News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by declan_roberts on Friday July 10, 2026 @04:20PM (#48864736)
> During this period, from the late fourth to the mid-seventh century AD, Christianity became the dominant religion, towns expanded across the country and Egypt served as one of the empire's richest provinces.

It's easy to forget how different the Middle East looked before the conquest of Islam starting in 600 AD.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by dismalaf on Friday July 10, 2026 @04:58PM (#48865168)
Not just Islamic conquest but Arab conquest. Up to this point Arabs lived mainly in, well, Arabia. The indigenous peoples of Egypt, Syria, Iraq, etc..., were all non-Arab. Nowadays those indigenous groups are known as Copts, Syriacs, Chaldeans, etc...
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by taeric on Friday July 10, 2026 @05:26PM (#48865509)
Legitimate question, in the early days was this a large distinction? Specifically, my understanding was that the earliest raids where this distinction is most accurate, they didn't actually change the local societies much. Mostly were raids for resources and did not stay.

That is, until the Islamic raids started, the indigenous groups took losses, but were not nearly as transformed. Is that not accurate?

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by thaumasiotes on Friday July 10, 2026 @11:15PM (#48868359)
Well, the distinction mattered. But because the distinction mattered, the modern labels aren't really accurate.

Arabs were the highest-prestige ethnicity within their empire. But they were numerically insignificant. You have "Arabs" and "Copts" in Egypt today, but most of the "Arabs" are Copts whose ancestors decided they wanted more respect. Same thing is true farther west, where the "Arabs" are Berbers.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by taeric on Monday July 13, 2026 @09:48AM (#48892635)
That isn't really addressing my question, I don't think? The assertion is that most of the Arab mixing into region came at the same time as the later invasions. Yes, they would have remained fewer in absolute numbers. But they weren't even there after the earlier raids.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by einpoklum on Friday July 10, 2026 @05:20PM (#48865438)
Local populations adopted Arabic. Somewhat like, several centuries earlier, they adopted Greek; and elsewhere and at other times, Latin. The peoples of the regions were not replaced by Greek or Roman colonists.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by senderista on Saturday July 11, 2026 @12:31AM (#48868770)
We call Arabic speakers “Arabs” but there wasn’t that much genetic replacement.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by dismalaf on Saturday July 11, 2026 @12:49PM (#48873574)
85% of Egyptians have some Arab DNA. Only 15% don't have Arab DNA.

Even if the amount of DNA only adds up to 20% of their mix (the average), it's still very significant.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by senderista on Saturday July 11, 2026 @02:56PM (#48874681)
Black Americans have on average 20-25% European ancestry but we don’t call them “Europeans”.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by gaiagraphia on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:01AM (#48869845)
Isn't this fuelling the conflict in Darfur? UAE-backed Arabs trying to muscle out the Africans?
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by throwaway30213 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @10:54AM (#48872593)
And indigenous groups in France (just to use an example) are called Occitans, Bretons, Catalonians, Flemish, Alsatians, Corsicans, etc., etc. This isn't a unique phenomenon.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by dismalaf on Saturday July 11, 2026 @12:54PM (#48873618)
Flemish, Alsatians and Corsicans are literally Dutch, German and Italian, who are just part of France due to recent history. Occitans and Catalans are near Spain.

Bretons are Celts just like Gauls, whom you missed. You also missed other Celtic groups. And they (Celts) were the majority before invasions, still the majority.

Indigenous doesn't mean minority, it means the original inhabitants.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by trhway on Friday July 10, 2026 @06:01PM (#48865871)
>It's easy to forget how different the Middle East looked before the conquest of Islam starting in 600 AD.

it naturally looked differently due to different climate. For example there was booming agriculture in Carthage back then - modern Tunisia. The climate warming during the first millennia made Mediterranean Basin less grain-production and animal farming suitable while more suitable for the nomadic Arabs riding out of Arabia. That warming also made life more convenient (in particular conditions became much better for agriculture, the backbone of the civilization) in the previously cold and swampy Mid and North Europe where as a result we see the wave of rise of the civilization.

Coincidentally, we have Caliphates decline and Reconquista happening when the climate started to cool down toward the Little Ice Age. The map of Reconquista looks like a geographical climate regions map https://stuffedeyes.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/what-was-... (compare to https://www.spanish-town-guides.com/photo/spain_climate_map....)

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by gaiagraphia on Friday July 10, 2026 @11:42PM (#48868507)
Islam has sure done a number on cultural diversity in the world.

It's such a shame that the various cultural holdouts in the Middle East never get much attention when they're systematically wiped off the map.

The Mandaeans in the marshes near Basra will probably be next to disappear into the sands of time. Not even a whisper in the media.

Oil sure has a way of drowning out 'human rights' in conversation.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by senderista on Saturday July 11, 2026 @12:28AM (#48868753)
Try reading about Kafiristan, where primitive Hinduism (think Rig Veda) survived for 3500 years before being wiped out in the 1890s by a British-appointed Islamic despot.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by gaiagraphia on Saturday July 11, 2026 @03:57AM (#48869828)
Always amazed me how the Kalash in Chitral Valley have managed to peacefully get on with things. I guess the terrain helps.

I always like to think how the region would've looked if all these remnants of peoples had thriving nations.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by senderista on Saturday July 11, 2026 @02:58PM (#48874708)
The Kalash are very similar genetically and culturally and are also facing cultural genocide by Islamists. Truly one of the most fascinating ethnic minorities extant.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by openuntil3am on Saturday July 11, 2026 @01:14AM (#48868966)
Christianity is no different.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by gaiagraphia on Saturday July 11, 2026 @03:50AM (#48869775)
I didn't claim otherwise. Thankfully Enlightenment values cleaned things up a little.

In the current day, I just find it very worrying when you line up a map of global conflicts and where Islam is thriving.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by graemep on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:48AM (#48870125)
Which Enlightenment values? Racism? Sexism? Colonialism?
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by KaiserPro on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:41AM (#48871164)
Translating the arabic texts of science (either copied and expanded from greek, latin and other places, or new research) and claiming that it was widom of the ancients?
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by throwa356262 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @05:03AM (#48870194)
What about Ukraine, Venezuela, North Korea, Taiwan, Panama, Greenland, Congo, Mexico, El Salvador, ...
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by throwaway30213 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @10:52AM (#48872568)
How many of those global conflicts are being fuelled, driven or outright perpetrated by western countries?
[dead]
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:10AM (#48869904)
And without the Muslims maintaining the Greek and Roman texts, that would've taken far longer. Even algebra and algorithm come from Muslim names.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:46AM (#48870112)
The Roman/Byzantine empire was pretty much destroyed by Muslims, though. Its a but like thanking the Franks/Goths/etc. for preserving Roman cultural identity in Western Europe by preserving some of their texts..
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by disgruntledphd2 on Monday July 13, 2026 @04:26AM (#48889527)
> The Roman/Byzantine empire was pretty much destroyed by Muslims, though

This is hilariously untrue, if one is talking about the Western Roman empire. An islamic state did conquer Constantinople, which I presume is what you mean.

The Roman empire (western) basically fell apart due to infighting more than anything else.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by warumdarum on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:28AM (#48871456)
Mostly enslaved yehudi and persian scholars..
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by defrost on Saturday July 11, 2026 @01:57AM (#48869184)
The subject wasn't the creation of technology, it was the propensity of theocracies to beat the native out of natives.

eg: https://www.theguardian.com/world/ng-interactive/2021/sep/06...

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by jsemrau on Saturday July 11, 2026 @02:58AM (#48869481)
Yet these are not the same. One is a backward medieval deathcult, the other creates the finest achievements of humanity. These are not the same.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by defrost on Saturday July 11, 2026 @03:09AM (#48869536)
Be fair now, the Catholic Church hasn't always and consistently been a backward medieval deathcult - there have been periods of non Crusading, non Inquisition, not slaughtering Cathars, not trading in babies, etc.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by jsemrau on Saturday July 11, 2026 @03:16AM (#48869581)
What a dumb argument. Over the millennia Christian theocracy has been a net benefit to the world. There is a reason why the world wants to live in Christian countries and not in Muslims countries. And its not for the food.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by defrost on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:02AM (#48869852)
Again, Christians have been just as appalling as any other religion.

They've killed, enslaved, done their best to eliminate cultures, railed against miscegenation, etc.

Not sure why you're working so hard to pretend o/wise.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:50AM (#48870135)
To be fair in addition to the uncountable horrible things it did or took part in the Catholic church did build the foundations that allowed the concepts of modern scientific thought to develop. No other religion did that.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by ghostDancer on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:17AM (#48870984)
And they burned quite people for defending the science that went against their beliefs. They only stopped when they thought it would be good for their economic profits. Exactly the same when they stopped protecting slavery, when they thought it would be good as they would get a lot of new followers and all the money and influence that would come with them.And all the fights that gave birth to the other Christian churches always for the same reasons power and money.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:39AM (#48871142)
Well yes it’s relative. However the Church in the 1400s to 1600s or so was generally very permissive of scientific debate and not strictly dogmatic. See Galileo’s story, the issue is that when they rejected something (based on a reasonably valid scientific process albeit based on flawed evidence available at the time) that was kind of it and continued to challenging the consensus got you into some deep trouble (with a few exceptions).

One interesting thing is that in the 1400s open debate and heterodoxy was generally tolerated or even accepted IF you did it in Latin and only inside the “international scholar network” that existed at the time and didn’t go around preaching your ideas to peasants and such.

I’m certainly not implying that it was in any way good or let alone perfect in absolute terms, just that it.

> same reasons power and money.

That’s highly reductive

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by ekianjo on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:06AM (#48871324)
> nd they burned quite people for defending the science that went against their beliefs

much less than the alternatives. muslims killed anyone who did not convert in case you did not know

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by ghostDancer on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:45AM (#48871578)
Oh playing the old game of "you more" , we're not debating which belief is more savage than the other, all of them are, we're pointing out that the followers of the supposedly all loving version of a god killed,should we say assassinated, lots of people just because their discoveries did not fit in their stories books.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:20PM (#48875480)
That varied wildly. Generally more of an exception that the rule but in the worst cases like under the Almohad’s you did have Jewish or even less extremist Muslim refugees fleeing to the more tolerant (at the time) Christian kingdoms.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by graemep on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:56AM (#48870158)
Its been the most anti-slavery religion and was the main motivation for the abolition of slavery. There is no Christian objection to 'miscegenation' and its a weird concept only taken up in America and a few other places like South Africa during apartheid, and it owes more to race science than Christianity.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by Hikikomori on Saturday July 11, 2026 @05:48AM (#48870445)
Yet Christians had no problems taking, owning an selling slaves on an industrial scale for 100s of years. Their book even includes an ownership guide. And then you want a gold star for stopping what you created? The theocratic mind is laughable.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by graemep on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:45AM (#48871192)
> Their book even includes an ownership guide.

You mean the books of the Bible containing rules explicitly rejected by Christians from the start? The rules that Jesus is recorded as saying was a moral compromise? You are also conveniently skipping over the declarations of equality (with regard to slavery, race and sex) in the New Testament.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by Hikikomori on Saturday July 11, 2026 @11:37AM (#48872957)
That's the thing, there's something about just about everything that can be interpreted in either direction. But christians are just humans, we do these things. The problem I have is when christians pretend they are better and always were because their new interpretation of some text. American slavery being a great example of this as the bible was just to both justify and in abolishment. And as usual, its all about what parts we currently like while ignoring the others.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by jsemrau on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:32AM (#48871083)
Like the rest of the world. Since there are many non-Western countries that still have slaves there is no original sin.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by KaiserPro on Saturday July 11, 2026 @10:08AM (#48872220)
> Its been the most anti-slavery religion and was the main motivation for the abolition of slavery.

Which branch of Christianity though? There was a huge disparity in approaches in new england colonies (ie rhode island thought the indigenous should have rights, Massachusetts couldn't give a shit about anyone other than the elected.)

A lot of the english abolitionists were radicals, well outside the mainstream. The Quakers, Methodists, shakers were all deeply scary to the establishment

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by graemep on Monday July 13, 2026 @10:10AM (#48893005)
There was always Christian opposition to slavery much of it from the mainstream as well as radicals. St Augustine, Gregory of Nyssa, several Popes and . Several Christian kingdoms (including England) abolished slavery and/or slave trading in medieval times.

The US has tended towards justifying slavery, and its arguments included the ¨curse of Ham" borrowed from Muslim slave traders. British colonies in the Caribbean produced censored version of the Bible for slaves.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by ekianjo on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:04AM (#48871313)
> Again, Christians have been just as appalling as any other religion

that is an opinion devoid of good arguments. humans under christianity have fared much better than any other kind of religion

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by defrost on Saturday July 11, 2026 @11:44PM (#48878076)
And they've been enslaved, killed, and had their cultures erased, in the name of Christianity and by Christians (many citations).

Why pretend not?

Nobody is, well at least I'm not, denying the good that has been done by Muslims, Christians, Jews, Hindu's, etc.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by MomsAVoxell on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:41AM (#48871557)
The reason is, those Christian countries tend only to bomb the Muslim ones, creating 34 million refugees from the Wests' illegal wars.

They're not coming to America for the strip malls and endless commutes. They're coming to America because America demolished their civilization.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by Hikikomori on Saturday July 11, 2026 @05:43AM (#48870420)
Both are backward medieval deathcults to atheists.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by ekianjo on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:07AM (#48871331)
atheists put in place MAID which is in itself a deathcult
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by Hikikomori on Saturday July 11, 2026 @11:00AM (#48872642)
Why are you complaining? Isn't it great that you get to meet your maker earlier?
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by warumdarum on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:45AM (#48871577)
But one couldbuild societies and institutions that made it fade into the background the other did not
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by Chu4eeno on Saturday July 11, 2026 @02:54AM (#48869460)
Isn't Canada a secular state? I think the grandparents point was to separate plain old xenophobia from religiously motivated erasure of culture.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by defrost on Saturday July 11, 2026 @02:58AM (#48869487)
The Vatican is a theocratic state, Catholic churches, schools, etc are effective theocracies.

There's a long list of questionable behaviour, eg. enslavement for Jesus: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1838_Jesuit_slave_sale

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by jsemrau on Saturday July 11, 2026 @03:25AM (#48869626)
There are more people enslaved now than at any point in time in history. Guess the countries.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by defrost on Saturday July 11, 2026 @03:56AM (#48869823)
There are more people now than at any point in time in history.

Meanwhile, in history, religions enslaved people.

Returning to the point you keep dodging, that includes Christians.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by jsemrau on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:31AM (#48871073)
I don't believe in the original sin of slavery in Western countries. Slavery has been existed for centuries before and, despite being abolished by Western countries (hint: there were several wars were people lost lives), still exists in China, India, Indonesia, and a large group of Arab countries.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by defrost on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:41AM (#48871158)
> I don't believe in the original sin of slavery in Western countries.

I have no idea what that sentence is specifically meant to mean, that aside, western countries have had actual slavery and effective slavery both in the past and the present.

eg: Past & actual: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1838_Jesuit_slave_sale

'Present' (Post WWII) & effective: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-04-27/child-abuse-royal-com...

I don't mean to exclusively beat on Christians or just Catholics here; but I do intend to counter your apparent narrative of good Christians and evil Muslims.

Christians certainly diminished a lot of cultures, just as other religions also did - the initial point that started this above.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by MomsAVoxell on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:40AM (#48871550)
Slavery has not been abolished in the West. It has just been put behind walls that the general public do not usually care to see.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by ghostDancer on Saturday July 11, 2026 @05:02AM (#48870188)
Capitalist countries all of them.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by MomsAVoxell on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:38AM (#48871536)
The USA has the world's greatest for-profit prison slave system in existence.

There has never been as many slaves in humanity as there are in the US' prisons.

What's that? Oh, they don't count because they're criminals?

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by conception on Saturday July 11, 2026 @02:59AM (#48869496)
Thousands of years… christian nations… educate yourself… hmm
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by raffraffraff on Saturday July 11, 2026 @05:13AM (#48870245)
I love hearing the guys from The Rest Of History discuss this from their different perspectives!
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by sdsdssweew213 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @06:11AM (#48870569)
I wouldn't thank Christianity for the scientific advancements of the West, except maybe for protestant work ethic. Science only started to flourish when Catholic church started to lose power, and religion became a bit more separated from law and politics.

Best religion for progress of humanity is the one that embraces work, tells people to treat each other fairly, and otherwise keeps its hands off from irrelevant details of people's lives - things like what consenting adults do in bed, what they eat or drink, what they can or can't say.

Unfortunately Christians have been historically way too focused on the bad parts while ignoring the good parts, leading to madness like wars between Catholics and Protestants and discrimination of minorities. Think of the current conservative elite in America for example - it's hard to find people who are further away from teachings of Jesus Christ than those greedy, hateful idiots.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by throwaway30213 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @11:02AM (#48872655)
More like the last 500 years. Before that the cultural and scientific centers of the world were variously in muslim, hindu, chinese, roman and other civilizations.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:41AM (#48870096)
To be fair for the most part Christianity didn’t spread top down through violent conquest (obviously with some huge exceptions) at least in the Middle East and surrounding regions. Also it’s historically better at integrating local cultural practices and languages.

Unlike Islam which which usually wiped out local cultural and linguistic identities (during the periods of Arab conquests, that shifted quite a but later on of course)

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by KaiserPro on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:40AM (#48871153)
I'm Just looking at the rich indigenous culture and languages of the US and how widespread and celebrated it is.

thats why all the signs in downtown Manhattan are in Munsee....

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by Hikikomori on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:52AM (#48870146)
Well the crusades, northern crusades and most of imperialism.

For the most part it's enough to conquer a place. People below the timing elite would switch religions as it would be beneficial for them, and eventually trickle down to peasants and such.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:14AM (#48870967)
> Crusades

Many of the regions they invaded were still (or until quite recently) majority Christian. After all initially it was a defensive relief expedition organized by the pope and the Byzantine emperor to free the territories the empire lost in Anatolia very recently. Of course it was massively more successful than anyone anticipated and they just kept on going and then the whole thing got “slightly” out of hand..

But yes, as I said there were some huge exceptions. However early on the way Christianity spread was fundamentally different to Islam. It was usually not through violent conquest but bottom up.

European imperialism was quite mixed as well. Christianity played a huge part in the Spanish conquests of the Americas. Much less so in British India and other similar places.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by Hikikomori on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:08AM (#48871336)
Very peaceful when you continently ignore all the violence.

Northern crusades were extremely bloody and defeated people would accept baptism or be executed.

Charlemange was more of the same deal.

Catholic church left pagans to their own devices?

Christian history is littered with these examples, it has not been a peaceful religion since it merged with Roman society. The only real good examples you could have are missionaries and top down conversion as kings and such voluntarily switched religions.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:25PM (#48875520)
As I said, in relative terms..

> Catholic church left pagans to their own devices?

It varied, although generally the Catholic church was fairly open at integrating or even occasionally tolerating pagan practices or providing alternative options to people used to more polytheistic religions. Like the whole saint worshipping (“venerating”) thing. Often (with some exceptions) pagans found conversion fairly easy since they could just map their gods to equivalent Christian saints continue worshipping them. Basically every converted pagan society had a multi-generationa transition period.

Then you had stuff lime praying to magical corpses or body parts, so their previous owners could perform miracles. With some exceptions it has generally been a highly flexible religion before the reformation.

Islam is much more rigid about following the rules and stuff like idol worship (as a consequence they brought back visual arts back to the stone ages..)

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by alfiedotwtf on Saturday July 11, 2026 @11:00AM (#48872635)
Did you just hand wave off the crusades?

And when you say “historically better at integrating local cultural practices”, India, China and Australia, would like a word with you. Holy shit you should just delete your account right now

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Sunday July 12, 2026 @02:57PM (#48883553)
No, why would you say I did that? Also if everyone ever referencing any historical event ever would have to explicitly list and condemn every single thing they think was wrong it would become rather verbose and boring to read. Overall the crusaders were worse than some violent conquerors and better than others.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by carlosjobim on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:13AM (#48871374)
Christianity was very different, and the evidence for that is undeniable and gigantic. The fruits of diversity within christendom is offered in great treasure heaps within science, music, art, philosophy, theology, lifestyles, ways of worship, mysteries of the faith, and culture in general.

Christianity merged with local cultures, removing some aspects and adding some aspects.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by tclancy on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:35AM (#48871099)
Hang on a tick, who made the oil valuable and happily pays for it while turning a blind eye?
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by flyinglizard on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:06AM (#48871319)
It doesn't absolve those who commit the atrocities, even if there are externalities involved. It's not always the White Man's fault - neither in Africa nor the Middle East. We can and should hold the societies in those places to a certain global standard of conduct.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by MomsAVoxell on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:35AM (#48871513)
Whose standard of conduct should the cultures you deem inferior be held to, exactly?
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by flyinglizard on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:47AM (#48871588)
That's an easy one - to the same standard we hold Israel. No more, no less.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by MomsAVoxell on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:54AM (#48871647)
Hell no, that's ridiculous. Israel is a wholesale violator of human rights at massive scale, along with its criminal 5-eyes cronies, and it is in the midst of an imperialist genocide, murdering children every single day. If a state cannot defend itself against children, it is failed and should be refactored by its citizens, immediately and with haste.

We also strike the USA off the list, which cannot even take care of its peoples' most basic needs.

Switzerland. The answer you're looking for, is Switzerland. /s

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by MomsAVoxell on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:34AM (#48871500)
>Islam has sure done a number on cultural diversity in the world.

So has Christianity and Capitalism.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by fragmede on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:35AM (#48871505)
And then there's math.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by MomsAVoxell on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:42AM (#48871565)
Yes, that's definitely done a few numbers.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by miroljub on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:49AM (#48871614)
Whataboutism
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by MomsAVoxell on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:54AM (#48871649)
No, "so-has'ism". Not whataboutism.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by throwaway30213 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @10:43AM (#48872480)
There is a certain irony in your comment written in English posted on July 11, the 2026th year of Our Lord (though not mine), according to the Gregorian calender (named after Pope Gregory XIII who issued the papal bull that ordained said calendar) at 03:42:12, Universal Standard Time (the local time in London, United Kingdom). And the fact that i am reading this comment in the weekend (the Christian and Jewish days of Sabbath) and replying in similar fashion, (which is mostly historically rooted in the fact that these customs and culture were originally imposed on my country, India by our conquerors, than because it won out in some nebulous contest in the marketplace of ideas)
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by hechang1997 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @12:28AM (#48868754)
> It's easy to forget how different the Middle East looked before the conquest of Islam starting in 600 AD.

It’s easy to forget because it’s a fabricated perspective. Islamic/Arabian conquest of MENA isn’t really that different from what Romans or Persians did. That region is literally the source of human civilization (in the Old World at least) and had seen empires come and go ever since the Bronze Age, and along with them all sorts of cultures and religions. What fundamentally changed the dynamics of the region is not the islamic conquest but the shift of the center of the global trade away from Middle East and the Mediterranean to the Western Europe.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:34AM (#48870064)
It is somewhat different. Romans or Greeks didn’t really violently impose their culture, religion and language to a comparable degree. Without the Islamic invasions Egyptian would likely still be speaking Coptic these days.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by ghostDancer on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:55AM (#48870153)
That's not exactly true. Spain, Portugal and France, at least, speak languages derived from Latin, while the original languages went extincted. And Christian religion taken by the Romans annihilated all the rest of religions in Europe.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:24AM (#48871027)
Well yes it highly varied. However Romans were generally more motivated by plunder and subsequent economic exploitation. To an extent they didn’t really suppress local cultural practices or imposed forced assimilation in cases where it didn’t conflict with that and even often allowed alternative power structures to exist. Assimilation largely happened over time and was mostly voluntary. To be fair gradual voluntary conversion to Islam to enhance your social/economic status was the main mechanism in the Muslim empires as well. However in Rome the transition wasn’t as binary and “multiculturalism” was much more tolerated. Also Romans were way more open to integrating and assimilating foreign cultures and practices (which is why the Roman Empire eventually turned into a “Greek Empire”) what being a “Roman” meant was way more malleable and flexible than being a Muslim.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by madspindel on Saturday July 11, 2026 @05:09AM (#48870222)
> And Christian religion taken by the Romans

It was not taken by the Romans. It was persecuted by the Romans for nearly 300 years.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by ghostDancer on Saturday July 11, 2026 @05:13AM (#48870243)
In the beginning it prosecuted the Christians but later the Roman empire embraced Christianity and imposed all through the empire. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_as_the_Roman_stat...
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by swasheck on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:43AM (#48871566)
i’m no apologist for christian history but you are both dancing around the nuances to make your own respective points. both things can be true but they require a lot of words: the roman republic, and subsequent empire were happy to allow conquered peoples to maintain their own ways of life as long as a few basic (in their estimation) requirements were met (taxes, fealty, etc). it was ripe for corruption to the conquered peoples tended to rebel and they got put down with severe violence

christianity offered a unifying thematic message and de facto polity under which constantine believed he could more effectively maintain power and peace. this system was ripe for corruption but now the people are generally kept in line by the conflation of church and state.

islam arises primarily as a repudiation of polytheism and what is perceived as loose monotheism and nonviolently sweeps through the area quickly.

regional leaders quickly learn the same lesson that constantine learned and use islam to prevent rebellion and exert control, with the added lesson learned that it’s best to just ensure everyone follows the same code from the start so that you don’t have to do a lot of political cleanup in the transition to a new belief system.

fractured “european” leaders realize how much power they’ve lost and decide that they should unify under the christian brand to go take back their power.

and the cycle goes on and on

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by hammock on Saturday July 11, 2026 @11:27AM (#48872861)
> islam arises primarily as a repudiation of polytheism and what is perceived as loose monotheism

I doubt that “repudiation” of said things was the main driver.

I’m pretty sure by 600ad Rome was pretty solidly Christian (or at elite levels, perhaps secular), what other gods did exist were folk/syncretistic practices, which also existed in Islam (sufis, Zoroastrian stuff, gnostic stuff etc) and which still existed today in Christianity (in the Philippines, the Caribbean, Africa, etc)

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by wqaatwt on Sunday July 12, 2026 @02:51PM (#48883504)
It was kind of problem that by the time Romans really got into suppressing all kinds of “heresies” and imposing Orthodoxy across the empire. Since most in their Middle Eastern provinces and Egypt weren’t Orthodox Catholic most locals didn’t really bother that much fighting for them since the Muslims at the time just seemed like another Christian sect just with a more hands off attitude to government and possibly lower taxes.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by ghostDancer on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:59AM (#48871673)
Yeah, also it was the way it happened, we should not judge those times with our vision of things, different times, different values. All religions are a form of control over the peasants, Islam grew and evolved in an area with a set of political and social characteristics and Christianity the same but different ones and that's why you find the differences and the same reason that Islam and Christianity split in several branches. And you can see east Europe went Orthodox, South Europe went Catholic and North went Protestant, add to that the fights for the power.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by carlosjobim on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:03AM (#48871300)
Weren't all the conquered obliged to worship the emperor along with their own gods?
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by gglanzani on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:44AM (#48871573)
No. Jews didn’t, f.e.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by thisislife2 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @10:02AM (#48872163)
And if the British hadn't conquered and exploited my country, modern India wouldn't have been an impoverished country that is now a developing nation whose identity and culture has been forever changed due to European imperialism. The Islamophobia (and the general lack of respect for most non-western cultures) in this discussion is based on real ignorance:

1. There are indeed many things to admire about the west. However, for all the cultural and scientific advancement made by the west, westerners choose to ignore that the backbone of the current western "empire" was also built on the knowledge and wealth you looted from other non-western empires. The reason that you are now the most "developed" nation is because you now follow the same political pattern as all the "superpower" empires of their time - you hoard the wealth and knowledge now, and deny it to others. (Please read about the The fate of the Library of Alexandria - https://www.britannica.com/topic/Library-of-Alexandria/The-f... to understand, for one, how much knowledge was created, collated and valued in the eastern cultures - even by the "barbarian" muslim empires.)

(I know there have been books written in the west trying to justify that slavery and imperialism isn't why the west are wealthy. I partially agree with some points in them but disagree that the wealth that you stole was inconsequential. If the west truly believes that the wealth stolen from us wasn't what made your economies rich, but only your own culture and ingenuity, why don't you repatriate that amount that was diverted to your economy and actually test that theory? Mughal India, for example was one of the richest economies that accounted for 24% of the world GDP - https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5724162 - before the British conquered and transferred most of that wealth to enrich itself).

2. Many of you pretend (or rather seek comfort in the idea) that State violence of ancient non-western empires is something cultural to only non-western cultures. That western / Christian nations are more "peaceful" by nature. A study of the history of crusades, and western imperialism, should immediately dismiss that notion. (Shamefully, even today, many western nations sponsor and support the ethnic cleansing and genocide of native populations by your allies in Africa and the middle-east).

3. Some of you resort to selectively applying modern cultural perceptions to criticise historical societies. That is not how history is studied - one strives to understand history based on the cultural contexts of their period.

E.g. Prophet Muhammad didn't marry a 9 or 10 year old Ayesha because he liked to diddle young girls. During his time, puberty was treated as someone entering adulthood. While marriages may be arranged between pre-pubescent kids, it was only after they had reach puberty that they were allowed to consummate the marriage. Marriage to Ayesha was also political - Muhammad was actually forced to marry someone from every tribal leader's family as that was the diplomatic equivalent of establishing a political alliance during his time! (That is why he is an exception to the rule that a muslim can only have up to 4 wives). Note that even before Muhammad, Mary, mother of Christ, was considered eligible to be married to Joseph (an old man, past his middle-age) when she turned 12. She was still a teenager when she became pregnant ( https://christianity.stackexchange.com/questions/12317/is-th... ) - is Christ's father / God a paedophile too? By today's modern standard, you would say yes, that's ephebophilia.

The nomenclature of "Child marriage" or even "teen marriage" is a modern cultural phenomenon because of the advancement we have made in understanding our own biology (i.e. reproductive systems) and our changing moral and cultural norms on the ideas of sexuality. Despite this, note that most of the world still can't agree on a universal age of consent or marriage. For example, Japan only recently raised the minimum age of consent for sex from 13 to 16 ( https://politics.stackexchange.com/questions/83755/why-was-t..., while in some parts of the US, an adult can still marry a teenager with the consent of their parents ( https://www.unchainedatlast.org/child-marriage-in-the-u-s/ )! My own grandparents were only 13 and 9 when they were married in the 1920's, a really common practice in India until the late 20th century, till it was made illegal and is nearly abolished now.

4. Some of you resort to judging other cultures by the worst members of their community. How would the west like it if only the Nazis were considered as their true representatives, and were solely judged based on their ideology?

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by throwaway30213 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @10:35AM (#48872432)
There is a certain irony in your comment written in English posted on July 11, the 2026th year of Our Lord (though not mine), according to the Gregorian calender (named after Pope Gregory XIII who issued the papal bull that ordained said calendar) at 08:34:41, Universal Standard Time (the local time in London, United Kingdom). And the fact that i am reading this comment in the weekend (the Christian and Jewish days of Sabbath) and replying in similar fashion, (which is mostly historically rooted in the fact that these customs and culture were originally imposed on my country, India by our conquerors, than because it won out in some nebulous contest in the marketplace of ideas)
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by declan_roberts on Saturday July 11, 2026 @11:51AM (#48873088)
Ah yea, Christianity, famous for spreading around the Middle East via the sword.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by miroljub on Saturday July 11, 2026 @05:29AM (#48870332)
None of the previous empire changes led to the population replacement. Islamic expansion (colonisation, conquest) brought Arabs and their way of life everywhere.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by cineticdaffodil on Saturday July 11, 2026 @06:17AM (#48870607)
You can see the cultural differences though. One culture has the ability to pool finances and invest its way out of crisis. The other invests it all into exponential humans and conflict. Ideal for spreading in squalid, burned down conditions, non-ideal, when more then spreading is in your definiton of what humanity should strife for.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by KaiserPro on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:36AM (#48871108)
You're gonna have to be more specific. which religion, and what time are you insinuating for spreading in "spreading in squalid, burned down conditions"
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by tclancy on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:33AM (#48871093)
> pool finances and invest its way out of crisis. The other invests it all into exponential humans and conflict

As an American, I am left wondering which side is us.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by soperj on Saturday July 11, 2026 @01:35AM (#48869075)
You had one group of people who believed in God that were completely wiped out by another who also believed in the same God.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by Chu4eeno on Saturday July 11, 2026 @02:52AM (#48869452)
Two, don't forget the jews.
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by madspindel on Saturday July 11, 2026 @04:58AM (#48870164)
Allahu akbar = (Our) God is greater

It's true that Islam is a Christian heresy but to be fair, Islam tries to be it's own State Religion only for the Arabs. So in that sense it's not the same God since they don't believe in the Trinity.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by asabil on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:41AM (#48871552)
Incorrect translation, Allahu Akbar means “the god is the greatest”

Allah is not a name that came with Islam but existed before, it just means deity. the Al prefix is the definite singular form. It just says one thing: god is a singleton and nothing is above it.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by madspindel on Saturday July 11, 2026 @08:47AM (#48871592)
No, the correct translation is "God is greater". And it was used as a war chant against Christians.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DKCx0JHzPs2/

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by thisislife2 on Saturday July 11, 2026 @10:39AM (#48872459)
When Indian army regiments, with predominantly Sikh soldiers, fight any army, they rally themselves for battle with cries of "Wahe Guru ki Khalsa, Wahe Guru ki Fatah" (which roughly translates to "[We] the pure are of the almighty, and the triumph in making is also of the almighty). Pakistani army, predominantly Muslim soldiers, do use the rallying cry of "Allahu Akbar". It's debatable whether these chants are meant more for themselves, than directed at their "enemies".
Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by alfiedotwtf on Saturday July 11, 2026 @10:53AM (#48872582)
Fun fact - not every Christian sect believes in the trinity.

Another fun fact, the Jewish God and the Christian God are the same… it’s just that the Jewish God didn’t have a son who was also himself that killed himself only to resurrect himself negating the sacrifice

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by yowo on Saturday July 11, 2026 @05:44AM (#48870423)
Completely wiped out? Christian copts were the majority for more than a century after Egypt became under Islamic rule, the shift took centuries of immigration and fertility rate changes. Many churches still stands in Egypt where they were before Islamic rule.

The copts themselves welcomed Islamic conquest as Muslims gave them more rights than previous rulers.

https://www.britannica.com/place/Egypt/From-the-Islamic-conq...

You are attempt to disguise your hate as history is a failure.

Re:Lost city discovered beneath Egypt's desert with ancient ... by stogot on Saturday July 11, 2026 @07:58AM (#48871266)
I’m not OP but to say Your article is incomplete and washed. It makes no mention of the jizya, of slavery, persecution, or rape. Read a history book written by a copt like Sword & Scimitar and then look at the references. He references the Muslim sources themselves. Determine the truth from that. The west keeps washing the truth