News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by jona-f on Monday April 27, 2026 @07:34AM (#47920238)
Apart from this app, I'm confused how proudly this guy presents his sleazy domain-squatting shenanigans. It seems to me, setting this friendster site apart, these people are the parasites of the internet. This whole domain name business is a corrupt stinking pile of crap. Why are we tolerating this? For this friendster app, I think we can be certain, if it has any success, it will become the same crap we already have, given where this dude stands.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by codingdave on Monday April 27, 2026 @07:42AM (#47920308)
Considering how little is actually interesting about the app aside from it using an old domain, my impression is that the entire post is just pseudo-marketing, attempting to encourage people to get back into domain name squatting.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by camillomiller on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:36AM (#47920796)
Well this vibecoded chatgpt crap is quite clearly an attempt at making Friendster more valuable than 30k
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by ca98am79 on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:15AM (#47920588)
Curious what you’d consider a better model for naming/ownership on the internet.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by phrotoma on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:22AM (#47920653)
IIUC it's not the model of buying domains from registrars which stinks of crap, it's the buying from registrars by domain squatters who then flip them for a profit having provided zero value that bears a whiff of shite. These ticket scalpers of the internet who contribute nothing can well and truly fuck straight off.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by mothballed on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:21AM (#47922036)
Speculators provide time-allocation of resources. They're pretty critical part of market dynamics to help resources get sold and developed when they are valued most. That is, they prevent domains from being captured prematurely for lower value use. Society profits immensely from their contribution.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by phrotoma on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:49AM (#47922365)
Hey I get it, we all gotta sleep at night. Tell yourself whatever you like to get them zzz's. As far as ticket scalpers and domain resellers go, my assessment stands: they are bottom feeding zeros providing nothing of value and they can fuck off into the sun.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by zurfer on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:15AM (#47922743)
Down voted because the comment is not providing any new insights and is just insulting.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by phrotoma on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:05PM (#47924280)
Upvoted because you're correct.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by jyscao on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:12PM (#47924364)
Despite being full of arrogant intellectual superiority, evidently the majority of the HN crowd has little understanding of basic economics.

While I personally wouldn't go as far as "Society profits immensely from their contribution", these types business people do serve an important function in the economy.

Much like traditional middle-men sellers, commodity speculators, insurance providers, and the like, domain name re-sellers take on the risk that no one else are willing to bear at some particular time (that the domain they're "squatting" could be worth nothing in X years). If and when the domains they're "squatting" later on become more valuable, either through their own direct efforts, or by re-selling them to other parties that can make better use of them, then the profits they make from such transactions are justified for the aforementioned risks they bore.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by jgeada on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:40PM (#47924743)
What risk? They contributed nothing, they have performed no function. Their only claim on it is having been first on the dictionary attack and laid claim to a bunch of useful letter combinations without providing any value or service.

If they didn't do any of this that combination of letters doesn't disappear, it just goes back to being available from the primary registrars.

The squatters are just vacuuming up some of the profit off people that would/could use that combination of letters to actually provide a service.

I don't view middle man parasitic behavior as valuable, and see no market value performed here other than extraction.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by jyscao on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:50PM (#47924876)
>I don't view middle man parasitic behavior as valuable, and see no market value performed here other than extraction.

Seeing middlemen businesses as "parasitic behavior" is a common misunderstanding of their role in the economy. They make possible commercial transactions between initial producers and ultimate end-consumers, where and/or when such transactions could never have taken place affordably without their presence.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by jgeada on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:01PM (#47925777)
Except in this case the middleman added thousands of dollars to the cost without adding anything of value: not curation, not discovery, nothing. Without this middleman acquiring an expired domain would have been whatever the nominal registrar cost (somewhere between $10 to $100 or so per year for a domain)

Useful middlemen do serve a role and add value. A parasitic middleman just extracts value without adding any value anything in return.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by jyscao on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:40AM (#47936052)
>Without this middleman acquiring an expired domain would have been whatever the nominal registrar cost (somewhere between $10 to $100 or so per year for a domain)

Except you have no idea if $10-100 charged by registrars should be the actual price of those domains. The only two factors that should determine the price of something is the lowest price the seller is willing to sell it at, and the highest price any single customer is willing to pay. That's it.

If some government policy existed that enforced domain names must be priced below $x, then that functions as an artificial price ceiling, which necessarily results in a misallocation of the resource in question. In this case, that would mean, domains going to people who are less incentivized to put them to the best possible use.

Take the very example of friendster.com: when Mike Carson bought the domain from his park.io customer, friendster.com went from a website that only generated ad revenue to now a new social networking app idea he's developing, which I'm sure even you'd agree is an improvement to its previous use. And that was only possible, because Carson believed the 30k he was being asked to pay in order to acquire ownership of friendster.com was worth it (to him).

If all domain prices were artificially capped to $100 (or whatever other arbitrary threshold) and below, then in all likelihood, you'd see the problem of malicious actors who bulk buy then squat domains become worse, not better. You might counter, why would they do that? Since on the surface, it'd appear that they cannot profit from those domains by re-selling them at a higher price later on. Sure, perhaps not directly (but even this is debatable, because what'll likely happen is you'll just create a black market for it); but maybe they'll just tell the people who want to take the domain off of him that whatever app idea they're building, he wants a x% stake in?

In economics, your intentions don't matter, it's all about the incentives your proposed policies create. And to that end, price caps never work, because they just shift the collateral damage elsewhere, while making the economy worse in net.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by jyscao on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:45AM (#47936094)
>Useful middlemen do serve a role and add value. A parasitic middleman just extracts value without adding any value anything in return.

And do tell how you distinguish "useful middlemen" from "parasitic middlemen". These are meaningless terms based on your own value judgements. In other words, they're completely useless in practice.

A universally recognized transaction-coordinating mechanism works much better. And guess what? We already have that: price.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by jona-f on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:48AM (#47920907)
The tragedy of the commons is real. I have no good idea how to solve it, but I know that you are the problem. Your domain squatting ad bullshit adds zero value to society, but it does a lot of harm. It is increasingly hard to find good information between all the spam and the energy cost is immense. Your greed to the detriment of everybody else.

Public ridicule, denunciation and mobbing works somewhat, better in countries with more societal coherence then the US, not that I'm a big fan of that, quite the opposite. In your case though, I think you shouldn't get any positive attention for anything you say besides "sorry what I did, let me help undo the harm".

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by johnfn on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:47AM (#47922327)
We must have read a different article because I read a neat one about how someone bought a domain no one was using.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by fsckboy on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:22AM (#47922850)
an article about a new app is an article about a new app, even if self promotional.

an article that spends most of its time talking about the sunshine and roses of purchasing domains from a domain squatter, even if you are a domain squatter, is an article about domain squatting.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by skeeter2020 on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:59PM (#47924202)
it WAS being used for what I hope we can all agree is a very low value use that generated significant revenues by essentially tricking people to visit. That's the morality question here. Maybe it speaks to the bigger, general question of "do the ends justify the means?"
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by _vertigo on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:46AM (#47922321)
It’s just an externality of online advertising
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by dang on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:25PM (#47926123)
You broke the site guidelines badly in this thread by posting much too aggressively and crossing into personal attack. We ban accounts that do this, so please don't do it on HN.

If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by jona-f on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @03:06AM (#47931271)
I don't see where exactly I broke the site guidelines. Was I too negative? That is a ridiculous guideline. So I'm supposed to talk positive about antisocial behavior or be quiet about it? What kind of a platform is that?

Also, I'm not sure about the personal attack and aggression. I only described search engine optimized ad spam pages with strong words. It was OP's decision to build this crap. Nobody, not even he himself argued against that these spam-pages have any value besides making him money.

I'm genuinely surprised that OP seems to not realize his past success story might be nothing to be proud of. I am also genuinely surprised that we, as a society tolerate this kind of behavior, and I actually wanted to have a discussion about this. The second post, I answered his question how I think we should deal with that and unfortunately mobbing is the only way I can think of. Again, I was open for discussion and put in alot of "I'm not sure, this is how it looks from my view" words. In the third post I tried to clarify that it's the seo ad - fueled, and that I consider that similar to littering with profit, which I guess is illegal in most countries.

A day later it still looks to me like I made a few very reasonable arguments. But sadly very little debate has been going on besides the typical low effort partisan comments. On that note, I'd like to point out that the karma system very much encourages these partisan comments, cause unfortunately solid argument are usually received much worse than snarky remarks.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by dang on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:43PM (#47943956)
"I know that you are the problem" is obviously a personal attack. Ditto "Your [...] bullshit adds zero value to society". Ditto "Your greed to the detriment of everybody else". We ban accounts that post like this, so please don't do it again.

If you'd like a heuristic to assess whether you're doing that or not, I'd say it's the combination of denunciatory language with second-person voicing (i.e. explicitly or implicitly addressing "you").

None of that has to do with making an argument - it's just directing aggression toward the other person. If you'd like to make your argument in a principled, neutral way, that of course is fine.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by oefrha on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:20AM (#47921219)
You don’t need to propose a better model of the world to despise the dirtbags profiting from legal but icky shit in this world.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by wussboy on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:06AM (#47921785)
I don't need to be able to cure cancer to tell you that cancer is terrible.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by Barbing on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:37AM (#47922227)
Wait people are upset, do the Friendster founders want their URL back?!

Maybe I glossed over something

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by skeeter2020 on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:57PM (#47924178)
I think it was more about how the OP talks about the backstory, and likely how they got the resources to do this.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by Barbing on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:16AM (#47934974)
Thank you, I just asked another commenter for some more details. I don’t want to be someone who misses big points like that.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by estearum on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:05PM (#47923384)
There should be a land value tax on domain names
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by skeeter2020 on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:02PM (#47924239)
there sort of is; you don't own a domain but lease it. The problem is all domains for a given TLD cost the same. What about the registration fee being a % of the value, where value is set to the current cost, but then assessed on the sales price? Or do we just end up with the scenario we're currently escaping with TM resale tickets?
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by brynnbee on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:52PM (#47924095)
ICANN's main process for handling trademark-based complaints is the UDRP (Uniform Domain-Name Dispute Resolution Policy). This policy is used for instances where someone claims you registered a domain in bad faith that matches their trademark, and they have a panel that looks at whether you have "rights or legitimate interests" in the name. Bad faith evaluations by this policy often involves intent to sell the domain to the trademark owner, disrupt their business, or attract users by confusion.

So the spirit of ICANN's philosophy around this is clear: we don't want people buying domains with the intent of withholding them and later profiting by selling them to trademark holders. I would argue that preemptively buying domains with the speculation that people will eventually want them and pay for them is basically a violation against the spirit of their policy, you're just operating in bad faith preemptively against any possible future owner rather than a current specific one.

Disputes around this are notoriously unsuccessful. I say all this context to get to the point that I think the current system would work fine if there were policies that included this style of preemptive squatting, and more of an ability to successfully dispute bad faith actors. Including by looking at: how many other domains does this person own and not meaningfully use, how much is the site a legitimate use versus asking ChatGPT to write 50 articles, and whether the effort or investment put into the site is proportional to a ballpark of the value of a domain name. With exceptions, perhaps, for situations like domains that are also your name.

I'm even fine with the idea that domains go to the highest bidder on fixed terms, like 5-10 years. Or that it will at least require good-faith evaluation after a fixed term. But it's a problem when that money goes to squatters instead of towards something useful, like funding infrastructure. Maybe we can have a non-profit version of Cloudflare.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by skeeter2020 on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:56PM (#47924162)
I don't necessarily support any of these, but it's essentially a solved problem when discussing the supply side - especially for artificial scarcity:

* lots of jurisdictions have occupancy taxes on vacant real estate

* taxation rules differ depending on the source of income, ex: employment vs. investment

* going concerns are legally treated different than inactive entities

* qualitative usage can define treatment

* lots of internet-focused legislation provides for challenging "what" is being served

You would think this is all in Google's best interest, as the SEO of these low-value domains is a major threat when LLMs are very effective in displacing google searches.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by arthurgibson on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:58AM (#47920998)
A little over reaction here, they were very open about the process. Lets not take down the horse before the carriage. The article mentions they started "park.io" which was backordering domains, so at minimum expertise and some relevancy exists (was acquired).

Lets look at Friendster from a less foggier lense, its an attempt in the right direction. Use it or don't use it.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by hacker161 on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:31AM (#47921336)
Their reaction is perfectly proportional
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by i386 on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:17AM (#47921191)
I kinda fucking love it. He’s doing something. It’s interesting. There’s no scam. Let live!
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by chneu on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:47AM (#47922331)
This is such a wild over reaction.

There is nothing inherently wrong with domain squatting. Lol. Blame the system, not the people operating within it.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by timedude on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:50AM (#47922378)
The people operating in it are the system.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by skeeter2020 on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:05PM (#47924281)
This is such a dumb response. The people playing the squat & resale game are the ones that built and maintain the system. This is like saying spam & phishing is the fault of the people who built email, not the jerks who exploit it. It's wrong because it extracts money from the commons without adding any value; i.e. this is why we can't have nice things.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by kube-system on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:12AM (#47922707)
Domain squatting is when you buy a domain purely for speculation with no intent of using it.

This person has built something using the domain. They are not squatting it.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by pavon on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:56AM (#47923271)
Agreed. The main problem with domain squatting and sniping is scammers either trying to impersonate another organization, or extort trademark owners into paying insane amount of money to obtain a domain which has no legitimate use to the current holder. Neither are happening here. Friendster intentionally let the domain and trademark go, and there isn't any entity that holds a legitimate claim to that name anymore.

I don't think that old business names should be "retired" and forever banned from use. After a certain amount of time the name should be free for someone to use again, and 10 years of non-use seems reasonable to me. The main concern with reuse is confusing consumers into thinking they are dealing with the old friendster, but I think consumers are savvy enough to realize that an old trademark rising from the dead often has nothing to do with the original, regardless of whether the current trademark holders purchased rights from the original, or claimed abandoned ones, as in this case.

His other business dealings aside, I don't have a problem with how he obtained/revived the friendster domain and trademark.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by rafram on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:13AM (#47922730)
He founded a domain brokerage for squatters and seems to be squatting on other domains for ad revenue (read the section about the trade he made).
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by aswegs8 on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:14AM (#47922740)
Doesn't strike me as particularly immoral.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by cbsks on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:16PM (#47923553)
The one takeaway I got from my engineering ethics class in college was that everyone has different morals. Debating if something is “moral” or not is useless. Education on a subject is useful, but once someone understands your point of view and still thinks it’s within/outside their morals, there’s nothing more to discuss.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by estearum on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:04PM (#47923377)
yeah just like laying claim to the most fertile land in your region, doing nothing with it, and waiting until your neighbors are sufficiently desperate to sell it to them for gigantic markup

hugely value-added activity, and a well-earned increment.

Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by rafram on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:19AM (#47922807)
I don’t know about immoral, but it is at the very least a bit sleazy. When I look for domains for side projects, I very rarely have to abandon a name because it’s been taken by an actual operational service; it’s almost always because someone is squatting it with a “parking” page filled with sketchy ads that they’re paying almost nothing for. That isn’t doing any good for anyone besides the squatter.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by Dave0X on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:57PM (#47924173)
Why does a practice have to do good for anyone other than the practioner?
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by rafram on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:12PM (#47924367)
Well, if we're discussing morality, it is generally considered immoral to enrich yourself at the expense of the public good.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by sillysaurusx on Monday April 27, 2026 @02:42PM (#47925530)
But it’s not a public good. .com stands for commercial. It’s literally the opposite of a public good.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by rafram on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:23PM (#47926097)
Allowing people to pay a fair price for the resources they need to start a business (rather than paying scalper prices to the bridge trolls who got there first) serves the public good. “For the public good” includes more than just feeding blind orphans.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by cornhole on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:14PM (#47924390)
“chattel slavery isn’t bad so long as I am the slave owner”
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by acessoproibido on Monday April 27, 2026 @02:00PM (#47925006)
A bit strong to compare domain squatting with slavery don't you think?
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by PowerElectronix on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:52AM (#47923216)
Zero added value while getting a money inflow ticks my box for immoral.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by bartread on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:37PM (#47924701)
Don’t forget parasitic.

A lot of the value of these domains stems from the popularity of sites they may have been attached to in the past, or search terms that relate to them.

So these people are literally making money off of the back of others’ work whilst providing no benefit themselves, probably not that much even to their advertisers.

Such squatting sites are, at best, an annoyance to web users as well.

[dead]
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by Dave0X on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:01PM (#47924231)
Many things should be illegal in a capitalist society. Domain investing is low in the list.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by Dave0X on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:56PM (#47924165)
Domain registration for the purpose of resale is legit. Plenty of available names and extensions to choose from.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by era-epoch on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:01PM (#47925784)
A thing can be both technically legitimate and also annoying and shitty.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by Dave0X on Monday April 27, 2026 @12:55PM (#47924149)
This comment sounds like entitlement and anti-capitalist.
Re:I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it by andy_ppp on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @05:57AM (#47932378)
This is a terrible take, he actually helped me get a domain back that I'd accidentally let expire. He's a genuine person just making a business with domains, everything everyone does has some kind of compromise to it if you look closely enough.