Describe making business in Europe with one evergreen sentence
Though, if the Americans in question just want to do their grifting in EU, it makes sense why they are upset at that, I guess, because it limits their grifting opportunities.
This is hilarious. This reminds me of Soviet propaganda. "No, there was no Chernobyl disaster. Please disregard the corpses. Yes, the centrally-planned economy is doing fantastically, better than expected. Reports of famines and shortages are imperialist propaganda."
(Mind you, the Soviets are not alone here, but the blatant chutzpah of Soviet propaganda is perhaps more conspicuous to the Western eye than the Western varieties of PR and psychological manipulation.)
Haha, yeah sure. What other fairy tales you gonna tells us next?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siemens#2005_and_continuing:_w...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirecard_scandal
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parmalat_bankruptcy_timeline
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus#Bribery_allegations
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CumEx-Files
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lafarge_scandal
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pfizergate
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ING_Group#Money_laundering_cas...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolls-Royce_Holdings#Corruptio...
How many people were punished for Enron? For the subprime crisis? Etc.
In the US, you just give a little money for the president's ballroom and you are pardoned. Or you settle out of court because your justice system is crap.
Interestingly the chief accountant of Enron ended up getting a job in Europe after he got out of prison.
But, but ..Europeans here said they don't tolerate crooks.
So yes, such companies exist and plenty of people see their existence as a good thing rather then something to mock.
I expect to see further selling out of these laws, as the economic prosperity declines. I can perfectly see german law limiting german companies from developing and selling AI products, while at the same time allowing us companies for a "pay our retires and pension-plans" kickback.
Joke's on you, I'm European not American, so "your president" in this case would be the unelected Ursula and she would technically be a con-woman, not a con-man.
Not sure what your argument was supposed to prove with this cheap jab though.
If you argue she wasn't elected by the European population, well, Trump technically isn't too.
Plenty of corporations are willing to break the rules, but never for free.
This is a weird hill to die on because it's not true. I can't find anything to support your world view and if anything evidence points to the contrary. Europe has a deliberately more complex legal framework, usually in the hopes of keeping out foreign competition (although it's dubious whether or not that actually works).
Just look at US laws pertaining to data that goes through US companies.
They still use US clouds that can have information pulled by the US government.
> So Mistral is developing its own data centers, starting with one outside Paris. Mensch projects it will have 200 megawatts of capacity by the end of 2027. Power from France’s state-owned nuclear plants will help, but the buildout could still cost an estimated $5 billion. Mensch tapped oil-rich Abu Dhabi and reportedly sought debt financing to help pay for it.
Though to your point it won't be running until 2027.
Well, ASML's EUV light sources are based on licensed US IP from Sandia Labs, and manufactured in the US by CYMER, which ASML bought, but they still operate and manufacture out of California, so the EU is not sovereign/independent here (neither is any country).
This doesn't mean much anyway, since despite ASML being European, their machines all go to export and EU doesn't put any of those machine to good use domestically, with the most cutting edge semiconductor fabs on EU soil being the Germany based TSMC fabs on the much older 16 and 12nm nodes, far bigger than the 3nm that Taiwan and US operate domestically.
1. the 2018 CLOUD Act mandates US companies — and their subsidiaries — to provide information to the US government on demand, regardless of where the data is stored
2. FISA secret courts prevent companies from even saying they where summoned, or telling anyone who or what the case was about (including canaries).
So you won't ever know if your data was handed over to the US government.
But assuming the owner is US company abiding US laws it's safe to assume that data would be transferred to US one way or the another.
Also consider that all communication between the European subsidiaries to the HQ is fair game under FISA.
The purpose of the CLOUD Act was to get at data that was stored outside the US but that was "in the custody, control, or possession of communications-service providers that are subject to the jurisdiction of the United States".
It arose from a situation where an email provider in the US used cloud storage services in several countries to store emails. They were asked for the email of a particular customer and said they did not have to provide it because they had happened to store that customer's mail at a non-US cloud provider.
What the CLOUD Act requires is that:
> A provider of electronic communication service or remote computing service shall comply with the obligations of this chapter to preserve, backup, or disclose the contents of a wire or electronic communication and any record or other information pertaining to a customer or subscriber within such provider's possession, custody, or control, regardless of whether such communication, record, or other information is located within or outside of the United States.
A company incorporated in the EU, even if it is owned by an entity in the US, is not subject to US jurisdiction and so that does not apply. The US owner is subject to US jurisdiction but the data of EU customers of the EU company is not in the US owner's possession, custody, or control.
No? Certainly sounds like it is in the US owner's control to me.
But even disregarding that fact. Given that the US government also started hiding what it was doing with FISA courts and forbidding that anyone, including the companies themselves, checks what actually happens ... do you think anyone will believe this? We HAD evidence of US companies refusing to hand over data before CLOUD and FISA, we do not see that anymore. (And that's before we start taking into account more some recent administration's respect for ...)
Of course this is also pretty hypocritical since EU countries have been caught more than once capturing communications of non-citizens. The problem that usually gets mentioned: the Boeing - Airbus fight wasn't a one sided US being untrustworthy to help Boeing.
Incorrect, this is EXACTLY the scenario that the Cloud Act was introduced to to handle.
What happened is in 2013 Microsoft Ireland refused an FBI warrant for information held on EU servers, under the control of MS Ireland.
Microsoft USA refused the warrant on the grounds on the jurisdiction grounds you mentioned above.
So the Cloud Act was passed: US law for access to digital information applies to any subsidiary anywhere on earth.
Sorry.
There's probably a very good business to be made of bringing close to frontier knowledge and finetuning recipes and infrastructure to enterprises that cannot hire that talent. But that's largely not a business that is going to be of a lot of interest to technologists as consumers.
EU based legal entities and strong compliance with local laws with some hard SLAs and contractual guarantees is not going to be optional for liability reasons. Provenance of models, their training data, and exact ways they have been instructed to act are also not just nice to haves.
I expect non EU jurisdictions are eventually going to be similarly picky about their AI suppliers and I expect all the big tech providers to adapt to local markets just like they did with cloud infrastructure.
I don't have much experience with Mistral yet. But I may need to get my hands dirty to be able to sell this to some of our customers. We have a few more picky customers in Germany.