News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by philipallstar on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @08:44AM (#45591552)
> audience engagement with the arts generated €16.9 million in social value, based on public willingness-to-pay for cultural experiences.

If people are willing to pay for their art then artists don't need a welfare check.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by throwforfeds on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:28AM (#45592179)
My wife has won multiple prestigious awards for her writing (novels, memoir). She's published by huge multinational corporations you've heard of. She got paid about $100k for her last novel, which took maybe 5 years to complete. It works out to less than $20k/year, after paying her literary agent. The publisher encourages her to spend her own money on PR (~$20k).

Many of our friends in the literary circles of NYC end up teaching in MFA programs (Columbia, NYU, New School), but then they have very little time for their own work and the pay isn't great (she's been offered $4k to teach a course for the semester at Columbia MFA). Of course we do have friends that have gotten $1 million advances, but that is exceptionally rare and you have to be a bestseller at that point.

So, that's all to say, you can have an artist that from the outside looks wildly successful because of the awards and articles written about them, but they're in reality poor.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by Hammershaft on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:40AM (#45592377)
This tracks with what publishers reported on the economics of books.

https://www.elysian.press/p/no-one-buys-books

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by ghaff on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @03:05PM (#45597017)
I earned about $10 for the last quarter for the second edition of a technical book I wrote--which actually earned out royalties. With rare exceptions, writing a book makes basically no sense unless you're on the clock for a company anyway and the book comes with lots of other benefits.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by cakealert on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @12:41PM (#45595175)
> She's published by huge multinational corporations you've heard of.

Publishers have an interest in publishing stuff that doesn't sell as long as ticks some other check-boxes to appear prestigious or politically correct for the time.

Should society bear the costs of maintaining artists who produce things that are not in demand or have low value?

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by golergka on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @03:08PM (#45597050)
So effectively what you're saying is that institutions are willing to reward her with attention, but people are not willing to pay for her art after all?
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by RHSeeger on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @08:47AM (#45591593)
It is possible that there can be a gap between "the amount people are willing to pay" and "the amount artists need to live on (food, housing, etc)"
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by CalRobert on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @08:50AM (#45591632)
Sure, but you could say the same thing for teachers, foodservice workers, nurses, etc.... yet they are unable to avail of this program, for reasons I don't understand.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by melesian on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:11AM (#45591913)
Ireland started by not leving tax on income from writing on writers for specific cultural reasons -- to support and encourage writers.

It's a cultural norm. Extending it to other generally penniless artists is too.

When universities in other countries start running courses on Irish food service workers we can reasonably expect them to be included.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by CalRobert on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:56AM (#45592642)
Perhaps valuing artists over nurses is why so many Irish nurses are in Australia.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by lou1306 on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:06AM (#45591843)
> teachers, foodservice workers, nurses

These are mostly employed positions, where employees have procedures to negotiate their salary with the employer (which might be the government itself).

Most artists otoh are self-employed, and the government decided that the country at large would benefit from giving some of them economic support. You can argue with the modalities but the reasoning does not seem that opaque to me.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by wqaatwt on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @10:35AM (#45593273)
I’m hypothetically a self employed Twitch streamer who has 0.5 viewers.

How is that different than being an “artist” whose art isn’t consumed by anyone willing to pay for it.

I kind of see the reasoning to some extent but then also e.g. “full time gardeners” if their yards are visible from the sidewalk should be paid.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by philipallstar on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:22AM (#45592093)
Then don't count that money in a fake economic justification. Just say "the bureaucracy would like to assign people your tax money based on vague criteria" and leave it at that.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by kingstnap on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:30AM (#45592230)
I think you need to solve the gap the other way, by bringing down the "amount people need to live", ideally to zero, and not by directly paying people.

There is no numerical value of UBI that makes any sense in Canada. Rent is expensive and toys are cheap.

You need universal basic services with income being a thing you use for toys and vices. So this hypothetical artist should instead get paid what other people are willing to pay but need $0 in pay for basic food, water, healthcare, and housing.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by philipallstar on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @11:10AM (#45593812)
> It is possible that there can be a gap between "the amount people are willing to pay" and "the amount artists need to live on (food, housing, etc)"

It's possible. It's possible that there can be a similar gap between "the amount people are willing to pay" and "the amount I need to live on while I pursue my career in snail sniffing". So what? That's why my snail sniffing is purely a hobby.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by everforward on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @01:35PM (#45595951)
Sure, but in practically every other non-essential situation (i.e. food, medicine, housing) that gap would be considered supply in excess of demand and allowed to work itself out.

This feels like it violates the social contract where we all produce things other people want/need, and in return we get the things we want/need. It feels wrong that artists get a special carveout there, where they get to produce things other people don't want (at a livable price) and everyone else is forced to create the things they want/need anyways.

This would be different to me if it were a full post-scarcity thing that everyone gets because the prior contract is based on a scarcity that doesn't exist anymore. This feels wrong because it both acknowledges that scarcity still exists, while taking money from the people producing those scarce goods to fund creating goods that are overabundant to a degree where the creators are destitute.

If we were collectively creating so many car tires that they were being sold below marginal cost, the solution would be to make fewer tires and have the workers go make something else. It reads wrong to me that for art the solution is just to levy taxes and continue making more than the market can bear.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by nilamo on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:17AM (#45592006)
Most artists don't make enough, though? Isn't that famously well known? Picasso was never rolling in it, burned his paintings to stay warm, and had trouble even eating.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by quickthrowman on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:35AM (#45592300)
I think you meant Van Gogh instead of Picasso.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by nilamo on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @04:01PM (#45597676)
I have forgotten the face of my father, please forgive me.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by I-M-S on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @04:43PM (#45598182)
Worse still, you're perpetuating a debunked myth of a starving artist. 99% of the artists you've heard of were able to support themselves with their craft - those that weren't stopped producing and that's why you've never heard of them (a prime example of survivorship bias). Van Gogh is an extreme outlier.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by Supernaut on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:24AM (#45592115)
Picasso was worth $240 million at the time of his death, and that's in 1976 dollars.

Plenty of artists become very, very wealthy.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by amanaplanacanal on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:36AM (#45592319)
"Plenty" is kind of vague. How many in total are we talking? 100? 1000? 10k?
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by Supernaut on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @10:20AM (#45593010)
Well, how many artists are there in total?
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by amanaplanacanal on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @11:29AM (#45594104)
Hundreds of millions. Up to a billion maybe? If you mean people that actually make a living at it, not many.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by overrun11 on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @02:26PM (#45596595)
Art is highly valued it's just a winner takes most market just like sports. A tiny minority make all the money and the rest get nothing.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by frm88 on Thursday October 16, 2025 @01:58AM (#45601897)
This seems both a) vague and b) based on a sample size of n=1. 85% of all visual artists in the U. S. make less than 25k/year [0]. Also, don't forget that most artists work in companies (again: visual art), like making story boards for anime etc.

[0] https://www.contemporaryartissue.com/art-world-statistics-ev...

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by dudeinjapan on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:32AM (#45592260)
Last week I also had to burn a Picasso to stay warm.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by tikhonj on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @11:32AM (#45594140)
There is a lot of value in reducing risk, variance and up-front costs for artists. Enough value that, to somebody barely scraping by, it makes the difference between a show/exhibition/etc being doable and not.

It also changes the distribution. I'd say it's a net positive if a bunch of artists get enough money to live on their art rather than the vast majority not making enough and a tiny fraction making the most. It's just a matter of correcting for structural factors that otherwise push towards an exponential distribution of income.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by philipallstar on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @02:27PM (#45596606)
> It's just a matter of correcting for structural factors that otherwise push towards an exponential distribution of income.

Why is this a thing that needs "correcting" in any field, and why anyone would start with art, a thing my children can do with their fingers and some paint?

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by tmtvl on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @08:55AM (#45591703)
Could be interesting to try negative tax on works from small artists up to a certain value. So when you buy a painting from some person of little name recognition the goverment pays like 20 percent extra up to 2,000 Euro, 10 percent up to 5,000 Euro, and over 10,000 Euro taxes are paid as normal for luxury goods.

Of course you'd need a bunch of bureaucracy to avoid it getting abused, but it would help artists make a living.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:18AM (#45592023)
Seems like it could be an "infinite money glitch" if the artist and customer are in cahoots. Churn out alot of cheap artworks, even just fake ones, then split the profits. The bureaucracy capable of preventing this would be so onerous, would anyone still be interested in the dole for it?
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by cma on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:14AM (#45591971)
> If people are willing to pay for their art then artists don't need a welfare check.

Copyright, and, to less extent, ticketed events, are a system of artificial scarcity, would be cool if this had a public domain aspect. At least a limited form within the nation subsidizing it.