News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by dralley on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:47PM (#46221758)
Targeted attacks against military/militia leadership is not terrorism - almost by definition.

If it was just random devices exploding, then sure, that could be considered terrorism. But it wasn't random devices, it was communication devices procured by Hezbollah and directly given by Hezbollah to their own members for their own purposes.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by zug_zug on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:55PM (#46221865)
Two things

Firstly, generals, like anybody else can be terrorized.

Secondly, even if you only kill generals, that doesn't mean you didn't cause terror for everybody else. Imagine for example that Hezbollah found a way to poison the food for Israel's top X military personnel. It would cause a state of emotional terror for many people in Israel about their food safety for decades most likely, even if they weren't in the military themselves.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by dralley on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:03PM (#46222003)
When Ukraine assassinates a Russian general with a car bomb, is that "terrorism" or is that just a targeted killing of a military leader during a war? Do you think this is somehow morally problematic beyond the typical standards of war?

Do you think that "normal" means of military action, like dropping a 500lb bomb, is less "terroristic" than essentially setting off a firecracker in their face/hands/pocket? Because, like, that's the alternative. If your position is that all forms of war are illegal, then you have the right to that opinion, but it's not a realistic position.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by mamonster on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:30PM (#46223333)
>When Ukraine assassinates a Russian general with a car bomb, is that "terrorism" or is that just a targeted killing of a military leader during a war?

That depends on when the car detonates. If the car detonates when he and his guard enter it at 6 am near the defense ministry sure. If the car detonates when it is parked in the middle of Moscow at noon and 100 people are around then by pre-2022 standards it would be terrorism.

I think instead of these fake whataboutisms we should just admit that there is no universal bar and if it's "our team" then we are willing to change the standard.

In this case, we know that when Israel set off these pagers some innocent bystanders got hurt. No need to "whatabout".

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by HappyPanacea on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:56PM (#46223707)
No it wouldn't, as long as the target is military and you didn't have opportunity to killed him in base it is fine. At most you could complain it is violates proportionality however no car bomb would kill 100 people. Not to mention your analogy is flawed - hezobllah doesn't have any marked bases.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by mamonster on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:24PM (#46224080)
>No it wouldn't, as long as the target is military and you didn't have opportunity to killed him in base it is fine.

"Opportunity to kill in base" is completely vague and varies depending on the military tribunal that will try you. Israel has, AFAIK, never said that there was no other way to kill those people.

>At most you could complain it is violates proportionality however no car bomb would kill 100 people.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mass_car_bombings

Plain disinformation

>Not to mention your analogy is flawed - hezobllah doesn't have any marked bases.

This line of thinking justifies bombing (with massive collateral damage) any partisan /resistance movement that is constantly on the move. Which I guess makes sense since that is what Israel did a lot in Gaza.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by raxxorraxor on Thursday December 11, 2025 @08:05AM (#46230883)
What massive collateral damage?
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by leksiso on Thursday December 11, 2025 @09:55AM (#46232122)
The posted article states 2800 people were injured in the first attack and 600 in the second. These numbers sound a bit questionable given only tens of people were killed. However, 3400 injured is massive collateral damage if true.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by impossiblefork on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:45PM (#46222656)
No. Generals are always legitimate military targets.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by zug_zug on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:59PM (#46222875)
So let me just understand your position here. Suppose the US declares war on Venezuela. Suppose a venezuelan living in America just looks up a bunch of US generals addresses online, and then sets all their houses on fire killing them in their sleep in their McMansions in suburbia.

Are you saying that's a valid military strike, and therefore can't possibly be terrorism? Suppose this person is so successful he kills 1,000 and generals and numerous quit their jobs and move in fear for their life, just to really clarify what you're arguing here.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by bjelkeman-again on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:20PM (#46223180)
I think it is a valid military strike if a Venezuelan soldier does it on an order. Military targets where a strike are in danger of killing civilians are a hard judgment call. Generally one should never risk targeting civilians. Military law is a complex subject and officers spend quite a lot of time being educated in it. Here is a Swedish defence college course on it. https://www.fhs.se/en/swedish-defence-university/courses/int...
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by impossiblefork on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:29PM (#46223314)
I'm pretty sure even that is allowed, yes.

Obviously he must wear a uniform while actually conducting the attack though.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by MrMorden on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:29PM (#46226942)
If he wants to be treated as a POW rather than a spy should he be captured.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by simmerup on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:57PM (#46223734)
That would be fine, it's war, and Venzeula would have to deal with the consequences also
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by stackedinserter on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:08PM (#46223873)
That's a valid military strike, period.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by adolph on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:34PM (#46223378)
> Suppose a venezuelan living in America just looks up a bunch of US generals addresses online, and then sets all their houses on fire killing them in their sleep in their McMansions in suburbia.

I don't think the analogy is apt. Members of Hezbollah do not occupy a positions of similar relationship to Lebanon as US generals does to the US. As far as I've heard, flag officers and others are escorted by personal security for an attack of any sort, such as the 2009 Ft Hood shooting. [0]

Moving past that, a civilian citizen of Venezuela in the US who performed actions against US military targets would not be a valid military strike since that person would not be an identifiable member or Venezuela's military. It would more akin to a spy or assassin. Below is an excerpt from an article representing a US-centric view of history [1].

  But the right to kill one’s enemy during war was not considered wholly 
  unregulated. During the 16th century, Balthazar Ayala agreed with Saint 
  Augustine’s contention that it “is indifferent from the standpoint of justice 
  whether trickery be used” in killing the enemy, but then distinguished 
  trickery from “fraud and snares” (The Law and Duties of War and Military 
  Discipline). Similarly, Alberico Gentili, writing in the next century, found 
  treachery “so contrary to the law of God and of Nature, that although I may 
  kill a man, I may not do so by treachery.” He warned that treacherous killing 
  would invite reprisal (Three Books on the Law of War). And Hugo Grotius 
  likewise explained that “a distinction must be made between assassins who 
  violate an express or tacit obligation of good faith, as subjects resorting 
  to violence against a king, vassals against a lord, soldiers against him whom 
  they serve, those also who have been received as suppliants or strangers or 
  deserters, against those who have received them; and such as are held by no 
  bond of good faith” (On the Law of War and Peace).
  
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_Fort_Hood_shooting

1. https://lieber.westpoint.edu/assassination-law-of-war/

Edit: /Hamas/Hezbollah/

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Zanfa on Thursday December 11, 2025 @02:57AM (#46228792)
Are you implying military personnel aren't a legitimate target in a war?

I'd understand if you were arguing against using excessive force, eg using thermobaric weapons in residential neighborhoods against an individual target, but there hardly exists a more targeted method than the pager attack / arson of specific houses.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by chasil on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:25PM (#46223259)
The Geneva Convention ought to have something to say about how a general may and may not be attacked.

If I remember correctly, the assailant must be dressed in some sort of military uniform to be considered a prisoner of war if captured. Lacking the uniform, it would be espionage and no Geneva Convention rights.

Obviously, neither side in the conflict is adhering to these rules.

I should give this a read:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geneva_Conventions

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jack_tripper on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:23PM (#46224059)
>The Geneva Convention ought to have something to say about how a general may and may not be attacked.

Except nobody in power actually gives a damn about the Geneva convention or the "laws of war" being thrown around in this topic.

Those laws were made up so that victorious powers can bully smaller countries when they lose a war, but superpower nations themselves don't have to abide by them because there's nobody more powerful than them to hold them accountable when they break those rules. Because laws aren't real, it's only the enforcement that is real.

Like the US also doesn't care about the Geneva Convention with all its warmongering and crimes against humanity in the middle east, and the torturing in Guantanamo Bay, and the likes of George Bush and Tony Blair will never see a day at the ICJ. Hell, not even US marines accused of using civilians for target practices in Afghanistan got to see a day at the Hague because the US said they'd invade the Hague if that happened. Russia also doesn't care about the Geneva convention and Putin won't see a day at the Hague. Israel doesn't give a crap about the geneva convention when bombing Palestinian hospitals, and Netanyahu won't see a day at the Hague. And if China invaded Taiwan, they won't care about the Geneva convention and Xi Jinping will never see the Hague. Trump can invade Venezuela tomorrow, and same, nothing will happen to him or the US.

THAT IS THE REALITY, that is how the world really works, dominance by the strong, subservience of the weak, everything else about laws, fairness, morality, etc only works in Tolkien tales and internet arguments, not in major international conflicts.

Edit: to the downvoters, could you also explain what part of what I said was wrong?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by fireflash38 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:23PM (#46224768)
There are indeed actors who only respect might. That is not universal. Preaching might is right is also not universal.

It is still important to have might even if you aren't in that camp because inevitably you will run into people with that worldview and they cannot be reasoned with without might.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jack_tripper on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:45PM (#46225053)
Military might is the thing keeping the USD the world reserve currency instead of the GBP, EUR or Yuan. It's literally the core keeping the US economy and prosperity.

And things don't have to be universal to be true, but just one leader/nation bombing or abusing the shit out of you is all you need to teach you this lesson, and waving the Geneva convention in their face won't help you.

The real world is harsh, unfair and unjust and pieces of paper named after European cities don't change that. A barrel in your hand pointed at them does. The ability to use force is the only thing in history that was guaranteed to change things in your favor.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Sabinus on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:32AM (#46228318)
>Military might is the thing keeping the USD the world reserve currency instead of the GBP, EUR or Yuan. It's literally the core keeping the US economy and prosperity.

No it's not. The size of the American economy, it's extensive trade, the independence of the Central Bank and the rule of law and commitment to paying debts do that. Americans do not force anyone to trade in USD.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by raxxorraxor on Thursday December 11, 2025 @08:14AM (#46230975)
That is naive, it is much more about the US hegemony and mainly about their military might. I would be good to sometimes reach such a state, but as of today it is not.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Supermancho on Thursday December 11, 2025 @12:42PM (#46234513)
>>Military might is the thing keeping the USD the world reserve currency instead of the GBP, EUR or Yuan. It's literally the core keeping the US economy and prosperity.

> No it's not. The size of the American economy, it's extensive trade, the independence of the Central Bank and the rule of law and commitment to paying debts do that. Americans do not force anyone to trade in USD.

The OP is correct, historically. US might, albeit aimed at anyone attempting to disrupt trade, WAS the basis for US hegemony. The US effectively policed the largest oceans, ensuring world trade was reliable and cost-stabilized since WW2. As long as you dealt in USD, you were supported. A type of soft influence that was very effective.

This has been disrupted recently. The US has declined to re-invest in the navy (ship construction has almost bottomed out), routed most of the navy to east asia, and antagonized other nations by disrupting agreements that could have sustained on momentum. This year's farming subsidy (to the tune of 12 billion) is due to those abandoned agreements, paired with unnecessary antagonism.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jack_tripper on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:30PM (#46235091)
>The size of the American economy

And how did the American economy get to that size without the military protecting it from IDK, the USSR just taking it?

>As long as you dealt in USD, you were supported.

And what happened to you if you wanted to trade with the USSR? You're omitting that part

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by Supermancho on Thursday December 11, 2025 @05:45PM (#46238387)
>> The size of the American economy

> And how did the American economy get to that size without the military protecting it from IDK, the USSR just taking it?

The US hegemony successfully strangled the USSR leading to the current Russian oligarchy (with a dictator at the top). The USSR never found itself in a position to expand its borders without threatening an internal insurrection, a coup, and/or the extermination of most of the military forces in a single conflict. US funded the rebuilding of Europe as part of the manufactured hegemony, allowing free trade to supply europe with cheap goods and workers safely across the waters, or under strict supervision of US intelligence for deals with the USSR and the rest of Asia. The USSR wasn't part of these agreement negotiations per se. They had to deal with their own internal politics and manufacturing limitations, while negotiating with countries that had a veto-enabled silent partner.

TBH, I have no idea what people are talking about when are implying "the American economy" is large. It's 8% of world pop and is largely an exporter of natural resources. The strength of the US economy is the reliability of the bond market. The USSR had no chance of taking the US, but did meaningfully threaten the security of the US during the cuban missile crisis. USSR was considered a credible threat to most of Europe for the duration of the cold war, in a carefully structured scenario of mutual destruction.

> And what happened to you if you wanted to trade with the USSR? You're omitting that part

World politics is not as simple as cause and effect. Many countries did deal with embargoed/sanctioned countries, including the US - notably the sale of grain to the USSR during the 70s. If you wanted first crack at new trade deals or wanted security guarantees from the US for delicate trade deals, you had to make allowances according to US wishes. Germany made it clear that they were going to purchase natural gas from the USSR as a matter of their own energy security. The US made an allowance. Maybe one US partner attacked another (Iraq vs Kuwait), the US would step in militarily. You wanted to sell oil to Russia? Sanctions or embargoes or worse, you were not able to call on the US navy when your shipping lanes were disrupted. Maybe the US called on some pirates regularly to raid your ships, maybe not. Thems the breaks, mafia style.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by reissbaker on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:04PM (#46222030)
Terrorism doesn't mean "anything that makes someone scared," or else all wars would be acts of terrorism.

There isn't a universally agreed upon definition, but generally it refers to targeting non-combatants: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorism

For example, when the Allies tried to assassinate Hitler with a smuggled briefcase bomb during WW2, that wasn't terrorism: that was just regular warfare. Hitler was the leader of Germany and directed its military.

Similarly, smuggling pager bombs to members of Hezbollah generally wouldn't qualify as terrorism, since Hezbollah a) is a militia (famously it's the largest non-state militia in the world), and b) was actively fighting a war against Israel — a war that Hezbollah themselves initiated.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by zug_zug on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:51PM (#46222750)
So you're arguing if the US declared war on Venezuela, that Venezuela could just use a drone to blow up the US president and that's just how war should work from now on?

Because it's only a matter of years until drones get small and stealthy enough that nobody is safe; exploding pagers are a clear first step in this direction.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by reissbaker on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:50PM (#46223636)
While I'm only adding to the choir of people telling you "of course," since I'm directly the person you're responding to it still feels worth saying: yes, of course, if America and Venezuela went to war, it's completely legal for Venezuela to attempt to kill the U.S. President.

As an American, I certainly hope they would fail. But do I think it's legal? Yes: it's a targeted strike on the leader of an enemy country they'd theoretically be at war with. Do I think it's wise? Well — no, Venezuela has a much smaller military, and assassinating the U.S. President would trigger a massive war that would devastate Venezuela for decades while modestly inconveniencing American taxpayers. But legal? Yes.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by zug_zug on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:45AM (#46233692)
Well you need to actually think about what you're saying here. Suppose for example China/Israel/whoever is the first to invent really, really great drones (like the size of a bird or even a bumblebee) that are lethal.

So then China could, at any point, call up the US president and say "Look there's a drone in the room with you right now. Shut down all your nuclear facilities or I hereby declare war and you're dead within 10 seconds." Then failing that they could hit the VP next, Secretary of state, etc etc.

Point being the idea of sticking with WW2 "rules" with current and future technology is laughably implausible.

And I guarantee you the citizens of Israel would NOT think it's perfectly legit, legal, and fair if Netenyahu got assassinated with a drone along with his military commanders.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by reissbaker on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:27PM (#46240557)
I don't care whether the citizens of Israel would think it's legal. It's not terrorism if you're at war to attack enemy combatants or their leaders, and that goes for any side in a war: whether you're Israel, Iran, China, America, Russia, Ukraine, whoever. That's just how war goes. There's no point to the term "terrorism" if it just means killing enemy combatants or leaders: it's duplicative of the term "war." What do you think war entails?

If your opponent has way better weapons technology than you: well, it sucks to be on the losing side. But you are, and that's how war goes sometimes. That's what happened to Japan, and the Mayans. If one side has guns and the other has obsidian spears, there's no law that the side with guns has to drop them on the ground because it's unfair to the stone-age side.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tguvot on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:05PM (#46240769)
actuall hezbollah did crash drone into netanyahy private residence (scratched windows) and iran tried to blow up secretary of defense with ied.

there was 0 discussion about "legit, legal and fair". the only discussion that took place it's that security measures need to be improved to prevent things like this in future.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by phantasmish on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:35PM (#46223395)
They could do that now and it might be legal under international laws of war.

We've massed forces for an attack, attacked their ships, violated their airspace with combat aircraft (that's today), and extensively and publicly threatened them. They'd be in their legal rights to strike preemptively, including possibly a decapitation strike (this is why the Dubya administration kept repeating the term "preemptive strike", even though it was obviously nowhere near applying in the case of Iraq—it was a way of asserting its legal basis)

[edit] As thereisnospork points out in a sibling comment, however, this doesn't mean it'd be a good idea.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by pbalau on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:01PM (#46222904)
If US and Venezuela are in a state of war, then the head of the US Armed Forces is a legitimate target.

Not sure why you have doubts about this.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by zoklet-enjoyer on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:29PM (#46223315)
The US and Israel do the equivalent of that and have been for years. An assassination is an assassination. The weapon makes little difference.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by thereisnospork on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:01PM (#46222920)
I mean of course they could, and should[0] how is that a question?

[0] Shouldn't - classic example of a tactical win being a strategic blunder. Killing the American president and would solidify American public support for the war - which would probably be undesirable in the balance.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by juntoalaluna on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:00PM (#46222891)
I can’t reply to zugzug underneath (is there a maximum comment depth), but it feels pretty obvious that the US President is a very legitimate target in any war with the US. Maybe the most legitimate target.

Good luck trying to get them though.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by hersko on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:45PM (#46222648)
> Firstly, generals, like anybody else can be terrorized.

You know terrorism doesn't mean people were terrorized, right? Surely you understand that.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:12PM (#46224650)
No, generals in an operational military force are definitionally combatants, and cannot in fact be "terrorized".
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by sysguest on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @11:02PM (#46227505)
this

why is that guy trying to fight against dictionary-definition of "terrorism"?

where did "intentionally creating a state of terror == terrorism" come from?

making up word definitions to win arguments?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by raxxorraxor on Thursday December 11, 2025 @07:51AM (#46230758)
Hezbollah is an organization that tries to destroy Israel. If any law doesn't have an answer to that problem, it isn't worth to discuss legality.

But that isn't the problem here, luckily. It was an extremely targeted operation, generals are military target and know the risks of war. A war that they started in this case.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by lm28469 on Thursday December 11, 2025 @07:51AM (#46230759)
> Firstly, generals, like anybody else can be terrorized.

This isn't part of any modern definition of terrorism, otherwise war is terrorism, stalking is terrorism, bullying is terrorism &c.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:17PM (#46222209)
The issue is that Israel has no idea where those pagers were at the time of the attack, civilians were directly hurt by the explosions: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/survivors-of-israels-page...
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by hersko on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:13PM (#46223085)
You think you are not allowed to do a military strike if civilians may be hurt?
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:34PM (#46224198)
Your comment is nonsense. What do you mean by “allowed”? Who is enforcing the rules of what is “allowed” and what isn’t? The fact is that Israel carried out an attack that severely harmed civilians. The question is whether it was targeted or whether it constitutes terrorism.

My claim is that since Israel could not have possibly known who was in possession of the pagers at the time of the attack, and since the attack occurred regardless of who was nearby—detonating all pagers in civilian-occupied areas—Israel did, in effect, target civilians.

If you attack a military target that is surrounded by civilians, and that attack injures or kills those civilians, then those civilians were also targeted. Do you think all that matters is who the primary target was, and that as long as Israel decides the civilian casualties were “worth it,” the decision is moral?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by rat87 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:46PM (#46227061)
> did, in effect, target civilians.

That's ridiculous

> If you attack a military target that is surrounded by civilians, and that attack injures or kills those civilians, then those civilians were also targeted.

They are not targeted.

You could say that depending on number of innocent casualties or the likely number the attacked could be reckless and/or disproportionate in attacking in a way that was likely to cause such injuries. In certain cases you could claim they broke the laws of war although the laws of war are practical (they're not meant to prevent all deaths of civilians, the countries who agreed to them didn't intentionally make it impossible to fight including in defense).

And even if something is not a war crime you could still claim it might be immoral but that is a more complex argument.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:52PM (#46227101)
I agree with your last point, but tbh, the exact idea of "targeted" is splitting hairs IMO. I'm not arguing that civilians were the primary target, but not caring that they were around, and being fine with their death as long as the combatant was dead, in my view makes it seem that Israel's enemies are not the combatants of Hezbollah, but generally just the Lebanese people.

If someone droped a nuke on a city to kill 1 person, does it matter who that person was specifically targeting? Does the distinction if his intended target matter at all? I would think you and I would agree that obviously it doesn't matter at that point, but then I ask, at what point does that distinction matter?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by rat87 on Saturday December 13, 2025 @08:37PM (#46260074)
It's not splitting hairs it gets to the point when people falsely accuse them of every single thing in the book. Weapons have always been imprecise but things that don't have any benefit to the war effort and target innocent civilian deaths are war crimes. You may ask how much the difference matters morally(it still does matter a lot intent it rule based vs consequences based morality systems I'd argue for somewhere in between) but yes targeting matters when it comes to usually false claims of crimes

They do care about not killing civilians the question is how much? And is that enough? There will almost never be any operation near cities without civilian casualties.

This particular operation was an extremely Targeted operation that included tricking Hezbollah into selling pagers meant for Hezbollah internal military use and only deploying small explosions minimizing any unnecessary casualties.

It's not a very good piece of rhetoric asking about nukes because Israel actually has nukes. They didn't use them.

They have carried out other heavier strikes on Lebanon that had worse ratios but were justified by military targets such as Hezbollah leader Nasrallah.

Your suggestion also seems to totally not understand how Israelis view Lebanon. Until recently and still Lebanon does not control violence within it's borders. Hezbollah (a militia/terrorist group that takes orders from Iran) was more powerful then the Lebanese army and decided what happened on the ground. Iran which had a countdown clock counting down to the destruction of Israel. Of course they were supposed to be disarmed after the Lebanese but unsurprisingly the UN resolution didn't have any effect so when they attacked and threatened to invade Israel did what they could to take them out. Israel would love to have peace with Lebanon but that's not likely if Iran and Hezbollah have anything to do with it.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:19PM (#46224723)
Israel had in fact very clear intelligence that the specific pagers they were detonating were overwhelmingly going to be in the custody of combatants. This was very probably the most precisely targeted large-scale military strike of the last 100 years. That's not a value judgement; it's a descriptive claim.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @07:55PM (#46226282)
Twelve civilians killed and 4,000 injured does not indicate a precise attack.

There is no credible figure for the number of combatants killed or injured. The Times of Israel reported that 1,500 fighters were injured. Taking these two data points together, a majority of those injured were civilians rather than combatants.

Where are you getting the claim that this was “probably the most precisely targeted large-scale military strike of the last 100 years”? That is a far-reaching assertion, especially given the lack of sources.

You say this is not a value judgment but a descriptive claim, yet the claim does not appear to be backed by facts.

(The 4000 figure) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_Lebanon_electronic_device... (The 1500 figure) https://www.timesofisrael.com/a-year-on-some-lebanese-bystan... (General HRW source) https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/09/18/lebanon-exploding-pagers...

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @08:02PM (#46226339)
Right, if in fact 1500 Hezbollah fighters were injured, any claim that over 1500 noncombatants were injured is suspicious. We have video footage of the explosions (along with a directional sense of the wounded vs. KIA count of the strike). It is not plausible that more noncombatants were injured than combatants, given the pagers were strictly military comms devices.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:21PM (#46226899)
Both the 1500 and 4000 number were confirmed by Lebanon, and no reputable watch organization has credibly disputed them, you're not citing evidence just conjecture on how you believe everything went down due to a relative small bits of information.

> along with a directional sense of the wounded vs. KIA count of the strike

I am not sure what this means.

To add, you're making it impossible to argue anything against your claim. We're discussing how the pagers hurt civilians and if they were properly targetting combatants. You're saying no matter what, since you know the pager was targetting combatants, the evidence that civilians were hurt must be false. Your logic circular.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by juliusdavies on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:45PM (#46227054)
Do you want some deeply studied anthropological journal article on “The use of pagers in Lebanese society “?

Do you know of any civilians anywhere in the world that currently use pagers?

Who had the pagers and why they had the pagers is almost derivable from first principles at this point, never mind the international journalism on the subject.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:46PM (#46227063)
I'm not deriving who had the pagers from first principles. They were military pagers, on a military network that Hezbollah fought an actual civil war to establish and maintain, with subverted devices that Hezbollah itself acquired directly. There's a lot of reporting on this. Israel did not booby trap the whole supply of pagers into Lebanon. The Hezbollah combatants carrying these pagers did not acquire them at a Beirut Cellular Retail Outlet.

Another way to say this is that if you have evidence/reporting suggesting that Israel did in fact set explosives in pagers that were broadly available to Lebanese civilians, my argument falls apart.

I think Hezbollah is inexcusably evil, far worse than Israel is, but I'm not particularly interested in defending Israeli governance; I have no commitment to the proposition that Israel doesn't commit atrocities (in fact, I think they commit rather many of them). So I'm fine with my argument collapsing; I'm just waiting for evidence to topple it. The trouble the preceding commenter is having with me is that I can't find a story that squares the circle of the numbers they're trying to present.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @10:04PM (#46227170)
It’s almost like explosives… explode, and hit the people and surroundings near them. Shrapnel travels. You’re trying to derive who had the pagers from first principles, yet you don’t seem to understand how a bomb actually works.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @10:25PM (#46227294)
(1) We have videos of the explosions and their scale.

(2) We have Hezbollah's own claims about how many of their fighters were actually killed.

(3) We have Hezbollah's own photographs of scores of injured Hezbollah fighters --- people not blown apart from the explosions, further backing a claim that all sides to the conflict are making (far more casualties than KIA).

(4) We know how small the pagers were (indeed, exactly what pagers they were) and what the explosive was.

To the extent Lebanon is reporting higher civilian casualties than Hezbollah fighter casualties, the balance of evidence is that at least one of two things is happening: either Hezbollah is dramatically understating its own casualties, or Lebanon is dramatically overstating civilian casualties.

later

(Or we're just misreading the statistics! Pretty normal outcome for a message board discussion!)

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @10:41PM (#46227390)
Further:

You, reasonably, cautioned against axiomatic reasoning --- I do feel like I'm bringing quite a bit of empiricism into this, though I am rejecting the ratio of casualties we're attributing to Lebanese and Hezbollah reporting --- so let me add a couple more empirical observations:

* We have reporting (Reuters, others) that the pagers were packed with 6 grams of PETN.

* 6 grams of PETN produces ~35kJ of explosive force.

* That's about 7x more powerful than a cherry bomb, or about 2% of the explosive force of a standard fragmentation grenade.

Later

In considering that yield statistic bear in mind also that the lethality of an M67 (lethal within 5m, casualties within 15m, well studied) is mostly a function of its construction --- its explosive charge, 50x greater than that of 6g of PETN, is designed specifically to propel fragments of a hardened steel case out through its blast radius.

The pagers were just pagers, with the explosive payload specifically designed not to have metal components (which would have been detectable by Hezbollah.)

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by UltraSane on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @11:57PM (#46227834)
The bomb in the pagers was so weak it could only harm someone directly holding it or if it was in a pocket.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @12:15AM (#46227928)
I think we have in fact pretty strong reporting that at least 2 children were killed, and while the explosions and payload were nowhere nearly as devastating as a grenade, they were still much bigger than a firework mortar (which themselves have killed children).

I think a stronger argument is that in the aggregate, the devices overwhelmingly targeted combatants.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by UltraSane on Thursday December 11, 2025 @03:52AM (#46229089)
The 2 kids killed picked up their dad's pager.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Thursday December 11, 2025 @09:01AM (#46231458)
There are videos where the surrounding people were hurt by the pagers, so, what's the explaination for that?
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @09:39AM (#46231931)
I'm sure those exist --- it has never been my claim there there were zero or even just few civilian casualties --- but the videos I've seen had people standing next to the person carrying the pager walking away, startled but apparently unharmed. The explosions were quite small (I quantified them downthread from what Reuters reported).
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by UltraSane on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:54AM (#46233820)
Please provide links to these videos because every video I saw showed only the person holding the pager getting hurt. They only had 6 grams of explosives.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by PepperdineG on Thursday December 11, 2025 @09:08AM (#46231526)
>Do you know of any civilians anywhere in the world that currently use pagers?

Dennis Duffy, but he is the Beeper King.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:44PM (#46227041)
No, it isn't.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46227021

(If you want to reply to that argument, can I ask that you do it on that leg of the thread, just to keep the thread simpler? Thanks!)

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by oa335 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:34PM (#46226964)
Do you have any sources at all for your assertion “This was very probably the most precisely targeted large-scale military strike of the last 100 years”? It is hard to engage with your statement in any reasonable fashion without knowing where you are getting your information.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by unyttigfjelltol on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @10:20PM (#46227273)
Here is an excellent and HN-worthy writeup of the argument for legality, and the counterargument that it was an improper booby trap.[1] It seems to me most of the polarizarion on this board could have been avoided had the original article recognized (as does the one linked here) "that the legality or illegality of the pagers attack can only be determined on the basis of a detailed factual analysis and that the relevant facts are still not fully known."

I disagree with @dang's decision to leave the original link up, as it is nearly valuless in framing this discussion.

[1] https://lieber.westpoint.edu/well-it-depends-explosive-pager...

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by dang on Thursday December 11, 2025 @12:13AM (#46227916)
> I disagree with @dang's decision to leave the original link up, as it is nearly valuless in framing this discussion

I'm open to replacing it with a better link, but the one you've listed here (even though it's a much more in-depth article) isn't about this specific topic.

I found https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/israel-used-palantir-its-... by googling. Is it better than OP?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @12:22AM (#46227956)
No, they're basically the same, and this Substack has some additional primary source material the MEE piece doesn't (MEE and this Substack have approximately the same editorial slant).

For whatever it's worth I think it's fine that the resource posted in that comment just makes it an especially valuable comment, without altering the story itself.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @10:45PM (#46227411)
This is really good. (As you say, it's mostly framing the question, rather than settling on a final disposition).
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @09:42PM (#46227021)
Just start from the premise that Israel targeted exclusively handheld military comms devices that would in ordinary practice only be in the custody of Hezbollah combatants, and from the additional premise that the explosions in the strikes were relatively small, so small that the overwhelming majority of the Hezbollah casualties were wounded and not KIA. Then try to make another story make sense.

We have significant evidence for both these premises!

This is not an argument that the strike incurred no civilian casualty, that no child of a Hezbollah combatant was in close proximity when one of the bombs went off, anything like that. It's rather a sanity check on arguments based on statistical claims about the casualties. There might have been quite a lot of civilian casualties! But for there to have been significantly more of them than combatant casualties, I would argue that you have to break one of my two premises.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @10:01PM (#46227150)
Premise 1: The pagers were military devices, but based on what we know about them, it is impossible to assert that all were in the custody of Hezbollah combatants at the moment they exploded. One would need to prove that the pagers were physically on the combatants’ persons—and not, for example, sitting on a coffee table or elsewhere—at the time of detonation.

Premise 2: The physical location of the pagers directly affects the pattern of civilian injuries. Hospitals reported that many of the injured were civilians, including children, women, and non-combatants who were at home, at work, or in public areas. Even pro-Israel outlets, such as the Times of Israel, reported the same distribution of casualties.

Footage from Reuters, Al Jazeera, AP, and local Lebanese reporters shows numerous injured civilians with bandaged hands and faces, including people hurt inside homes, markets, farms, and workplaces, as well as children with hand and facial burns.

Now I would pose the question to you, why is your (likely novice) understanding of explosives and the footage you seen enough to overwrite the opinions of the hospitals and government of Lebanon?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @10:03PM (#46227166)
Premise 1: I accept that they could have been on coffee tables! The problem isn't that I'm sure every pager was in a combatant pocket; it's that they were microcharges (we have videographic evidence!), and unless most of the pagers were for whatever reason not on hand to a combatant but rather for some reason close to a civilian, the Lebanese civilian/combatant casualty figures can't be made to make sense.

Premise 2 just repeats Premise 1, from what I can tell.

The footage argument doesn't rebut any claim I made. You're treating this as if it's an argument that the pager strike was clean, or even morally justifiable; I have made neither claim.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by richardfeynman on Thursday December 11, 2025 @12:02AM (#46227867)
Premise 2 is false. The vast majority of the injured were Hezbollah terrorists. You say The Times of Israel reported "many of the injured were civilians, including children, women, and non-combatant" - show me a source, please.

It's also false that footage shows numerous injured civilians with bandaged hands and faces. Again, show a credible source and explain how this happened to them.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Thursday December 11, 2025 @08:58AM (#46231429)
Cmon man, there are sources pasted all over this thread from my discussion with OP. I'm not going to post the same source that was already discussed with him, why would I waste my time to do so?

OP did split this chain, but a sibling comment has the sources you want.

EDIT: Getting downvoted because I didn't want to paste the same source N times. Nice.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by UltraSane on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @11:54PM (#46227824)
Israel was able to monitor communications on the pagers for years and this allowed them to be quite certain of who they were targeting.

"Footage from Reuters, Al Jazeera, AP, and local Lebanese reporters shows numerous injured civilians"

How do you know they were civilians?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Thursday December 11, 2025 @08:59AM (#46231440)
How do YOU know they were terrorist? What would you call people who were around the individual with that pagers?
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by UltraSane on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:56AM (#46233846)
They weren't terrorists they were Hezbollah members during a time when Hezbollah was shooting thousands of missiles at Israel that forced 60,000 people to evacuate. This made them fair targets. The pagers contained about grams of explosives which only injured the person holding it.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @09:28AM (#46231801)
Mostly, "uninjured".
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:40AM (#46232741)
So, we established that there were injuries among people surrounding those with the pagers. Therefore, the parent comment’s claim was false — the explosions could hurt people nearby and weren’t small enough to affect only the combatant.

My other points still stand, but it’s strange to me that the argument seems to go (not necessarily from you, but from other commenters above):

The explosions were too small to hurt others, so the reported number of civilians injured must be false.

We see that the explosions did hurt civilians.

Well, only a small fraction — the numbers must still be false.

Can you see how this is moving the goalposts? The argument shifted from “the explosives were so precise that Israel must have known exactly who was targeted, and those injured were combatants,” to, in the grandparent comment:

How do you know they were civilians?

Now we see that civilians were present and injured. Perhaps you're correct that the videos show only a small number, but the videos still confirm the core point: civilians were harmed.

@tptacek, I don’t have a problem discussing this with you, but each thread you respond to splits off into new points I have to address. It feels like arguing with two people making contradictory claims.

I’ll leave you with this: the videos show only a minority of the pager detonations. Civilian injuries are most reliably known by Lebanese hospitals and government sources. The idea of detonating explosives in civilian-populated areas without knowing who is immediately around those devices is deeply problematic. And there is no way Israel could have known who would be harmed with any reasonable certainty; the reported numbers only reinforce that fact.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by UltraSane on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:58AM (#46233880)
"we established that there were injuries among people surrounding those with the pagers"

No we haven't. You haven't provided any proof.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by jackling on Friday December 12, 2025 @11:12AM (#46245505)
Sources show, the source commenter I was discussing with in this thread agreed, why are you challenging this that were established in the thread? Why are you insisting that we don't use the context in the thread to continue discussion?
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by UltraSane on Saturday December 13, 2025 @09:43AM (#46254849)
He never provided any evidence. Every video of a pager explosion I saw showed it only injuring the person holding it. The amount of explosives in the pagers was so small it would be unlikely for it to harm bystanders much if at all.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:47AM (#46232824)
I'm not moving the goalposts. Instead, what I'm pretty sure is happening is that you see this as an argument about whether the strike was good or justified. I don't. I'm not interested in that question, which will never, ever be resolved on a message board. I'm just interested in getting the clearest picture of what actually did happen.

Most of this comment is you arguing points that I don't disagree with. The one place we're clearly not aligned is your belief that there were more civilian casualties (or even a comparable number of civilian casualties) than combatant casualties. I've argued, at length and with specific details, as to why that doesn't seem possible, regardless of what Lebanon or Hezbollah reports. If you want to keep hashing this out, that's probably the place where there's something to actually discuss.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by blks on Thursday December 11, 2025 @05:42AM (#46229794)
They knew who purchased those devices. Did they know that at the moment of detonation only military personnel had those devices on them? Military propaganda of course will nod at “intelligence” to defend any actions in public, as there is no way to prove these statements.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tstrimple on Thursday December 11, 2025 @02:25AM (#46228619)
Zionists don't care about civilian casualties. It's extremely well documented. They even defend the explicit rape of their "prisoners". They will just explain them away as Hamas sympathizers and people will shrug their shoulders and move on.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by richardfeynman on Thursday December 11, 2025 @03:35AM (#46228994)
I, like roughly 90% of the world's jews, am a zionist and I care about civilian casualties. In fact, I don't know a single zionist who doesn't care about civilian casualties. You just made up this racist nonsense, and your comment is totally inappropriate for HN.

What is true is that I'd deny allegations about civilian casualties that I think are false, but that would be because I think they're false, nothing to do with zionism.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tstrimple on Sunday December 14, 2025 @12:02AM (#46260870)
Sure you do. Just like MAGA voters who are suffering from the decisions from their vote "didn't vote for this". Except you explicitly did. Zionism necessarily removes land and homes from people to carve out a "safe space" for Jews without any consideration for the generations you're fucking over. Just like you conveniently ignore the decades of "settlers" taking over other people's land. Just like you ignore the destruction of Palestinian wells and hospitals. Just like you ignore the rape of prisoners and the celebration among Zionists for it. It's a nasty belief system that puts Jews above other humans. It is explicitly bigoted and xenophobic and it is proudly announced and broadcast throughout Israeli society.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/israel-hamas-war-idf-palestinia...

> A member of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's Likud party, speaking Monday at a meeting of lawmakers, justified the rape and abuse of Palestinian prisoners, shouting angrily at colleagues questioning the alleged behavior that anything was legitimate to do to "terrorists" in custody.

> Lawmaker Hanoch Milwidsky was asked as he defended the alleged abuse whether it was legitimate, "to insert a stick into a person's rectum?"

> "Yes!" he shouted in reply to his fellow parliamentarian. "If he is a Nukhba [Hamas militant], everything is legitimate to do! Everything!"

That is what you are defending. It's fucking disgusting.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by raxxorraxor on Thursday December 11, 2025 @08:17AM (#46230995)
Some Zionists are some crazy people, some others might have learned from their enemies. Some just want Israel to exist. Some people just dislike Jews.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ignoramous on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:30PM (#46223324)
> Targeted attacks against military/militia leadership is not terrorism - almost by definition.

I mean, you're not wrong: the State seeks monopoly on violence; the kind of damages it can inflict, where, when and however it wants. Everyone else is ... a terrorist, and whatever they do is ... terrorism.

> communication devices procured by Hezbollah and directly given by Hezbollah

Replace "Hezbollah" with "the US Govt" and you'll arrive at some answer.

Btw, off-duty / non-combat personnel aren't deemed to be "at war".

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:27PM (#46224815)
The reason foreign military organizations don't routinely target active duty US military generals isn't that they're worried about being dragged into some mostly-fictitious courtroom to answer for their misdeeds. It's that the United States armed forces will very quickly reduce their entire organization, and much of the surrounding area, to its combustion products.

There aren't a lot of opportunities in life you get to use the word "annihilatory"; this is one of them. And in the immortal words of William Munny out of Missouri: "deserve's" got nothing to do with it.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ignoramous on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @08:05PM (#46226355)
> US military ... worried about being dragged into some mostly-fictitious courtroom to answer for their misdeeds...

Acutely aware of this fact, yeah.

> There aren't a lot of opportunities in life you get to use the word "annihilatory"; this is one of them.

Not wrong. None of the former great empires that fell were as military capable as the super powers of the modern era.

> And in the immortal words of William Munny out of Missouri: "deserve's" got nothing to do with it.

True. Some on the Left have extreme take on "Nation States" for this reason:

  One was to challenge the thesis that nationalism and colonialism are two separate things — that nationalism is the good side, colonialism the bad side; that nationalism came first, colonialism later, or vice versa. I wanted to show that they were twins joined at the hip. And I also wanted to show that from the outset, the nation-state project could not be achieved without ethnic cleansing and extreme violence. This could be seen in the expulsion of Jews and Muslims [from the Iberian Peninsula], and that soon led to a conflict between states, because each state had an official majority — the nation it claimed to represent — and its minority, or minorities.

  The human rights paradigm focuses on the perpetrators of violence. It wants to identify them individually so that we can hold them individually accountable. It does not look for the beneficiaries of that violence. Beneficiaries are not necessarily perpetrators. To address beneficiaries, you need to identify the issues around which violence is mobilized ...
The Idea of the Nation-State Is Synonymous With Genocide: A conversation with political theorist Mahmood Mamdani (2024), https://www.thenation.com/article/culture/mahmood-mamdani-na...
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @08:49PM (#46226684)
And all I have to do to operationalize this logic is to accept the premise that the idea of a nation-state is synonymous with genocide.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ignoramous on Thursday December 11, 2025 @06:46PM (#46238983)
At least we've established it is capable of inflicting undeserved "annihilation". That's a start ;)
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Thursday December 11, 2025 @06:55PM (#46239073)
I didn't say "undeserved". I said "deserve's got nothing to do with it". Sovereigns relate in the state of nature, not under the rule of any specific law.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday December 11, 2025 @09:20AM (#46231699)
Of course, by Mamdani's logic here we're fully justified in mobilizing force on the scale of the Allied war in Europe during WW2 against any and every nation-state for the crime of being a nation-state. Go ahead and bomb Dresden again out of nowhere, because the nation-state is genocide!
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ignoramous on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:33PM (#46235121)
> Go ahead and bomb Dresden again out of nowhere, because the nation-state is genocide!

This is the 2nd time "[bomb] Dresden" at me in this thread. Interesting.

> by Mamdani's logic here we're fully justified ...

Well, if you're curious about where his "logic" (his political hypothesis) leads, Mamdani wrote an entire book on it (which is in fact the subject of the interview): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neither_Settler_nor_Native

(from the book's Introduction):

  ... Nuremberg effectively depoliticized Nazism, saddling responsibility for Nazi violence with particular men and ignoring the fact that these men were engaged in the project of political modernity on behalf of a constituency: the nation, the volk. The Allies who prosecuted individual Nazis at Nuremberg were invested in ignoring Nazism's political roots ... After the war, the Allies engaged in many atrocities similar to those the Germans had ... Germans were loaded onto the same cattle cars the Nazis used to transport Jews to concentration, labor, and death camps ... Some half a million Germans died amid the ethnic cleansing.

  ... If Nazism had been understood not as a crime but as a political project of the nation-state, there may yet have been a place for Jews in Europe, in denationalized states committed to the equal protection of every citizen. However, because the response to Nazism took the nation-state for granted, the solution for the Jews turned out to be the nation-state, again.

 ... South Africans didn't give up their cultural identities and reject diversity. They rejected the politicization of diversity. Decolonizing the political through the recognition of a shared survivor identity does not require that we all pretend we are the same; far from it. It requires that we stop accepting that our differences should define who benefits from the state and who is marginalized by it.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday December 11, 2025 @03:46PM (#46236925)
Right, now I'm not South African so I can't speak to that angle of what he's writing. I can speak to the angle of Jews in post-WW2 Europe. Mamdani's thesis here has the problem of rather dramatically, in fact insultingly, ignoring the most basic fact: almost nobody in the displaced-persons camps for Jews after the war wanted to go back into post-war European societies, and most of those who tried were murdered or faced state repression (eg: from the Soviet Union) for their trouble. After surviving the Holocaust and/or the war, everyone was much more interested in getting the hell away from people they perceived as their murderers than in a theoretical project of "denationalization" that wouldn't be invented for several decades more anyway.

> After the war, the Allies engaged in many atrocities similar to those the Germans had ... Germans were loaded onto the same cattle cars the Nazis used to transport Jews to concentration, labor, and death camps ... Some half a million Germans died amid the ethnic cleansing.

And this is, de facto, Nazi apologia on Mamdani's part, because he willfully refuses to see significant differences between alternative regimes within the paradigm of the nation-state, as against the post-national ideal he wants to realize in post-colonial Uganda (but which, of course, post-colonial Uganda has never actually implemented).

>It requires that we stop accepting that our differences should define who benefits from the state and who is marginalized by it.

I would also say Mamdani is an entire paradigm behind the times here. Whether you define it via educational credentials, income, or relation to the means of production, politics has been repolarizing around class, not identitarian belonging. "Who benefits from the state" is a deepity concealing Mamdani's social-democratic imaginary in which nation-states rule nations, rather than network-states administrating international markets in labor, capital, and goods.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by MPSFounder on Monday December 15, 2025 @03:10PM (#46279837)
Why is an Israeli visitor to the US commenting on our politics? You are welcome to return to Israel and genocide innocent civilians. Can we report this SOB to ensure his visitor pass is cancelled? He is a hate filled propagandist for the greatest evil of this generation (I-L)
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday December 17, 2025 @08:07AM (#46301545)
I'm an American citizen born on American soil.
[dead]
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tomhow on Thursday December 18, 2025 @01:23AM (#46309483)
Hey, it's not OK to comment like this on HN, not matter how upsetting the topic is to you. The guidelines [1] make it clear this is not acceptable.

These lines in particular are relevant:

Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes.

Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.

Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.

Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents, and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email [email protected] and we'll look at the data.

Further, Dan posted a message [2] at the very top of the thread asking everyone to avoid commenting in this style. This kind of comment was against the guidelines and against Dan's plea right from the very beginning. Now that the thread is seven days old, it's well past time to stop.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46221528

[dead]
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by TiredOfLife on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:52PM (#46224401)
How is communication devices procured by Hezbollah and directly given by Hezbollah to their own members not a directed attack?
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by sirfz on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:24PM (#46224783)
Hezbollah is an organization consisting of civilian infrastructure besides its military wing (political party, media, hospitals/medical centers, schools, banking, etc) . These devices were distributed amongst different personnel of whom nobody knows their military activity and can safely be assumed it's highly likely they're civilians (hence the randomness of this, not targetted at all). Besides the fact that these targets weren't in active duty but rather targeted in their homes, workplaces, and other random whereabouts (supermarkets, playgrounds, etc) again emphasising how random and not targetted any of it is and the danger it imposes on others (physical or psychological) around them. It's just insane.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by tptacek on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:30PM (#46224864)
The pagers had strictly military use.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by marcosdumay on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:47PM (#46225076)
The Irish terrorists that were mostly the responsible to put word "terrorism" into political discourse targeted almost exclusively politicians and military. And targeted way better than that Israel attack.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by blks on Thursday December 11, 2025 @05:34AM (#46229744)
Not only military leadership was killed, there was a significant amount of civilians being harmed.

Even if you drop a bomb to target a military personnel, but you drop it in the middle of busy city, this will be a war crime, as you didn’t do anything to avoid civilian casualties, and disregarded them.