News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by ungreased0675 on Monday January 19, 2026 @10:47AM (#46680275)
> Event studies around discrete tariff shocks on Brazil (50%) and India (25–50%) confirm: export prices did not decline. Trade volumes collapsed instead.

What if that was the intended result?

Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by philk10 on Monday January 19, 2026 @10:50AM (#46680300)
your question implies that the person in charge of tariffs has any idea of the effect of using them...
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by __s on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:44AM (#46681107)
I've heard this defence plenty from other Americans. & the campaign pushed "built in America" as a goal, so it seems likely the person in charge had this idea
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by philk10 on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:47AM (#46681155)
so as stupid an idea as the tariffs then
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by ta988 on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:06AM (#46680538)
What if the idea was to add a tax without calling it a tax so they would have more revenue to apply their plan?
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by the_gipsy on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:26AM (#46680830)
Or to tax the poor.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by nozzlegear on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:01AM (#46680450)
Bob Woodward's book Fear: Trump in the White House made it pretty clear that Trump (in his first term) either did not understand how trade works between countries or did not care. At the time he was singularly focused on "trade deficits," especially the one between the US and South Korea, because on paper it seemed like the US was "losing" or "being taken advantage of" by South Korea. That was all he cared about, reducing that trade deficit so the US came out on top.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by dyauspitr on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:57AM (#46681349)
Even if it was, the problem is that this is a classic trap where protecting your own market will result in overpriced goods in the home market. We would be paying extravagant amounts for everything. Most other countries wouldn’t have that problem and would result in being stuck in time like a lot of the former Soviet Union.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by carlosjobim on Monday January 19, 2026 @12:40PM (#46681983)
Why should something be cheaper to produce in China than in the United States or Europe?
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by dyauspitr on Monday January 19, 2026 @02:45PM (#46683546)
Labor laws, PPP and standard of living.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by carlosjobim on Monday January 19, 2026 @03:03PM (#46683768)
Then maybe it's morally right to tariff their goods? (As all countries already do, not only the US) Otherwise, what's the purpose of labor laws within the US or Europe?
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by dyauspitr on Monday January 19, 2026 @05:47PM (#46685617)
Economics doesn’t go well with gut feels or idealism.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by ChromaticPanic on Monday January 19, 2026 @02:03PM (#46683027)
Automation. Ability to innovate without made up IP BS .
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by speakfreely on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:08AM (#46680561)
It certainly was to anyone who has been paying attention. I would highly recommend that anyone who thinks the tariff strategy is irrational to read through Michael Kao's substack and his analysis of the administration's 2.0 playbook [1]. There's good news and bad news, but overall there's glimmers of hope.

[1] https://archive.ph/kLxw3

Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by nkmnz on Monday January 19, 2026 @02:12PM (#46683127)
How can one come to the conclusion that US consumers suffered from the US trade deficit with China? They’ve effectively received free stuff every single year, manufactured by Chinese workers, without paying them. I don’t get it.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by stavros on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:22AM (#46680768)
Isn't that exactly the point of tariffs? To decrease import volumes so local industry can fill the gap and compete?
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by rjrjrjrj on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:28AM (#46680853)
Not so much compete as being protected from having to compete.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by nathan_compton on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:44AM (#46681103)
Talking about competition between places with good labor standards and environmental regulation and places without those things is bullshit.

I would be 100% pro free trade between nations with identical labor rights and environmental protections, but that really isn't what free trade is about, is it?

Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by rjrjrjrj on Monday January 19, 2026 @12:22PM (#46681747)
The EU and Canada have better labor standards and environmental regulation than the US.

Perhaps the US should charge them negative tariffs until it gets up to snuff.

Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by dsr_ on Monday January 19, 2026 @10:51AM (#46680323)
Then it was a big win for Putin and his agent in the White House.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by diydsp on Monday January 19, 2026 @10:56AM (#46680383)
Ive done a lot of analysis on the Trump as Putin agent topic. I found he nearly as often acts agents Russia as with. What's more likely is he treats Putin as an inspiration, wrt to converting the country to an oligarchy and offshoring national funds for himself.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by bryanrasmussen on Monday January 19, 2026 @12:14PM (#46681613)
is the acting against Russia and against American interest, in a way that helps Russian interests, of equivocal effect?

For example if I shoot Batman in the back when he's fighting The Joker (because Batman is a vigilante so that's illegal, gotta take him down), and later make a statement to the press after Joker has been sent to Arkham "You know I think Arkham is a good place for that guy, he got what he deserved", I have acted for and against The Joker's interest, which is a good cover for me as an agent of The Joker.

I have often seen Trump doing stuff that is counter Russia's interests, but stuff that seems extremely weak sauce in contrast to weakening Nato, as just one example. It is spycraft 101 that you give your assets some simple stuff they can do against you, to make them seem trustworthy.

Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by Sharlin on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:04AM (#46680500)
Yeah. The idea that he's a Russian asset, although tempting, has always seemed to me like a coping mechanism of sorts – externalizing the evil, like blaming the devil for one's bad deeds.

And, of course, Hanlon's razor is very much relevant here, although certainly it doesn't apply to everybody in Trump's inner circle. Some of them are very much competent and malevolent.

Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by lobsterthief on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:33AM (#46680931)
Why not both?
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by enaaem on Monday January 19, 2026 @12:39PM (#46681970)
I found Vlad Vexler’s take interesting. Trump has a narcissistic personality disorder. Not a narcissistic trait that many elites have, but an actual disorder. He looks up to Putin and wants to bask in Putin’s glory to elevate himself.

[1] https://open.substack.com/pub/vladvexler/p/we-need-to-talk-a...

Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by quakeguy on Monday January 19, 2026 @10:58AM (#46680412)
*acts against
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by dboreham on Monday January 19, 2026 @12:27PM (#46681820)
Wrong. Never actually acts against Putin interests. Blusters a bit, for sure, but never acts.
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by sigmoid10 on Monday January 19, 2026 @03:54PM (#46684373)
Curious. Can you name a few instances where he intentionally acted against Russia and did not just throw around words without following them up?
Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by whodidntante on Monday January 19, 2026 @07:32PM (#46686480)
He is an equal opportunity a-hole, though my personal feeling is that he looks up to Putin, and wants to be like him

Some things he has done that Putin is probably not fond of:

Javelins in his first term, I believe that was the time the us supplied military weapons to Ukraine. These weapons made a big impact during the invasion

Tried to get Europe off of Russia gas, making very public warnings about depending on Russia. This was first term

Tried to get Europe to invest heavily in thru military, first and second term

Syria, Iran and Venezuela, all allies of Russia, especially Iran for military technology and Venezuela as part of its shadow fleet.

Sanctions

Re:Kiel Institute Analysis: US Americans pay 96% of tariff b... by sigmoid10 on Tuesday January 20, 2026 @05:38AM (#46690352)
Strongly disagree. If you look into the details, you'll find he never actually intentionally hurt Russia.

>Javelins in his first term, I believe that was the time the us supplied military weapons to Ukraine.

Trump was always reluctant about it and actually got himself into yet another impeachment inquiry for withholding part of this congressional aid package, because Zelenskyy did not want to investigate Hunter Biden. He wasn't able to overcome congress, but he did manage to limit Javelin use for western Ukraine only, were Russia was not active back then.

>Tried to get Europe off of Russia gas

That goes into the aforementioned category of things he said but never acted on. Russia caused Europe to actually move away from Russian gas in the end.

>Tried to get Europe to invest heavily in thru military

Same category and same answer. Could also be seen as his start of dismantling NATO from the inside, which seems to have been his (and ofc. Putin's) ultimate goal from the very beginning - which in turn dates back all the way to the 1980s, when Trump bought anti-NATO advertising in the New York Times after visiting Russia. So it's not even that far fetched to accuse him (or his handlers) of long term schemes.

>Syria

The US had troops there for a veeeery long time, but rarely threw hands with the regime under any US admin. After all, this was mostly about curbing IS. Putin apparently never really cared about Syria in the end either. They were just an alternate location for a warm water Navy port to them, which became obsolete once they took over Crimea. Assad got to feel that pretty hard.

>Iran

They were allied, but Iran actually started going against Russia in 2023 because Putin supported the UAE claim on the Strait of Hormuz. It's all been downhill since then and the eventual US military strike was definitely pro-Israel, not anti-Russia.

>and Venezuela

They literally halted the immediate seizure after one of those "shadow fleet" ships suddenly displayed a Russian Flag. This was always more about hurting Venezuela and they explicitly tried to handle Russia with appeasement.

>Sanctions

Not sure what you mean here. Safe for one pointless act on oil companies that were already heavily sanctioned, all relevant sanctions came under the Biden admin. He famously did not put tariffs on Russia, despite putting them on basically every other country in the world (allied or not).