Second, with that out the way, these cars are not playing the same game as horses… first, and quite obviously they have massive amounts of horsepower, which is kind of like giving a team of horses… many more horses. But also cars have an absolutely massive fuel capacity. Petrol is such an efficient store of chemical energy compared to hay and cars can store gallons of it.
I think if you give my horse the ability of 300 horses and fed it pure gasoline, I would be kind of embarrassed if it wasn’t able to win a horse race.
Actually that's too generous, because the humans are given a time limit in ICPC, and there's no clear mapping to say how the LLM's compute should be limited to make a comparison.
It IS an interesting result to see how models can do on these tests - and it's also a garbage headline.
I'm talking about the headline saying they "won gold" at a competition they didn't, and couldn't, compete in.
We are at that point now with AI, so a more fitting headline analogy would be "In a world first, automobile finishes with gold-winning time in horse race".
Headlines like those were a sign that cars would eventually replace horses in most use-cases, so the fact that we could be in the the same place now with AI and humans is a big deal.
A vetoed 1896 Pennsylvania law would have required drivers who encountered livestock to "disassemble the automobile" and "conceal the various components out of sight, behind nearby bushes until [the] equestrian or livestock is sufficiently pacified". The Locomotive on Highways Act of 1865 required early motorized vehicles to be preceded by a person on foot waving a red flag or carrying a red lantern and blowing a horn.
It might not quite look like that today, but wild-eyed, fear-based regulation as AI use grows is a real possibility. And at least some of it will likely seem just as silly in hindsight.
To celebrate the raising of the speed limit to a daring 12mph, a group of motorists organised a drive from London to Brighton. At the time, driving 54 miles in a single day was seen as an audacious feat and few people imagined that such a great distance could be travelled in such complicated and newfangled contraptions without mechanical incident.
For decades, the car was seen as a plaything for the wealthy that served no practical purpose. The car only became an important mode of transportation after very many false starts and against strong opposition.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locomotive_Acts#Locomotives_Ac...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_to_Brighton_Veteran_Car...
That would be indeed an interesting race around the time cars were invented. Today that would be silly, since everyone knows what cars are capable of, but back then one can imagine a lot more skepticism.
Just as there is a ton of skepticism today of what LLMs can achieve. A competition like this clearly demonstrates where the tech is, and what is possible.
> there's no clear mapping to say how the LLM's compute should be limited to make a comparison
There is a very clear mapping of course. You give the same wall clock time to the computer you gave to the humans.
Because what it is showing is that the computer can do the same thing a human can under the same conditions. With your analogy here they are showing that there is such a thing as a car and it can travel 100 meters.
Once it is a foregone conclusion that an LLM can solve the ICPC problems and that question has been sufficiently driven home to everyone who cares we can ask further ones. Like “how much faster can it solve the problems compared to the best humans” or “how much energy it consumes while solving them”? It sounds like you went beyond the first question and already asking these follow up questions.
Not enough to say they "won gold". Just say what actually happened! The tweets themselves do, but then we have this clickbait headline here on HN somehow that says they "won gold at ICPC".
That's a very interesting question. When comparing wildly different computing machines, how to make a fair comparison?
At least two criteria comes in mind: the volume and the energy consumption.
Indeed we can safely assume that more volume and more energy leads to more computation power. For example, it is not fair to compare a 10m^3 room filled with computers with 10cm^3 computer. The same goes with the number of kilowhat-hours used.
Thinking further on those two criteria for GPUs and humans, we could also consider the access to energy and volume. First, energy access for machines has dramatically increased since the industrial revolution. Second, volume access for machines has also increased since the beginning of the mass production. In particular, creating one cube meter of new GPUs is faster than giving birth to a new human.
tldr: fair comparison of two machines should take into account their volume and their energy consumption. On the other hand, this might be mitigated by how fast a machine can increase its volume, and what is its bandwidth for energy consumption.
"They really cant run like a human," they say, "a human can traverse a city in complete silence, needing minimal walking room. Left unchecked, the transitions to cars would ruin our city. So lets be prudent when it comes to adopting this technology."
"I'll have none of that. Cars move faster than humans so that means they're better. We should do everything in our power to transition to this obviously superior technology. I mean, a car beat a human at the 100m sprint so bipedal mobility is obviously obsolete," the car maker replied.
Yes. That’s why cars don’t compete in equestrian events and horses don’t go to F1 races.
This non-controversial surely? You want different events for humans, humans + computers, and just computers.
Notice that self driving cars have separate race events from both horses and human-driven cars.
"did we build a vehicle faster than a horse, yes/no?"
Which matters a lot when horses are the fastest land vehicle available. (We're so used to thinking of horses as a quaint and slow mean of transport that maybe we don't realize that for millennia they've been the fastest possible way to get from one place to another.)
Yeah fair. There's also that famous human vs horse race that happens every few years. So far humans keep winning (because it's long distance)
That’s how I read it at least - exactly how you put it
The other commenter is pointing out how ridiculous it would be for someone to downplay the performance of cars because they did it differently from horses. It doesn't matter if they did it using different methods, that fact that the final outcome was better had world-changing ramifications.
The same applies here. Downplaying AI because it has different strengths or plays by different rules is foolish, because that doesn't matter in the real world. People will choose the option that that leads to the better/faster/cheaper outcome, and that option is quickly becoming AI instead of humans - just like cars quickly became the preferred option over horses. And that is crazy to think about.
Now obviously it's more impressive as they don't have infinite compute and had finite time but the car only has one entry in each race unless we start getting into some anime ass shit with divergent timelines and one of the cars (and some lesser amount of horses) finishing instantly.
To your last point we don't know that this was cheaper since they don't disclose the cost. I would blindly guess a mechanical turk for the same cost would outperform at least today.
Even though all the criticism were, in a sense, valid, in the end none of it amounted to a serious challenge to getting good at the task at hand.
(I did enjoy the sarcasm, though!)
Ergo, it's impressive with nuance. As the other commenter said.
If a human can look up similar previous problems just as the "AI" can, it is a huge advantage.
Syzygy tables in chess engines are a similar issue. They allow perfect play, and there is no reason why a computer gets them and a human does not (if you compare humans against chess engines). Humans have always worked with reference material for serious work.
Perhaps this helps:
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/technology/tech-news/exp...
https://mathstodon.xyz/@tao/114881418225852441
Especially:
"* The team leader gives the students unlimited access to calculators, computer algebra packages, formal proof assistants, textbooks, or the ability to search the internet."
Also, who cares? It's a self contained non-human system that could solve an ICPC problem it hasn't seen before on its own, which hasn't been achieved before.
If there was a savant human contestant with photographic memory who could remember every previous ICPC problem verbatim and can think really fast you wouldn't say they're cheating, just that they're really smart. Same here.
If there was a man behind the curtain that was somehow making this not an AI achievement then you would have a point, but there isn't.
Small model solves an easy problem; big model solves a challenging problem. I wouldn't call those problems; they are more like invented puzzles. Perfect match for the AI marketing department to "solve".
The marketing speak of some companies goes into effectively fantastical territory. Some claims that are made effectively imply P = NP, which is like bad TV-series-level science fiction, but some people fall for it.
Humans have surpassed their own strength since the invention of the lever thousands of years ago. Since then, it has been a matter of finding power sources millions of times greater such as nuclear energy
Are the humans allowed to bring their laptops and use the internet? Or a downloaded copy?
Humans are more efficient watt for watt than any AI ever invented.
Now if you were to limit AIs to 400 watts we could probably thinks it's fair.
Indeed they are. For now. The long term trend is not in our favor.
https://www.voronoiapp.com/energy/-China-Generated-More-Elec...
But you can also conclude that putting a lot of money and effort pays off. It's more like comparing a horse to a Ferrari that had millions of development costs, has a team of engineers maintaining it, isn't reusable, and just about beats Chestnut. It's a long way until the utility of both is matched.
I don't know what your personal experience with competitive programming is, so your statement may be true for yourself, but I can confidently state that this is not true for the VAST majority of programmers and software engineers.
Much like trying to do IMO problems without tons of training/practice, the mid-to-hard problems in the ICPC are completely unapproachable to the average computer science student (who already has a better chance than the average software engineer) in the course of a week.
In the same way that LLMs have memorized tons of stuff, the top competitors capable of achieving a gold medal at the ICPC know algorithms, data structures, and how to pattern match them to problems to an extreme degree.
That may well be true. I think it's even more true in cases where the user is not a programmer by profession. I once watched someone present their graduate-level research in a different field and explain how they had solved a real-world problem in their field by writing a complicated computer program full of complicated heuristics to get it to run fast enough and thinking "hmm, I'm pretty sure that a standard algorithm from computer graphics could be adapted to directly solve your problem in O(n log n) time".
If users can get usable algorithms that approximately match the state of the art out of a chatbot (or a fancy "agent") without needing to know the magic words, then that would be amazing, regardless of whether those chatbots/agents ever become creative enough to actually advance the state of the art.
(I sometimes dream of an AI producing a piece of actual code that comes even close to state of the art for solving mixed-integer optimization problems. That's a whole field of wonderful computer science / math that is mostly usable via a couple of extraordinarily expensive closed-source offerings.)
Take a look at Google OR-Tools: https://developers.google.com/optimization/
Compute and such is a fair point but that AI is here at all is mind-blowing to me.
This is where I see the biggest issue. LLMs are first-and-foremost text compression algorithms. They have a compressed version of a very good chunk of human writing.
After being text compression engines, LLMs are really good at interpolating text based on the generalization induced by the lossy compression.
What this result really tells us is that, given a reasonably well compressed corpus of human knowledge, the ICPC can be view as an interpolation task.
- compress (in a relatively recoverable way) the entire domain of human knowledge
- interpolate across the entire domain of human knowledge
- draw connections or conclusions that haven't previously been stated explicitly
- verify or disprove those conclusions or connections
- update its internal model based on that (further expanding the domain it can interpolate within)
Then I think we're cooking with gasoline. I guess the question becomes whether those new conclusions or connections result in a convergent or divergent increase in the number of new conclusions and connections the model can draw (e.g. do we understand better the domains we already know or does updating the model with these new conclusions/connections allow us to expand the scope of knowledge we understand to new domains).
You don't remember every detail of what you've seen correct? You store some lossy compression like "I went to a park"
My argument does feel a bit like the “Watson doesn’t need to physically push the button” equivalents from when that system beat Jeopardy for the first time. I assume 5 hours on a single high-end Mac would probably still be enough compute in the near future.
https://www.wired.com/2011/02/ibm-watson-speed/
> __Brown: __ Watson has a mechanical button-presser. It uses the same signaling device [the button] that the human competitors use in the game. Once Watson has decided that it wants to ring in because it has found an answer with a high-enough confidence, and it receives the signal that the buzzers are open and you can ring in, it then has to trigger the mechanical button presser and mechanically press the button.
The fact that they don't disclose the cost is a clue that it's probably outrageous today. But costs are coming down fast. And hiring a team of these guys isn't exactly cheap either.
- We're currently unlocking capabilities to solve many tasks which could previously only be solved by the top-1% of the experts in the field.
- Almost all of that progress is coming from large scale deep learning. Turns out transformers with autoregression + RL are mighty generalists (tho yet far from AGI).
Once it becomes cheap enough so the average joe can tinker with models of this scale, every engineering field can apply it to their niche interest. And ultimately nobody cares if you're playing by the same rules as humans outside of these competitions, they only care that you make them wealthy, healthy and comfy.
We are most definitely in agreement about the folly of comparing the abilities of LLMs to humans, since LLMs are to a greater extent the product of much collective human endeavour. "Living memories" would perhaps be a better description of their current state, and their resultant impact on the human psyche.
Training one model nowadays uses more than that. So the model also cost more to train than to raise a team member (possibly all three of them)
That works out to about 72 years365 days2000 kcal = approx 61 gWh
Rather, the impressive thing is simply that an AI is capable of solving these problems at all. These are novel (ie not in training set) problems that are really hard and beyond the ability of most professional programmers. The "gold medal" part is informative more in the sense that it gives an indication of how many problems the AI was able to solve & how well it was able to do them.
When talking with some friends about chatgpt just a couple years ago I remember being very confident that there was no way this technology would be able to solve this kind of novel, very challenging reasoning problem, and that there was no way it would be able to solve IMO problems. It's remarkable how quickly I've been proven wrong.
If not were penalities applied for multiple solutions.
First, this is really impressive.
Second, with that out of the way, these models are not playing the same game as the human contestants, in at least two major regards. First, and quite obviously, they have massive amounts of compute power, which is kind of like giving a human team a week instead of five hours. But the models that are competing have absolutely massive memorization capacity, whereas the teams are allowed to bring a 25-page PDF with them and they need to manually transcribe anything from that PDF that they actually want to use in a submission.
I think that, if you gave me the ability to search the pre-contest Internet and a week to prepare my submissions, I would be kind of embarrassed if I didn't get gold, and I'd find the contest to be rather less interesting than I would find the real thing.