News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by tancop on Saturday June 27, 2026 @06:15PM (#48702297)
selectively giving away free money to big business is straight corruption. there is no other way to put it. everyone involved should lose re election and get investigated by the financial crimes unit.

but i dont think "leave it up to the market" is a better idea. investments like this just need to be transparent, open to everyone and set up strict punishment for stealing the money with prison for executives.

if they wanted to actually create jobs they would support small companies and set up open competitive programs based on project quality. or start a state investment bank giving super low interest loans so factories can expand without cutting profitable divisions like in china.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by tantalor on Saturday June 27, 2026 @06:48PM (#48702517)
One idea I like is directly funding apprenticeship. It pays for job training and classroom instruction on a per-individual basis. The jobs are in long-term career sectors like advanced manufacturing, shipbuilding, aviation, healthcare, and technology.

Here's one example: https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/osec/osec20250923

In Georgia, the employer is reimbursed $2,500 when an apprentice starts and up to $10,000 when they finish. They can also get up to 75% of the apprentice's hourly wage covered during their initial on-the-job training.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by diogenescynic on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:55PM (#48703294)
It will just be abused like the money for in-home daycares and elder care is.

I'd rather they just lower our taxes and quit squandering our money on these programs that never work. I never once hear democrats looking to lower taxes or remove wasteful spending, it's practically encouraged. They defend SNAP recipients buying soda and candy even while admitting there's a correlation between SNAP recipients and having diabetes and being overweight. They do the wrong thing and know it and expect us to ignore that and keep funding these programs.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by glenpierce on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:03PM (#48703327)
The reason you never hear that is because waste and fraud are very low in reality. That’s why this made the news. It’s uncommon.

We should be using the government to help people and when we do, it often does a good job.

Examples: Roads, libraries, fire departments, schools, safety regulations…

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by roenxi on Saturday June 27, 2026 @11:40PM (#48704107)
> The reason you never hear that is because waste and fraud are very low in reality. That’s why this made the news. It’s uncommon.

Fraud might be relatively rare, but we hear about waste constantly and it isn't newsworthy because a high level of waste is expected from a government operation. If it wasn't then there would be good results by putting things under government control, rather than the more realistic outcome of a politically controlled market oscillating erratically between gluts and shortages depending on who won a popularity contest this year.

To be newsworthy political waste generally has to be competitive with wartime levels of destruction. Things like a 2 billion dollars going down the tubes with basically nothing to show for it. Which is similar to the cost/benefit to the US of a day of wild flailing in Iran, US assaults typically run at around a billion dollars per day. If it is less damaging than that then there isn't much point bringing it up because there are bigger fish to fry.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by coryrc on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:17PM (#48703391)
Our public transportation infrastructure literally cost 10x per mile than France or Hong Kong. That's not waste to you? For what California has spent/is spending on high-speed rail from nowhere to nowhere, China blanketed their country?

Notice you also left out police. How's our spending working there?

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by dgoldstein0 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:30PM (#48703789)
California high speed rail has been a mess. Which is likely in part because politics dictating routes has raised the costs and timelines substantially. On a smaller scale SF was building a new subway in 2013 that had been on the drawing board for years. I remember thinking maybe I'd ride it to work one day. Opened in 2023 or 2024, after I had moved offices twice and then went to work from home. It's not a terrible line but because it had to go to the center of our Chinatown instead of 2 blocks over, it took quite a bit longer and became the deepest subway line in the city. Several other bits of stupidity too in that project but a big piece of the delayed timeline was that tunneling in SF is hard.

Plenty of other transit projects exist that have made real differences. Personally I'm a fan of the simple improvements: revised bus routes with dedicated bus lanes and improved stop & shelters, added bike lanes, etc. those sorts of projects are relatively cheap investments and while no single one is a silver bullet they add up. On a bigger scale - Caltrain's electrification was a big win. Both kinds of projects are easier than building whole new tracks or digging new tunnels. Extend and improve the existing systems. Most cities have something to start from.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by littlexsparkee on Sunday June 28, 2026 @01:00AM (#48704519)
Note Atherton's delays cost Caltrain electrification 3 years and $400m IIRC

https://peninsulaforeveryone.org/blog/atherton-spent-145k-to...

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by coryrc on Sunday June 28, 2026 @01:43PM (#48709609)
> Personally I'm a fan of the simple improvements

Stockholm Syndrome. Because our government is so paralyzed and ineffective, we can't even dream big anymore.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by dgoldstein0 on Sunday July 12, 2026 @02:37AM (#48878897)
I mean I'd be a fan of a roadmap of simple improvements that contribute to a big vision. Shipping incrementally just seems to work better when possible.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by windows_hater_7 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:13PM (#48703703)
I’d note that China does not need democratic approval for any of its projects and thus is substantially more efficient.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by D_Alex on Sunday June 28, 2026 @12:40AM (#48704427)
And what lesson should be drawn from that?
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by camgunz on Sunday June 28, 2026 @11:39AM (#48708345)
That it's easy to build things when you oppress and enslave people.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by throwaway85825 on Sunday June 28, 2026 @02:40PM (#48710166)
We seem to get the worst of both.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by coryrc on Sunday June 28, 2026 @01:42PM (#48709602)
We don't either. It's a Democratic Republic. Our electeds could do their job.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by xphos on Sunday June 28, 2026 @02:15AM (#48704877)
I mean building infrastructure is literally done by private groups the government hires not the government itself. Infantalizing the government as unable to do anything is the biggest myth of the 20th century. When the government did build the roads for the interstate high system they were much cheaper. They cut through any possible regulations and just built them. If government is slow its because we have regulated government to be slow because people would get tremendous power and than plow over large African American communities with roads and rail roads. Its very well documented the speed and brutality that government can move with.

All this to say the government can be fast and efficient mostly because we have an almost infinite number of examples in the US of it doing it.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by coryrc on Sunday June 28, 2026 @01:39PM (#48709586)
> because we have an almost infinite number of examples in the US of it doing it.

... before the 1970s. Nothing this millennium, or even the last quarter of the 20th century. It's been, at minimum, 50 years since we've cost-effectively built anything at scale.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by expedition32 on Sunday June 28, 2026 @07:50AM (#48706529)
The police in America is amongst the best in the world. They do a good job keeping people in line projecting authority and terror.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by coryrc on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:42PM (#48703541)
And another, our recidivism rates are much higher than comparable countries. Is that how we do a "good job" helping people?
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by ZenoArrow on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:06PM (#48703341)
> I'd rather they just lower our taxes and quit squandering our money on these programs that never work.

Would you support cutting military spending? It's a lot higher than other countries.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by diogenescynic on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:15PM (#48703712)
Definitely and we should have affordable universal healthcare and subsidized state university tuition. Everything else should be cut as much as possible. I don't see any programs that are working well.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by WalterBright on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:56PM (#48703618)
> It's a lot higher than other countries.

That's because the US also defends the free world.

Besides, not spending enough on the military can get very, very expensive.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by deaux on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:15PM (#48703713)
> That's because the US also defends the free world.

The US invasions of Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya and Iraq have sure helped defend the free world. How many trillions went into those combined? Fantastic return per $ of "free world defense".

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by paulddraper on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:46PM (#48703871)
Don’t forget Ukraine!
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by deaux on Sunday June 28, 2026 @08:11AM (#48706642)
Unfortunately Ukraine too is a rounding error compared to the invasions. It's negligible compared to Afghanistan on its own, let alone if you include Iraq.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by WalterBright on Sunday June 28, 2026 @12:20AM (#48704304)
Consider all the US bases in Europe, there to defend Europe against Russia. And the bases in the Pacific and Japan. Greenland, too!

When I lived in Germany in the 70s, we were driving on the Autobahn one day, and I saw a jet hedgehopping at full blast over the countryside. I asked my dad what was going on, and why didn't the Germans complain about it. (Hedgehopping is how you avoid radar detection.)

He replied that the Germans didn't particularly like it, but they understood the reason for it. We were in Wiesbaden because my dad worked on the US base and their job was to ensure that there wasn't going to be nuclear combat toe to toe with the Russkies.

Later on, we lived near Luke AFB in Arizona, where Luftwaffe pilots were trained. I'd ride my bike out to the flight line and watch those glorious F-104s blast off with their afterburners lit up.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by deaux on Sunday June 28, 2026 @08:10AM (#48706641)
I did consider those. The cost of the overseas bases is a rounding error compared to the invasions.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by SecretDreams on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:28PM (#48703459)
> One idea I like is directly funding apprenticeship. It pays for job training and classroom instruction on a per-individual basis. The jobs are in long-term career sectors like advanced manufacturing, shipbuilding, aviation, healthcare, and technology.

This is basically what grad school does too. I'm into funding education further any day of the week. For higher education, I'd only add a string attached like "must practice trade in state that funded you if job is available for x years or must pay back funding pro rated".

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by winrid on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:42PM (#48703854)
You mean what companies used to do before we decided to import cheap labor instead?
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by browsingonly on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:06PM (#48703039)
> open competitive programs based on project quality

This will never, ever happen. There will always be bonus points available, even if they're awarded to "conservative"-leaning feel-good attributes like veteran-owned sponsor businesses.

These investments are likely to always fail at their declared purpose. Better to put the money towards free childcare and maybe trying to convince parents to read to their kids.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by abirch on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:44PM (#48703548)
The government should limit innovation and direct resources to proven ROI spending such as free daycare, nutrition, and public infrastructure
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by neonstatic on Sunday June 28, 2026 @01:09AM (#48704555)
> There will always be bonus points available, even if they're awarded to "conservative"-leaning feel-good attributes like veteran-owned sponsor businesses.

Why are you singling out "conservative" causes?

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by ww520 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:01PM (#48703015)
It's straight corruption, no matter of big or small business. It should have been randomized blind selection of business who have existed for more than a year, and the granted money pays for new employees' taxes. Blind selection takes out the path to corruption (not who you know to get the fund). Randomized to be fair. Government is bad at picking winners or losers anyway. Business more than a year to screen out frauds. Granted money for new employees' taxes to encourage hiring new employees. Paying the taxes only so that the money can be spread out to more people.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by betaby on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:50PM (#48702942)
> selectively giving away free money to big business is straight corruption

Liberals in canada call that 'making housing affordable', https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/prime-minist...

It feels that in Canada business is impossible unless it's directly funded by the government.

Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by diogenescynic on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:58PM (#48703306)
They're always handed out as political favors or lotteries at best. How is a lottery sustainable or scalable? These solutions do not work. It's at best virtue signaling and at worst corruption (as OP says).
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by paulddraper on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:20PM (#48703746)
Or —- hear me out —- create laws and tax policies compatible with growth, and apply them equally to everyone.
Re:Michigan spent $1.8B and only created 602 jobs by neya on Sunday June 28, 2026 @12:25AM (#48704338)
> everyone involved should lose re election and get investigated by the financial crimes unit

The flawed assumption here is assuming elections are an exception to every other democratic process riddled with corruption and are operated fair and square, in general.