So because TUIs look universally bad, they're better than cross-platform GUI?
qBittorrent looks great on KDE, and would look great on macOS too if they used native icons (I’ve made a theme for that but was too lazy to install it when I was switching laptops). No idea about Gnome and Windows, but probably alright as well.
So, Qt can get you a long way. But you should of course adapt your app to platform conventions and guidelines.
You can't stay engaged if the menus don't bleep and bloop at you and confetti rains down on every click? That's a personal problem. A minimal UI is not automatically a bad-looking UI.
sounds like your terminal emulator is just crap, terminal and iterm on mac just work
If you mean what Claude Code does when you paste longer text, you can just press Cmd-V again to show the full text.
> TUIs run on any OS with minor patches to support quirks
So, which one is it?
TUI that runs on any OS |----------------| TUI without any compatibility mess
You really can't have both at the same time, either you have great compatibility (which will be a mess), or you don't, to varying degree of course.In any case we can surely do better than emulating DEC hardware from 50 years ago.
Even in the microcomputer era, standardizing behavior to where it’s literally everywhere someone might want it takes time (e.g. the browser compatibility wars). Re-standardizing terminal behavior is both chasing a way wider (in terms of the number of places folks expect terminals to work the exact same way) but shallower in feature complexity target compared to browsers, and would necessarily be replacing a widely adopted existing standard behavior. That’s a tall order—I am hopeful for and impressed by the efforts of folks like Hashimoto, but expectations here should be tempered.
TUIs look bad everywhere, so that's strictly worse
I would definitely be pro minimalist unicode-character-themed GUIs for what it's worth. Where every graphical primitive is basically a unicode character, without the restriction on font size.
Have you tried to write a GUI program lately? I suspect things may have changed. I can write one using Qt, EGUI, etc (Or many other options), and it will just work on Windows, Mac, Linux/Wayland, and Linux/X.
Basically, you write your application on top of a GUI framework that smooths over OS differences for you.
This is hard to square with the continuing obsession with Electron.
I thought Claude could do anything nowadays.
Querying into the DOM and working off of that means you're not futzing about holding onto a bunch of component references for the one thing you might need later on.
Web layout is also pretty easy to just get right, native GUI frameworks have a different kind of layout model that is not as amenable to "arbitrary" data (at least at first blush).
the reactive programming model also works quite well. While there are native GUI frameworks that lean into reactive programming, they tend to be doing a bunch of weird stuff that cause other issues.
And at the end of the day, when you package something like a Qt app it still often ends up being quite chunky.
In the end tho... the simplest thing is if you do web stack you get a web UI _and_ your "native" GUI in one go. Build things once, not twice. Hard to argue against that when that's presented.
Mobile has significant paradigm changes that makes using both terminals and traditional GUIs harder anyway though. I do expect the need for completely different cross-platform libraries for mobile UIs.
Also, Qt does support Android development.
The official NDK documentation on what is supported for NDK written code on non rooted devices, and the hurdles that Termux faces to keep running on standard Android images via PlayStore distribution, show why it isn't right.
I expanded on this point nearby: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49400697
If you're only targeting macOS/Windows/Gnome/KDE then the solution is easy: just grab a GUI control set and go ham.
Then there's remote access: you can spawn an X11 app through X forwarding and have a terrible laggy experience on Linux, you can use RemoteApps on Windows to have a good remote experience (but almost no other platform), you can use VNC to have an awful cross-platform experience, or you can use a TUI and have all the graphs and interactivity you need over a responsive, low-bandwidth connection on any combination of client+server.