News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by mid-kid on Monday November 24, 2025 @06:09PM (#46040493)
For some of us software freedom enthusiasts it is worth noting that PebbleOS contains some proprietary blobs for some peripherals in the watch[1]. This is not just firmware you upload to the peripheral but also properietary .a libraries that run on the main core.

Though to be fair to OpenDevices, this is source code they don't have acces to either.

[1]: https://github.com/coredevices/pebbleos-nonfree/tree/57a94e2...

[dead]
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by ddlsmurf on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @01:03AM (#46042775)
Well the Pebble specific parts are. This is an unfortunate state of affairs from hardware manufacturers, they are very late to the open source game, if at all.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by bayindirh on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @02:38AM (#46043289)
Between the cross-licensing of hardware IP blocks and 3rd party software which never sees the light of the day, hardware manufacturers work like a secretive three letter agency to be able to control every part of their ecosystem.

I tend to understand where this comes from. It's part business, part continuation of old customs and the way they did it and being able to control obsolescence to be able push new things to the market.

However, if the periphery of the software you put out is closed source, even though this periphery is optional, it's not fair or ethical to say it's 100% open source.

From my perspective, it can be said it's open core, and it's pretty fair, and acceptable in my case, but writing 100% Open Source* (*: 100% of the open part of the software stack, exceptions apply) is not fair game. It's misleading.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by ddlsmurf on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @01:34PM (#46060818)
Seems a bunch are angry about this, honestly, 100% of what they made/control is open source was a good enough bar for me. Specially if all closed components are optional. I value the flexibility of being able to use or not even closed stuff. It's unclear to me what the issue is, false advertisement ? This is as good as it gets for things like this, maybe the "100%" was indelicate, but I wouldn't go so far as misleading. I can also understand the hardware companies, history has shown that the vast majority of industry actors have a purely parasitical relation to open source, and have no qualms copying/stealing IP.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by bayindirh on Thursday November 27, 2025 @10:38AM (#46070225)
Personally, I'm not angry. On the contrary, I'm pretty neutral about closed-source, optional add-ons. I started playing/working with computers pretty early, and the current state is an utopia when compared to olden times in terms of Free and Open Source software (OTOH, both Free Software and Open Source is under heavy attack because of many reasons I won't enter here).

What bothers me is "100%" part of the open source claim. I personally like the Debian model a lot. It's DFSG compliant by default, and if non-free software is needed, it's attainable. Debian is "as Free as you want, as closed as you need".

I see, new Pebble follows the same model, and it's perfectly fine, but branding it as 100% Open Source is not.

I'll not discuss hardware companies. It's a can of worms that doesn't belong to that reply. Let's say while I understand some of their reservations, these reservation doesn't change that they're greedy and selfish (beyond acceptable limits).

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by bloppe on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @02:31AM (#46043240)
Surprising because you'd think the hardware itself would be their primary moat.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by ddlsmurf on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @01:38PM (#46060851)
Hardware isn't that hard to copy paste really, to make it hard you need to use really expensive processes (extreme uv etc), but otherwise, mostly you can pretty much take a picture. (very grossly speaking here, but just saying, the software is definitely a critical part)
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by paxcoder on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @01:17AM (#46042846)
From the article:

>Another important note - some binary blobs and other non-free software components are used today in PebbleOS and the Pebble mobile app (ex: the heart rate sensor on PT2 , Memfault library, and others). Optional non-free web services, like Wispr-flow API speech recognizer, are also used. These non-free software components are not required - you can compile and run Pebble watch software without them. This will always be the case. More non-free software components may appear in our software in the future. The core Pebble watch software stack (everything you need to use your Pebble watch) will always be open source.

100% should mean 100%

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by darkwater on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @02:21AM (#46043184)
If they are not mandatory it's 100%. Otherwise according to your standard, Debian is not 100% free software either.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by bayindirh on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @02:41AM (#46043301)
Debian doesn't advertise itself as 100% open source, either.

Main and Contrib has to obey DFSG guidelines, and there's an optional non-free repository which you can enable if you prefer.

Firmware is a gnarly can of worms though, and while I prefer 100% free firmware myself, companies are not brave enough to open that part of their ecosystem, yet, if ever.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by aallaall on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:48AM (#46044916)
Companies typically move more and more functionality to closed firmware, so they can ”open source” a thin wrapper, like a driver, that is often completely useless, and often encumbered with cryptography restrictions, strict trademarks and software patents anyway.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by bayindirh on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @07:01AM (#46045019)
This is not always true.

NVIDIA does exactly what you said. Move everything to firmware and closed GL libraries, and open source a kernel module to facilitate communication. They even created different firmware versions to prevent open source drivers to use the whole card.

AMD did the inverse: They re-implemented a fully open driver from scratch, opened up the specs, made every part which they can make (legally) accessible, accessible, open sourced ROCm and send in packages to major distributions' (main / open source) repositories. Their firmware is closed source, but it's obtainable and doesn't require signatures to enable the card. They even clashed with HDMI forums to make a libre implementation of v2.1, but the forum basically threatened them.

Intel's graphics drivers are basically the same with AMD.

Broadcom / Intel / Realtek NICs work without their respective firmware blobs, yet their offloading capabilities are disabled. Either way, the drivers are completely open source and in the kernel mainline.

Same for most sound cards sans Creative Labs. I want to hit them with a foam cluebat so bad.

Logitech's all stuff works with open drivers. They are the primary contributor to V4L standard, standardize their webcam interfaces and provide drivers or help.

Do you have any examples in mind?

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by wafflemaker on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @03:03AM (#46043438)
IMHO, it's much closer to 100% than an iWatch or a Garmin.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by aallaall on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:51AM (#46044932)
1% is closer to 100%, than 0% is, yes.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by rnewme on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @02:38AM (#46043286)
100% of their own software.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by RobotToaster on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:48AM (#46044914)
> More non-free software components may appear in our software in the future.

That sounds ominous.

I can understand not being able to remove non-free dependencies that were used previously, but that sounds like they intend to create new non-free components.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by gf000 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @02:37AM (#46043279)
Above a certain complexity, there is basically no 100% open-source hardware out there.

Like none of the Pinephone, Librem, Framework laptops are "open-source" to the bone.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by asdefghyk on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @03:49AM (#46043761)
The framework laptop , any hard drive ( meaning the hard drives , internal system software ) would not be open source. the embedded software in a SSD , possibly, but the chips could have backdoors etc
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by squarefoot on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @02:45AM (#46043330)
Given how easy is to put and keep hidden malware into devices, governments should demand openness in that field as well. By "putting malware" I don't mean script kiddies in their moms basement but malware/spyware planted by design, which is extremely easy to do if you're the manufacturer, extremely easy to demand/force if you're the government above that manufacturer, and extremely hard to detect if you're a different user in a different country under a government that didn't demand full openness. I know it's impossible as business rules go, but ideally it shouldn't be.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by RobotToaster on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @04:16AM (#46043962)
Every intel processor has a closed source IME, which is probably a NSA backdoor.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by aallaall on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:39AM (#46044851)
Isn’t minix open source?
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by RobotToaster on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @07:07AM (#46045049)
Yes, the original is, but it's under a permissive license so Intel don't have to release the modified source code of their version.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by graemep on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @07:35AM (#46045214)
The thing is governments are the people doing it, and most governments want to be able to put backdoors in more badly than they want other governments to not put backdoors in.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by cncjchsue7 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @03:03AM (#46043439)
So don't say 100%? Not hard.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by gf000 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @03:19AM (#46043556)
Human speech is not mathematical formalism. What would even "open-source" mean in case of hardware, is there a consensus on it to begin with? Is it only 'every firmware is open-source and available', or would you want the whole floorplan of the chip?

So given that the word doesn't really apply to hardware, I believe they used it correctly (100% means the set of things where it makes sense to be used) and are not misleading. In fact I strongly dislike some of the "open-hardware" marketing of some previously mentioned devices, when that is obviously false and misleading.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by f1refly on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @04:06AM (#46043897)
"Not needing binary blobs" would be a start, wouldn't it?
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by gf000 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @04:14AM (#46043953)
I don't know, depends on a lot of stuff. If you are interested in this property from a security perspective, then no -- it's trivial to have hardware backdoors without any binary blobs.

This likely would also mean that it can't be flashed, so if you care about future maintainability, this is also a negative -- it can not be updated/fixed in the future, which may or may not make sense depending on what part we are talking about.

But if there are some kind of signature validation then it gets even more complicated (like e.g. iphone screens knowing if they are from apple or not).

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by philipallstar on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @04:43AM (#46044139)
> I don't know, depends on a lot of stuff. If you are interested in this property from a security perspective, then no -- it's trivial to have hardware backdoors without any binary blobs.

This is a "necessary but not sufficient" thing.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by fsflover on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @04:22AM (#46044001)
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by rowanG077 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:16AM (#46044382)
It's not. Most of the ICs and components are not open. Most notably the Xilinx XC7S50 FPGA. It does go much further then any other phone.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by lrvick on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:03AM (#46044674)
Open silicon is a big leap beyond open hardware schematics and BOMs that allow people to repair boards, or redesign them to use alternative components.

Precursor is the most open personal computing device that can be built currently.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by rowanG077 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:16AM (#46044738)
The comment I replied to was about being "fully open". That indeed goes beyond open hardware. Precursor could go further by at least using an FPGA that has great open source tooling support. It's also not impossible to fab an open FPGA but that's also another hard(and expensive) step.

Precursor goes far, but definitely not as far as currently possible.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by lrvick on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:00AM (#46044654)
The BeTrusted/Precursor devices and Raptor Engineering workstations are actually 100% open software and schematics.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by kchr on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @08:30AM (#46045604)
> Above a certain complexity, there is basically no 100% open-source hardware out there. > > Like none of the Pinephone, Librem, Framework laptops are "open-source" to the bone.

As an aside, GNU Librephone aims to rectify that by reverse-engineering those blobs and develop their own firmware for baseband chips etc. But I am carefully optimistic about the success since it is a relatively new project and quite a moonshot, even though I would personally stand first in line to buy one if it would materialize.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by pjc50 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @04:40AM (#46044107)
Incidentally, this is one reason why there's not so much open source hardware out there: people get pedantic about it and apply gradually more unreasonable levels of requirement, rather than accepting partially or substantially open source solutions.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by 0xEF on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:41AM (#46044545)
I can be pedantically forgiving myself, admittedly, but this is one thing I'm staunchly behind. If I cannot read every character of every line of code, including packages/dependencies, that makes the hardware function and allows me to alter it as I see fit, then it is not truly open-sourced.

For me, the open-source movement is about keeping my software and hardware in alignment with my values and security concerns. If there is a part of that "open-sourced" software that is closed to me, I have no way to evaluate that and determine if I want to use it. Yes, this imposes some extremely strict limitations about what I end up with in my projects, but I'm okay with this since it forces me to think differently about certain problems.

I also don't mind that other people use product with closed-source portions or whatever, and in fact, find some of them quite good. I'm a wearer of an original Pebble to this day, and I'm fine with knowing some proprietary libraries are needed to make it go. I didn't build it, I'm not hacking on it, it's just serving my meager smartwatch needs in this instance.

What I do mind is misappropriation of what I consider a clearly defined term. I am not sure why we haven't come up with another term to mean "partially open-sourced" yet (or have we, and I am just not aware of it?) but I think it's time we did so more discerning users can delineate between the two when making a decision about products to purchase or build.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by pimterry on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:03AM (#46044670)
From the article:

> These non-free software components are not required - you can compile and run Pebble watch software without them. This will always be the case.

This seems like a reasonable balance. They're shipping default distributions with these blobs included, but you can remove them and run the literally completely purely open source version directly instead if you prefer (although it sounds like you'd notably lose heart rate tracking, along with speech recognition & similar).

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by 123pie123 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:13AM (#46044356)
The reason why people get "pedantic" about this stuff, is due the ability in the future to get screwed over when the priority blob owner start to charge money or other pull other license crap
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by aallaall on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:38AM (#46044845)
Enshittification. Open source is a valuable guarantee against that.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by user3939382 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:38AM (#46044530)
Read Reflections on Trusting Trust to understand why having little bits of binary blobs sprinkled all over your compute arch is actually a major problem. Just because it’s a hard problem doesn’t mean we’re gonna pretend it’s fine.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by 0xEF on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:48AM (#46044572)
PDF link for those that are curious: https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~rdriley/487/papers/Thompson_1984_Ref...

The general sentiment is that you cannot trust code you did not write yourself and that we need to be able to trust the person who did, but you can form your own conclusions about how that fits into the modern tech landscape.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by kchr on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @08:26AM (#46045577)
One of the points made in that paper is that you can't even trust the compiler, even if you write the code yourself. I think this is one of the stronger points as it shows you it is unfeasible to require everybody to audit all source code before running it. Be pragmatic, know your threat model, decide who you trust and move on with more important things in your life.

Full disclosure: am free software advocate.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by user3939382 on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @12:46AM (#46054515)
There’s a way to fix Ken’s problem with zero trust. I’ll release it soon.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by saagarjha on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @07:05AM (#46045038)
Reflections on Trusting Trust has never been a real problem, though.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by carlosjobim on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @09:51AM (#46046264)
FOSS enthusiasts are the worst customers imaginable. Not only are they pedantic to the absurd levels you mention, they are also political extremists and will start a witch hunt unless you and your entire company does exactly as they say in every matter imaginable.

And worst of all: They are incredibly cheap and don't want to spend any of their money on high quality products or services. Scream at every dollar they have to spend. "I'm better off with this hand-me-down computer that my sister gave me when her office job upgraded machines".

Trying to please FOSS people is like opening a five star budget restaurant for people with complicated allergies. You're going to deal with the worst of humanity and go broke in the process.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by npteljes on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @10:25AM (#46046634)
1. It's the other way around: because people don't care that much, that's why there is almost exclusively proprietary hardware around.

2. The people who require the "higher grades" of being open source are simply not a large enough market

3. Being open source is not a natural advantage of a product, in fact, it's more of a risk, liability, responsibility, and effort than being proprietary.

Hence, proprietary is the default.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:05AM (#46044681)
They said 100% of Pebble Watch software. The binary blobs are other people's software.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by aallaall on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:44AM (#46044893)
Closed verilog I can accept. But in general firmware is also software, for example it has become quite popular in the recent years to execute firmware on an embedded riscv cpu. And move more and more functionality to that kind of firmware.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by Vexs on Monday November 24, 2025 @11:21PM (#46042309)
I don't really know that this is avoidable without buckets of work and probably legal issues on behalf of core's (or anyone's) engineers- it's really just something that plagues hardware in general.

Hell, lots of sensors/etc these days are running fairly complicated software that's totally opaque.

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by bytesandbits on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:41AM (#46044861)
By that reasoning the linux kernel is also not open source. Be reasonable.
Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by npteljes on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @10:21AM (#46046591)
And, for this reason, different entities ship different versions of the Linux kernel (and system) as well.

For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trisquel

The simple statement that it's not 100% open source is not an attack on the effort. It needs to be said, because the blog entry's title is "Pebble Watch Software Is Now 100% Open Source".

Re:Pebble Watch software is now 100% open source by jrmg on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @08:12AM (#46045465)
Hardware and software are fungible.

Do you demand circuit schematics? Hardware description language source code for all the ICs? Does it matter if it’s a FPGA vs a custom IC? What about CAD files for the industrial design - some of that is ‘functional’ (camera lenses and antennas being obvious examples).

If you don’t require hardware description language source or circuit schematics, does your position change if it’s a microcontroller with firmware? The functionality could be outwardly identical to a fully ‘hardware’ IC or FPGA, down to pinout and timing (see, for example, the many projects ‘cloning’ obsolete and unavailable custom ICs with microcontrollers in the retrocomputing field).