On the money thing though you really need to come to terms with the fact that there is way more random chance than there is earned riches in the tech business. For every person who got rich being the most brilliant mind on the problem at the right time, there are hundreds, if not thousands, of people who got rich just because who ever was sitting in the seat they happened to be sitting in also got rich. The folks who just happened to be at Sun when it founded, or HP, or Google, or FaceBook. Randomness, not skill, plays a huge role there. There was a guy at Sun whom I helped manage out of the organization, he landed a job at a start up that two months later got bought with a full vesting of everyone. He walked away with several million dollars. It took a lot of thinking about that series of events to let it sit in my head without pissing me off.
Different people exploit their opportunities differently. I know that if I both knew how, and could have, shorted stock I held but was locked up but worth 'millions' I would have. I would have said "That's enough for me, sell it all, and when it dribbles out via my acquisition contract timed unlock I'll hand over the shares." That would have made me 'evil' in the eyes of the shareholders who bought stock during that time (and later sued the company) but my motivation would have been quite pure (FU money is a good thing). But I don't think of myself as an evil guy, and generally am pretty nice.
Bottom line is people with large holdings in a startup will look to 'liquify' a chunk of that to diversify and allow them to activate the wealth 'ratchet' (that is where you solidify your position by converting equity into real goods). If the value of the company continues to grow nobody ever remembers, if the value plunges, they get the short end of it. But its mostly randomness at work.
But really there are two points here:
1) People with a lot of equity in a single company will sell it when they can to diversify their risk (not evil)
2) People who end up with a lot of equity in a single company that is worth a lot of money are 'lucky' not necessarily 'good', 'smart', or 'evil.'
I certainly felt it raised eye brows when Pincus and other officers dumped big chunks of stock in a pre-arranged sale, but note that had Zynga continued to go up in value nobody would have blinked, but since it so spectacularly has crashed they are reviled. As bad as that looked I felt the Groupon folks turning down Google's $6B offer and instead selling their own stock through a private placement was a lot further down the scale toward 'poor judgement' than Zynga's moves.
I totally agree with point #1 though. People should be able to diversify their risk.
A 10b-5 plan or similar is the only legally safe way to act during a quiet period.
But trading during a post-IPO employee lockup, when there is no insider information concern, maybe isn't as tight as "the week before earnings release". Seems like it shouldn't be legally. But employers certainly would order their employees not to trade.
There was a nasty loophole/scandal a few years back where people would set up a legal auto-sale plan like "Sell 1000 shares every week", and selectively cancel the plan on weeks they didn't want to transact. I'm not sure what became of that.
Why did that piss you off? Sounds like it was a win-win situation for you and that guy.
I haven't heard this expression before, but it sounds like he had the guy fired. He didn't like the guy, or felt that the guy wasn't functioning well in his position at Sun.
Because of that I don't share your interpretation that "FU money" is correlated at all with the sense of obligation. In my world view that obligation is intrinsic in the person and not affected by the source of income. When I see the good that the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation is doing, the Lucille Packard Children's hospital, and others, I think that is pretty cool.
[1] http://www.macfound.org/programs/fellows/
See: http://techrights.org/wiki/index.php/Gates_Foundation_Critiq...
So with his vast fortune Gates ensures that he pays the minimum required in taxes (which may support policies he disagrees with), and instead spends money on policies he supports.
That sounds perfectly rational.
If the perspective is that everything is disconnected and that you are more important than everyone else then yes, it does.
If one can see that all is connected and everything affects everything else then it makes very little sense. Those taxes pay for poor people's sustenance when they cannot work. They pay for people who can't afford private healthcare. It's rational to help them because more national unrest means more stress, less productivity and, in the end, less likelyhood of people buying your products.
The problem with being perfectly rational is that one may not consider the flaws in one's assumptions. Rationality is only as good as the information it's acting on and is not a silver bullet for making the right decisions. A blind man might conclude that while the sun may be hot at times, it's also extremely dark.
The point is that FU money is the point at which you have enough that you can walk away from situations that you don't agree with without that impacting the rest of your financial life in any manner.
In other words, it's retirement but at a younger age.
It's not to say you don't walk away from situations you don't agree with before you have FU money. It's just that you're at a point where it won't impact the rest of your financial life.
I don't really see why it has such a negative connotation.
/edit I should add this term is usually used in terms of someone who has spent 20+ years in a career (and typically the same company) and is at loggerheads with upper management in an unresolvable situation and is about to get forced out over the situation. i.e., upper mgmt is doing something that person believe is wrong, unethical, etc.
I think if you work for a screwy company like Zynga you should be very paranoid about cashing out of the company. If they have such a low opinion of their customers, who is to say they won't have the same sentiment towards their employees.
Anyone remember this from almost a year ago? http://news.cnet.com/8301-13506_3-57322150-17/zynga-to-emplo...
I get the distinct impression Zynga only has a high opinion of money.
How did that ever pan out? Were employees forced to renounce their prior options grants, or did the pressure change management's mind on this?
Otherwise, yes, Zynga's present situation's been a long time coming, pity it's the bastards who made off like bandits.
Take patio11's advice and go into B2B, you'll make money hand over fist with much more manageable working hours.
Not everyone in the industry is scum, though it's certainly not uncommon.
That means that there is a much more abundant supply of labour and that the demand side is exploiting this by offering lower wages, worse working environment, crazier hours etc.
The main difference between fashion, music and art is that the discrepancy is much more poignant in the games industry because there's an abundant supply of well-paying cushy jobs just around the corner which involve almost the exact same skill-set to compare against.
I know several people working quite happily at gaming companies (doing, from what I can see, some pretty cool stuff), and those game companies who are the most abusive generally have well-known reputations as such.
I suppose it might not be the best industry to go into straight out of college, when you have little leverage and lack industry smarts...
Also > (with all that tracing going on...)
:D
So - to some degree, the crash and possible termination of Zynga's business model, enables these people to escape the company. If the stock had value, then they would be trapped in that really horrible (for some of them) career. When the stock has no value - they are all now free(er) to go - no handcuffs.
Their conviction was greater than the potential wealth and very commendable.
Your comment insinuates that these employees had no morals and were freed by the failure.
This is actually a fucked up position.
There are many factors that play into this, the most significant of which is the employees living paycheck to paycheck where they cannot actually leave on a high ground position due to their needing the money... and your point is that "well, at least the company failed freeing them of any moral risk of staying with the company should it have succeeded and trapped them with lucrative options!"
To this I say, fully and openly:
Fuck every single thing about Zynga and the attitudes and policies it may beget.
FUCK ZYNGA
and I have zero sympathy for any of its employees in any regard.
I have been openly decrying this company for years - and I still will - I can't stand such bullshit in any industry and Silicon Valley should SHUN them and be ashamed of every relation to this company.
We are trying to make a better world here, aren't we folks?
If not, then fuck you - because if your goal is only self-enrichment then I despise you.
Understand there is a difference between working for a lame company, and a morally objectionable company.
I could make an argument that what Zynga did with Tiny Towers/Dream Heights wasn't that much different than what Samsung did with it's Galaxy Tab/iPad. In both cases, these companies took another product as an example, and put their own spin on it.
Neither of them is really "morally reprehensible" - but, if you want to do original work, or make the world a better place, there are probably other places you can work - and taking money out of the equations makes it that much easier.
What if the Zynga employee/s in question had not a moral objection to virtual cow trade, but a mild distaste?
You can work in an industry that you think is kind of stupid, but not morally offensive.
This is totally separate from the issue of working for a company that steals other people's work as a matter of course, which was not addressed here.
Glad the decision to leave is easier, at least.
I hope this is just an isolated incident of bad company strategy than an overall industry trend.
I also feel unnerved when I see unsustainable companies go on unsustainable hiring binges. It's like the first scene in a horror movie. Are you crazy? Don't go in there! He'll kill you!
My startup is based out of Capital Factory, and if you even just walked in the door during Friday happy hour and announced that you were a developer here in Austin looking for a job, hungry funded startup owners would descend on you like wolves.
All that to say: You have nothing to be worried about. And also, come to more events...especially ones held at Capital Factory. :)
Both employ game dynamics to get participants to part with their money - the only difference being that casinos require you to pay up front, and Zynga doesn't have the same level of overhead.
The company will only face a race to the bottom, though, as others enter this space and competition for user time ramps up.
Your last sentence will probably hold true, unless they start producing something innovative and useful for a change..
It will be interesting to see if management bails from Zynga over the coming quarters. Personally, I would watch and see if management unloads on any stock or options.
Yeah, it's a bummer they'll have to find new jobs, but I don't feel particularly bad for them.
Practically, though, bad Zynga news feels terrible. Because the guys who architected this repugnant exploitation machine already got paid. They made millions selling their stock before the market truly understood what a shit business they were running. Meanwhile, front-line employees sat with their plummeting stock locked up.
So any bad Zynga news is nothing more than notice that yet another group of hardworking folks is, somehow, getting fucked over, despite their leadership enjoying tremendous rewards.
Very frustrating to watch.