News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Aozora7 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @03:49AM (#49308632)
This is one of the obvious consequences of not having a national identity number assigned to everyone at birth, which exist in most developed countries, except for anglosphere, for some reason.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by pibaker on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:15AM (#49308777)
Objection to ID numbers as a concept aside, I don't think it actually solves the problem this author faced.

Fake identities are dime a dozen. It is not exactly hard for an illicit entity to just put some random ID numbers it bought off the dark web on its books. And now you have just made it even harder for the people who had their identities stolen to clear themselves. How do you convince some company drone doing sanction compliance that you didn't actually work for Sanction Circumvention Ltd when your ID number matches the one on their company's payroll files?

Not to mention the sanction list is full of foreigners. The American authorities compiling the list aren't going to know what's the national ID of a random Russian or Iranian guy running an import business. So what is going to happen if your name matches someone who's on the list with a blank ID field? Probably the same thing that happened to the author, I guess.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by larsnystrom on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:24AM (#49308811)
If they put an ID on a sanction list, there’s a possibility to verify it. They could verify that it actually belongs to the person they want to sanction before putting it on the list. Failing that, the actual person can prove that they don’t belong on the list by verifying their identity.

Verifying identity is a much simpler problem than establishing identity.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by pibaker on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:35AM (#49308859)
> If they put an ID on a sanction list, there’s a possibility to verify it

They didn't care to figure out if the Sean Byrne of County Sligo actually existed before putting the name on the list. I doubt they would bother verifying an ID number.

Plus, going back to my point about the list being full of foreigners, how do you verify the validity of a foreign ID number and address? Maybe Ireland is going to comply with a US request, but many other countries won't, and you are now back to square one.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by larsnystrom on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:28AM (#49309090)
Don’t let perfect be the enemy of good. As you said, Ireland might comply, which would’ve solved this particular issue.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by msandford on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:42AM (#49310995)
Yes it's true we shouldn't let perfect be the enemy of good. But good also has to be good enough to solve the problem without creating more problems faster than it solves them.

It's fine to propose a solution but if people aren't convinced just throwing an aphorism grenade at them isn't productive.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by okayishdefaults on Saturday August 15, 2026 @12:19PM (#49311829)
I like to tack on "good enough" when throwing this particular aphorism grenade
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by fairlyaday on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:12AM (#49309617)
The courts obviously never had an id document for the US to find. Is the US going to omit all partial identities to avoid false positives or is Ireland going to illegally investigate lists for the US from extra judicial processes that likely involve non-extraditable crimes? Will the US believe every country that says these investigations found no real citizen?

Not bending to the US might be less convenient at times but if you bend for them you will eventually be bending for China.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by JSR_FDED on Saturday August 15, 2026 @11:46AM (#49311550)
Testing a new Markov chain? What is this incoherent drivel?
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by vlovich123 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @02:01PM (#49312757)
From the article which clearly wasn’t read:

> In both cases the courts called for better matching. Compare the date of birth. Compare the middle name.

> There is no version of that available to me. The listing has no date of birth to compare. No middle name and no passport number, because the person doesn’t exist. A screening system that does its job perfectly will still flag me, forever, on the only two facts the record contains: a common Irish name and a country.

These systems operate by matching as much information as possible. If the information isn’t there but the rest matches (even if it’s just a name) it flags in the system.

> Failing that, the actual person can prove that they don’t belong on the list by verifying their identity.

Sounds like you should tell the author. They’ve been living with this problem for 6 years but I’m sure your zero experience with these systems or trying to deal with it will help him immensely.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by chrisjj on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:46AM (#49309788)
> It is not exactly hard for an illicit entity to just put some random ID numbers it bought off the dark web on its books. And now you have just made it even harder for the people who had their identities stolen to clear themselves.

The idea is you largely prevented the theft, and made it easier to prove, by linking to a physical verifiableb address.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by neximo64 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:02AM (#49308706)
Its not as if it even helps since the numbers can be leaked and stolen and then abused & the situation ends up even worse since it is so centralised.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by larsnystrom on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:09AM (#49308740)
You’re talking about different things. Sweden has personal identity numbers and they’re public information. It protects you from being mixed up with someone with the same name. Not from identity theft though.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by trollbridge on Saturday August 15, 2026 @08:46AM (#49310124)
Making them explicitly public is better than the US situation where they’re treated like a password - a password you can’t change if it gets disclosed, and that lots of people feel entitled to get.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Aozora7 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:08AM (#49308733)
Identity numbers being abused is a consequence of them being misused. And as far as I can tell, this happens more often with american SSNs than anywhere with actual national identity numbers.

All that these numbers do is uniquely identify people. They aren't private. To actually prove your identity, you present your ID, passport, or a digital signature tied to that identity number.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by lotsofpulp on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:18AM (#49308793)
The abuse only happens because US courts deemed a third party liable for a lender’s error/cost cutting in attempting to verify a borrower’s identity.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by unixhero on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:15AM (#49308775)
It helps. Period.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by ramraj07 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:39AM (#49308873)
In most countries you cant do anything with a single number id of a person. Except ironically the US so youre doubly so off.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by nkrisc on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:04AM (#49309579)
Unique identifiers should be public. There shouldn’t be any leaking.

That also means they should be used simply as an identifier and not as any for of authentication or secret knowledge.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by chrisjj on Saturday August 15, 2026 @08:00AM (#49309878)
We just need untheivable unlosable numbers /i
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by yassa9 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:03AM (#49308708)
in Egypt, every person is born with a universal national ID number , which is standardized everywhere here, but it created some problems, it became extremely valuable to attackers. If leaked, it can be reused across completely different services ( and you can never change it under anycase )

Having the full name + national ID was enough to bypass verification and activate various services, and many people weren't tech savvy enough to realize how dangerous it was to share or leak that info

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by foxglacier on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:34AM (#49308852)
Clearly it was the services that weren't tech-savvy using a non-changeable non-secret ID as some kind of authentication. Can't blame the users here.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by ramraj07 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:40AM (#49308875)
This is the SSN in the US too though.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by JuniperMesos on Saturday August 15, 2026 @06:31AM (#49309422)
One good reason to introduce a national ID system in the US would be in order to replace and deprecate the Social Security Number, which is a terrible system that never should have been used as a de-facto national ID system.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by lmz on Saturday August 15, 2026 @01:38PM (#49312533)
Something tells me the people misusing the SSN would just misuse this new national ID number too. Wasn't the issue that people were treating knowledge of the (de facto public) ID number as proof of identity? Nothing is stopping them from doing the same with any future ID number.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Terr_ on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:22PM (#49314456)
Ironically, a certain level of secrecy is worse than having them fully public, because it leads people to (wrongly) design systems and processes that trust it or assume something from it.

All else being equal, I'd rather see national ID numbers which are so incredibly obviously un-secret that, at least on their own, they're nothing except a tool for avoiding overlaps and collisions.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by JuniperMesos on Sunday August 16, 2026 @07:25AM (#49318999)
Yes, a number of countries with national ID systems have (wisely) designed the system such that there is no secrecy associated with the number, and people can and do give it out freely without worrying that someone will use it to compromise their identity. Sweden's system works this way for instance, as does Estonia's. The United States can and should create a system similar to this, which would entirely end the problem of stolen Social Security Numbers once old-style SSNs were phased out in favor of the newer, better system.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by smsm42 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @03:41PM (#49313630)
So, instead of SSN dumps on the darknet, we'd have national ID dumps, which will be stolen within months (either from the government itself, or from credit bureaus or data brokers). How did that improve anything exactly?
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Terr_ on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:19PM (#49314439)
Right, people and organizations failing to (care to) distinguish between "highly distinctive" versus "true" is not a data design problem, it's a social/political one.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by graemep on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:16AM (#49308782)
National ID numbers will not help with cross border situations like this.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by nephihaha on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:54AM (#49308943)
Don't worry, I don't doubt it will be turned into an international system like phone numbers.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by dgellow on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:56AM (#49309238)
Isn’t that already the case?
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by tonfa on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:51AM (#49309828)
I guess ITINs are already pretty cost to this.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by reaperducer on Saturday August 15, 2026 @03:51AM (#49308648)
for some reason.

The reason is there. It's no big secret. Pick up a history book.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Extropy_ on Saturday August 15, 2026 @03:57AM (#49308677)
Care to be a little less vague? Maybe a little more helpful?
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by rendall on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:11AM (#49308747)
A government may have entirely benign reasons for creating a comprehensive population database, but you cannot guarantee who will control that database later. You have to trust the people who control it, not only now, but at all times in the future, but history does not support that.

Nazi Germany and occupied forces used census data, municipal population registers, etc., to identify and track down targeted people. The United States, during World War II, used census information to assist in the removal and incarceration of citizens with Japanese, Italian, and German heritage. The Rwanda population database explicitly classified people as Hutu, Tutsi, or Twa. This became the mechanism to target Tutsi during the Rwandan genocide. In China today, these databases are used to surveil and imprison Uyghurs.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by toasty228 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:18AM (#49308790)
Uh? The reason is that the constitution doesn't explicitly allow the federal gov to do it, so it's a state power.

It's not like you care about all the thing you enumerated, they literally ask you for your "race" when getting a driver's license, which is the defacto ID document anyways. You're installing flock cameras everywhere and gargling palantir's balls while they implement the surveillance state.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by po1nt on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:42AM (#49308881)
Yeah and that's exactly what shouldn't happen. Government's should not have a power to ask a private company for data under any circumstances and they should not make "race" a compulsory data to submit, so that you could exercise your rights.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by tonfa on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:55AM (#49309849)
In some European countries government (and private entities) isn't allowed to collect ethnicity information.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by po1nt on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:37AM (#49310958)
Unfortunately ethnicity isn't the only thing you can discriminate on. You can figure out the ethnicity from surname a lot of the times.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Aozora7 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:34AM (#49308853)
A government won't give up on malicious acts just because it lacks accurate census. The United States does a lot more surveillance and oppression than EU countries that have national ID and mandatory ID documents.

The lack of a comprehensive population database only seems to hinder the actual useful civilian bureaucracy, not law enforcement, intelligence services, or ICE. The latter just grab anyone who looks brown enough.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by wizzwizz4 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:29AM (#49309095)
In the US, where race is entirely defined by skin pigmentation and there's heavy segregation ("redlining") of living quarters, sure: databases aren't necessary. But in places where race is defined by heritage or culture, things which can be disguised by the targets of a regime, these databases are a vital part of any serious ethnic cleansing operation. I don't remember the statistic in IBM and the Holocaust that compares Jew survival rates in occupied countries with versus without digitised censuses, but the difference was stark.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by dgellow on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:59AM (#49309255)
Are you aware that pretty much every developed country has such database? Even the US, its guaranteed US 3 letters agencies have such comprehensive population databases
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by bagels on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:34AM (#49308854)
He has a passport with a number on it. Why isn't that sufficient? There are also multiple countries involved in this story.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Aozora7 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:09AM (#49309007)
When you renew your passport, the new one will have a new serial. Not matching a passport serial doesn't mean anything. Not matching a national identity number does.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by po1nt on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:35AM (#49308857)
Attaching numbers to people is unbelievably creepy. My identity is not a number. We recoil at the idea of having assigned and tattooed numbers on our bodies and I don't feel it's okay to do it, just so you could maybe avoid misidentification.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Almondsetat on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:50AM (#49308923)
You are the one somehow conflating an identity card with your actual identity as a self, which seems extremely strange and spurious.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by pibaker on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:00AM (#49308978)
The one conflating the two isn't the author, but the state. A fixation on the state sanctioned representation of someone's identity instead of the actual, living person himself is exactly what caused TFA's author troubles.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Almondsetat on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:33AM (#49309717)
You could ask every company to have a specialized department to handle investigations for these nuanced cases... or you could rely on the state/nation to give you some actual assuranced. National ID solves this. Does Apple have the budget? Yes, but then are smaller companies justified for fucking up? Wouldn't a more objective, verifiable, and automatable procedure be preferred to level the playing field?
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by goobatrooba on Saturday August 15, 2026 @06:52AM (#49309510)
The problem seems to be that the state has no other way to really identify them differently, also as one of them doesn't exist. An actual identity identifier would have solved this from ever occurring.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by ramraj07 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:38AM (#49308868)
Why did it need to go to tattooed numbers?

Also the implication that cultures and countries which have happily accepted id numbers are filled with non individualistic people is it?

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by pibaker on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:41AM (#49308880)
> Why did it need to go to tattooed numbers

Many countries have laws about having to carry an ID on you all the time. Not as bad as a tattoo, but still not acceptable IMO.

> Also the implication that cultures and countries which have happily accepted id numbers are filled with non individualistic people is it?

Are we really gonna keep pretending there are no differences between cultures?

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Aozora7 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:54AM (#49308939)
Very few countries require you to carry an ID. Many countries require you to own one and keep it up to date, but don't care whether you carry it outside.

Also, I find the point kind of moot for the US where a driving license is essentially an ID card, you have to carry it to drive, and you have to drive to go anywhere in most places.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by 8n4vidtmkvmk on Saturday August 15, 2026 @02:03PM (#49312780)
In the US, permanent residents technically have to keep their green card on them at all times.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by po1nt on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:49AM (#49308921)
So that you could not impersonate some other identity. Same in the spirit of carrying a plastic card, just without somebody touching you by force.

Either way you are branded forever.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by esikich on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:46AM (#49308893)
Is your identity a string of letters? Don't be ridiculous.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by po1nt on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:55AM (#49308952)
Yes, if there is a set of strings that can uniquely identify you, and you can't have it removed, nor act like somebody else, it's your identity.

Even GDPR admits it

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by skywhopper on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:28AM (#49309091)
So, your name is also this sort of identifier. But an “identifier” is not an “identity” in the way you mean it. Sometimes words are used in multiple ways.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by matherial on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:31AM (#49309102)
How so? The article is talking about a fictitious person that's listed by name only on a sanctions list despite the government knowing the person doesn't exist. There is no possibility of the real Sean Byrne presenting a government number that is a negative match against the list because the fake Sean Byrne has no known ID to match against. The essence of the entry is just "here's a name to avoid".

The real Sean Byrne can produce a government-issued passport number, but that's clearly not enough for Apple.

I think it's more of a problem of all these "hyperscale" platforms where the cost of not being zealous enough is long litigation and devastating fines, while the cost of losing a single customer (or a thousand) is basically nil. This leads to all kinds of opaque, customer-hostile outcomes like this, also if you trip some filters not related to sanctions / mistaken identities. There's a recurring theme of HN posts along the lines of "an automated process at Google cut my business off, HN plz help".

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Aozora7 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:41AM (#49309151)
In this particular case, it would be harder to produce a fake signature from a non-existent person if the signatures in questions were digital and backed by a national identity number. The kind of that I'm submitting when signing documents at work.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by layer8 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @08:11AM (#49309948)
Aside from the fact the entry in question was added to the list almost two decades ago, it’s naive to assume that people would only be put on these lists if they have a verified identity number. If that was a rule, the easier rule of requiring a birth date would already have helped. Because while not everyone has a national ID number, pretty much everyone has a birth date.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by necovek on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:03AM (#49310671)
There are people whose birth date is not really known (babies left at doorsteps, people from war-torn countries with no official record who had no parents to tell them of their birth date...).

I do not know how are they handled, but they probably get assigned one plausible date and it probably depends on the country.

In a sense, a birth date can be just as much an assigned number as an ID is. An ID can also have a checksum in it, potentially even a cryptographic one that only government can sign.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Macha on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:44AM (#49309173)
Ireland has a PPS number which everyone who’s ever had a job or claimed government benefits has. The union of those sets is basically everyone. Clearly that hasn’t helped.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by basilikum on Saturday August 15, 2026 @06:32AM (#49309429)
That is far from everyone.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by boxed on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:58AM (#49309247)
Well.. yea, because it's the US that creates the list, and they don't know or understand that systems like ID numbers exists.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by nevdka on Saturday August 15, 2026 @06:14AM (#49309342)
Americans use their social security numbers like id numbers in all sorts of systems. This problem has nothing to do with id numbers.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by boxed on Monday August 17, 2026 @07:44AM (#49329341)
Well.. it does. There's no checksum in social security numbers for example, that's actually a pretty big deal. The lack of proper buy in on what a personal ID number IS and what it's for is also a huge deal (although not a technical issue, more legal and social for sure).
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by dghlsakjg on Saturday August 15, 2026 @01:00PM (#49312211)
Or they understand that ID numbers are a less than perfect way to identify people.

I’m applying for a second citizenship. That means that I can have two national ids that are unlinked. In the US, you can petition to have your SSN number changed, as well, so that doesn’t work. If you are willing to commit crimes and lie, it isn’t that hard to spin up an entirely new identity. Some people are born to parents that don’t notify the government. The real world is incredibly messy.

If I were to be placed on a list with one passport/id, I could just use a different one.

The bigger issue is that the list is meant as a risk alert, but companies treat a match as truth because the penalty for doing business with a sanctioned entity is far higher than whatever they might lose by not hiring someone mistakenly.

What you need, at minimum, if you are going to make these lists is an easy way for false positive people to prove they aren’t the person named (tsa/homeland security have a “redress number” you can provide if you have the same name as someone on their list). Then a legal requirement that anyone checking this list must also ask for additional documentation if they are making a decision based on a hit.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by boxed on Monday August 17, 2026 @07:45AM (#49329348)
> I’m applying for a second citizenship.

I'm sorry what? A second citizenship to the same country?

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by dghlsakjg on Monday August 17, 2026 @10:23AM (#49331496)
A different country. Many countries allow their citizens to be a citizen of other countries.

I won’t have two unlinked national ids to the same country, I would have a national id in two countries.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by boxed on Monday August 17, 2026 @11:49AM (#49332971)
Well obviously national IDs are... national.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by hdgvhicv on Saturday August 15, 2026 @06:00AM (#49309258)
America has social security numbers. U.K. has national Insurance numbers, Ireland had a PPS and Canada has an SIN
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by UltraSane on Saturday August 15, 2026 @06:56AM (#49309531)
I wish people were assigned a identity certificate with public and private key at birth.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by sneak on Saturday August 15, 2026 @09:13AM (#49310270)
What happens when they lose it? What happens when someone else gets a copy of the private key?

What happens when every app, website, and mobile OS requires a signature for every single post or message, tying all communication to an identity that the government can retaliate against?

This creates many more problems than it solves.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by necovek on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:17AM (#49310798)
I agree and believe revocation is the most important problem.

With services requiring it, you can just not use them: as long as it does not get mandated (unfortunately, a direction we are heading in), hopefully market self-regulates and privacy conserving options win.

Yes, we all know that's not how that movie plays out :)

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by sneak on Monday August 17, 2026 @09:32PM (#49340047)
“just not use them” is not a solution. This rapidly means no banking, no payments, no travel, no publishing, no communications, no medical care.

Try existing in the USA for a month with no phone number.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by UltraSane on Saturday August 15, 2026 @11:56AM (#49311623)
The private key would be generated and stored on the most secure hardware security modules like how AWS stores many billions of symetric and asymmetric keys.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by sneak on Monday August 17, 2026 @10:42AM (#49331862)
ok, then how do users authenticate to those modules? what happens when they lose their authentication credentials?

or do you mean HSMs in the possession of the user? what happens when they lose it, or the device is stolen?

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by defrost on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:01AM (#49309557)
Multiple distinct sets of such things would be better.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by chrisjj on Saturday August 15, 2026 @08:04AM (#49309912)
For the 0yr-old to keep private?
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by UltraSane on Saturday August 15, 2026 @08:50AM (#49310157)
Private key would be stored on a government HSM obviously
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by chrisjj on Saturday August 15, 2026 @11:54AM (#49311614)
Unfortunately so. Any solution would rely on trust and for that reason alone would be unworkable.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by UltraSane on Saturday August 15, 2026 @06:51PM (#49315032)
I wonder if you could leverage etherium smart contracts to reduce the need for trust.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by chrisjj on Saturday August 15, 2026 @11:18PM (#49316590)
Yes, but still someone/thing real has to be trusted to ID the human initially.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by KronisLV on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:42AM (#49309761)
UUIDv7 for all!
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:53AM (#49309840)
I'm from Greece, where I have a national identity number. In fact I've had several (maybe half a dozen?) national identity numbers. You see, the national identity number is, literally, the number on your national identity card, or in other words the serial number of the document; not the person. When the document changes, the number changes with it.

Same as with passports. Even in the Anglosphere people have passports with passport numbers. They could be used to uniquely identify the passport holder, except of course there are many passports, and therefore, many numbers, for each passport holder.

Small problem? Just update whatever database is holding the information for sanctionted persons (or, indeed, persons who should not be sanctioned)?

Turns out, that is not a small problem.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by eru on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:14AM (#49310777)
> You see, the national identity number is, literally, the number on your national identity card, or in other words the serial number of the document; not the person. When the document changes, the number changes with it.

In Singapore, your number is fixed, even when they give you a new document.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by thetimewotitis on Saturday August 15, 2026 @09:20AM (#49310308)
I mean in theory, it doesn't have to be a serial number, and I think that's better. Something about it suggests being enlisted in a national army.

It says the state assigns "A body" a number.

-vs-

The state is made up of us as individuals.

So while the serial keyfield is a data engineers dream, politically I'd welcome something more personal.

Time of birth/parents and other identifying information is on our birth certificates in the UK. Concatenate some of that.

I could be.

DavidAndrewEvans-01011980-0036-MRI-JeanDavis-AlexEvans

Name-DOB-TOB-LocationCode-Parent(s)

Location of Birth like an airport code - MRI (Manchester Royal Infirmary), Parent(s)... i mean we can use their birthdates too.

I actually quite like the idea of it. It seems intrinsically validating to a person to identify them in this way.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by necovek on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:14AM (#49310776)
The problem with that is that it leaks too much information to anyone seeing it — this is bad if it needs to be used with any party you might not trust (or not trust their security). Serbia (former Yugoslavia) already does something similar since 1970s, and your Unique Citizen Number (JMBG) is derived from your date of birth and county of issuance (usually birth county) and sex at birth, a couple of digits and a single digit checksum.

Ideally, government could issue a cryptographically signed ID, so anyone with access to countries' public key can verify authenticity (with revocation mechanism built-in for both individual keys and all keys signed with one government — this is where it gets tricky). Obviously, governments become new CAs, and people in them can provide fakes when they want if they are corrupt, but anyone can easily validate it.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by oasisbob on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:46AM (#49311029)
Names and even dates of birth aren't consistent enough in records for this.

You're reinventing a natural key with a bunch of identifiers which aren't stable enough.

Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by functionmouse on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:40AM (#49310985)
Yes. And they should be tattooed onto the person's arm, so there can be no mistake. Maybe a bar code?
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by karel-3d on Saturday August 15, 2026 @01:29PM (#49312458)
Tony Blair joined the chat
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by Georgelemental on Saturday August 15, 2026 @03:37PM (#49313588)
No, the problem is the due-process-free list of government-designated undesirables
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by smsm42 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @03:39PM (#49313609)
How the identity number would help? It's not like terrorists tell each other their identity numbers. So if the LEOs learn about a terrorist guy that goes around under the name "Sean Byrne", how would they know which ID number that is? And even if I needed some ID number to put on my fake documents, it's easy to download one of the dozens data dumps on the darknet now, and just use any of the IDs there. The LEOs then have a choice - put that number into their ban database (therefore banning some innocent person whose only fault is that he made a mistake of participating in the economy) or go just by the name (which is not better). Don't see how it changed anything.
Re:The other Sean Byrne doesn't exist by numpad0 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @06:54PM (#49315055)
That doesn't work unless everyone is always referred to by that number. All it takes is a "credible" information on some database that says you're the other Sean Bryne, now with the related national ID.