News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by scrlk on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @02:41PM (#45429423)
To add to this & the Jobs interview - an oil industry proverb: a healthy oil company has a geologist in charge, a mature one has an engineer in charge, a declining one has an accountant in charge, and a dying one has a lawyer in charge.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by SirHumphrey on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @04:50PM (#45431065)
A bit ironic though because the CEO of Boing during their best years was William McPherson Allen, a lawyer.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by flkiwi on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @06:59PM (#45432301)
One of the most exceptional CEOs I've worked with was a lawyer. I still think the proverb is largely correct, along with the other proverb about the exception proving the rule.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by parineum on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:46PM (#45433479)
That's not what "the exception proves the rule" means.

It means, when you see a sign that says an exception, "no parking Wednesdays between 8 and 12", it proves the rule that parking is allowed otherwise.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by ma2rten on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:55PM (#45434108)
Your use of the phrase makes no sense. It's the "no parking" that proofs the rule and not the exception.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by parineum on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @12:47AM (#45434321)
"No parking on Wednesday between 9-12pm"

Imagine you got a parking ticket on Tuesday. What would your defense in court be?

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by ddalex on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @12:47AM (#45434324)
that's actually the correct use of the phrase "the exception proves the rule"

the rule is that the parking is allowed; the exception is that it's not allowed on Wednesdays; they didn't bother spelling out "parking is allowed at all other times except"

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by rendaw on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:27PM (#45433979)
GP's use is listed here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exception_that_proves_the_rule... under "Proving the validity of a rule of thumb"
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by parineum on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @12:44AM (#45434312)
It's listed there as a way that people use it and then calls that usage objectionable and a misunderstanding.

I don't dispute that people use it that way but it's objectively a misuse. The phrase's misuse implies that evidence against a statement supports the statement.

> In many uses of the phrase, however, the existence of an exception is taken to more definitively 'prove' a rule to which the exception does not fit.

> In what Fowler describes as the "most objectionable" variation of the phrase,[1] this sort of use comes closest to meaning "there is an exception to every rule", or even that the presence of an exception makes a rule more true; these uses Fowler attributes to misunderstanding.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by sach1 on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @01:01AM (#45434386)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_description

Try to understand that there is no individual ownership over turns of phrase, and that they tend to shift around over time. Bugs Bunny turned Nimrod from a byword for a competent hunter into an insult.

This is natural and all of your favorite words have or will be subject to it as long as there are humans to communicate with them.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by riffraff on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @01:32AM (#45434576)
Ooooh that's why nimrod is an insult! Now it makes sense! Thank you!

Btw, let me add my personal pet peeve: "egregiously" somehow went from meaning "very good" to mean "very bad" in American English.

In my native language "egregiamente" still has the original meaning so I was confused for a long time.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by willvarfar on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @04:29AM (#45435569)
I'm still momentarily paused when kids today say 'shit' to mean 'good' etc. Yeah some words shift in meaning and other words swap in meaning.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by qzw on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @06:28AM (#45436161)
Shit (meaning “how true”), shit is veritably the aladeen of words. It can basically mean anything depending on usage, context, attitude, or tone of voice.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by cvcount on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @05:00AM (#45435698)
Dictionaries - at least the ones I checked - mark the "very good" meaning of "egregious" as archaic. I'm only aware of the "very bad" meaning (in UK English), and was quite surprised, when studying maths, to learn of Gauss's "Theorema Egregium", and that the word could have positive connations.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by speerer on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @01:45AM (#45434659)
> The phrase's misuse implies that evidence against a statement supports the statement.

The original meaning of 'prove' was more like 'test'. The original sense was therefore opposite to this.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by cgio on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:12PM (#45433609)
A phrase does not mean anything by itself. People mean something when they use it. You could argue that expressions carry some meaning, by virtue of shared use. But your definition does not align with the meaning most people make of this specific expression as you can witness above.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by parineum on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:25PM (#45433672)
The way most people use it is wrong though and not in the normal "language evolves" way.

The exception of a lawyer being a good CEO does not, in any way, prove that lawyers are not good CEOs .

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @02:46AM (#45435024)
The phrase "most people mean the wrong thing by this phrase" makes no sense. A phrase means what most people mean by saying it, or understand by hearing it. So, "the exception that proves the rule" is, as its main modern meaning, a joking way of admitting that a rule (especially one that the speaker had argued for) is not actually a universal rule, while maintaining that it generally holds true.

The examples of legal signs and so on are a more specific, technical, meaning that is only used in certain contexts, such as actual legal proceedings or at least informal discussions about laws or contract terms.

When /u/flkiwi above said this phrase, they obviously meant it in the joking sense I gave, and which they had actually explained above. They agree that, in general, lawyers make bad CEOs, but they also personally know of exceptions. This is not "wrong usage", as proven by the fact that everyone who read the comment understood exactly what they meant.

This whole thing reminds me of the people who complain about the use of literally as an amplifier instead of for its primary meaning as "wrong", with seemingly no understanding of how flourishes and rhetoric work (nor even of the history of words like "very", which used to be quite similar to "literally" a long time ago).

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by bildung on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @03:34AM (#45435288)
Words are just noises. Think of them as pointers. They point to a concept in the brain. What concept that may be differs from person to person. But as long as the words point to something, they aren't used wrongly.

The idea that there was some point in history were the pointer target was officially designated to be x is just false. That point in time never existed.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by parineum on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @10:31AM (#45438164)
My point isn't that the use of the phrase is wrong, the point is that the colloquial understanding of the phrase is a bad concept.

[All] lawyers are bad CEOs is a statement that was made. Evidence to the contrary was presented. "The exception proves the rule" was used to dismiss that evidence.

It's used in a similar way as "God works in mysterious ways".

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by sfn42 on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @02:38AM (#45434971)
People misuse expressions. A common one is the customer is always right. The actual wording is the customer is always right in matters of taste but people cut off the ending which changes it from a sensible and useful proverb to a bunch of nonsense. Of course the customer isn't always right. They're always right in terms of what they want to buy, not in all other terms.

Similarly an exception like a lawyer being a good ceo does not prove a rule like lawyers are bad CEOs. It's nonsense. People who don't understand the proverb took it and misused it and then others took after them and here we are, I've been wondering about that proverb my entire life and I never understood how it makes any sense. Now I finally do, and I'm glad the other commenter clarified it

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by j5r5myk on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @09:15AM (#45437336)
There is a common phenomenon where people claim proverbial quotes were originally longer. One I often hear is “Jack of all trades master of none” originally including the follow up “often better than a master of none.”

If you research this, as well as the customer as always right as you claim, you will find no evidence of their longer ‘original’ forms [1].

[1] https://www.snopes.com/articles/468815/customer-is-always-ri...

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by bee_rider on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @09:37AM (#45437584)
On top of what j5r5myk mentioned, there is a fairly good record of the origin on “the customer is always right,” (described on Wikipedia) because it was something like a moderately well known person’s catchphrase, in an era when newspapers and marketing existed.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_customer_is_always_right

There’s some quibbling to be had about the meaning, but it puts it closer to “assume good faith” or something like that, rather than reducing it to just preferences.

> The earliest known printed mention of the phrase is a September 1905 article in the Boston Globe about Field, which describes him as "broadly speaking" adhering to the theory that "the customer is always right".

> However, John William Tebbel was of the opinion that Field never himself actually said such a thing, because he was "no master of idiom". Tebbel rather believed it probable that what Field would have actually said was "Assume the customer is right until it is plain beyond all question that he is not."

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by ahoka on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @06:13AM (#45436100)
A lot of people say a lot of stupid things, it does not make them less stupid and incorrect. Unless a million flies can't be wrong!
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by SilasX on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @10:51AM (#45438382)
But the intended insight isn't stupid, and "the exception proves the rule" is a natural, easily-inferred contraction of "the rarity of finding an exception proves the general validity of the rule".
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by embwbam on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:06PM (#45433587)
I have heard that phrase a million times and never understood it until your example. Thank you
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by jackyinger on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @12:27AM (#45434227)
There’s no need to be so literal. We’re discussing here, not formulating mathematical statements.

Read for what was intended by the author and you’ll learn more.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by parineum on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @10:42AM (#45438289)
> Lawyers are bad CEOs

> That's weird because this one was good

> Ah an exception to the rule. That proves it, lawyers are bad CEOs!

Is that not what was intended by the author?

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by ahoka on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @06:11AM (#45436086)
Attributed to Cicero, who was basically a lawyer.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by flkiwi on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @07:08AM (#45436381)
God Internet pendants are exhausting. I KNOW, but it's a harmless rhetorical device. This begs the question of why you care. There you go, that's a good one to get fired up about.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by parineum on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @10:40AM (#45438276)
> I KNOW, but it's a harmless rhetorical device.

I don't really care but but when I found out the actual meaning of the phrase (the usage of which never really made sense to me), it made a lot more sense to me. I thought it was interesting.

I'd also argue that "it's harmless" is not always accurate. It's usage dismisses counter-evidence to a statement. Depending on the case, it may or may not be harmless.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by amelius on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @08:01AM (#45436691)
That's a logical fallacy.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by bee_rider on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @09:40AM (#45437620)
But parking signs are not proofs.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by amelius on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @03:26PM (#45442126)
That doesn't absolve you from being at least logically correct.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by bee_rider on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @08:17PM (#45445149)
I think denying the antecedent (that’s what this is, right?) is a well known fallacy precisely because it is often the intended implication in typical speech.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by SilasX on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @10:49AM (#45438362)
Yes, but in common usage it has come to also mean "the [rarity of finding an] exception proves the [general validity of] the rule", and it was clear from context which one the parent meant.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by safety1st on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @06:03AM (#45436049)
Well, the proverb doesn't necessarily attribute the death of the company to the lawyer.

If a company is dying (aka winding down), you most likely do in fact want a lawyer in charge, whatever their job title may be. For instance why would you put a scientist or engineer in charge of negotiating your acquisition?

It's a great proverb and in particular the "accountants in charge to extract maximum value after maturity, lawyers in charge at the end to wind it down or sell it off" part is accurate of many businesses in general. No company gets to live in the startup and growth stages forever. At a certain point shareholders decide to get everything they can out of their investment and move on.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by bluGill on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @06:38PM (#45432113)
There are always people who work out despite common sense saying they shouldn't that doesn't mean common sense is wrong, it just means we don't understand what the real factors are.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by potato3732842 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:12PM (#45432862)
Or we don't care because it's a rule of thumb not a law of physics.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by sitharus on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @06:16PM (#45431890)
He initially turned down the job because he felt that a lawyer wasn't the right person to run an engineering company, and from reports of people who worked with him he knew his knowledge limits and listened to the engineers. He took serious risks with the 707 and 747 projects because he trusted the people who understood the technology.

MBAs and final-gasp lawyers concentrate on making the reported number go up in the short term, they won't take a hit now for a payoff in ten years.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by grepfru_it on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @07:04PM (#45432348)
Fun fact the 707 had the first implementation of “MCAS” because the plane had a tendency to pitch up in a certain flaps configuration. They added a stick nudger which applied light pressure in said config. Not a stick pusher, as it did not alert the pilots, it simply applied an extra input independent of the pilots. However this was made aware to all pilots of the plane and likely contributed to its certification.

Also the 707 tail was extended by 40ft to give it better minimum ground speed control, this was retroactively applied to already built planes. Very interesting to see how this was applied in the past with a lawyer at the helm vs the current ceo during the launch of the 737Max

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by quacksilver on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @07:48PM (#45432711)
Assume 40 inches rather than 40ft

Adding 12 meters to an aircraft is quite a big change.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by grepfru_it on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:32PM (#45433374)
Mistake on my part they extended the tail to 40ft from 32ft
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by exidy on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @02:00AM (#45434740)
I think there might be some confusion here. The vertical stabiliser (not the tail) was extended by 40 inches [0] to combat concerns about poor yaw control.

Although the Wikipedia article cites the UK ARB as the influence, it was also in response to the 1959 crash [1] of a 707 being used for training, in which Dutch roll was induced and later became so violent it ripped 3 engines off the wings.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_707#707-420

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1959_Washington_Boeing_707_cra...

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by izacus on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @05:41AM (#45435935)
Hmm, you now highlighted an interesting thing - every company (I've seen) being run to the ground by MBAs and Lawyers was done so because they outright refused to trust their employees. The usual playbook is severance of any transparency and communication and implementation of more and more paperwork and oversight over their employees with no nuance. In other words - complete lack of trust into employed specialists being able to do their work.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by sitharus on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @04:16PM (#45442867)
yep, that's the most important thing about his operation of Boeing.

Both the 707 and 747 were "bet the company" projects, in particular the 747 pushed Boeing to the brink of bankruptcy. However both were major successes because they took a gamble on the future of the aviation industry.

In these days of "fiduciary responsibility" it's difficult to imagine any public company taking that kind of risk. Risk is what should make returns.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by taneq on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @10:40PM (#45433778)
I’d wager he wasn’t just a lawyer.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by dennis_jeeves2 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:02PM (#45433886)
Exactly, mostly likely he would have made a great engineer if that were his line of expertise.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by dennis_jeeves2 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:14PM (#45433932)
He was talking about stereotypes ...

And yes professions have stereotypical personalities. Like the used car salesman.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by ExoticPearTree on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @05:37AM (#45435920)
> A bit ironic though because the CEO of Boing during their best years was William McPherson Allen, a lawyer.

Just as there are good engineers, there are also bad ones. Same for every profession.

I guess the question is: can Boeing really design a new plane where cost cutting, regulation interpretation and skirting, and greed are _not_ the driving factors?

It feels like what Boeing is saving from all the nickel-and-dime it does on everything it ends up paying lawyers, fines and damages. I wonder how they manage to see this as good business. Or maybe they hope that "the next" time they'll score big without any penalties?

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by ffsm8 on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @07:55AM (#45436666)
I think you're taking the proverb too literal.

It's about how the person in charge behaves, not the literal previous job.

It's a proverb, not a unquestionable truth after all. And the thought it's meant to illustrate is how a litigation-first approach to business makes only sense as a final attempt to stay relevant.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by pavlov on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @04:59PM (#45431173)
Nokia’s CEO between 2006 and 2010 was their former chief lawyer.

It’s like they knew they were dying even before Apple delivered the actual blow.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by davidkwast on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @05:12PM (#45431319)
Nokia is the best case study of what not to do. In 2005 Nokia launched the 770 Internet Tablet. It was the groundwork for the modern smartphone. But the management did not allow it to have a GSM modem. So it was not a smartphone. Only after the iPhone Nokia launched the N900 but it was too late. Nokia did not believe in touch screen too.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by zdw on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @05:20PM (#45431396)
The 770 and Maemo environment were pretty amazing back in the day - high resolution screen for the time, but a somewhat laggy interface given the compute available at the time. Hardware was somewhat compromised - the half-height MMC storage expansion was particularly difficult to find. I still have one sitting around somewhere.

It did support touch, with a stylus built in - I forget if the stylus was needed or if you could use your bare fingers.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by foobarian on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @05:47PM (#45431650)
I got to briefly try a N900 back in the day. When it powered on you would briefly see the raw X background stipple and the x-shaped cursor before the window manager loaded. I liked the nerd factor of it but I knew at that point the company was in the weeds.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by davidkwast on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @05:38PM (#45431571)
True. But Nokia could do many improvements before Apple launched iPhone. But Nokia decided to stay only with Symbian without touch. And we had to wait 4 years to Android show what a Linux with Java smartphone would be. And we saw Nokia going down with Microsoft. It was interesting times back then.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by tim-- on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @06:10PM (#45431852)
Interesting times indeed. It was also just before the Nokia acquisition that Microsoft was selling their first Android phone (under the Nokia brand) so they could see the winds of change.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_X

Nokia already had Android phones released months before the Microsoft acquisition closed. Makes me wonder if Nokia would have pulled out completely from making Windows phones had Microsoft not purchased them.

Even Microsoft changed their tune, releasing Android phones themselves years later under the Surface brand.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by yk on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @08:35PM (#45433006)
Maemo was an actual GNU/Linux, not just kernel with custom userland. Logging into a cluster from my N900 and having plots just appear on screen thanks to X network transparency is still one of the most futuristic things I have ever seen a computer do.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by wkat4242 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:48PM (#45433487)
Symbian did have some touch models in the end but they were very poor because they still used resistive touch and the UI was not well laid out for it.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by throwaway173738 on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @07:56AM (#45436670)
X does not support touch natively. What it does support is mouse emulation from the touch input. This also greatly limits how good you can make it.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by wkat4242 on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @11:28AM (#45438896)
Symbian didn't use X in any way. That was Maemo, used on the 770. But there were also some Symbian-based touch devices like the 5800 XpressMusic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_5800_XpressMusic

But Symbian didn't have any roots in Linux. It came from the Psion organiser line originally (and specifically the 5/7 series, not the earlier 3's).

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by Arch-TK on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @07:01PM (#45432322)
If the 770 was anything like the N900 then the screen was resistive and the stylus was passive. So you could use your fingers but in my experience, for any finer task, you needed the stylus.

Damn, I really miss the N900. I was seriously using it as recently as about 4-5 years ago.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by nicce on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @05:23PM (#45431422)
They also threw away Meego, which was praised for UI and design.. and it was Linux.. not often heard in the same phrase. Build with Qt.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by noosphr on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @06:09PM (#45431848)
I have an n9 that I turn on once in a blue moon.

Even today it looks better than any of the major mobile OSs, is more responsive and just _feels_ better to hold and use.

The road not taken.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by mrmlz on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @03:01AM (#45435103)
I loved my N9, truly one of the best experiences i've had with a mobile phone. I've watched Sailfish from a distance but their very limited choice of phones have always been off-putting.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by modo_mario on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @04:28AM (#45435567)
I feel like Nokia would still be a notable smartphone company albeit not on the scale of apple (as the single alternative to the android ecosystem) if not for Microsoft and it's plant delivering the actual blow.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by chithanh on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @06:41AM (#45436229)
It is just an urband legend that Apple caused Nokia to fail. Apple didn't even compete in the price range where Nokia sold most of their smartphones.

When you look at where most Nokia customers defected to, it is Samsung and Android.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by wnc3141 on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @07:25PM (#45432527)
In most cases,the successor to a founder CEO is a finance person - because their mandate is to massage the stock on the behalf of the appointing board.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by buildsjets on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @07:47PM (#45432705)
Dennis Muilenberg has a BS in Aerospace Engineering and a MS in Aeronautics and Astronautics. He was Boeing’s CEO during and after the MAX disaster. He cannot be blamed for the first crash, but he absolutely bears a direct responsibility for every person who died in the second crash, as by that point he knew that he had delivered a product that had not been correctly and fully certified by the regulatory authority.

An ethical person with that knowledge, whether they be an engineer, lawyer, or a circus clown, would have fought tooth and nail to ensure the aircraft was grounded.

I am much more interested in the ethics of any particular leader, than their credentials.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by goku12 on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @12:43AM (#45434300)
The mistake was committed willfully well before the first crash. Their emails during the development and testing of the Max 8 show some strongly worded exchanges clearly indicating their full awareness of the troubles with the MCAS system. There was one simulated flight by a test pilot where the MCAS had activated and was deemed a catastrophic failure. In another instance, the chief test pilot said, "I basically lied to the regulators, unknowingly" - a mistake that he chose not to rectify. It was abundantly clear at that point that business as usual was going to cost lives. The entire top management knew this and yet, not one of them decided to step in.

The first crash was already too late for them. A team that behaved so callously earlier wasn't going to stop at that point without an external intervention. They were in fact attempting to scapegoat the pilots even after the second crash. Therefore, putting the blame on one CEO at the time of the first crash is illogical. The blame must fall on the team that established such an unbelievably flawed safety culture in the first place. Who was that? And why?

I'm not insisting that accountants and lawyers are unfit for top management. There are corporate portfolios that they're the best fit for - like accounting and law firms. Then there are the exceptions who do a sensible job even outside their portfolio. But I have seen both engineering heavy and accounting heavy managements. As expected, their priorities and operational philosophies are drastically different. But their influence doesn't end there. They also define the wider company culture - A culture that not even a CEO can change without significant personal effort against institutional inertia.

So, accountants or lawyers may be sufficient to lead IT companies. But if they choose to lead an industry where so many lives are at stake, they better hold back their profit-seeking instincts and understand the safety culture and the consequences of their decisions damn well.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by gamblor956 on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @11:33AM (#45438979)
declining one has an accountant in charge, and a dying one has a lawyer in charge.

You would think by now that HN would understand that there is a difference between the accountants and the finance guys. The greatest con that Finance achieved is convincing everyone that the accountants were to blame for everything finance did. But the accountants just handle the transactional details. They don't make the financial decisions.

And generally a dying company should have a lawyer in charge because their mandate is to try to negotiate selling off the company or its assets, or to run it through bankruptcy.