News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by panarky on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @02:16PM (#48283588)
My doctor recommended a combination FIT+DNA test instead of colonoscopy (brand name "Cologuard"). She said it's not quite as good as the "gold standard" colonoscopy, but it also doesn't have the risks of colonoscopy.

And the FIT+DNA test is so cheap and easy, you can do it every year or three instead of every 10 years with the colonoscopy.

She still recommends colonoscopies for high-risk patients, but she thinks the risks outweigh the benefits for low-risk patients, so she recommends Cologuard in those situations.

I appreciate this risk-adjusted and probabilistic approach rather than one-size-fits all recommendations.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by antinomicus on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @02:39PM (#48283950)
Risks? The risks of a colonoscopy are crazy low though.
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by aprdm on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @03:54PM (#48285103)
They are until they aren't. My grandmother had a puncture and almost died
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @02:42PM (#48283989)
There is still the rush of perferating the colon, but I assume it doesn't happen very often. Cologuard has got to be cheaper though.
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by ramesh31 on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @03:09PM (#48284431)
>"Risks? The risks of a colonoscopy are crazy low though."

Not at the statistical level. Death rate from complications is about 1 in 10,000: https://www.endoscopy-campus.com/ec-news/risk-of-death-from-...

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by panarky on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @04:54PM (#48285825)
The risk of serious complications like major bleeding or perforation is closer to 40-80 per 10,000, significantly higher than the roughly 3-5 per 10,000 annual chance of actually having colorectal cancer for low-risk groups.

My doctor says that since Cologuard catches a large percentage of those 3-5 per 10,000 without any of the colonoscopy risk, the marginal benefits from colonoscopy really aren't justified since FIT+DNA testing is almost as good, at least for low-risk cohorts.

Very few things in medicine are zero risk. I wish more doctors would help balance the risk of doing A vs. the risk of doing B vs. the risk of doing nothing.

It's all Bayesian conditional probabilities, considering your own individual risk factors, and considering the false positive rate and false negative rate of each test.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by bonsai_spool on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @06:51PM (#48287098)
> The risk of serious complications like major bleeding or perforation is closer to 40-80 per 10,000

What's your reference for this? That's incredibly (read, unbelievable) high for a routine procedure.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by genewitch on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @07:02PM (#48287215)
not who you asked but the perforation is 3-5 per 10,000; cardiovascular issues is 52 per 10,000, polyp removal carries risks of bleeding or perforation, and underlying patient physiology.

RESULTS Among the 30,818 records identified, 82 population-based studies from 24 countries were included, involving a total of 38.5 million colonoscopies. The estimated incidence per 10,000 colonoscopies was as follows: gastrointestinal AEs, including perforation (5.15; 95% confidence interval [CI] 4.19-6.34, I2 = 99%), bleeding (18.39; 95% CI 13.53-24.99, I2 = 100%), and splenic injury (0.61; 95% CI 0.43-0.85, I2 = 93%); nongastrointestinal AEs, including cardiovascular events (52.11; 95% CI 18.67-144.59, I2 = 100%), respiratory events (4.26; 95% CI 0.73-24.99, I2 = 100%), and deaths related to colonoscopy (0.18; 95% CI 0.10-0.34, I2 = 74%). Subgroup analyses yielded partially divergent findings. The majority of the included studies exhibited a low to moderate risk of bias.

just ask any AI, i don't got time to play tic-tac-toe with the NIH.gov website gating me behind click bus images for 10 minutes

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by bonsai_spool on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @07:19PM (#48287355)
You are hardly describing "serious complications" ('bleeding', and 'respiratory events' are very non specific, and the fact that this is an uncited meta-analysis across nations makes the whole enterprise suspect), even less so since your source averages 24 countries while we are speaking about US colonoscopy recommendations.

My source is not seeing one perforation each week at work.

> just ask any AI

These do not give reliable answers, as I am sure you know

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by genewitch on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @10:46PM (#48288913)
they give citations which i was going through and literally copied and pasted the CITE to you, not the AI.

i only answered the specific question of where the number "48" or the range 40-80 came from.

my cite even shows perforations are 3-5 per 10000 so i don't know what you're on me about

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by bonsai_spool on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @10:40AM (#48295135)
> they give citations which i was going through

Yes, I am sure. Do send the actual citations.

> my cite even shows perforations are 3-5 per 10000

An implausible number for humans who have actual, non-LLM experience in this area

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by genewitch on Thursday May 28, 2026 @01:30PM (#48312444)
my EXPLICIT SOURCE was 10.14309/ajg.0000000000003429 do you require other ones, or do you wanna keep harping on the fact i used LLM as a fucking search engine?

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2779987 3.5 per 10,000

take it up with JAMA and the AJG.

do you do SCREENING or DIAGNOSTIC/POLYP REMOVAL?

because there's a difference. And it has nothing to do whether i use google.com or chat.whatever.com to find that out.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by bonsai_spool on Thursday May 28, 2026 @06:39PM (#48316544)
> do you wanna keep harping on the fact i used LLM as a fucking search engine?

You didn't give me a source before now, so I unfortunately had no other source to challenge except the LLM!

> https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2779987 3.5 per 10,000

Different source, friend. Please note that they say 3.1, not 3.5.

That is at about 25% less than 4 (and even less than 5, let alone your previous assertions). And if either you or your LLM troubled yourself to read the article, even this is a confounded number in that we cannot determine whether low-volume, 'community' operators are worse than high-volume settings.

> do you do SCREENING or DIAGNOSTIC/POLYP REMOVAL?

We are talking about screening—once you have a target to remove, you are looking at a high-likelihood-of-cancer population. I am fully aware of this, so I don't understand why you are bringing up this difference which has not yet figured into our discussion. Is this something your LLM suggested to you?

---

I think the thing to take away is that LLMs do not yet replace human understanding and discretion.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by genewitch on Saturday June 06, 2026 @06:43PM (#48429777)
we're both being jerks, so let's both stop. Me first. Sorry. the AJG paper shows 5.15 (the meta study) and JAMA shows 3.1

those two numbers fall within the range of "3 - 5 per 10,000"

the thing in the first sentence of my reply is called a DOI, it's a document identifier, that you can type into google or bing and it will pull up the correct journal citation i was citing.

I understand that the JAMA paper said 3.1, but it also said a number almost 5 times higher near there for "major complication", separate from perforation.

My original reply, where i did the > block quote, is from the AJG source; 10.14309/ajg.0000000000003429

And, for all we know someone is using a roto-rooter to perform colonoscopies and throwing the statistics off

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by BobbyTables2 on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @11:24PM (#48289189)
The real risk is getting a doctor that is more interested in money than medical care. These seem to be more like 3000-5000 per 10000.
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by bonsai_spool on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @07:50PM (#48287578)
>>"Risks? The risks of a colonoscopy are crazy low though."

> Not at the statistical level. Death rate from complications is about 1 in 10,000:

THAT IS NOT what this paper says. Please avoid commenting about things that you do not understand!

Here is the actual article: https://www.cghjournal.org/article/S1542-3565(20)31076-4/ful...

First, the study looks at people who had a positive screening Cologuard/FIT test. These are not normal people!

Second, the test looks at DEATHS WITHIN THIRTY DAYS of the procedure. In fact, the article goes on to say that there are ZERO deaths related to the actual procedure. ZERO.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by m3047 on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @08:08PM (#48287722)
This is funny. I've had an unbelievable string of bad doctors / clinics... almost as though something is wrong with medical care around here.

Couple of years ago the latest doctor who I fired started talking colonoscopies. I asked some basic questions like how do they get paid? How much do they get paid? Who inspects their facilities?

He took great umbrage at the notion that the doctors were getting "bounties" for nipping pieces of tissue for lab review, refused to discuss that. (Tell me you know something without telling me you know something.) He also took umbrage at the notion that his clinic wasn't "clean" and that it was inspected regularly... didn't say by whom.

So here's the deal. Here in Washington State, USA his clinic gets a "wet work" inspection, just like a slaughterhouse or restaurant, as part of the occupancy / doing business license. But there is no ongoing inspection, and fuck no there is no "safe to eat here" poster in the window of his clinic.

It gets more interesting when you start looking at the datasets an inquiry like that turns up. Like: how many deaths / hospitalizations are there per 1K procedures? Actuarily we have a number. Now clinics, at least the ones doing things on a regular basis, have to report adverse events leading to hospitalization: the reporting rate is impossibly lower than the actuarial rate, complications leading to hospitalization are not being reported. But.. there's more! The State collects "foreign contamination" stats from pathologists; you can look at this by pathologist, if they do enough of them. The majority of pathologists scoring colonoscopy samples report ZERO foreign contamination; among the pathologists actually reporting, the rate for presence of foreign contamination is around 25%.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by kelvinjps10 on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @08:32PM (#48287923)
What is your point?
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by boppo1 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @12:01AM (#48289463)
What an interesting and obvious approach, wish I'd thought of it. Tell me more about your inquiry for the answers the doctor avoided.
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by m3047 on Thursday May 28, 2026 @01:46PM (#48312666)
I tend to let Feynman, Fermi, and Bayes guide my inquiries generally in that order. Part of the process is generating good questions; another part of the process is generating good actionable questions (tailored to the moment). Questions which are obvious, which are "horseshoes and hand grenades" type questions, based on what we know now. Follow things a little bit, test it, see where it's soft.

In this case I called public health and building inspection agencies and asked them what sort of ongoing inspections there were for clinics and other medical facilities. That turned up databases online, and keywords which turned up other databases.

What was the germ (pun intended) of this inquiry? Several years earlier, sitting in the waiting room of a different clinic, and the linen supply company pushes a cart through (gets buzzed through to the back) to collect the dirty linen, wearing gloves. Like they did this every day. Many years ago, the memo taped to the doors to a lab wing at a biotech: "gloves must be removed when greeting visitors". Various reports over the years concerning improperly sterilized dental instruments.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by NotGMan on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @03:42PM (#48284952)
2 to 3 colonoscopies per ~1k to 2k people cause severe rupture of the intestines that require urgent surgery.
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by goosejuice on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @04:48PM (#48285757)
The risk is the primary reason the age for first colonoscopy is so high. Even with cologuard it's not typical before 40 unless you have family history.

There's also risks of false positives/negatives for some tests which complicate matters as well.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by bonsai_spool on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @06:50PM (#48287084)
> The risk is the primary reason the age for first colonoscopy is so high

What? I have a hard time understanding this, what is your primary reference.

Colonoscopies take a lot of resources and GI docs are in high demand—these seem much more plausible limiting factors than undefined 'risks' inherent to the procedure.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by goosejuice on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @08:43PM (#48288003)
Those are also factors for sure, but the the risks from complications aren't undefined. Even cheap and non invasive screening carry risk due to false positives inviting unnecessary downstream procedures.

Not an MD but have worked in cancer prevention for a while in a software capacity.

See figure 5 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34003219/

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by bonsai_spool on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @09:01PM (#48288123)
> https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8409520/figure/F5/

You can link to the figures directly for PMC articles.

My point is that the risks aren't the limit for how we think about testing (though they exist), but instead the low marginal improvement in diagnostic yield and life expectancy.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by Double_a_92 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @02:43AM (#48290558)
I remember reading somewhere that the highest risk is you falling off the table while you are sedated.
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by jghn on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @04:58PM (#48285873)
The main issue with those tests is they have a relatively high false positive rate. If you pop on that one you need to follow up with a colonoscopy to confirm.

The big issue has been that in the US, the followup colonoscopy was often no longer covered by insurance as it was no longer classified as part of the preventative medicine tier, and instead was now a different sort of procedure. My understanding is that this is no longer true though.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by genewitch on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @06:56PM (#48287145)
my PCP thinks i am over 50 twice a year and mentions i should get one, and he knows i won't pay for anything, so that means my insurance covers it.

This is anecdote by induction.

Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by xocnad on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @10:13PM (#48288636)
Got burned by exactly this when on a high deductible HSA plan.
Re:Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"? by deaton on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @05:01PM (#48285906)
Kinda annoying that the minimum age is 45 and its explicitly not for high risk individuals though. Like you would think having a non-invasive test would be incredibly important for that.