News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Ajedi32 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:11PM (#45203801)
"Give me liberty or give me death!" - Patrick Henry, 1775

Same sentiment. For a lot of people, freedom is more valuable than even life itself.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by k099 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:52PM (#45204439)
The difference is, Henry was only offering himself.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by jadamson on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:50PM (#45206734)
> "Give me liberty or give me death!" is a quotation attributed to American politician and orator Patrick Henry from a speech he made to the Second Virginia Convention on March 23, 1775, at St. John's Church in Richmond, Virginia. Henry is credited with having swung the balance in convincing the convention to pass a resolution delivering Virginian troops for the Revolutionary War.

Were the troops his clones?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dionian on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:20PM (#45203911)
I agree with Henry
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by firesteelrain on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:28PM (#45204054)
Why are comments like this exact quote being posted everywhere?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by FireBeyond on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:58PM (#45204530)
Kirk felt that preventable gun deaths were an acceptable cost to the continuation of the Second Amendment.

This time, it was he that fell victim to a preventable gun death. No more, no less.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by laverya on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:38PM (#45205046)
Even California and Hawaii don't ban hunting rifles. Same with Australia and the UK. Can you name a single country that totally bans the ownership of all firearms and enforces it? Would you like to live there?

(The rifle used isn't known yet, but only one shot was fired)

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by twixfel on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:41PM (#45205083)
OK but these assassinations an assassination attempts are happening in the US, not the UK.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by laverya on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:50PM (#45205188)
Agreed, but the difference in the use of rifles in assassination attempts between the US and UK/EU/AUS/etc can't purely be because of a lack of gun control in the US if the same rifles are available in those other countries too. (semiautomatic military style rifles like used in the first attempt on Trump are almost always more restricted overseas, but again this was only a single shot and could easily have been from a bolt-action rifle)
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by twixfel on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:09AM (#45208374)
That's not the whole story though. Whatever weapons are available in the UK, they're far harder to obtain than in the US. It's a mixture of both of these issues. Whenever I visit the USA, what always strikes me quite quickly, is just how many mentally ill people there are literally everywhere just roaming the streets, and how the non-mentally-ill people deal with them. I've only had my life threatened once in my life, and that was when a homeless man threatened to kill me in New York. No big deal in the USA, happens all the time, but quite difficult to understand how you guys accept this "way of life" and just let it be and choose to do nothing about it at all.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by FireBeyond on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:33PM (#45206621)
Interesting choice of countries - as someone who was actually born in the UK, grew up in Australia, and now lives in the US, I have no idea what the relevance of those details has to what I said.

I merely remarked that someone else considered preventable gun deaths an acceptable cost to what he considered as sacrosanct. Well, tragic as his death is, I'm not the one who considered it an acceptable cost.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by laverya on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:24PM (#45206997)
Australia and the UK are commonly used in the US gun control debate as places where gun confiscation worked, and CA/HI are the states with the most restrictive gun control policies.

My response was meant to illustrate that this was essentially not a "preventable gun death", or at least not preventable by any level of gun control ever implemented in a Western country. Similarly, the assassination of Shinzo Abe using a homemade pistol/blunderbuss was not a preventable gun death.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by defrost on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:03PM (#45207236)
> where gun confiscation worked

Australia now has more guns per capita than it did prior to the national unification of gun laws.

Unwanted guns, guns no one was willing to license, and guns not acceptable for licensing were bought back for cash, filling skip bins full of guns - much publicized as confiscation in the US.

Australian gun control was about regulation - every legal gun registered and tracked, every gun sale logged, twelve year olds joining gun clubs only with qualified supervision and unable to purchase and own a gun until adulthood.

Gun regulation following the Port Arthur massacre, the largest mass shooting in the world at that time, changed relatively little in West Australia at that time - what did happen was that regulation in Queensland, in Tasmania, and the Northern Territory and the ACT were all bought in line with with the major states of Australia for a uniform nation wide code.

I'm in rural Australia, I have firearms, my close neighbour target shoots at 5,000 yards (not a typo - 24 inch steel targets at five thousand yards - longer than any confirmed sniper shot as he and his partner are ULR (ultra long range) fanatics .. and good at it).

What regulation in Australia has achieved is a near elimination of mass shooting events, since Port Arthur there have been fewer than fingers on hand such events in 25+ years total - ie fewer mass shooting than occur in five days in the USofA.

It's also made guns extremely difficult to access for village idiots, the stupidly violent, petty criminals, etc.

Unregistered guns are on the rise in Australia being smuggled in and used by criminal enterprises with not stupid ex military enforcers, ghost guns are about, etc.

Having strong regulation makes for more open ground and an easier time of it cracking down on criminal use of guns.

It hasn't eliminated assassination by gunshot, but such events are relatively rare in Australia.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by yacthing on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:36PM (#45204173)
It's a form of "I told you so". It's insensitive, but probably appropriate given the importance of moving forward gun control efforts.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dpkirchner on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:18PM (#45204791)
I'm tired of us non-right-wingers being expected to be more sensitive.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by typeofhuman on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:51PM (#45204423)
Gun control efforts never prevent gun crime.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by faku812 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:16PM (#45204766)
The only thing gun control does is it replaces some of gun crime with knife crime (just look at Europe).
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by bobsomers on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:46PM (#45205139)
It's pretty hard to kill 40 people in 5 seconds with a knife.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by idontwantthis on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:32PM (#45204968)
Show me a knife that can kill at 200 yds.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by yacthing on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:31PM (#45204955)
Wow, I didn't expect to see so many disingenuous right-wing talking points on HN.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by cosmicgadget on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:31PM (#45204951)
> While we recognize that assault weapon legislation will not stop all assault weapon crime, statistics prove that we can dry up the supply of these guns, making them less accessible to criminals.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by yacthing on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:07PM (#45204653)
What's your definition of "prevent"?

Eliminate? Of course it doesn't. Especially in a country with 400 million guns already out there.

Reduce? Of course it does.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by firesteelrain on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:56AM (#45207936)
He was a commentator and a right to articulate his views. He didn’t deserve to be murdered
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dyauspitr on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:39PM (#45205056)
Because it’s ironic since by his own admission his death is is acceptable and not a big deal.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by firesteelrain on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:57AM (#45207937)
He was a commentator and a right to articulate his views. He didn’t deserve to be murdered
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dyauspitr on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:03AM (#45208339)
He can preach a denial of empathy to others but he deserves our empathy?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by firesteelrain on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:08PM (#45213221)
Empathy is not a reciprocal contract. If you only give it to those who already endorse it, you are practicing favoritism, not empathy. Kirk may have rejected empathy, but choosing to extend it to him tests our own principles rather than his.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dyauspitr on Thursday September 11, 2025 @03:20PM (#45215181)
No, if you refuse empathy to others then refusing that same empathy to you makes me a better person- an upholder of the social contract.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by firesteelrain on Friday September 12, 2025 @08:22AM (#45221359)
What you describe is reciprocity, not empathy. Empathy is unilateral. If you only extend it to those who extended it first, it stops being empathy and becomes retaliation. Choosing to empathize with someone who denied it is about who you are, not who they were.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by aj7 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:51PM (#45203502)
The entire right banks in the fact that the left has a passivist mentality in the U.S. That said, when the left is violent, they are brutally suppressed.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by criddell on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:46PM (#45204346)
The last time the NRA fought for gun control (AFAIK) is in response to Black Panther open carrying back in the 1960’s.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by aj7 on Friday September 12, 2025 @02:30PM (#45225100)
Just what was going through my head when I made the comment.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slt2021 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:54PM (#45203530)
its not the 2nd amendment that killed him, it is political violence.

Political violence cannot be deterred with strict gun laws. Remember, it is only law abiding citizens who are affected by the gun laws. Criminals by definition don't need to follow the law and they don't need the 2nd amendment

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by yepitwas on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @07:57PM (#45205830)
One of the most popular arguments in favor of the necessity of the second amendment as an individual (not collective) right is precisely so ordinary people can engage in political violence.

The current president even suggested doing so was ok, in his first campaign, naming the amendment in the process. (Anyone who was paying attention at the time and noticed this didn’t immediately end his campaign like it definitely would have in any prior election in living memory, should have been able to guess we were about to have a spike in political violence)

There’s no “defense of liberty” justification for the individual right to bear arms that isn’t also saying “political violence is sometimes necessary”.

(I happen to think that justification’s silly, personally—I’m not endorsing it)

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by joshlemer on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:26PM (#45204905)
> Criminals by definition don't need to follow the law and they don't need the 2nd amendment.

This is kind of an argument from tautology that is disconnected to reality. In the real world, supply of criminality and violence is elastic, if you raise the cost, you lower the amount supplied. Crimes and violence committed are affected by committers having the opportunity and tenacity to do so. If you erect more barriers to achieving it, make it less convenient or straight forward to do it, you'll deter some percentage of violence/criminality who just give up or don't make it past the hurdle or whatever.

Otherwise, to take your argument to its logical conclusion, we could get a whole bunch of dumb conclusions, like:

We should just abolish auditing and other anti-corruption accountability mechanisms. By definition, cheats don't need to follow the law, so auditing doesn't catch them, it just imposes extra paperwork on law-abiding citizens!

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:25PM (#45204012)
> Political violence cannot be deterred with strict gun laws.

Definitely, considering what is happening in Nepal ATM. However, some kind of ban on gun supply (not just controlling them) definitely has an impact on your country's murder rate. You can't just expect 20 million guns produced in the USA for consumers not to get in the hands of people who want to do bad things with them. Really, I would be happy if they just lowered that number a lot (to say 1 million) without any other gun control laws, the murder rate across the whole continent would fall.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slt2021 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:31PM (#45204111)
or just jail criminals El Salvador style. Bukele showed us that having a high crime environment is a policy choice, an explicit policy chosen by the government
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:39PM (#45204234)
Police state measures are only temporary, El Salvador can't sustain a 2% incarceration rate forever.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by pjc50 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:53PM (#45204461)
Doesn't the US have something like a 3% incarceration rate already, for years?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:23PM (#45204871)
You just have to use search no?

El Salvador:

Rate: Over 1,000 per 100,000 residents as of early 2024, with a specific rate of 1,659 per 100,000 in March 2024.

USA:

The U.S. incarceration rate was approximately 541 per 100,000 residents in 2022, with nearly two million people in state or federal prisons and local jails. The U.S. has the highest incarceration rate among independent democracies and is home to the world's largest prison population.

(we don't get a rate for 2024, but it probably hasn't grown much since then)

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by wpm on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:27PM (#45204914)
Is it sustainable?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by crooked-v on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:44PM (#45204326)
Criminals, plus the other (and this is a very lowball number) 50,000+ people incarcerated for life with no due process. El Salvador has incarcated 2.5% of the entire adult population, most of those in sham mass trials where an entire group of people get marched through the same kangaroo court with no individual legal process.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by cm2187 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:44PM (#45204310)
particularly if he was killed indeed with a hunting rifle. You can find those in pretty much any country.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by esarbe on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:32PM (#45204122)
What makes you think this was political violence?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by bdhe on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:22PM (#45203944)
> Political violence cannot be deterred with strict gun laws.

If a simplistic definition of political violence is targeted killings of political leaders, then this is trivially false. Look at Europe, Australia and other countries with comparable statistics to US and look at the number of events you'd classify as political violence. It is likely zero. The only person I can think of from recent memory is Shinzo Abe.

In the US alone, thanks to no gun control, we have attempts at Presidential candidates, and successful killings of state-level law makers, CEOs, and now, political influencers.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slt2021 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:30PM (#45204089)
>>thanks to no gun control

talking about gun control as a form of solution is talking about spilled milk under the bridge. There are 100 guns per capita in the US and even if gun sales are banned, the black market will be enough to supply guns for another century

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by 01100011 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:38PM (#45204230)
Por que no los dos?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:10PM (#45203774)
> Criminals by definition don't need to follow the law and they don't need the 2nd amendment

"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed. " - The US Constitution

Neither do private citizens.

What part of "well regulated militia" is unclear? Maybe all of it if you have a political slant, but no literate person who didn't set out with an agenda actually takes the second amendment to mean "any lunatic with $100 and an axe to grind should be allowed to own weapons of mass destruction without even proving they're sober and sane."

It means what it says, not what some gun owners like to pretend it says and the simple truth is that making them harder to get does actually reduce crime every single time it's been tried.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by jandrewrogers on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:32PM (#45204124)
The definition of "militia" has been explicitly written into US law since the 18th century, you don't need to guess at its meaning. It essentially includes every able-bodied male and explicitly recognizes that this militia exists separate from any "organized" militia. Being part of the militia is not an exclusive club, a large percentage of all Americans are a member as a matter of law.

That said, I would argue that the definition should be updated to include women as well.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:40PM (#45204245)
Actually, lets let James Madison (who wrote the amendment) explain what a militia is:

Madison said "the advantage of being armed," together with "the existence of subordinate governments, to which the people are attached, and by which the militia officers are appointed, forms a barrier against the enterprises of ambition, more insurmountable than any which a simple government of any form can admit of."

Source: https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/amdt2-2/ALDE_...

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:34PM (#45204148)
You will note that the 18th century is quite some time AFTER the constitution was drafted.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by zamadatix on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:46PM (#45204355)
I often get the indexing confused myself - the 18th century is the 1700s.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:13PM (#45204737)
You are right of course. Thanks for explaining rather than just downvoting.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by skulk on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:34PM (#45204145)
This is off-topic, but it always amuses me that the sentence isn't even a grammatically correct construction in English, and I don't think it was in the 1770s or whenever this was written.

  - A well regulated Militia: noun phrase,
  - being necessary to the security of a free State: parenthetical phrase,
  - the right of the people to keep and bear Arms: another noun phrase
  - shall not be: verb 
  - infringed: adjective
Two consecutive noun phrases separated by a parenthetical is not valid English grammar. The only time I can imagine you'd see consecutive noun phrases is as part of a list of at least 3 elements (like "x, y, and z"), but there is no list here.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:51PM (#45207161)
The history explains the oddness a bit. It was originally loosely based on Pennsylvania and Massachusetts Bill of Rights which said:

> "That the people have a right to bear arms for the defence of themselves and the state; and as standing armies in the time of peace are dangerous to liberty, they ought not to be kept up; And that the military should be kept under strict subordination to, and governed by, the civil power."

I think that's very clear. They were deeply concerned about the threat a standing army posed, and wanted the militias to act as a balance. Based loosely on that Madison's first draft then said:

> "The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed; a well armed and well regulated militia being the best security of a free country: but no person religiously scrupulous of bearing arms shall be compelled to render military service in person."

Again, more comprehensible than what we have today. Still a bit oddly phrased, but it's clear that the right can't be infringed BECAUSE we need a well regulated militia.

Then, after much debate and quibbling over the exact phrasing and in regard to religious objectors the committee submitted this to the senate:

> "A well regulated militia, composed of the body of the People, being the best security of a free State, the right of the People to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed, but no one religiously scrupulous of bearing arms, shall be compelled to render military service in person."

As you can see, even this version was a more complete thought, and made it very clear what the purpose of those arms actually was.

However, the senate then did the final butchery, that resulted in the version we have today and because unscrupulous people have exploited it's vagueness, school children can't be safe:

> A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

Reference: https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/amdt2-2/ALDE_...

To me, the real bitch is that the original purpose (to serve as a balance against the standing army) is completely null. There is no militia, or even professionally trained army strong enough to stand against the permanent army the founding fathers didn't even want us to have. Thermonuclear warheads and fighter jets didn't exist back then.

Even though the NRA likes to claim the "militia" means every American, that is NOT what Madison and the others meant by it. It's made clear in the Federalist papers, and even if it were what the founding fathers meant not even the NRA seems to be taking the stance that since the "miltia" means "Everyone" then "Everyone" can own thermonuclear warheads.

The second amendment has been wrongfully interpreted, and it's killing people.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dexterdog on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:28PM (#45204053)
> What part of "well regulated militia" is unclear?

What part of "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed" is unclear? If you're going to base your argument on the first few words you can't win against the opposition does the same with the last part.

> Maybe all of it if you have a political slant, but no literate person who didn't set out with an agenda actually takes the second amendment to mean "any lunatic with $100 and an axe to grind should be allowed to own weapons of mass destruction without even proving they're sober and sane."

What WMDs can be had for only $100 that would actually fall under firearm regulation?

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:42PM (#45204276)
> What WMDs can be had for only $100 that would actually fall under firearm regulation?

Maybe I have a coupon? Is the price really the part of this that sticks in your craw?

>If you're going to base your argument on the first few words you can't win against the opposition does the same with the last part.

I'm fine with not infringing on the well regulated militias rights. Exactly as it was written.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dexterdog on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:14PM (#45217073)
> Maybe I have a coupon? Is the price really the part of this that sticks in your craw?

It was the price and also the reference to WMDs. You can't get WMDs at all so the price part is irrelevant.

> I'm fine with not infringing on the well regulated militias rights. Exactly as it was written.

That's also a cherry-picking way to interpret that line. You're intentionally leaving out the part that is inconvenient to your opinion.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:54PM (#45217315)
> You can't get WMDs at all so the price part is irrelevant.

How many deaths per minute do you consider the minimum to qualify as a WMD? There are probably several firearms legally available that can meet it.

> That's also a cherry-picking way to interpret that line.

See my other post beneath this grandparent. It's long, but a bit more nuanaced.

It's objectively clear what the founding fathers meant, and it wasn't "lunatics should be able to buy guns without a drug test first" as the NRA seems to think.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by WillPostForFood on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:29PM (#45204066)
It is unclear, it is easy to misread using inaccurate modern interpretation of the words.

well regulated = properly functioning, like a watch is well regulated when it keeps good time

militia = everyone, all citizens. In counterpoint to the army, professional paid soldiers.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:37PM (#45204202)
> well regulated = properly functioning, like a watch is well regulated when it keeps good time

No it doesn't. Even then that usage was uncommon. This is something later scholars made up to justify their position.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:21PM (#45207375)
I was wrong about this.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by HaZeust on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:22PM (#45203953)
Heller put your claims to sleep. For better or worse, this ideologue lost.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by mapontosevenths on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:33PM (#45204132)
It did, but it was a politically motivated decision that had most serious scholars without an agenda agree was flawed. Scalia decided to treat the miltia bit as if it were entirely prefatory, which of course begs the question "why did the put it in there if they didn't mean it?"

Again, common sense says that it means what it says and you don't get to ignore the bits you don't like.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ohdeargodno on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:13PM (#45204726)
"I can't stand the word empathy. I think empathy is a made up new age term that does a lot of damage" -- Charlie Kirk, who would be very angry at your condolences apparently.

But then again, when it comes to quoting a culture war grifter, you can find a lot of stupid ass quotes.

[dead]
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by Hammershaft on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:10PM (#45203780)
I don't agree with Kirk's politics but it really doesn't take much effort to recognize that no, he didn't say he wanted to live in a country with gun violence. I think an honest interpretation is that he valued the freedom to own guns, despite recognizing that freedom might result in violence or death.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dijit on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:22PM (#45203951)
i think you’re both saying the same thing here.

Gun violence doesn’t just happen to other people, it happens randomly and to anyone, even those who choose not to own guns.

Pointing out the irony that he died because of gun violence despite stating that gun violence is an acceptable cost is mean spirited and insensitive in the moment, but not incorrect.

He advocated for circumstances for which this could happen, he probably just assumed it would never happen to him.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slg on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:22PM (#45203961)
I didn’t say Kirk wants this to happen, I said he wants to live in a country in which this happens. He knew gun violence was a trade off for the policies in which he advocated and he was willing to make that trade.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ImJamal on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:04PM (#45203698)
He didn't wish for stuff like this to happen. He was saying that the 2nd amendment is more important than losing it even if some people die as a result.

This is no different than many of us who think that the 1st amendment is worth retaining even if people use it to hire hitman or coordinate kidnappings and what not.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slg on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:27PM (#45204030)
Part of the problem with defining the 2nd amendment as a defense against tyranny, like Kirk did, is that none of us have any control over how one crazy individual defines tyranny. I don’t fear what that hypothetical crazy individual can do with their 1st amendment rights, but I do fear what they can do with their 2nd amendment rights.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ImJamal on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:30PM (#45204084)
> I don’t fear what that hypothetical crazy individual can do with their 1st amendment rights

Plenty of people use free speech to do bad things. Look at Trump using his rhetoric to get into power. Or outside the US you can see all sorts of crazy leaders gaining power.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slg on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:57PM (#45204518)
Sorry, I’m not going to follow you down this path. Violence is more dangerous than words. It’s one of the first lessons we all learn as kids, sticks and stones…
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ImJamal on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:14PM (#45204740)
I'm not saying that words are more dangerous. I'm saying that allowing certain speech can lead to violence yet many of us would still like to protect free speech.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by slg on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:38PM (#45205047)
I don’t know what point you’re trying to make. Inciting violence is not protected speech.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ImJamal on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:29PM (#45206112)
I'm talking about indirect calls to violence that are protected. Trump's rhetoric, despite an explicit statement to not break the law, led to January 6th.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by klaff on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:20PM (#45203909)
What does the first amendment have to do with hiring a hit man?
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ImJamal on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:28PM (#45204049)
Sorry, I wasn't clear. People support encryption saying they have the right to private communication and algorithms are protected under the first amendment. People use encrypted communication to do unsavory things like hiring hitmen, viewing child porn, etc.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by jakeinspace on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:44PM (#45204312)
Neither of those things are considered protected speech, and you can be imprisoned for conspiracy to commit kidnapping/murder even if neither actually occur.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ImJamal on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:28PM (#45206102)
And murder is against the law and not a proper use of the 2nd amendment. My point is that people can abuse their rights to do bad things. We don't use people doing bad things with their speech to remove the 1st amendment.