News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by gwd on Friday June 12, 2026 @08:50AM (#48503484)
"Don't expend more effort than they are" has actually long been a good principle to have internalized. Someone done only cursory research before asking a question on a mailing list? Give a cursory answer. Someone obviously spent hours trying to figure things out on their own? Give them a good chunk of your time. Someone on HN responding to you with single-sentence responses? Either don't respond, or respond in kind. Someone obviously engaging with your ideas and taking time to explain their position? Take time to engage with their ideas too.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by nucleardog on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:58AM (#48504153)
I've had this same policy since before AI. I kind of formalized it for myself (and this team) after enough instances of "I'm trying to do X. It's not working. Help." type messages.

You need to put as much effort into the question as you expect someone to put into the answer.

It's not "fairness" or "AI" or anything else, it's that doing this any other way fundamentally fucks up the team dynamics.

You have a problem. You want someone's help. If the cost to you is effectively nil (or negative, since you're asking someone to do your job for you), but the cost to the other person is non-zero, then incentives aren't lining up here. Pretty quickly that person is going to start carrying too much load and become a bottleneck.

It can also mask that the context of the work is too concentrated in one person, and does little to nothing to help build that elsewhere in the team.

The other end of this is exactly what you're saying--put as much effort into the answer as they put into the question. You're not doing anyone a service by taking their low effort input and giving them high effort output, least of all yourself. If someone asks "how do I X", that's low effort. If you happen to know the answer off the top of your head, spare a few sentences to explain or point them where in the code they need to be. If you don't know, don't go track it down for them.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by astqs on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:58AM (#48505775)
I’d add that it’s basic respect and decency for your fellow humans who are paying for the attention with their own life.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by nucleardog on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:42PM (#48512212)
Yeah, that's a reason to do it too! And one I'd hope would land with most people, but "respect and decency" aren't universal unfortunately.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by hluska on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:51AM (#48504945)
I don’t formalize anything that extreme for my teams because I can’t diagnose people, but I know that things like anxiety, imposter syndrome and a whole wack of things that aren’t related to work get involved. It’s acceptable to ask for help. I like to know what people have tried but sometimes they don’t know how to start. And that’s a great place to start.

I guess we all have different styles but some may be more inclusive than others.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by bisby on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:35AM (#48505500)
How the problem and request are presented matter. "I don't know where to start" is a different problem than "I've done nothing, just solve this for me." And how someone shows an effort was made will vary person to person, so I agree a strict formalized set of rules doesn't make sense. The concept boils down to "expect people to put forth some effort of their own"

"Teams" are also going to have different dynamics than "strangers on a help forum."

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by nucleardog on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:36PM (#48512140)
Yeah, after the dozenth time with the same person where the "help" is "playing 20 questions to finally get the stack trace out of them which they should have sent in the first place and then then error explains exactly what is wrong and what they need to look at next" you might feel a little different about it. Or not.

End of the day, though, there's a huge, obvious difference between "asking for help" and "asking for someone to do all my thinking for me".

As a _person_, I'm very sympathetic to why that might be happening. I will do everything I can to help. And sometimes it does feel like I'm bordering on practicing psychology without a license.

As someone responsible for making sure _everyone_ is getting paid this month so they can keep a roof over their head and their kids fed, I do need to be mindful of and address issues that are dragging the entire team down. Regardless of why it's happening, if we're in a situation where you are doing the more company more good by _not showing up to work_ (you're contributing negatively), we have a problem and it needs to be addressed. We can work together on addressing it, but we can't ignore it.

For whatever it's worth, every single person on the team I manage says one of the things they love most about working here is how helpful and cooperative everyone is. Everybody's always happy to hop on a call and work through stuff together and really has a mindset of a rising tide lifting all boats--people are always volunteering to pitch in and help others before being asked. I like to think I've had some part in creating that environment. I am _more_ than happy to _help_. I had to starting making a distinction between "helping" and "doing someone's work for them" because I was getting burned out from overwork. I made it "formal" because I work with the kind of people who really appreciate clear rules and guidelines for things, including communication

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by Sohcahtoa82 on Friday June 12, 2026 @12:21PM (#48506056)
> after enough instances of "I'm trying to do X. It's not working. Help." type messages.

Related to this, I will never for the life of me understand why people think it's okay to say "I get an error" without saying what the error is.

I don't expect a non-technical person to understand the error, but I do expect a non-technical person to know that what the error message is is useful to the person trying to help you and to proactively provide the contents of the error message, even if it's a shitty cell phone picture of the error.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by gwd on Friday June 12, 2026 @03:41PM (#48508592)
The thing is, they've still taken the time to actually write "I get an error". So by principle of reciprocity, you can just take 2 seconds to say, "What's the error?" Usually that won't lead anywhere; but as long as you don't spend more time than they are, you aren't really wasting much time; and they can't exactly complain that you weren't helpful. And occasionally it will lead somewhere, in which case it's a win.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by purpleflashing on Saturday June 13, 2026 @04:12AM (#48514776)
Because modern tech and modern tech support has a terrible UX in general built by engineers around their engineering heuristics.

By the time a non-tech user reaches the point of seeing an error they are cognitively overloaded and since the errors are pretty much incomprehensible to the users, the user doesn’t get the feeling of it being anything that’s tied to their actions. It’s just anxiety-inducing noise, it never registers as something that has a meaning, so even copying and pasting an error feels like a meaningless step that their overloaded and already anxious brains skip.

If errors are meant to be shared with tech support, the UX should reflect that (and some interfaces do that where you just have a button to send the crash report or smth). If errors are meant to give users agency to solve the problem on their own, the UX should reflect that too.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by Slow_Hand on Friday June 12, 2026 @05:15PM (#48509509)
I intuitively put this much effort into asking good questions when I need help, and what I often find is that by spending time to formulate a question that makes it easy for others to help me I end up discovering the answer for myself or identifying a much more salient problem that I should be asking instead.

In this way, putting more effort into the question ends up putting me closer to the answer without actually receiving help.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by msla on Friday June 12, 2026 @08:43PM (#48511040)
When I'm a newbie at things, I tend to have the opposite problem: I can overthink things to Hell and gone, but since I don't know what I'm doing, I focus on the wrong things and 80% of my effort is worthless. Like trying to make a multithreaded GUI in tkinter in Python: I tried to find a good way to do it, but the answer is a brief "Don't do that, use root.after() instead so your worker function can run in the main thread without blocking the event loop." I just had the wrong mental model and put forth effort an expert would have avoided entirely.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by Archer6621 on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:23AM (#48503802)
These kinds of principles are sensible at their core, and I am a big proponent of the mindset, but the main problem as a sibling comment pointed out in a way is that this assumes that everyone is striving for an honest and accurate correlation between display of effort and value, and that everyone is looking deep enough into and behind that display to recognize the true value behind it. But actual effort, let alone value, is not always clearly visible or honestly displayed, and the perception of it is also subject to your own biases.

You could say that people have the responsibility to demonstrate that they put in the effort and created value, but then you get the situation where people naturally optimize perception of effort or value over actual effort or value, because in the end that is what is rewarded. Then you can also say that people also have the responsibility to look a bit closer before estimating real value, but that takes more effort and people naturally strife towards efficiency. I would guess that the problem today is that the balance between these two is off, and we're doing too much of the former and too little of the latter.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by CWuestefeld on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:17AM (#48505253)
an honest and accurate correlation between display of effort and value

Hmmm. Your choice of words here has just sparked a realization for me.

Before you said this, I was completely on board with the original post. But in juxtaposing effort with value, it illustrates that we're basing the idea on the Labor Theory of Value. That idea seems intuitive, and Adam Smith wrote about it 250 years ago. But it turns out that LTV is very wrong. Economists showed that effort does NOT impart value.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by hliyan on Friday June 12, 2026 @12:21PM (#48506066)
Use value or exchange value?
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by Archer6621 on Saturday June 13, 2026 @10:16AM (#48517600)
They're the same no? If I see exchange value in something, that is its use value to me: to exchange it for other things that I deem valuable.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by CrazyStat on Friday June 12, 2026 @12:31PM (#48506190)
Labor theory of value is a Marxist idea, not an Adam Smith idea. Internet Marxists sometimes point to a passage in The Wealth of Nations to suggest that Smith also supported a labor theory of value, but this is—in the most generous interpretation—a misreading. Smith says that the value of a thing can be measured by how much labor it can be exchanged for: an exchange theory of value, not a labor theory of value (which says the value of a thing is based on how much labor it takes to create).
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by CWuestefeld on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:51PM (#48507999)
I mostly agree with your criticism of my post. I was being generous trying to avoid being inflammatory here, since I know there are readers that strongly support socialist ideas (in the strict sense, not just the "safety net" sense). It was certainly Marx that pushed it so hard.

But researching this a bit, I find that it still predates Marx. I find:

Sir William Petty, 1662: "If a man can bring to London an ounce of Silver out of the Earth in Peru, in the same time that he can produce a bushel of Corn, then one is the natural price of the other."

More important, it seems that David Ricardo (a big name in economic history), in 1817 latched onto what Smith had written and states it quite definitively.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by CrazyStat on Friday June 12, 2026 @04:03PM (#48508827)
Fair. The concept predates Marx, but in contemporary thought is most closely associated with Marxism.

The quote about silver from Peru is particularly striking to my ears. That’s a long and dangerous journey, and obviously (to my modern sensibilities) the person making it should be compensated appropriately for the far greater risk taken on.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by Archer6621 on Saturday June 13, 2026 @10:14AM (#48517574)
I was hesitant to elaborate there, because the relationship between effort and value is quite complex.

For instance, you can put a lot of effort into something, without creating any value for yourself or for others. But it is often true that things of utility need a sufficient amount of compounded effort behind them before they become valuable, otherwise they are common and easy to obtain. Value is necessarily relative.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by mindwok on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:03AM (#48504214)
I’d push back on this, I think people have a very intrinsic sense of what is valuable and often if you think it’s “perception” of value being rewarded, it’s just that you value something different than that person.

Even in performative scenarios, like say someone gets promoted at work over another person because they are a great “performer” and always make noise, whereas the other actually delivers - they’re being promoted because the promotion is defensible and legible for their superior. That is true value for them, just not to another viewer.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by suncemoje on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:53AM (#48504095)
I experienced a similar interaction recently, where this principle was hard to apply, when I was emailing with a CTO / hiring manager who had some "deeper" screening questions. It was essentially:

1. HM: AI generated email with "tailored" questions

2. Me: AI assisted response with answers (I confess)

3. HM: AI generated email with a "thoughtful" response + invite

4. Me: AI generated "thank you & looking forward" response ...

Looking back at the thread, I have to laugh and cry at the same time. It's so obvious and sad.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by paulddraper on Friday June 12, 2026 @05:26PM (#48509617)
Counterpoint: I know it when I see it.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by bluGill on Friday June 12, 2026 @08:55AM (#48503539)
> Someone on HN responding to you with single-sentence responses? Either don't respond, or respond in kind.

"I have made this longer than usual because I have not had time to make it shorter." - Blaise Pascal.

The length of the response doesn't indicate effort.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by keiferski on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:44AM (#48503979)
This is true if you're writing a letter about a difficult topic.

For HN comments, 99.9% of the time, a short comment is a low effort one and should be disregarded.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by mlhpdx on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:22AM (#48504557)
on the other hand, when I see a long post here I assume it’s yet another ego-driven tirade and skip past it.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by hliyan on Friday June 12, 2026 @12:27PM (#48506149)
> yet another ego-driven tirade

I tried to recall the last time I saw what I felt was an ego-driven tirade on HN comments, and I'm currently drawing a blank. There's a lot of what's called "performative erudition", and there is the occasional lengthy diatribe, but I would call neither one of those ego-driven tirades.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by warkdarrior on Friday June 12, 2026 @05:19PM (#48509551)
"performative" = "ego-driven"
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by dijksterhuis on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:33AM (#48504701)
long, low: copypasta; rant; sales; slop.

(brevity, purposeful /s).

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by hackable_sand on Saturday June 13, 2026 @01:50PM (#48519643)
A comment should fill exactly the amount of space that it fills, no?
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by Bootvis on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:38AM (#48504769)
For him, the cost of editing was much larger. Condensing your writing in his time meant rewriting it more concisely, requiring strictly more time than collecting his thoughts as he went.

With LLM's, we are in a new state of the world: it can expand any one sentence off hand remark in an essay.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by necovek on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:03AM (#48505091)
You seem to be talking about how one can expand information into useless babbling, whereas you are responding to a comment about condensing information into true essence.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by bluGill on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:45AM (#48505612)
This is about human attention and what is worth getting it. Both points are very important and valid.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by gwd on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:58AM (#48504145)
Sure; I was using shorthand. Sometimes a whole edifice of ideas rests on one shaky one; and if you can challenge that one the whole thing falls apart. But even being able to identify the shaky one demonstrates engagement. That's really the key.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by Telaneo on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:32AM (#48503869)
There are obvious exceptions to that rule. Laconic phrases are short but have a lot to them, while AI slop is long while having very little to it. But it's a decent rule of thumb when considering the middle of the bell curve.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by someguyiguess on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:29AM (#48503847)
Couldn't agree more.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by monkeydust on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:47AM (#48505633)
AI has collapsed the cost of producing content while leaving the cost of reviewing, verifying higher imho. This has inverted the economics of collaboration. Reviewer attention, not output volume, is now the scarce resource, this happened with my engineering teams (PR reviews) and is now happening in my world in Product.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by whstl on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:05PM (#48507401)
In some cases there's also no preparation or verification happening at all, which massively inflates the productivity gains of AI. Lots of VCs and investors asking companies to move into "trust the AI" mode.

I once consulted for a company in the content marketing business that was one of the largest and fastest growing startups of its country. The content production in itself was "cheap", a dollar for 500 words. But it collapsed, due to the unbearable amount of people required to review

Now virtually all content is generated by AI and the old customers don't have anyone to verify anymore.

Companies are made of people who are shitty to each other but trust machines blindly.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by andrekandre on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:58PM (#48512361)

  > Now virtually all content is generated by AI and the old customers don't have anyone to verify anymore.
i see this first-hand at $company, where the pr's are so obtuse and descriptions are incomprehensible or just too long and gratuitous that thorough code review is also falling by the wayside and becoming more of a "rubber stamp"; this is what management is calling "productivity boost"...
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by whstl on Sunday June 14, 2026 @06:09AM (#48525796)
Another productivity boost I'm seeing is from $COMPANY is asking devs to let AI do the design, instead of having a designer do it.

I have a dirty secret: I do the design myself.

Productivity gains are still there. People are amazed at the "AI".

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by justin66 on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:39AM (#48504781)
> Someone on HN responding to you with single-sentence responses? Either don't respond, or respond in kind.

Or, depending on the context, perhaps give a thorough enough answer with citations that it should either answer questions on the topic fully or explain where anyone interested in the topic can do their own research, such that if the question is asked again one could just link to your previous post.

This might not satiate a poster if they're dumb enough, but it's worth remembering that the post will be searchable and usable for reference by other people.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by CWuestefeld on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:39AM (#48503927)
This has been my policy for a couple of decades. When somebody posts just a bare link (especially if it's to a video), I refuse to click. If it's not worth your time to introduce why something is relevant, then it's not worth my time to go figure that out.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by dentemple on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:11AM (#48503698)
> Either don't respond, or respond in kind.

!

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by dredmorbius on Friday June 12, 2026 @01:30PM (#48506969)
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by toss1 on Friday June 12, 2026 @10:43AM (#48504833)
Yup. The most concise version I've heard of this, which I find useful for many situations, is:

"If it isn't important to you, it isn't important to me."

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by TallGuyShort on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:45AM (#48505607)
"Use your brain before you use mine"
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by jappgar on Friday June 12, 2026 @08:55AM (#48503535)
It takes considerable energy to train models and run inference. You can't dismiss AI generated content as "low effort", but you can dismiss it as a wasteful diversion.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by lewispollard on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:51AM (#48505682)
That's like saying that low effort human-generated posts are worth your time because the phones and computers they're writing on take a lot of time and effort to build from scratch.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by Telaneo on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:33AM (#48503884)
The person copy-pasting an AI response is generally not the person who trained said AI. Even if the total amount of effort is fairly large, the amount of effort put in by the person you're actually interacting with, is generally small.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by inigyou on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:55AM (#48504115)
Back when people would train Markov bots on IRC that was actually something novel for the first 30 minutes and you could appreciate it because they put in the work
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by doctorpangloss on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:42AM (#48505563)
@dang it's too bad the most interesting single comment in this whole thread is grayed out. as much as i love reading the same thing written 1,200 different ways, maybe the whole system needs to be revisited
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by kingkawn on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:23AM (#48503800)
You can’t take credit for other people’s work to displace the absence of your own
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by yCombLinks on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:04AM (#48503622)
Way to miss the point. Bob on the other side of the room didn't train the model
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by cestith on Friday June 12, 2026 @01:58PM (#48507328)
From the other side, there have been brief tutorials for many years about how to ask useful questions in a technical forum. Making hundreds of other people fish for details about your case is poor form.

https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/how-to-ask-good-technical-... is a pretty good example.

Going back more than two decades is ESR’s “How to Ask Smart Questions”. http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by reddit_clone on Friday June 12, 2026 @03:08PM (#48508200)
> Give a cursory answer

That may be enough in some cases.

Sometimes people are not looking for fully fleshed out high-effort answers. They want a pointer (to documentation, or a repo) to get going from someone more experienced.

Google search may throw up too much information and it is hard to make a choice. A one sentence answer from an expert may be enough to set them on the right path.

Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by eli_gottlieb on Friday June 12, 2026 @07:53PM (#48510766)
This is the policy I was always told to exercise about cold emails, both those I receive and those I send. Someone seems to have spent weeks reading your books and papers before emailing to meet with you? Make time for that guy. Someone just asks if you've got time to meet about your work because they'd like to work for you? LOL they didn't check enough to realize you're not a supervisor.
Re:If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human ... by cgio on Friday June 12, 2026 @09:12PM (#48511254)
Short responses are increasingly becoming a signal of genuine human attention.