that it was heavily LLM influenced, which suggests that it was not done thoughtfully and did not remain invisible to the user.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:15AM (#49787584)
I get it, and frankly I don't know about this app.

But the parent comment positioned itself against all "LLM-aided apps", the author didn't say a slop or poorly coded. And even if it looks like LLM coded, we still can't tell about the level of thought that went into it. Developers had many poorly coded UIs and yet the apps functioned well and served it's purpose.

So the entire chain of reasoning is a form stereotype forming. Looking at this specific app, I can see that the author thought about the marketing/business and functionality, more than other alternatives, maybe because they had more mental bandwdith to do so.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by n4r9 on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:21AM (#49787663)
To be fair, I personally only said that I'd like a label that indicates whether an app has "had thought put into it". That could involve e.g. another human reviewing the code and architecture and giving it a stamp.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:36AM (#49787842)
You are right - my apologies. It could be a good idea given that we will end up with so many doubts and comments like this.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by clear0250 on Monday September 21, 2026 @02:14PM (#49791113)
This comment and some of your other ones are giving off AI smells...
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @02:45PM (#49791545)
I hand written each one of them, I think they are full of typos and grammatical errors as well since English is not my first language.

I assume you are saying that because I apologized. I apologize for sounding like AI, I assure you it was hand written and I put thoughts into those comments.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by stetrain on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:16AM (#49788401)
I don’t see how this comment is “against all LLM-aided apps.”

> But... I get a "buy merch" popup the moment I open the page, and there seems to be a pro option for what seems to be a very much LLM-aided app? ...IDK, rubs off a bit wrong IMO. Just my personal opinion.”

Again, if the user of the app comes away with the impression that the app “seems to be a very much LLM-aided” then the LLM usage has affected the end product.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @02:50PM (#49791614)
I think people are judging mainly the UI of the app. This is closed code app so they don't know, but they are judging by patterns in the UI and/or wording of documentation. And I think it is mainly tech or artists or whoever else is impacted by the AI usage.

That is not say there are really mindlessly produced apps out there. But the comment made it sound that anything LLM-aided is negative.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by ImPostingOnHN on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:34AM (#49787810)
> if the app does work and serves the utility you are after, then why not using it?

Take a step back and think about your question in the context of privacy and software security.

For a few example answers, look at:

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adware

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spyware

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trojan_horse_(computing)

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:43AM (#49787933)
But what does this has to do with LLM-assisted coding? I wouldn't trust this app even it was manually coded.

In fact, given the recent reports, in terms of security, one is better off consulting LLMs on the exposure surfaces. Something a solo developer can now do cheaply but in the past required a lot of specialized knowledge.

Sorry I don't understand your argument.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by ImPostingOnHN on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:51AM (#49788030)
> But what does this has to do with LLM-assisted coding?

What does "LLM-assisted coding" have to do with the question I answered? Here's that question again:

> if the app does work and serves the utility you are after, then why not using it?

Note that this question does not contain any reference to "LLMs". Indeed, an LLM-generated product can contain adware, spyware, or trojan horses just like a human-written one.

For additional context, this app in question seems to actually contain adware and spyware, and has a closed source codebase, so might contain a trojan horse as well.

Those seem like pretty good reasons to not run this totally-vibe-coded software, so I'm sorry, but I don't understand your argument that LLMs make this okay or not okay or whatever.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:10AM (#49788321)
I get it - I think there mis-communication here.

My comment was about not equating every LLM assisted app as poorly thought of. Your comment is about this specific app, and I personally would not install this app regardless of how it was coded.

But again in terms of security since you brought it, I'd argue that having LLM assisted coded app might be secure than manually coded application given the recent advancements. Again, this is a generic statement, not specific to this app.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by ImPostingOnHN on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:22AM (#49788458)
The original discussion was not about every LLM assisted app, it was specifically about vibe-coded apps, particularly ones with so little human input that experienced coders can tell they were vibe-coded.

Your later comments generalizing to "every LLM assisted app" seem like a bit of insecurity you might be feeling for using LLM assistance. No need to feel that way. LLM assistance is okay. We're discussing something different from mere LLM assistance.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @02:43PM (#49791523)
That is the original comment: " for what seems to be a very much LLM-aided app? "

The author mentioned LLM-aided app, not even AI assisted; nor vibe coded hence my reaction. I don't have insecurity from using LLM nor from coding manually. But I noticed a trend in people thinking and biases and it threw me off hence the comment.

My original comment was heavily downvoted and furthermore some of my comments were accused of being written by AI meanwhile I'm writing it by hand. Again, people are taking tribes/camps, if you speaking of insecurities, it actually the opposite clearly, many programmers are worried of being displaced and automated. And I do understand the concern, I'm just stating the fact that one can have very deeply thoughted LLM-aided app.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by ImPostingOnHN on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:32AM (#49787793)
It sounds more like you are equating a totally-vibe coded product with no verified code, with a product thoughtfully written by a human with LLM assistance.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by phoghed on Monday September 21, 2026 @09:58AM (#49787385)
Bro wants the government to tell him when someone tried hard on an app, smdh

Damn FDA organic app users are mad about this one

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by aogaili on Monday September 21, 2026 @03:00PM (#49791746)
People flag/downvote what they don't like without explaining much, and a lot of it are just feeling based/snap reactions.

HN is not that rational of a discussion form but there are some good articles/comments so worth being around.

Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by joquarky on Monday September 21, 2026 @04:50PM (#49793211)
I'd love for Nutrition Facts to include some kind of standardized glycemic index.
Re:ZuckOff Know when a camera is in the room by josh_carterPDX on Monday September 21, 2026 @02:03PM (#49790935)
If it works the way it says it does, I'd be happy to buy merch as a way to support the team behind this!