News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by kjksf on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:19PM (#46996689)
Tesla never had lidar so they didn't abandon it.

Also, Tesla started FSD in 2016. The very core of their strategy was (and is) to sell $40k car with hardware capable of running FSD.

Cameras are super cheap, FSD chip is reasonably inexpensive. Lidar is not. Maybe today the cost isn't completely prohibitive (I think it still is, because you need multiple lidars) but it certainly was for the first 8 years of FSD program.

Tesla just didn't have the luxury of adding $50k to the cost of the car for the hardware, the way Waymo did. And they didn't have sugar daddy (Google) willing to burn several billions a year for many years.

So the Waymo approach was not an option for Tesla.

And given that in Austin they just reached parity with Waymo (i.e. completely unsupervised robotaxi service), they are not doing badly.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by dinobones on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:58PM (#46997056)
> And given that in Austin they just reached parity with Waymo (i.e. completely unsupervised robotaxi service), they are not doing badly.

There is no unsupervised robotaxi service in Austin and there won't be, for years, if ever. Just like the way "FSD" is not fully self driving and likely never will be.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by llboston on Thursday February 12, 2026 @07:37PM (#46997377)
According to https://robotaxitracker.com/ there are 7 unsupervised robotaxi in Austin right now.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by DerekL on Thursday February 12, 2026 @08:17PM (#46997723)
Are these the cars where the safety driver is in a car tailing the robotaxi, or do they actually run without the need for a safety driver?

https://electrek.co/2026/01/22/tesla-didnt-remove-the-robota...

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by WarmWash on Thursday February 12, 2026 @08:55PM (#46997985)
It seems they run without a safety driver or follow car (mostly?).

However the area it operates is extremely small, and they are still only allowing Tesla bros to try it.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by senordevnyc on Thursday February 12, 2026 @09:10PM (#46998083)
So in other words, like literally every other word out of Elon’s mouth for a decade now, it’s incredibly dishonest. He lies about everything, all the time, without any acknowledgment. Nothing is ever delivered on time, most of it isn’t delivered at all, and virtually every bit of promised capability is exaggerated.

Why does anyone want to do business with a person or company like that? I genuinely do not understand.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by small_model on Friday February 13, 2026 @06:16AM (#47001479)
Nope is open to the public and covers bigger area then Waymo. EDS is limiting a lot of people here's ability to critically evaluate the current autonomous auto rollout.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by senordevnyc on Friday February 13, 2026 @08:32AM (#47002508)
This is totally false. If there are any truly autonomous robotaxis in Austin (a bit if, since Tesla has repeatedly lied and faked things like this in the past), it’s only a handful and they’re limited to a tiny area. The “robotaxis” with a safety driver are the ones that have the bigger area, probably because Tesla sucks at actual self-driving. Still. After a decade of broken promises and shitty engineering practices.

Elon has been blatantly lying about FSD for years, and yet the fans still take whatever he says as gospel. And yet the skeptics are the ones with EDS? lol, ok.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by WarmWash on Friday February 13, 2026 @09:26AM (#47003112)
The unsupervised area is a tiny subset of the supervised area.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by small_model on Friday February 13, 2026 @10:47AM (#47004036)
Any evidence of this?, even it its true right now, and they are being ultra cautious, (they are hardly going to just dump 100k unsupervised teslas in one week), it won't stay that way for long. They will overtake Waymo in a few months, then kill them by the end of the year.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by WarmWash on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:35PM (#47006050)
https://www.reddit.com/r/SelfDrivingCars/comments/1qvf7hu/te...

It's unsurprising someone so out of the loop on its true status is so hyped on it's future...

If robotaxi was doing legit rides, Elon would be posting about it 20 times a day.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by small_model on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:06PM (#47006437)
Reddit is extremely anti Musk and Tesla, that sub reddit being the typical example. Let's just wait and see where we are in 6 months.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by testing22321 on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:38AM (#46999278)
> and there won't be, for years, if ever.

That is a lot of confidence. Do you work in the autonomous vehicle space?

What makes you so certain?

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by UltraSane on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:55AM (#46999381)
Because camera only simply won't be reliable enough with current technology.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by red75prime on Friday February 13, 2026 @03:09AM (#47000209)
Try to find a single ablation study of a sensor suite. Waymo is in a good position to do such a study and the corporation would have benefited from showing that vision-only systems aren't viable (by demonstrating the corporation's good will to maintain public safety and by making it harder for vision-only competitors), but no such study from them.

I guess they understand that computer vision is a fast-moving target and their paper might become obsolete the next day.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by UltraSane on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:46PM (#47005457)
FSD and Robotaxi are plenty of evidence vision only aren't viable.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by red75prime on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:47PM (#47006194)
Read Electrek articles with a mouthful of salt. Fred Lambert’s “robotaxi is 10x worse than a human” estimate is based on his personal statistical reasoning, which somehow arrived at 200,000 miles per accident for humans. Minor accidents that Tesla reports for robotaxis (such as low-speed collisions with stationary objects) do not make it into publicly available statistics, so his estimate might be significantly off.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by UltraSane on Friday February 13, 2026 @05:39PM (#47008811)
Not a single waymo requires a "safety driver" and the self driving never disengages the way it does on Teslas.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by red75prime on Saturday February 14, 2026 @04:49AM (#47013178)
Waymo routinely uses safety drivers, sorry, "autonomous specialists" when expanding to new cities[1][2]. Waymo cars occasionally contact the remote support. If support is not available, the cars just stay where they stopped[3].

Tesla has rolled out a small number of cars with no safety driver[4].

In short, you are either grossly misinformed or intentionally lying. Is it a political echochamber you are stuck in?

[1] https://waymo.com/faq/ "Our vehicles are primarily driving autonomously, but you’ll sometimes notice that our cars have autonomous specialists riding in the driver’s seat. These specialists are there to monitor our autonomous driving technology and share important feedback to help us improve the Waymo experience."

[2] https://waymo.com/waymo-in-uk/ "Our autonomous specialists who are present in the vehicle during testing are highly trained professionals."

[3] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c36zdxl41jro

[4] https://youtu.be/03e5ixbXIa4

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by UltraSane on Saturday February 14, 2026 @02:25PM (#47017469)
You are grossly misinformed. Waymo self driving never disengages the way Tesla FSD does. It is active at all times. In novel situations humans will provide instructions on what path to take but this is relatively infrequent. Tesla Robotaxis are so bad they need a safety driver in every single car at all times ready to take control when the car does something stupid. The small number of robotaxis without safety drives are limited to a tiny area and not open to the public.

Waymo works while robotaxi doesn't.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by red75prime on Sunday February 15, 2026 @05:55AM (#47022768)
> Waymo self driving never disengages the way Tesla FSD does. It is active at all times

Consumer version of FSD can park a car if a driver doesn't take contol[1]. Waymo seems to require a remote command to initiate parking instead of just standing there with hazard lights on[2].

> Tesla Robotaxis are so bad they need a safety driver in every single car at all times ready to take control

Every single robotaxi in Austin doesn't have a driver behind the wheel. So a driver can't be ready to take control. Stop lying. I no longer believe that you are misinformed.

[1] https://youtu.be/VU3i1Pgk4M0?t=1460

[2] https://waymo.com/blog/2025/12/autonomously-navigating-the-r... "We directed our fleet to pull over and park appropriately"

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by UltraSane on Tuesday February 17, 2026 @03:45PM (#47053063)
"Every single robotaxi in Austin doesn't have a driver behind the wheel."

Almost ALL of them do. And NO waymo's need them.

https://electrek.co/2026/02/17/tesla-robotaxi-adds-5-more-cr...

Robotaxis is checkers compared to Waymo Chesss

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by testing22321 on Friday February 13, 2026 @09:30AM (#47003153)
Technology is moving fast.

When do you think it will be reliable enough?

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by UltraSane on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:50PM (#47005508)
Not for a very long time. Just think about how big of an advantage lidar and radar are at night or radar is in snow and rain?

If Tesla had been smart they would have used regular cameras and event based cameras where the pixels send a signal whenever their brightness changes enough. These can have microsecond latency. And multi spectral cameras. Combined this data would provide very rich data for neural networks.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by testing22321 on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:02PM (#47006392)
Sounds like you’re an expert. Do you work in the autonomous vehicle space? In what capacity?
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by UltraSane on Friday February 13, 2026 @05:41PM (#47008824)
I'm not an expert, just someone who understand how these technologies work. Sensor fusion is a fascinating thing.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by small_model on Friday February 13, 2026 @06:14AM (#47001464)
lol its running now and growing every day, the thing about Tesla's solution is it works globally and the costs are much much less than Waymo will ever be able to achieve (Given there reliance on third parties for most of the hardware) Waymo and uber will be gone in a year.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by senordevnyc on Friday February 13, 2026 @08:32AM (#47002499)
Been hearing this for years now. But sure, any day now…
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by youarentrightjr on Friday February 13, 2026 @11:40AM (#47004665)
> lol its running now and growing every day, the thing about Tesla's solution is it works globally and the costs are much much less than Waymo will ever be able to achieve (Given there reliance on third parties for most of the hardware) Waymo and uber will be gone in a year.

A year? They'll be gone in two weeks!

Seriously, what portion of your financial and emotional net worth is tied up in TSLA?

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by small_model on Friday February 13, 2026 @11:48AM (#47004781)
None, it's just obvious to anyone who has a high school level of business knowledge.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by youarentrightjr on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:26PM (#47005243)
> None, it's just obvious to anyone who has a high school level of business knowledge.

That's a highly ironic statement given your position on "cost per mile".

With a small amount of business acumen, you'd know that betting on technology staying expensive is a bad idea. This is seen in all industries, but especially electronics, where there are many competitors continuously optimizing for cost. E.g., we're at the point now where an internet enabled phone is basically disposable, costing people ~ a few hours of wages.

History has shown that technology costs decrease over time, and rapidly if it's a critically important technology. If you don't agree, share a counter example.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by small_model on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:10PM (#47006479)
Phones were about $400-500 years ago now they are over $1k which is not 'a few hours of wages' well not for most of us. I agree technology prices decreases over time but Waymo is starting at 5x the cost, by the time a Waymo costs even the same price as a Model Y, let alone a Cybercab it will be too late. That's my prediction, I could be wrong though, maybe Elon and Tesla are lying and so are all the users of least version of FSD.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by youarentrightjr on Saturday February 14, 2026 @04:30PM (#47018578)
> Phones were about $400-500 years ago now they are over $1k

https://www.walmart.com/ip/ST-MOTOROLA-XT2413V-CDMA-LTE-BLUE...

Try to avoid cherry picking if you want to have a discussion where you or the other person learns something. All the Elon stans on this site that I've encountered are highly disingenuous, starting to think that's not a coincidence.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by gcanyon on Thursday February 12, 2026 @07:05PM (#46997118)
> And they didn't have sugar daddy (Google) willing to burn several billions a year for many years.

Tesla's market cap is $1.3 trillion. Granted the company itself doesn't have access to all of that, but surely if they wanted to spend, say, $10 billion per year on something big like FSD, they could have.

> didn't have the luxury of adding $50k to the cost of the car for the hardware

A little more extreme, but: Tesla has sold something like 8.5 million cars total. If they simply dumped an extra $50K of material into every single one of those cars without raising the price a dime, that would be only $425 billion. That's a ridiculous sum of money, but still <checks notes> substantially less than $1.3 trillion.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by dmoy on Thursday February 12, 2026 @07:27PM (#46997286)
I'm not a fan of Tesla's approach to self driving, but

> If they simply dumped an extra $50K of material into every single one of those cars without raising the price a dime, that would be only $425 billion. That's a ridiculous sum of money, but still <checks notes> substantially less than [their market cap of] $1.3 trillion.

That is an apples to dishwasher comparison. Money is fungible only when it's the same kind of money on both sides. You can't compare market cap like that. (Even for a company whose market cap is seemingly divorced from reality like Tesla's)

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by raw_anon_1111 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @07:46PM (#46997452)
You can’t trade market cap for goods and services. Tesla is not exactly rolling in cash these days.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by kiba on Thursday February 12, 2026 @09:58PM (#46998416)
They squandered their lead with the CEO's focus elsewhere.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by bradleyjg on Friday February 13, 2026 @04:39AM (#47000828)
You can. It’s called a secondary offering. The SEC has a whole process.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by raw_anon_1111 on Friday February 13, 2026 @07:35AM (#47001998)
You can sell more stock to raise money regardless of market cap.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by testing22321 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @07:39PM (#46997387)
If they had done so, their financials wouldn’t have attracted investors and they wouldn’t be worth near 1.3T
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by fooker on Thursday February 12, 2026 @10:02PM (#46998442)
They'd need one more thing, a time machine.

TSLA market cap was about 50B for the first several years of their FSD effort.

I think they'd choose lidar if they started now.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by golem14 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @10:17PM (#46998518)
If you ordered 8M LIDARs, the unit price would quickly plummet. Thankfully, this is already happening thanks to Chinese efforts in that space.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by nasreddin on Thursday February 12, 2026 @10:32PM (#46998598)
This is probably the most "techbro understanding of finance" moment if there ever was one. Laughable stuff.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by digitalPhonix on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:25AM (#46999558)
$50k? The sensor kit on the Waymo’s ipace is north of $300k. (Which completely inverts that calculation)
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by AlotOfReading on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:47AM (#46999683)
You're years out of date on that number. I doubt it's been true this decade. Reasonable current estimates are under a few tens of thousand at most.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by digitalPhonix on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:04AM (#46999782)
No, I know how much each honeycomb costs (BOM cost, that is); pretty confident on the radars; and I can guess at the cameras and compute.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by AlotOfReading on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:21AM (#46999886)
Then they're way behind others in the industry, and I'm not sure I believe that given the people I know there.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by digitalPhonix on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:50PM (#47005496)
Then you should be asking them instead of arguing with random internet people
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by ddalex on Friday February 13, 2026 @07:17AM (#47001869)
It's between 7k (chinese) and 17k (european) now.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by surajrmal on Friday February 13, 2026 @10:54AM (#47004140)
You are either intentionally lying or very confident about facts you don't know. Could you please source your numbers?
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by digitalPhonix on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:51PM (#47005515)
You are confident that I am wrong - why don't you share your source?

I'm giving ballpark numbers because I am in this space and don't want to dox myself.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by g947o on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:56PM (#46997036)
> it certainly was for the first 8 years of FSD program.

Nobody is talking about any of this using past tense. It is 2026 now, not 2016.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by WarmWash on Thursday February 12, 2026 @08:56PM (#46997988)
Tesla has the dumbest (and many of the richest) shareholders in recent history. They absolutely would have funded it. Tesla could probably do an offering tomorrow to raise $100B and the share price would be back to ~$420 in a month.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by bobsomers on Thursday February 12, 2026 @11:21PM (#46998891)
> And given that in Austin they just reached parity with Waymo (i.e. completely unsupervised robotaxi service), they are not doing badly.

Parity is not defined by how willing one is to let their robots kill the general public.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by UltraSane on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:55AM (#46999379)
Tesla Robotaxi is a Potemkin village con whose only purpose is to inflate Tesla stock. Musk is relying on this more and more, most recently with his claiming SpaceX will put data centers in space.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by throw-qqqqq on Friday February 13, 2026 @08:52AM (#47002705)
> And given that in Austin they just reached parity with Waymo

Tesla is far behind Waymo on all meaningful measures.

Waymo sells more than 450k rides every week. Tesla is nowhere near that number.

Waymo offers rides in six cities. Tesla does two.

According to https://robotaxitracker.com/ Tesla has ~250 taxis in total. Waymo has +2500.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by small_model on Friday February 13, 2026 @10:56AM (#47004159)
Well Tesla just launched their robotaxi 6 months ago whereas Waymo has been going for a decade? Just looking at a point in time is a bit silly, look at the change over time.

The bottom line is cost per mile and Waymo can't complete here, there is also style, Waymo's vehicles are extremely ugly looking cars vs the Cybercab. Tesla also has integrated everything from the chip up. Waymo is a cobbled together solution from multiple third party (very expensive) components.

Is the consumer going to pick a more expensive, ugly, non integrated vehicle for their trip?

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by throw-qqqqq on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:47PM (#47005466)
> Well Tesla just launched their robotaxi 6 months ago whereas Waymo has been going for a decade? Just looking at a point in time is a bit silly, look at the change over time.

I am only refuting the claim that Tesla has reached parity with Waymo in Austin. They are nowhere near.

Because Tesla has a history of over-promising and under-delivering, I will want to see Tesla scale up the robotaxi business to the level of Waymo (which is currently far ahead) before I proclaim them the winner.

You are not really backing your claims with facts or numbers, just opinion and future predictions which may or may not come true.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by jerlam on Friday February 13, 2026 @06:53PM (#47009502)
> Is the consumer going to pick a more expensive, ugly, non integrated vehicle for their trip?

The consumer does not care about which car picks them up or what hardware integration it has. The consumer cares about which car is available in their service area, how quickly it will arrive, how much it will cost, how safely it can get to their destination, and safely it will do so.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by hnburnsy on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:50PM (#47005511)
I hope they are both successful, find their own niche, and even more players enter the market.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by throw-qqqqq on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:58PM (#47005595)
Agree, competition is healthy.