I'm convinced no more than a handful of humans understand all of C# or C++, and inevitably you'll come across some obscure thing and have to context switch out of reading code to learn whatever the fuck a "partial method" or "generic delegate" means, and then keep reading that codebase if you still have momentum left.
https://262.ecma-international.org/16.0/index.html
I don't agree. (And frankly don't like using JS without at least TypeScript.)
It has some strange or weirdly specified features (ASI? HTML-like Comments?) and unusual features (prototype-based inheritance? a dynamically-bounded this?), but IMO it's a small language.
- Regular expressions - not just in the "standard library" but in the syntax.
- An entire module system with granular imports and exports
- Three different ways to declare variables, two of which create temporal dead zones
- Classes with inheritance, including private properties
- Dynamic properties (getters and setters)
- Exception handling
- Two different types of closures/first class functions, with different binding rules
- Async/await
- Variable length "bigint" integers
- Template strings
- Tagged template literals
- Sparse arrays
- for in/for of/iterators
- for await/async iterators
- The with statement
- Runtime reflection
- Labeled statements
- A lot of operators, including bitwise operators and two sets of equality operators with different semantics
- Runtime code evaluation with eval/Function constructor
And honestly it's only scratching the surface, especially of modern ECMAScript.
A language spec is necessarily long. The JS language spec, though, is so catastrophically long that it is a bit hard to load on a low end machine or a mobile web browser. It's on another planet.
By the time you understand all of typescript, your templating environment of choice, and especially the increasingly arcane build complexity of the npm world, you've put in hours comparable to what you'd have spent learning C# or Java for sure (probably more). Still easier than C++ or Rust though.
Modules were added in, like, 2016.
How would the proportion of humans that understand all of Rust compare?
C# is actually fairly complex. I'm not sure if it's quite at the same level as Rust, but I wouldn't say it's that far behind in difficulty for complete understanding.
[1] https://rustfoundation.org/media/ferrous-systems-donates-fer...
So while it has quite a bit of essential complexity (inherent in the design space it operates: zero overhead low-level language with memory safety), I believe it fares overall better.
Like no matter the design, a language wouldn't need 10 different kinds of initializer syntaxes, yet C++ has at least that many.
In contrast writing C++ feels like solving an endless series of puzzles, and there is a constant temptation to do Something Really Clever.
The packaging story is better than c++ or python but that's not saying much, the way it handles private repos is a colossal pain, and the fact that originally you had to have everything under one particular blessed directory and modules were an afterthought sure speaks volumes about the critical thinking (or lack thereof) that went into the design.
Also I miss being able to use exceptions.
I'm not saying it's awful, it's just a pretty mid language, is all.
But mid is not all that bad and Go has a compelling developer experience that's hard to beat. They just made some unfortunate choices at the beginning that will always hold it back.
The idea that it's natural and accepted that we just have python v3.11, 3.12, 3.13 etc all coexisting, each with their own incompatible package ecosystems, and in use on an ad-hoc, per-directory basis just seems fundamentally insane to me.
Alas there are plenty of people who do[0] - for some reason Go takes architecture astronaut brain and wacks it up to 11 and god help you if you have one or more of those on your team.
[0] flashbacks to the interface calling an interface calling an interface calling an interface I dealt with last year - NONE OF WHICH WERE NEEDED because it was a bloody hardcoded value in the end.
Yes, not even for testing. Use monkey-patching instead.
They do make some sense for swappable doodahs - like buffers / strings / filehandles you can write to - but those tend to be in the lower levels (libraries) rather than application code.
This always feels like one of those “taste” things that some programmers tend to like on a personal level but has almost no evidence that it leads to more real-world success vs any other language.
Like, people get real work done every day at scale with C# and C++. And Java, and Ruby, and Rust, and JavaScript. And every other language that programmers castigate as being huge and bloated.
I’m not saying it’s wrong to have a preference for smaller languages, I just haven’t seen anything in my career to indicate that smaller languages outperform when it comes to faster delivery or less bugs.
As an aside, I’d even go so far as to say that the main problem with C++ is not that it has so many features in number, but that its features interact with each other in unpredictable ways. Said another way, it’s not the number of nodes in the graph, but the number of edges and the manner of those edges.
I can imagine myself grappling with a language feature unobvious to me and eventually getting distracted. Sure, there is a lot of things unobvious to me but Go is not one of them and it influenced the whole environment.
Or, when choosing the right language feature, I could end up with weighing up excessively many choices and still failing to get it right, from the language correctness perspective (to make code scalable, look nice, uniform, play well with other features, etc).
An example not related to Go: bash and rc [1]. Understanding 16 pages of Duff’s rc manual was enough for me to start writing scripts faster than I did in bash. It did push me to ease my concerns about program correctness, though, which I welcomed. The whole process became more enjoyable without bashisms getting in the way.
Maybe it’s hard to measure the exact benefit but it should exist.
I'm in academia doing ML research where, for all intents and purposes, we work exclusively in Python. We had a massive CSV dataset which required sorting, filtering, and other data transformations. Without getting into details, we had to rerun the entire process when new data came in roughly every week. Even using every trick to speed up the Python code, it took around 3 days.
I got so annoyed by it that I decided to rewrite it in a compiled language. Since it had been a few years since I've written any C/C++, which was only for a single class in undergrad and I remember very little of, I decided to give Go a try.
I was able to learn enough of the language and write up a simple program to do the data processing in less than a few hours, which reduced the time it took from 3+ days to less than 2 hours.
I unfortunately haven't had a chance or a need to write any more Go since then. I'm sure other compiled, GC languages (e.g., Nim) would've been just as productive or performant, but I know that C/C++ would've taken me much longer to figure out and would've been much harder to read/understand for the others that work with me who pretty much only know Python. I'm fairly certain that if any of them needed to add to the program, they'd be able to do so without wasting more than a day to do so.
> As an aside, I’d even go so far as to say that the main problem with C++ is not that it has so many features in number, but that its features interact with each other in unpredictable ways. Said another way, it’s not the number of nodes in the graph, but the number of edges and the manner of those edges.
I think those problems are related. The more features you have, the more difficult it becomes to avoid strange, surprising interactions. It’s like a pharmacist working with a patient who is taking a whole cocktail of prescriptions; it becomes a combinatorial problem to avoid harmful reactions.
That would be me. I _like_ C#, but there are elements to that language that I _never_ work with on a daily basis, it's just way too large of a language.
Go is refreshing in it's simplicity.
C++ is a basket case, it's not really a fair comparison.
The thing people tend to overvalue is the little syntax differences, like how Scala wanted to be a nicer Java, or even ObjC vs Swift before the latter got async/await.
I don't see it. Can you say what 80% you feel like you're getting?
The type system doesn't feel anything alike, I guess the syntax is alike in the sense that Go is a semi-colon language and Rust though actually basically an ML deliberately dresses as a semi-colon language but otherwise not really. They're both relatively modern, so you get decent tooling out of the box.
But this feels a bit like if somebody told me that this new pizza restaurant does a cheese pizza that's 80% similar to the Duck Ho Fun from that little place near the extremely tacky student bar. Duck Ho Fun doesn't have nothing in common with cheese pizza, they're both best (in my opinion) if cooked very quickly with high heat - but there's not a lot of commonality.
I read it as “80% of the way to Rust levels of reliability and performance.” That doesn’t mean that the type system or syntax is at all similar, but that you get some of the same benefits.
I might say that, “C gets you 80% of the way to assembly with 20% of the effort.” From context, you could make a reasonable guess that I’m talking about performance.
Rust beats Go in performance.. but nothing like how far behind Java, C#, or scripting languages (python, ruby, typescript, etc..) are from all the work I've done with them. I get most of the performance of Rust with very little effort a fully contained stdlib/test suite/package manger/formatter/etc.. with Go.
I can only think of two production bugs I've written in Rust this year. Minor bugs. And I write a lot of Rust.
The language has very intentional design around error handling: Result<T,E>, Option<T>, match, if let, functional predicates, mapping, `?`, etc.
Go, on the other hand, has nil and extremely exhausting boilerplate error checking.
Honestly, Go has been one of my worst languages outside of Python, Ruby, and JavaScript for error introduction. It's a total pain in the ass to handle errors and exceptional behavior. And this leads to making mistakes and stupid gotchas.
I'm so glad newer languages are picking up on and copying Rust's design choices from day one. It's a godsend to be done with null and exceptions.
I really want a fast, memory managed, statically typed scripting language somewhere between Rust and Go that's fast to compile like Go, but designed in a safe way like Rust. I need it for my smaller tasks and scripting. Swift is kind of nice, but it's too Apple centric and hard to use outside of Apple platforms.
I'm honestly totally content to keep using Rust in a wife variety of problem domains. It's an S-tier language.
> Go... extremely exhausting boilerplate error checking
This actually isn't correct. That's because Go is the only language that makes you think about errors at every step. If you just ignored them and passed them up like exceptions or maybe you're basically just exchanging handling errors for assuming the whole thing pass/fail.
If you you write actual error checking like Go in Rust (or Java, or any other language) then Go is often less noisy.
It's just two very different approaches to error handling that the dev community is split on. Here's a pretty good explanation from a rust dev: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZhwOWvoR3I
Rust forces you to think about errors exactly as much, but in the common case of passing it on it’s more ergonomic.
It could as well be Haskell :) Only partly a joke: https://zignar.net/2021/07/09/why-haskell-became-my-favorite...
OCaml is pretty much that, with a very direct relationship with Rust, so it will even feel familiar.
You can make about anything faster if you provide more memory to store data in more optimized formats. That doesn't make them faster.
Part of the problem is that Java in the real world requires an unreasonable number of classes and 3rd party libraries. Even for basic stuff like JSON marshaling. The Java stdlib is just not very useful.
Between these two points, all my production Java systems easily use 8x more memory and still barely match the performance of my Go systems.
As for the stdlib, Go's is certainly impressive but come on, I wouldn't even say that in general case Java's standard library is smaller. It just so happens that Go was developed with the web in mind almost exclusively, while Java has a wider scope. Nonetheless, the Java standard library is certainly among the bests in richness.
It’s your preference to prefer one over the other, I prefer Java’s standard library because atleast it has a generic Set data structure in it and C#’s standard library does have a JSON parser.
I don’t think discussions about what is in the standard library really refutes anything about Go being within the same performance profile though.
[0] https://benchmarksgame-team.pages.debian.net/benchmarksgame/...
https://benchmarksgame-team.pages.debian.net/benchmarksgame/...
I know on HotSpot they’re planning to make G1 the default for every situation. Even where it would previously choose the serial GC.
Rust is great. One of the stupidest things in modern programming practice is the slapfight between these two language communities.
To add to the above comment, a lot of what Go does encourages readability... Yes it feels pedantic at moments (error handling), but those cultural, and stylistic elements that seem painful to write make reading better.
Portable binaries are a blessing, fast compile times, and the choices made around 3rd party libraries and vendoring are all just icing on the cake.
That 80 percent feeling is more than just the language, as written, its all the things that come along with it...
I keep using the analogy, that the tools are just nail guns for office workers but some people remain sticks in the mud.
This Go community that you speak of isn't bothered by writing the boilerplate themselves in the first place, though. For everyone else the LLMs provide.
For non-trivial tasks, AI is neither of those. Anything you do with AI needs to be carefully reviewed to correct hallucinations and incorporate it into your mental model of the codebase. You point, you shoot, and that's just the first 10-20% of the effort you need to move past this piece of code. Some people like this tradeoff, and fair enough, but that's nothing like a nailgun.
For trivial tasks, AI is barely worth the effort of prompting. If I really hated typing `if err != nil { return nil, fmt.Errorf("doing x: %w", err) }` so much, I'd make it an editor snippet or macro.
You missed it.
If I give a random person off the street a nail gun, circular saw and a stack of wood are they going to do a better job building something than a carpenter with a hammer and hand saw?
> Anything you do with AI needs to be carefully reviewed
Yes, and so does a JR engineer, so do your peers, so do you. Are you not doing code reviews?
If this is meant to be an analogy for AI, it doesn't make sense. We've seen what happens when random people off the street try to vibe-code applications. They consistently get hacked.
> Yes, and so does a JR engineer
Any junior dev who consistently wrote code like an AI model and did not improve with feedback would get fired.
From Rob Pike himself: "It must be familiar, roughly C-like. Programmers working at Google are early in their careers and are most familiar with procedural languages, particularly from the C family. The need to get programmers productive quickly in a new language means that the language cannot be too radical."
However, the main design goal was to reduce build times at Google. This is why unused dependencies are a compile time error.
From Russ Cox this time: "Q. What language do you think Go is trying to displace? ... One of the surprises for me has been the variety of languages that new Go programmers used to use. When we launched, we were trying to explain Go to C++ programmers, but many of the programmers Go has attracted have come from more dynamic languages like Python or Ruby."
I wonder if it's that Ruby/Python programmers were interested in using these kinds of languages but were being pushed away by C/C++.
https://go.dev/doc/faq?utm_source=chatgpt.com#unused_variabl...
> There are two reasons for having no warnings. First, if it’s worth complaining about, it’s worth fixing in the code. (Conversely, if it’s not worth fixing, it’s not worth mentioning.) Second, having the compiler generate warnings encourages the implementation to warn about weak cases that can make compilation noisy, masking real errors that should be fixed.
I believe this was a mistake (one that sadly Zig also follows). In practice there are too many things that wouldn't make sense being compiler errors, so you need to run a linter. When you need to comment out or remove some code temporarily, it won't even build, and then you have to remove a chain of unused vars/imports until it let's you, it's just annoying.
Meanwhile, unlinted go programs are full of little bugs, e.g. unchecked errors or bugs in err-var misuse. If there only were warnings...
I believe the correct approach is to offer two build modes: release and debug.
Debug compiles super fast and allows unused variables etc, but the resulting binary runs super slowly, maybe with extra safety checks too, like the race detector.
Release is the default, is strict and runs fast.
That way you can mess about in development all you want, but need to clean up before releasing. It would also take the pressure off having release builds compile fast, allowing for more optimisation passes.
At least in the golang / unused-vars at Google case, allowing unused vars is explicitly one of the things that makes compilation slower.
In that case it's not "faster compilation as in less optimization". It's "faster compilation as in don't have to chase down and potentially compile more parts of a 5,000,000,000 line codebase because an unused var isn't bringing in a dependency that gets immediately dropped on the floor".
So it's kinda an orthogonal concern.
Whats good for the junior can be good for the senior. I think PL values have leaned a little too hard towards valuing complexity and abstract 'purity' while go was a break away from that that has proved successful but controversial.
I think my favourite bit of Go opinionatedness is the code formatting.
K&R or GTFO.
Oh you don't like your opening bracket on the same line? Tough shit, syntax error.
"This is Go. You write it this way. Not that way. Write it this way and everyone can understand it."
I wish I was better at writing Go, because I'm in the middle of writing a massive and complex project in Go with a lot of difficult network stuff. But you know what they say, if you want to eat a whole cow, you just have to pick and end and start eating.
I don't know but for me a lot of attacks on Go, often come from non-go developers, VERY often Rust devs. When i started Go, it was always Rust devs in /r/programming pushing their agenda as Rust being the next best thing, the whole "rewrite everything in Rust"...
About 10 years ago, learned Rust and these days, i can barely read the code anymore with the tons of new syntax that got added. Its like they forgot the lessons from C++...
I see it as a bit like Python and Perl. I used to use both but ended up mostly using Python. They're different languages, for sure, but they work in similar ways and have similar goals. One isn't "better" than the other. You hardly ever see Perl now, I guess in the same way there's a lot of technology that used to be everywhere but is now mostly gone.
I wanted to pick a not-C language to write a thing to deal with a complex but well-documented protocol (GD92, and we'll see how many people here know what that is) that only has proprietary software implementing it, and I asked if Go or Rust would be a good fit. Someone told me that Go is great for concurrent programming particularly to do with networks, and Rust is also great for concurrent processing and takes type safety very seriously. Well then, I guess I want to pick apart network packets where I need to play fast and loose with ints and strings a bit, so maybe I'll use Go and tread carefully. A year later, I have a functional prototype, maybe close to MVP, written in Go (and a bit of Lua, because why not).
The Go folks seem to be a lot more fun to be around than the Rust folks.
But at least they're nothing like the Ruby on Rails folks.
By 20% of the effort, do you mean learning curve or productivity?
I think go is fairly small, too, but “size of spec” is not always a good measure for that. Some specs are very tight, others fairly loose, and tightness makes specs larger (example: Swift’s language reference doesn’t even claim to define the full language. https://docs.swift.org/swift-book/documentation/the-swift-pr...: “The grammar described here is intended to help you understand the language in more detail, rather than to allow you to directly implement a parser or compiler.”)
(Also, browsing golang’s spec, I think I spotted an error in https://go.dev/ref/spec#Integer_literals. The grammar says:
decimal_lit = "0" | ( "1" … "9" ) [ [ "_" ] decimal_digits ] .
Given that, how can 0600 and 0_600 be valid integer literals in the examples?) octal_lit = "0" [ "o" | "O" ] [ "_" ] octal_digits .Are there other modern languages that still have that?
octal_lit = "0" [ "o" | "O" ] [ "_" ] octal_digits .No, the o/O is optional (hence in square brackets), only the leading zero is required. All of these are valid octal literals in Go:
0600 (zero six zero zero)
0_600 (zero underscore six zero zero)
0o600 (zero lower-case-letter-o six zero zero)
0O600 (zero upper-case-letter-o six zero zero)
We shall not talk about compile time / resource usage differences ;)
I mean, Rust is nice, but compared to when i learned it like 10 years ago, it really looks a lot more these days, like it took too much of a que from C++.
While Go syntax is still the same as it was 10 years ago with barely anything new. What may anger people but even so...
The only thing i love to see is reduce executable sizes because pushing large executables on a dinky upload line, to remove testing is not fun.
It took a few more years before I actually got around to learning it and I have to say I've never picked up a language so quickly. (Which makes sense, it's got the smallest language spec of any of them)
I'm sure there are plenty of reasons this is wrong, but it feels like Go gets me 80% of the way to Rust with 20% of the effort.