News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by ChiperSoft on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @06:56PM (#49457050)
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by delichon on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:11PM (#49457178)
I don't think I've seen a snuff film of that scale before. I'm not good with even fictional horror. This may haunt my dreams. For most of the people there was just nothing they could do. But others would have had a chance if they had run perpendicular to the flow and climbed like their life depended on it. I'll try to remember that the next time I'm fleeing in panic from a flash flood.

Looks like a warning siren could have saved some lives. But apparently this was a black swan.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by markdown on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:39PM (#49457403)
I think the Japan tsunami videos showed as many, but it was spread out over the course of almost 2hrs and happened in slow motion over a large area. You could see some cars speeding to safety while others were washed away. Some stayed in taller structures assuming they were safe and were slowly washed away.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by ghastmaster on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:27PM (#49457800)
Perpendicular is not the scientifically best path. 45 degree angle is the best angle if the threat is moving toward you at the same velocity that you can move. As the velocity of the threat increases, the angle gets closer to perpendicular. The size of the threat and distance of course matter as well. I think about this before tree felling. In chainsaw classes they teach you to move at a 45.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by Reason077 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:55PM (#49458043)
Looking at the footage, the water/avalanche was moving far faster than anyone could move on foot. Well over 100 km/h, I would estimate.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dgellow on Thursday August 27, 2026 @08:04AM (#49463399)
And taking the entire infrastructure with it, including buildings and roads
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dredmorbius on Thursday August 27, 2026 @09:05PM (#49473204)
Scrubbed bare from what I've seen to date of post-incident footage, though that's still preliminary.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dreamcompiler on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:51PM (#49458482)
Likewise if your car stalls on a railroad crossing, run at a 45 degree angle toward the train. This puts you away from the path of flying debris.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by ANH on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:00PM (#49458069)
| But apparently this was a black swan.

What is your definition of black swan? This paper is from 2022 and scientists have been warning about climate change for decades. It's not like this possibility wasn't anticipated. It seems likely we'll see more glacial events as the atmosphere warms.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by throwup238 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:53PM (#49458505)
There have been maybe three such events in the 21st century (glacier or landslides producing more than a magnitude 5 quake), and none of them have happened in an area like the Himalayas. The other two were in Alaska on Mt Steller in 2005 and the Lamplugh Glacier in 2016, neither of which produced massive downstream floods.

It usually takes entire icebergs calving off to produce such seismic events and intense monsoons to create such flooding.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by ElProlactin on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:29PM (#49458787)
> There have been maybe three such events in the 21st century

It seems that past history (especially recent) will not be a good predictor of future events.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by throwup238 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:43PM (#49458931)
Spoiler alert: that’s the whole point of a black swan event.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by ElProlactin on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @11:25PM (#49459264)
A black swan event is an event that is unpredictable because it is so rare.

While I'd wait for confirmation about the cause of this specific incident, the point you seem to be ignoring is that, due to climate change, events that would have been considered "black swans" historically will become more and more common, to the point that they are expected to occur.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by throwup238 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @11:57PM (#49459503)
I think that’s a misreading of the entire book. A black swan event is a rare, high-impact outlier that is nearly impossible to predict under normal circumstances, but is rationalized as having been inevitable in hindsight.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by ElProlactin on Thursday August 27, 2026 @12:35AM (#49459750)
For whatever reason, you continue to try to ignore the point I'm making, which is that, in terms of natural disasters related to climate in particular, what would have been "rare, high-impact outlier[s]" are increasingly becoming common enough to be not rare and not outliers.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by throwup238 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:14AM (#49460048)
And you continue to ignore what I said (and what the book said). The whole point of a black swan event is exactly what you just described.

It’s the inflection point when our priors change.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by fc417fc802 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @02:31AM (#49460656)
Maybe I misunderstand (either you or the topic in general) but I don't think what you're saying is correct. A black swan event is (to my understanding) something unexpected and generally remains so. Not (as you seem to be suggesting) "oh hey that was historically unexpected but going forward it's now considered a standard contingency".

And I have no idea where you got the "rationalized as inevitable in hindsight" thing. I've never heard of that in relation to black swan events before.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by gos9 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:04AM (#49460934)
Have you read the book?
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by crote on Thursday August 27, 2026 @04:47AM (#49461741)
If events like these are "nearly impossible to predict", how come this post is linking to a scientific paper predicting exactly this scenario?

This flood is like The Big One in California. We know it is going to happen, it is virtually a certainty. The only question is when and where.

If glacial floods come as a surprise to you, it is only because you have been deliberately ignoring all the climate change warnings. So, a short recap: we'll see massive droughts, giant wildfires, huge floods due to rainfall, significantly more intense hurricanes, mass starvation due to large-scale crop failure, and low-lying countries drowning due to sea level rise. Oh, and add a high likelihood of the AMOC collapsing triggering a cooldown of the East Coast and Europe to the list.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dredmorbius on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:19AM (#49460081)
Anticipation is one thing, effective response in the seconds before disaster strikes is quite another thing. This might not have been an absolute black swan, but even with foresight it is challenging in the extreme to avoid risk.

I've been reviewing what coverage I can find of the present event in Nepal/China, in context with Section 5.1, "Comprehensive approach to disaster risk management", of TFA.

It seems that what would be required would be:

- Active surveillance of glacial lake formation.

- Active mitigation of glacial lakes, reducing risk.

- Warning and response infrastructure, procedures, and protocols along the likly flood path.

From video of what I presume are among the worst-hit areas (see: <https://twitterwebviewer.com/?tweet=2092542957060841592>), there appear to have been at best a few seconds of warning. Very robust structures are demolished virtually instantly. Even had people been sheltering within those structures, or headed up-slope above the water flow, either structural integrity would prove insufficient, or response time inadequate to reach a safe elevation above the debris flow. The latter problem is compounded by what appears to be an extraordinarily strong air blast (likely hurricane-strength or greater) as well as massive amounts of airborne debris, much of it rock.

Terrain is severely constrained in the region, and the only buildable regions are in river valleys themselves. The Gyirong Port border crossing is located deep within a river channel, and despite robust construction simply could not survive the event.

See:

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gyirong_Port> (Wikipedia article on the port.)

Map / satellite view: <https://www.google.com/maps/@28.2792579,85.3752907,1341m/dat...>

(Take a few minutes to examine the region around the port itself ... there are several communities and businesses all well within the disaster zone, and I suspect that obliteration to those matches or exceeds what was captured on video at the crossing itself.)

From the first video at this Twitter post, a camera situated roughly 20m above the base terrain did not survive the event (though it transmitted for roughly a minute).

A second camera (I believe near the same location) shows similarly catastrophic damage, and no chance for anyone at base level to climb to a safe elevation before being overtaken by the debris flow.

Wikipedia notes "Floodwaters reached settlements as high as 270 feet (80 m) above the river level", citing <https://english.onlinekhabar.com/rasuwa-flood-in-pictures.ht...>.

Climbing that far would require 4--8 minutes for even a highly-fit person. Available response time in the videos I've seen is on the order of 1--2 minutes. Anyone beginning within the debris zone is already walking dead.

As the Cowboy Junkies said:

  But if there's on thing in my life
  That these years have taught
  It's that you can always see it coming
  But you can never stop it
Anticipation isn't sufficient. Other than entirely abandoning such locations during all periods of high risk, loss of life is likely, and catastrophic property and infrastructure damage inevitable.

<https://twitterwebviewer.com/?tweet=2092542957060841592>

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by totetsu on Thursday August 27, 2026 @02:04AM (#49460436)
When I was researching this morning I found papers related to this kind of risk from at least 2000. Given 20 years there could have been things done I think. And there is a lot of settlement on the tops of the ranges in that area too.. Maybe the roads have to be on the river valley, but not everything else. People living there could have been offered alternative land to move out of the path of it.. monitoring and early warning could have been set up.. at the checkpoint, if it had to be there, there could have been a big evacuation tunnel carved into the hillside, or something.. I guess Nepal doesn't have a lot of resources though. The same thing even happened a year ago in the sample place, but at a smaller size https://www.stimson.org/2025/investigating-an-emerging-clima...
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by lazide on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:20AM (#49461101)
Flat lowland is great because it's cheap and easy to build on, and not a hassle to actually use.

Ridgelines and slopes are terrible to build on (and often use) because there is little to no actual flat usable area without extensive construction. They also tend to be unstable and slide/erode.

That said, if I was in that area, of course i'd never build/live on anything but the highest ridgeline or slope around.

One of those 'long term/outlier risks cause daily costs' type of things. :s

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dredmorbius on Thursday August 27, 2026 @08:24PM (#49472953)
So, one of the most notably impacted locations to date has been the Gyirong port border crossing, noted in a couple of my earlier comments. Part of that is due to there being surveillance closed-circuit camera footage available, and there are other areas which would have been similarly affected. A few additional thoughts and facts have come to light:

- The crossing was substantially renovated in January of this year following an earlier flood which washed out the bridge connecting the station (in China) to Nepal.

- The crossing, part of China's Belt and Road Initiative (<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative>), by needs must sit on the principal highway through the region. Which ... follows the river valley. Now, it's possible for that highway to be raised substantially off the valley floor, but consider that "inundations reached heights of 800m (2,600 ft) in a valley some 7km (4.3 mi) from the origin" (<https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/news/20260827_22/>, via Wikipedia).

- The inundation reached the Gyirong port seven minutes after the initial avalanche. Even with absolutely timely warnings, that is only just barely enough time for a fit person to reach a safe elevation above the port itself. Wikipedia now mentions two people (of apparently hundreds present) being rescued from Gyirong port.

- Early reconnaissance footage above the site of the former Gyirong port shows nothing but bare land. All of the apparently quite substantial structures on the site were simply scrubbed from existence. The forces involved are formidable. <https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202608/1369215.shtml>

I believe that the end of this video shows post-incident video of the same site, though frankly it's unrecognisable. I'm sure we'll have more definitive evidence soon. <https://www.msn.com/en-ca/video/other/china-video-shows-muds...>.

- The event is, as has been noted, foreseable, but also unprecedented. There are no events of comparable magnitude in the area, despite previous flooding. The likelihood that this week's incident represents a potential new baseline must be considered.

- Debris flows were moving at roughly 50m/s, or 180 kph (about 110 mph). That's not only an absolutely formidable speed, but a formidable force, where kinetic energy = mass * velocity squared.

The only possible safe refuge I could see would be some sort of underground bunker, into which all staff and travelers would have to locate to in a matter of seconds, and then sealed against water intake, this in a busy border crossing with multiple nationalities and languages in a region with a < 70% literacy rate.

And that's for the Gyirong border station itself. Note that that was a Chinese facility, where China is the vastly wealthier and better-resourced partner to Nepal. Nepal's capabilities to effect similar measures at an equivalent facility or in numerous communities throughout the region is quite limited.

Also affected were numerous other facilities, including a shrine (being visited by numerous Hindu pilgrims), apparently utterly destroyed and all present killed, numerous villages, etc. Roads are heavily damaged if present at all, bridges are washed away, and in a region with tens to hundreds of thousands of inhabitants (based on various county/district Wikipedia pages I've examined), a dozen or so rescue helicopters have so far been summoned.

Oh, and a new glacial/debris dam and lake have formed which is feared may pose an additional outburst flood event within days (<https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/aug/27/nepal-tibet-fl...>).

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by snowwrestler on Thursday August 27, 2026 @07:47AM (#49463233)
Black swans are actually fairly well-populated birds that are easy to spot. So as a metaphor it works well for a common thing that smug people of limited knowledge try to claim is rare and surprising.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by suzzer99 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:04PM (#49458099)
I wonder if the river went dry first, like the water receding off into the horizon before a tsunami?
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by ghastmaster on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:11PM (#49458149)
It is possible if you consider madaxe_again's theory(comment here). If the debris just started descending without interruption, there would be no receding.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by suzzer99 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:36PM (#49458868)
Well supposedly it was caused by a landslide blocking the river for a few minutes, then the dam burst all at once.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dredmorbius on Thursday August 27, 2026 @08:51PM (#49473132)
Based on video footage which has emerged, no.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by colechristensen on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:20PM (#49458229)
The great flood myths across the world are quite possibly ancestral memories of this kind of flood on a continental scale. Retreating ice age glaciers would make lakes the size of states held at bay by an impromptu dam of various kinds of debris (or more glacier) which then would break dumping great lake amounts of water hundreds of miles into the ocean within days. This kind of thing probably happened in lots of places.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by delichon on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:30PM (#49458799)
You just pushed me into a rabbit hole called the Zanclean megaflood.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zanclean_flood

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by hommelix on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:14AM (#49460040)
It is supposed that such an event happened, when the land between continental Europe and England got flooded. This was as well during a warmer period when glacier melted. And there was human population on that land.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doggerland

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by colechristensen on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:41AM (#49461257)
Oh there's geological evidence of these things happening in the pacific northwest, the waves and water scouring the landscape in an unimaginable fashion left evidence to be seen today. Like 1000 Niagra falls for a month straight. Outflows measured in billions of gallons per second or 10+ cubic kilometers per hour.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Channeled_Scablands

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by GolfPopper on Thursday August 27, 2026 @02:26AM (#49460619)
The Missoula Floods in the northwestern US were a similar sort of event, though I'm not sure how the scale compares.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missoula_floods

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by colechristensen on Thursday August 27, 2026 @02:34AM (#49460680)
Yes this is exactly the kind of thing i'm talking about and in the time frame which is at least plausible to make its way through mythology to modern day (not so much for the flooding of a dry mediterranean sea five million years ago)
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dredmorbius on Thursday August 27, 2026 @08:51PM (#49473128)
The flooding of the Black Sea, OTOH, might have played a part in the Flood Myth, having occurred around 7,600 years ago (5600 BCE):

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Sea_deluge_hypothesis>

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dredmorbius on Thursday August 27, 2026 @08:56PM (#49473152)
The potential drainage of glacial Lake Agassiz triggering the Younger Dryas period ~13,000 ya is another potential such event.

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Agassiz>

<https://www.nature.com/articles/nature08954>

<https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00335...>

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Younger_Dryas>

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by scheme271 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @12:31AM (#49459727)
There was another similar flood on the same river about a year or two ago. The problem was the the glacial flooding started in Tibet and affected people just over the border (one of the videos is from the border crossing). There's no international data sharing for this sort of thing between China and Nepal and Nepal can't deploy sensors in Tibet to give sufficient warning.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by 21asdffdsa12 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @02:24AM (#49460602)
We have tsunami warnings all the times now. Nobody is stopping people from burying sensor posts upstream.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by regularfry on Thursday August 27, 2026 @06:56AM (#49462750)
I suspect you are dramatically overestimating how fast humans can climb. I hope I'm wrong.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dredmorbius on Thursday August 27, 2026 @09:04PM (#49473201)
From further information that's emerged:

- The site captured in the video, the Gyirong Port border crossing between China and Nepal, was struck by the flood roughly seven minutes after the presumed avalanche thought to have triggered the event.

- Flood inundation is seen up to 800 m (2,600 ft) above river level, and the camera position in the video at approximately 20--25m (roughly 6--8 stories) above ground level was engaged in the debris flow.

- It would take a fit person 4--8 minutes to climb even 250m or so above ground level, presuming instant notification and a clear evacuation path. Even with an instant warning of upstream conditions survival was overwhelmingly unlikely.

- Subsequent footage appears to show complete obliteration off all structures, with no trace remaining. This is based on preliminary imagery, without precise location information, and in a landscape changed beyond all recognition.

- Astoundingly, two survivors from the Port are mentioned in Wikipedia presently.

Though yes, one of the peculiarities of flood risk is that elevation equals safety. That's modulo a number of other factors though.

In particular, with an event of this magnitude, wind blast is a major effect. Toward the end of one video a line of buses in a car park is seen shifting backward, I suspect due to wind. These can reach well above hurricane force, and of course carries its own debris and threats, where even grass and straw can penetrate deeply. There's also the risk of secondary landslides and the like in steep terrain. One of the regions affected by this event has an etymology from "mud wall", which may be a reference to the geology of the canyon walls themselves. Those could easily be unstable.

Best option is to be lucky and not be there when things go horribly wrong.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by arjie on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:20PM (#49457239)
150 confirmed with 47 Americans? Surprising fraction. Mountaineers or that area is popular for some reason?
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by keyle on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:16PM (#49457692)
Likely the tourists are better accounted for than the locals. Numbers are likely much higher :(
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by don_esteban on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:20AM (#49461097)
This.

You could probably count 100+ people in the death zone of the border crossing video alone. The final death toll will be terrible, with most never found.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by adelie on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:39PM (#49457401)
it's a popular area for tourists and mountaineers, but also i think it's a lot easier to estimate missing/dead tourists since most of them will be there with tours/companies that have to keep track of exactly where they are.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by markus_zhang on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:20PM (#49457246)
Nepal is popular for Westerners I think. Maybe for religious reasons?
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by porridgeraisin on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:56AM (#49460379)
Mountaineering.

For indians, you also have the religious aspect because the immigration center you go to to visit Mt Kailash is there.

That immigration building was the white one that got completely shredded in the popular video going around.

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by markus_zhang on Thursday August 27, 2026 @06:11AM (#49462364)
Ah thanks for clarification.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by janhaa on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:28PM (#49457306)
i understand it as 150 dead, with more people missing, of which 47 are americans.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by segmondy on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:38PM (#49457395)
Way too early to get an accurate count
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by suzzer99 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:05PM (#49458103)
I feel like I've easily seen more than that get swept away in videos.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by lazide on Thursday August 27, 2026 @04:08AM (#49461459)
Zero chance the actual death count is sub-1000
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by tppiotrowski on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:38PM (#49458350)
Syabru Besi is downriver of the border and the starting point for the Langtang valley trek which is probably the third most popular trekking location in Nepal (behind Everest basecamp and Annapurna circuit). I think the tourist data they have is from tourists that are traveling with guides but from my experience many tourists also bypass the official requirements and trek solo so the number could be much higher if the Langtang is affected.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by markus_zhang on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:20PM (#49457242)
I have watched a few and they look like the four horsemen TBH.
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by alephnerd on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:40PM (#49458905)
It is harrowing. It also explains why the villages in my ancestral region in India (JK, HP, UK) with close cultural and ethnic ties with Nepal used to build them at the upper portions of the sides of mountains/hills and only shifted to building at the bottom of those kinds of valleys when motorized roads became a thing in the 20th century.

Rescue operations in Nepal are in good hands, but this is sadly because those same response orgs had to respond to a similarly brutal cloud burst floods back in 2013 [0], 2021 [1] and 2025 [2].

It also shows the very real and brutal effect climate change is already having, and will only get worse.

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_North_India_floods

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Uttarakhand_flood

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_Kishtwar_district_flash_f...

Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by totetsu on Thursday August 27, 2026 @12:41AM (#49459800)
That makes sense. You can see lots of settlements on the hills above the sight of this flood too. I also found this study of the risk perceptions of people living there interesting too. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221242092...
Re:Worst-case glacial lake flood scenarios in a transboundar... by dgellow on Thursday August 27, 2026 @08:01AM (#49463369)
Look at the CCTV at https://apnews.com/article/climate-change-nepal-tibet-glacie... (second video in the carousel).

That’s just pure horror, nightmare material