News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by skeptic_ai on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:25AM (#46886969)
Still go to prison for not showing. So until devices have multiple pins for plausible deniability we are still screwed.

What’s so hard to make 2-3 pins and each to access different logged in apps and files.

If Apple/android was serious about it would implement it, but from my research seems to be someone that it’s against it, as it’s too good.

I don’t want to remove my Banking apps when I go travel or in “dangerous” places. If you re kidnapped you will be forced to send out all your money.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by stouset on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:36AM (#46887128)
Absolutely every aspect of it?

What’s so hard about adding a feature that effectively makes a single-user device multi-user? Which needs the ability to have plausible deniability for the existence of those other users? Which means that significant amounts of otherwise usable space needs to be inaccessibly set aside for those others users on every device—to retain plausible deniability—despite an insignificant fraction of customers using such a feature?

What could be hard about that?

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by gabeio on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:50AM (#46887319)
> despite an insignificant fraction of customers using such a feature?

Isn't that the exact same argument against Lockdown mode? The point isn't that the number of users is small it's that it can significantly help that small set of users, something that Apple clearly does care about.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by achierius on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:15PM (#46888515)
Lockdown mode costs ~nothing for devices that don't have it enabled. GP is pointing out that the straightforward way to implement this feature would not have that same property.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by stouset on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:14PM (#46888504)
Lockdown mode doesn’t require everyone else to lose large amounts of usable space on their own devices in order for you to have plausible deniability.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by PunchyHamster on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:22AM (#46887773)
now I want to know what dirty laundry are their upper management hiding on their devices...
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by tosapple on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:40PM (#46888876)
The 'extra users" method may not work in the face of a network investigation or typical file forensics.

Where CAs are concerned, not having the phone image 'cracked' still does not make it safe to use.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by NitpickLawyer on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:48AM (#46887284)
Truecrypt had that a decade+ ago.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by ratg13 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:23AM (#46887784)
Not sure if you know the history behind it, but look up Paul Le Roux

Also would recommend the book called The Mastermind by Evan Ratliff

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by edm0nd on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:40AM (#46888040)
imo Paul Le Roux has nothing to do with TrueCrypt
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by ratg13 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:56AM (#46888266)
He wrote the code base that it is based on in combination with code he stole. The name is also based on an early name he chose for the software.

Whether he was involved in the organization and participated in it, is certainly up for debate, but it's not like he would admit it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E4M

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by hackerfoo on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:09AM (#46887568)
Maybe one PIN could cause the device to crash. Devices crash all the time. Maybe the storage is corrupted. It might have even been damaged when it was taken.

This could even be a developer feature accidentally left enabled.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by billfor on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:56AM (#46887394)
Android phones are multi-user, so if they can do it then Apple should be able to.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by Gud on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:59AM (#46887429)
And how do you explain your 1TB phone that has 2GB of data, but only 700GB free?
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by deno on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:45AM (#46888099)
The "fake" user/profile should work like a duress pin with addition of deniability. So as soon as you log in to the second profile all the space becomes free. Just by logging in you would delete the encryption key of the other profile. The actual metadata that show what is free or not were encrypted in the locked profile. Now gone.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by tosapple on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:43PM (#46888911)
Good idea, but this is why you image devices.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by deno on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @06:07PM (#46893203)
Sorry I explained it poorly and emphasized the wrong thing.

The way it would work is not active destruction of data just a different view of data that doesn’t include any metadata that is encrypted in second profile.

Data would get overwritten only if you actually start using the fallback profile and populating the "free" space because to that profile all the data blocks are simply unreserved and look like random data.

The profiles basically overlap on the device. If you would try to use them concurrently that would be catastrophic but that is intended because you know not to use the fallback profile, but that information is only in your head and doesn’t get left on the device to be discovered by forensic analysis.

Your main profile knows to avoid overwriting the fallback profile’s data but not the other way around.

But also the point is you can actually log in to the duress profile and use it normally and it wouldn’t look like destruction of evidence which is what current GrapheneOS’s duress pin does.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by deno on Thursday February 05, 2026 @10:43AM (#46900912)
The main point is logging in to the fake profile does not do anything different from logging in to the main profile. If you image the whole thing and somehow completely bypass secure enclave (but let's assume you can't actually bruteforce the PIN because it's not feasible) then you enter the distress PIN in controlled environment and you look at what writes/reads it does and to where, even then you would not be able to tell you are in the fake profile. Nothing gets deleted eagerly, just the act of logging in is destructive to overlapping profiles. This is the only different thing in the main profile. It know which data belongs to fallback profile and will not allocate anything in those blocks. However it's possible to set up the device without fallback profile so you don't know if you are in the fallback profile or just on device without one set up.

Hopefully I explained it clearly. I haven't seen this idea anywhere else so I would be curious if someone smarter actually tried something like that already.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by tosapple on Thursday February 05, 2026 @01:49PM (#46903312)
What you say makes sense, just like the true/veracrypt volume theory. I can't find the head post to my "that's why you image post" but what concerns me is differing profiles may have different network fingerprints. You may need to keep signal and bitlocker on both, EVERYTIME my desktop boots a cloud provider is contacted -- it's not very sanitary?

It"s a hard problem to properly set up even on the user end let alone the developer/engineer side but thank you.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by morkalork on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:06AM (#46887527)
The same way when you buy a brand new phone with 200GB of storage that only has 50GB free on it haha
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by heraldgeezer on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:10AM (#46887583)
System files officer ;)
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by davidwritesbugs on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:31AM (#46887900)
"Idunno copper, I'm a journalist not a geek"
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by jb1991 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:59AM (#46887430)
This is called whataboutism. This particular feature aside, sometimes there are very good reasons not to throw the kitchen sink of features at users.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by stouset on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @01:22PM (#46889528)
That is about one fiftieth of the work that needs to go into the feature the OP casually “why can’t they just”-ed.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by vlovich123 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:51AM (#46888199)
iPhone and macOS are basically the same product technically. The reason iPhone is a single user product is UX decisions and business/product philosophy, not technical reasons.

While plausible deniability may be hard to develop, it’s not some particularly arcane thing. The primary reasons against it are the political balancing act Apple has to balance (remember San Bernardino and the trouble the US government tried to create for Apple?). Secondary reasons are cost to develop vs addressable market, but they did introduce Lockdown mode so it’s not unprecedented to improve the security for those particularly sensitive to such issues.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by achierius on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:16PM (#46888529)
> iPhone and macOS are basically the same product technically

This seems hard to justify. They share a lot of code yes, but many many things are different (meaningfully so, from the perspective of both app developers and users)

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by ashdksnndck on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:47AM (#46888145)
You think iPhones aren’t multi-user for technical reasons? You sure it’s not to sell more phones and iPads? Should we ask Tim “buy your mom an iPhone” Cook?
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by izzydata on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:45AM (#46887240)
It doesn't seem fundamentally different from a PC having multiple logins that are accessed from different passwords. Hasn't this been a solved problem for decades?
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by bsharper on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:00AM (#46887449)
You can have a multiuser system but that doesn't solve this particular issue. If they log in to what you claim to be your primary account and see browser history that shows you went to msn.com 3 months ago, they aren't going to believe it's the primary account.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by inetknght on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:16AM (#46887675)
My browser history is cleared every time I close it.

It's actually annoying because every site wants to "remember" the browser information, and so I end up with hundreds of browsers "logged in". Or maybe my account was hacked and that's why there's hundreds of browsers logged in.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by paulryanrogers on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:49AM (#46887297)
Apple's hardware business model incentivizes only supporting one user per device.

Android has supported multiple users per device for years now.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by compiler-guy on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:48AM (#46887285)
Multi-user has been solved for decades.

Multi-user that plausibly looks like single-user to three letter agencies?

Not even close.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by izzydata on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:01AM (#46887462)
Doesn't having standard multi-user functionality automatically create the plausible deniability? If they tried so hard to create an artificial plausible deniability that would be more suspicious than normal functionality that just gets used sometimes.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by wtallis on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:35AM (#46887954)
What needs to be plausibly denied is the existence of a second user account, because you're not going to be able to plausibly deny that the account belongs to you when it resides on the phone found in your pocket.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by greesil on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:09AM (#46887573)
Android has work profiles, so that could be done in Android. iPhone still does not.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by skeptic_ai on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:05PM (#46888383)
Police ask: give me pass for work profile. If you don’t: prison.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by reaperducer on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:17AM (#46887683)
Android has work profiles

Never ever use your personal phone for work things, and vice versa. It's bad for you and bad for the company you work for in dozens of ways.

Even when I owned my own company, I had separate phones. There's just too much legal liability and chances for things to go wrong when you do that. I'm surprised any company with more than five employees would even allow it.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by PunchyHamster on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:23AM (#46887782)
you're surprise corporations are cheap
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by greesil on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @01:53PM (#46889983)
What's the risk? On Android, the company can remotely nuke the work profile. The work profile has its own file system and apps. You can turn it off when to don't want work notifications.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by palmotea on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:55AM (#46887386)
> Still go to prison for not showing. So until devices have multiple pins for plausible deniability we are still screwed.

> What’s so hard to make 2-3 pins and each to access different logged in apps and files.

Besides the technical challenges, I think there's a pretty killer human challenge: it's going to be really hard for the user to create an alternate account that looks real to someone who's paying attention. Sure, you can probably fool some bored agent in customs line who knows nothing about you, but not a trained investigator who's focused on you and knows a lot about you.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by fluoridation on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:41AM (#46888051)
But at that point it turns from "the person refused to unlock the device" to "we think the person has unlocked the device into a fake account".
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by skeptic_ai on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:06PM (#46888400)
That’s what plausible deniability. How can you even tell?
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by skeptic_ai on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:05PM (#46888391)
Just use an account for “regular” stuff. And only use the “secret” account as needed.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by ashdksnndck on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:49AM (#46888177)
Doesn’t matter if the agent believes you. Only matters if the court jails you on a contempt charge.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by davidwritesbugs on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:34AM (#46887943)
Background agent in the decoy identity that periodically browses the web, retrieves email from a banal account etc.?
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by palmotea on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:40AM (#46888036)
> Background agent in the decoy identity that periodically browses the web, retrieves email from a banal account etc.?

No. Think about it for a second: you're a journalist being investigated to find your sources, and your phone says you mainly check sports scores and send innocuous emails to "grandma" in LLM-speak? It's not going to fool someone who's actually thinking.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by stouset on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @01:24PM (#46889550)
Even more complications for a “why can’t they just…”. It’s almost as if this kind of thing is difficult to do in practice.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by Zak on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:52AM (#46888209)
Assuming the rule of law is still functioning, there are multiple protections for journalists who refuse to divulge passwords in the USA. A journalist can challenge any such order in court and usually won't be detained during the process as long as they show up in court when required and haven't tried to destroy evidence.

Deceiving investigators by using an alternate password, or destroying evidence by using a duress code on the other hand is almost always a felony. It's a very bad idea for a journalist to do that, as long as the rule of law is intact.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by dboreham on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @01:07PM (#46889312)
I think it's pretty clear at this point that rule of law isn't functioning. Perhaps it never was. It was just rule of law theater.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:45AM (#46887232)
How does "go to prison for not showing" work when a lot of constitutions have a clause for a suspect not needing to participate in their own conviction / right to remain silent?

A detective can have a warrant to search someone's home or car, but that doesn't mean the owner needs to give them the key as far as I know.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by SoftTalker on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:52AM (#46887355)
It does mean that. You can't be forced to divulge information in your head, as that would be testimonial. But if there are papers, records, or other evidentiary materials that are e.g. locked in a safe you can be compelled to open it with a warrant, and refusal would be contempt.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by Steltek on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:08AM (#46887558)
They need to prove that those materials exist on the device first. You can't be held in contempt for a fishing expedition.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by SoftTalker on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:31AM (#46887910)
You need "probable cause to believe" which is not as strong as "prove" but yes, it can't be a pure fishing expedition.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by lostlogin on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:09AM (#46887575)
FaceID and TouchID aren’t protected by that as I understand it.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by plagiarist on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:26AM (#46887840)
That's correct, they are not. A complete failing of legislation and blatant disregard of the spirit of the 5th Amendment.

So do not have biometrics as device unlock if you are a journalist protecting sources.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by SoftTalker on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:30AM (#46887898)
They are considered to be more like keys to a safe than private knowledge. They also can't be changed if compromised. A sufficiently unguessable PIN or passphrase is better than biometrics.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by parineum on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:06AM (#46887542)
I know it seems like an incredibly dubious claim but the "I forgot" defense actually works here.

It's not really that useful for a safe since they aren't _that_ difficult to open and, if you haven't committed a crime, it's probably better to open your safe for them than have them destroy it so you need a new one. For a mathematically impossible to break cipher though, very useful.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by jibe on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:29AM (#46887020)
Hannah Natanson is not in prison though.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by eviks on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:56AM (#46888260)
There is no plausible deniability here, that's only relevant in a rule-of-law type of situation, but then you wouldn't need it as you can't be legally compelled to do that anyway. "We don't see any secret source communication on your work device = you entered the wrong pin = go think about what your behavior in jail"
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by hangonhn on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:59AM (#46888294)
Out of curiosity, if a court orders you to unlock it and you use a theoretical distress/duress pin to show there is nothing, would you have committed perjury? If so, in terms of severity of crime, would not showing or perjury be the lesser crime?
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by AdamN on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:54AM (#46888234)
Even if this worked (which would be massively expensive to implement) the misconfiguration possibilities are endless. It wouldn't be customer-centric to actually release this capability.

Better for the foreseeable future to have separate devices and separate accounts (i.e. not in the same iCloud family for instance)

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by ryanmcbride on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:22AM (#46887768)
It's more a policy problem than a phone problem. Apple could add as many pins as they want but until there are proper legal based privacy protections, law enforcement will still just be like "well how do we know you don't have a secret pin that unlocks 40TB of illegal content? Better disappear you just to be sure"

For as long as law enforcement treats protection of privacy as implicit guilt, the best a phone can really do is lock down and hope for the best.

Even if there was a phone that existed that perfectly protected your privacy and was impossible to crack or was easy to spoof content on, law enforcement would just move the goal post of guilt so that owning the phone itself is incriminating.

Edit: I wanna be clear that I'm not saying any phone based privacy protections are a waste of time. They're important. I'm saying that there is no perfect solution with the existing policy being enforced, which is "guilty until proven dead"

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by Blackthorn on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:57AM (#46887406)
They are willing to kill people and then justify it by calling them terrorists. Plausible deniability is pointless.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by jb1991 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:01AM (#46887456)
Uh, that escalated quickly.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by ryanmcbride on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:28AM (#46887863)
Actually it's been escalating pretty steadily for 250 years
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by snowwrestler on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:45AM (#46888107)
“Plausible deniability” is a public relations concept. It doesn’t confer any actual legal protection.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by dkarras on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:53AM (#46888217)
It absolutely offers some legal protection. If it is implemented correctly, no legal framework for it is required. Government forces you to enter your password. You comply and enter "a" password. The device shows contents. You did what you were asked to do. If there is no way for the government to prove that you entered a decoy password that shows decoy contents, you are in the clear. Done correctly (in device and OPSEC) government can't prove you entered your decoy password so you can't be held in contempt. And that is the entire point. It is not like asking the government to give your "plausible deniability" rights. It is about not potentially incriminating yourself against people that abuse the system to force you to incriminate yourself.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by snowwrestler on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:55PM (#46889104)
> You comply and enter "a" password. The device shows contents. You did what you were asked to do.

No, you did something fake to avoid doing what you were asked to do.

> If there is no way for the government to prove that you entered a decoy password that shows decoy contents, you are in the clear.

But there are very effective ways to find hidden encrypted volumes on devices. And then you’ll be asked to decrypt those too, and then what?

This sort of thing is already table stakes for CSAM prosecutions, for example. Law enforcement can read the same blog posts and know as much about technology as you do. Especially if we are hypothesizing an advertised feature of a commercial OS!

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by dkarras on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @02:19PM (#46890341)
>No, you did something fake to avoid doing what you were asked to do.

Yes, that is what plausible deniability is.

>But there are very effective ways to find hidden encrypted volumes on devices. And then you’ll be asked to decrypt those too, and then what?

I emphasized "done right". If existence of hidden encryption can be proven, then you don't have plausible deniability. Something has gone wrong.

My point was: OP claimed plausible deniability does not apply in legal cases which is a weird take. If you can have plausible deniability, then it can save you legally. This does not only apply to tech of course, but encryption was the subject here. In all cases though, if your situation is not "plausible" (due to broken tech, backdoors, poor OPSEC in tech, and / or damning other evidence in other cases as well) then you don't have plauisble deniability by definition.

Having ways of definitively detecting hidden encrypted volumes might be the norm today, might be impossible tomorrow. Then you will have plausible deniability and it will work legally as far as that piece of "evidence" is concerned.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by cr125rider on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:28AM (#46887007)
Fourth and Fifth amendments disagree
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by twelvedogs on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:32AM (#46887056)
I don't think we're doing amendments any more
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by ddtaylor on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:41AM (#46887181)
And if we are it will be a new one with a high number and it will be pure insanity
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by lm28469 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:35AM (#46887100)
Sure but in the real world it can take months or years, Francis Rawls stayed 4 years in jail because he didn't want to unlock hard drives.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by kyrra on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:35AM (#46887092)
People are jailed for contempt of court for failing to provide passwords.

https://reason.com/2017/05/31/florida-man-jailed-180-days-fo...

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by fluoridation on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:57AM (#46888273)
Wow, so US judges are just making it up as they go along, huh? It's like every case is a different judgement with no consistent criterion.

>Doe vs. U.S. That case centered around whether the feds could force a suspect to sign consent forms permitting foreign banks to produce any account records that he may have. In Doe, the justices ruled that the government did have that power, since the forms did not require the defendant to confirm or deny the presence of the records.

Well, what if the defendant was innocent of that charge but guilty of or involved in an unrelated matter for which there was evidence in the account records?

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by pluralmonad on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:40AM (#46888039)
I always wondered if this was the feature of TrueCrypt that made it such a big target. LUKS is fine, I guess, but TrueCrypt felt like actual secrecy.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by lm28469 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:38AM (#46887146)
Yep, you need an emergency mode that completely resets the phone to factory settings, maybe triggered with a decoy pin. Or a mode that physically destroys the chip storing the keys
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by bitexploder on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:35AM (#46887097)
You do not. We have this thing in our constitution called the 5th amendment. You cannot be forced to divulge the contents of your mind, including your pin or passwords. Case law supports this. For US citizens at least. Hopefully the constitution is still worth something.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by John23832 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:52AM (#46887341)
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by bitexploder on Thursday February 05, 2026 @01:46AM (#46896500)
It took 4 years. What is your point?
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by John23832 on Thursday February 05, 2026 @10:19AM (#46900607)
That you don't want to be in jail for 4 years for not providing the key?

I personally don't want to say "oh but my liberty", in a jail cell. Whatever floats your boat though.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by bitexploder on Thursday February 05, 2026 @04:39PM (#46905751)
It is salient to point out the individual almost certainly had incriminating evidence on that system. There aren't really any cases of a person being /randomly/ detained and held in contempt. Especially not a fishing expedition by the DOJ against a journalist. And if you know the act of giving away the password has some upper limit on contempt jailing vs. assured evidence against you in some much higher consequence felony wouldn't you just stay quiet? No amendment or right is absolute, but this one is rather strong, especially if you haven't, you know, been doing any crimes.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by lm28469 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:39AM (#46887159)
That's in the fantasy world of constitution maximalists. In real world it doesn't work like that and you might still lose money/time/your sanity fighting a system who cares less and less about your rights
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by bitexploder on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:46AM (#46887250)
The case law on this specific topic is convincing. If you are ever in that situation it is usually going to be worth your time and money to assert the right and see it through. Case law supports this. The general maximum “penalty” is being held in contempt of court. And if the government is wrongly persecuting you, it is lose / lose if you divulge.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by carlosjobim on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:50AM (#46887329)
Do you think this is for fighting parking tickets? It is for journalists to not reveal their sources, whom might be at risk of severe consequences including death.

That's a whole lot more to loose than your money and time.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by lm28469 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:22AM (#46887767)
That's not what we're discussing here, you can't just say "I plead the fifth" and walk away if the people in charge decided you wouldn't walk away, no matter what's right or "legal"

Francis Rawls stayed 4 years in jail despite pleading the fifth all day long

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by bitexploder on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:27AM (#46887850)
That case also established 18 months as an upper limit. If you are in that situation it is usually better to simply jot divulge. Especially if there is incriminating evidence. Or you are a journalist being harassed by the DOJ. It can only bring you more pain. They will always find something.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by lm28469 on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:52AM (#46888210)
Yeah well that's what I'm saying... "just plead the fifth" is nice on paper, in practice you're going to suffer for a long time.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by lostlogin on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:14AM (#46887642)
> You cannot be forced to divulge the contents of your mind, including your pin or passwords.

Biometric data doesn’t need the password.

And good luck depending on the US constitution.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by stackghost on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:41AM (#46887178)
You're forgetting about the Constitution-Free Zone within 100 miles of all points of entry including international airports that covers essentially all of the 48.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by Zak on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:56AM (#46887398)
This is a misunderstanding. That's the area in which the border patrol has jurisdiction to can conduct very limited searches of vehicles and operate checkpoints without individualized suspicion in order to enforce immigration law. It does not allow searches of electronic devices.

There is a separate border search exception at the point a person actually enters the country which does allow searches of electronic devices. US citizens entering the country may refuse to provide access without consequences beyond seizure of the device; non-citizens could face adverse immigration actions.

To be clear, I do think all detentions and searches without individualized suspicion should be considered violations of the 4th amendment, but the phrase "constitution-free zone" is so broad as to be misleading.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by lostlogin on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:17AM (#46887681)
With ICE on the prowl, I’d have thought ‘Constitution Free Zone’ a fitting description of how they operate.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by bitexploder on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:48AM (#46887286)
I am not. You can still assert your rights at border points. It is very inconvenient. I have done it. If you are returning from international travel there is little they can do. If you are trying to leave the country they can make that difficult to impossible. Otherwise your rights still apply.
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by eduction on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:55AM (#46887388)
Completely separate decision with a higher legal bar for doing that.

It's one thing to allow police to search a phone. Another to compel someone to unlock the device.

We live in a world of grays and nuance and an "all or nothing" outlook on security discourages people from taking meaningful steps to protect themselves.

Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by frogcommander on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @10:46AM (#46887256)
Why are you on a website for programmers and software developers if you arent a software developer and you know nothing of the subject?
Re:FBI couldn't get into WaPo reporter's iPhone because Lock... by DamnInteresting on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:00AM (#46887454)
> What’s so hard to make 2-3 pins and each to access different logged in apps and files.

I've been advocating for this feature for years, as evidenced by this HN comment I made about 9 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13631653

Maybe someday.