News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by GolfPopper on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:06PM (#47650804)
Speaking for myself (who has been fascinated with the space program since I was a small child), any joy I might feel around Artemis II feels tainted, by the immense amount of pork involved (SLS is called "Senate Launch System" for good reason) to the point where Artemis is more corporate welfare that happens to involve the Moon than a real space program, and by my belief that it is intended to be little more than a quick, dirty, and vainglorious Apollo repeat by a failing government.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by al_borland on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:22PM (#47650965)
I ran across this video[0] yesterday with Neil deGrasse Tyson talking about how it’s always been political. The first moon landing was more about global politics than science. As a child you likely weren’t concerned about that side of it, or were shielded from it.

It isn’t always the purist motivations that push the human race forward, but forward it moves us.

[0] https://youtu.be/j_AlXChA9F4

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by ryandrake on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:50PM (#47651267)
I don't think OP's problem with it is that it's "political" but that it's a product of pork and corporate welfare. The political thrust of the Apollo program was more "beat the Russians" and less "funnel money into dozens of already-rich corporations in favored districts." Even thought there was a lot of that, too. Modern space (and defense) projects seem to be almost 100% "pork funnel" and zero anything else.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by bps4484 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:00PM (#47652711)
It's not "almost 100% pork funneling" and I know this because....they're there! they are at the moon! I don't like pork either, but let's not blow this out of proportion.

How much do we think that it should have cost, if everything was perfectly optimized, to get to the moon? 50b instead of 100b? so ok, 50% was pork, and that's bad, but let's not overstate it and instead allow a little joy in our lives.

also the original apollo program was about 300b in today's dollars, so seems like things have always been a little porky.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by actionfromafar on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:04PM (#47652755)
Only 300b for the Apollo program? That sounds downright lean.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by richwater on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:34PM (#47653012)
Not when you consider how we got lucky on some aspects
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by bombcar on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:00PM (#47651371)
The pork funnel is going to exist unless something major changes; so I'd rather get moonshots out of the pork.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by dingaling on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:38PM (#47651840)
But how many Moonshots could we have got out of $100 billion of vegetarian non-pork?

Everything about SLS, and most of Artemis, has been dictated by Congress, often overriding expert advice.

Why not just give NASA the money and let them get on with it?

The same happens with the US military, Congress constantly deleting funding for programs they don't like to fund ones they do.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by trothamel on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:02PM (#47652110)
We're about to find out.

The new NASA administrator, Isaacman, seems to have done a very good job of convincing the various Senators to, if not get rid of the pork, allow him to allocate it in a way that benefits the lunar program.

The result was the Ignition event, which looks like it's planning to send up 17 small and 4 crew-capable landers by 2028, along with a fleet of orbital assets.

You can find out more https://www.nasa.gov/ignition/ , especially the "Building the Moon Base" section. The cost is $10B spread out over 3 years.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by Aloha on Monday April 06, 2026 @12:28AM (#47657000)
Also, if you dont think Apollo had pork in it, you're not aware enough of the history, the various assembly plants were placed mostly for political support, the shuttle and now SLS follows the same pattern.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by SmirkingRevenge on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:08AM (#47659847)
Possibly none, until we can figure out how to engineer political institutions that function without pork.

We tend to look at pork as unambiguously bad because it's wasteful or often has more than a whiff of corruption, but the picture for political scientists is more mixed.

Turns out it's easier to bargain with legislators when policy can give them a win in their districts or states. It greases the wheels for negotiation or provides levers to flip opposition party members. Legislatures often become more sclerotic and dysfunctional after reforms to pork barrel spending.

I don't want to call pork good, but there are real trade-offs to pork-free government that we haven't figured out how to solve any other way

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by bombcar on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:02AM (#47660368)
The reality is that "anything" can be pork - if you have large amounts of money sloshing around, someone benefits from getting it, and you can use that benefit for negotiations.

The first question for me is always is this a thing worth doing - which has an aspect of price involved, but isn't the definitive answer.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by bobmcnamara on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:19PM (#47652285)
we've also got 50 years of baseline tech improvement to try out.

In the 60s we weren't going to land in the darkness because we couldn't see to land.

But the shadows are probably where the water might be, and that's where we're going next!

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by overfeed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:00PM (#47652706)
> The political thrust of the Apollo program was more "beat the Russians" and less "funnel money into dozens of already-rich corporations in favored districts."

Artemis feels a bit more "Beat the Chinese, and show the world we still got it." I think cost-effectiveness[1] is a fig-leaf for what are SpaceX fanboys: had the same mission been on a Starship, HN would be awash with how other companies (Blue Origin) were late to earth-orbit, and the gap had widened beyond Earth's orbit.

1. In contrast, I haven't seen any complaints about Military-Industrial pork on any of the Iran threads, even when contrasting the cost of interceptors vs drones. Let slone have pork dominate the thread.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by KellyCriterion on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:33PM (#47651780)
> more about global politics than science

I had a great Prof during my bachelor from Russia - this is what he always told -> and it makes sense: Back then was cold war

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by nemo44x on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:49PM (#47653725)
It’s a weak take and here’s why. Huge tasks like going to the moon are made up of many different individuals that have different goals. Some are rocket scientists that want to innovate on the science of rocketry. Others are government admins with political goals.

So to call the entire thing “political” ignores the purpose of those involved and critical to the outcome at the expense of just labeling it all “political”.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by skeeter2020 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:03PM (#47654378)
this is why I mark the divide between the manned and unmanned space program. Historically the unmanned accomplishments have been less political (at least IMO) and made far larger advances. I don't need a human to take a photo of the dark side of the moon and then email it to me if a satellite can do it (with 1980's tech)
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by drjasonharrison on Monday April 06, 2026 @12:33AM (#47657029)
"far side of the moon"
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by thfuran on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:49PM (#47656041)
Even if the Apollo program was similarly politically motivated, it at least was seriously cutting edge science and engineering. I mean, there were many people born before the Wright brothers’ first flight watching the moon landing on TV. Basically repeating Apollo 8’s much less iconic flyby decades later is obviously going to be less impressive.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by dreamcompiler on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:54PM (#47651308)
The manned space program launches from Florida but is controlled from Houston. Why? Wouldn't it make more sense to have both in the same place?

Florida is because there's no other safe place in the US to launch a big rocket on an easterly trajectory* than Florida. Or the extreme southern tip of Texas, which SpaceX uses.

Houston is because NASA needed LBJ's support. They even named the place after him.

* Why easterly? Because that's the direction Earth rotates. If you orbit in that direction you get some free momentum from the planet itself.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by EvanAnderson on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:03PM (#47651409)
I know the RS-25 engines[0] (aka SSME, Space Shuttle Main Engine) were "reusable" in an academic sense (needing a ton of refurbishment after each use) but it hurts my heart that we're dropping them in the ocean and it makes it hard for me to feel good about the Artemis program. It's irrational but it makes the kid who loved the Space Shuttle (which, itself, was a political pork barrel and a jack-of-all-trades-master-of-none kind of program) sad.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RS-25

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by philistine on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:44PM (#47651912)
You and me both. They don’t even put a parachute on the boosters to get them back. Some pieces on these boosters have been in use since the 80s.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by NetMageSCW on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:58PM (#47652686)
And all of that reuse was so expensive that it set back reusable rocketry for decades as the common wisdom said it was uneconomical - even after it was demonstrated that you could have reuse without expensive refurbishment.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by magicalhippo on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:52AM (#47657712)
I'm reminded of Ian over at Forgotten Weapons which has presented several rifles which were converted from the old thing to the new thing, say bolt action to semiautomatic.

Each time the government looked at existing stock, thought "hmm surely we can save money by refurbishing these old firearms".

And just about each time they at best ended up with a subpar weapon that cost as much as a brand new model designed from scratch. And often something which cost way more...

The idea looks better on paper than it usually is.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:41PM (#47653664)
> it hurts my heart that we're dropping them in the ocean

They are functionally obsolete. Chances that we’re still using SLS in ten years is slim. Any resources going towards refurbishment are better spent on Starship and Blue Moon.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by oceanplexian on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:57PM (#47652063)
> my belief that it is intended to be little more than a quick, dirty, and vainglorious Apollo repeat by a failing government.

If the USA successfully sends people to the Moon, achieves all of NASA's technical goals, and the astronauts make it back in one piece, isn't that literally the opposite of failure?

It might be expensive and you can argue that it's wasteful. But even to that point, the $11B cost of SLS is nothing for the US Gov. For example the F35 is a >$1T government program. That doesn't seem a lot to explore a new frontier and expand the scope of humanity.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by anjel on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:13PM (#47652838)
Its not Pork and its not science. Its a strategically costly land grab rather than a political vain-glorious stunt.

Same as Mercury/Gemini/Apollo except this time China instead of Russia.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:40PM (#47653658)
> its not science. Its a strategically costly land grab

Step away from your screens. Framing everything exclusively in these hard terms isn’t healthy (or true).

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by unethical_ban on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:30AM (#47661432)
Jumping in late here. I think both can be true, that it's an inspirational moment and the idea of humans exploring and visiting other worlds is amazing. That a society's ability to do so implies its scientific prowess. And that we are in competition with other top nations to "have a seat at the table" if/when those nations start trying to put controls on the use of those celestial bodies.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by randomNumber7 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:01PM (#47652720)
> That doesn't seem a lot to explore a new frontier and expand the scope of humanity.

There is no gain in knowledge from this mission. It's more like cheering for your favorite soccer team.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:59PM (#47653807)
> There is no gain in knowledge from this mission

This is wrong. We’re learning a lot about the new life-support systems. (Courtesy of the ESA.) We’re also going to learn more about the heat shield on 10 April.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by seb1204 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:10PM (#47655741)
Yes true, but these are all technologies required for humans in space. Toilets in space, as intriguing the topic and discussion are, are only needed because we decided to go there. I think the tech is interesting but the human unification vibe is tainted at the least.
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by jrumbut on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:52PM (#47653200)
> the immense amount of pork involved (SLS is called "Senate Launch System" for good reason

Most of science has always had this dual use purpose.

No senator ever would have voted for any kind of space program just to send a few tourists to the moon. It's a way to have a substantial workforce, spread across a wide area (so they can't all be hit by the same bomb), that knows how to make and launch rockets and to do weird stuff in space and to work with very energetic materials.

But I agree that it feels hollow right now because of the war abroad and also the needless disrespect we've shown to our Canadian friends at home.

It reminds me a little bit of The Man in the High Castle, it's like these videos are sent from some happier timeline that we don't live in. Hopefully they inspire some people to bring the spirit of curiosity and friendship they present back to our earth.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by influx on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:54PM (#47653769)
You know the whole point of the space race was to prove that we could send ICBMs to the USSR right?
Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:58PM (#47653804)
> the whole point of the space race was to prove that we could send ICBMs to the USSR right?

No, it wasn’t. The real world seldom has single causation. Some people supported Apollo as a messaging exercise. Most had other reasons.

And in any case, there are easy ways to demonstrate ICBM competence. Pyongyang isn’t going to the Moon to prove it can bomb Alaska.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by SmirkingRevenge on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:56AM (#47659745)
People complaining about "pork" - reminds me of the 90's.

In general, pork is an overstated problem. We've had far less so-called pork in legislation the past 20 years or so, but that reality has actually contributed to grid-lock and dis-empowerment of the legislature. Pork often functioned as a kind of grease on the wheels and, while gross, gave legislators incentives to bargain and levers with which to do it. The war on pork is one part of the story of how the US congress has calcified.

Re:Artemis II crew see first glimpse of far side of Moon [vi... by stronglikedan on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:45PM (#47665955)
Dude, we went to the moon again. Who the fuck cares how. If we waited for the no-pork solution, we'd still be planning the first test. I'm over the moon right now!