News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by lordofgibbons on Monday September 08, 2025 @05:51PM (#45174492)
Given how WhatsApp is the de-facto way to communicate outside of the West and China, these security/data-handling "weaknesses" are most likely a feature, not a bug. An absolute bonanza for the certain intelligence services.

Remember, kids: End to end encryption is useless if the "ends" are fully controlled by an (untrustworthy) third party.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by cataflam on Monday September 08, 2025 @06:55PM (#45175183)
> outside of the West

you probably mean outside of the USA, it's huge in Europe/UK

(which doesn't contradict your main point)

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by kwanbix on Monday September 08, 2025 @08:12PM (#45175811)
It is huge in Latin America.

USA is special because it is the (only?) country where iPhone has more users than Android.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by brazukadev on Monday September 08, 2025 @09:02PM (#45176169)
It's crazy how an US company dominates the world's messaging market but not in the US
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by oarla on Monday September 08, 2025 @09:20PM (#45176277)
It’s not uncommon. Orkut back in the day was wildly popular in Latin America and India. WhatsApp is the same. I think users in NA have a lot of high quality options as against those in Asia and LatAm who don’t have much reliable options other than ones developed in NA.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by SoftTalker on Monday September 08, 2025 @10:13PM (#45176616)
You can get an android phone for about one tenth of what a new iPhone costs. That’s why android dominates lower income markets. Apple decided they just don’t want to be there.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by somenameforme on Monday September 08, 2025 @10:40PM (#45176772)
It's definitely not the world's messaging market. For instance in Japan and many places in SEA, Line is the standard messenger - one many people probably haven't even heard of. Though it does have a nice play on words - are you on Line?
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by unethical_ban on Monday September 08, 2025 @09:40PM (#45176417)
Instagram and iMessage are also US owned services.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by tacker2000 on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @03:01AM (#45178479)
Well, FB didnt build up the initial user base, just purchased it and grew it from there.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by Sgt_Apone on Monday September 08, 2025 @09:17PM (#45176262)
iPhone has more users than Android in Canada and Japan as well. I think some Nordic countries too.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by 101008 on Monday September 08, 2025 @09:23PM (#45176294)
Yeah, huge in Latin America in the sense that a lot (most?) business only have a number that they use with Whatsapp (you can't call or even text them). Is it the same in Europe? Since I am from Latin America I never know if people from other continents use Whatsapp as much as we do, and if when I ask them to use Whatsapp I am imposing a new app or it's what they regularly use.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by Semaphor on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @12:41AM (#45177489)
No. Here in Germany WhatsApp is not even that widespread for businesses. But WA is very big here for personal communication, though Signal comes in second (at least amongst older people, and amongst my circle)
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by Vinnl on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @06:16AM (#45179992)
I think Europe is not homogenous enough for this, but in the Netherlands at least, there are plenty of companies that you can't call, email or text, but they'll have some other options: a chatbot, a web form, maybe a Twitter account, and sometimes via WhatsApp indeed.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by dontlaugh on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @03:00PM (#45186995)
Not quite, but not too far off.

If you give someone your number, they’ll text you on WhatsApp.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by heresie-dabord on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @02:25AM (#45178154)
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by zer0zzz on Monday September 08, 2025 @09:28PM (#45176333)
I’m not sure that’s true. I’m fairly certain UK, France, AU, Canada WhatsApp is not vastly more popular than the blue bubble alternative. At least I believe this was the case a few years ago, based on data I’d seen.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by cataflam on Monday September 08, 2025 @09:42PM (#45176428)
France and UK, from personal experience, whatsapp is big, especially for professional use, or friends/family groups.

Blue bubble isn't really a thing ever mentioned in France either, not enough iPhone market share.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by StopDisinfo910 on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @01:55AM (#45177939)
> Blue bubble isn't really a thing ever mentioned in France either, not enough iPhone market share.

Nobody uses iMessage. People with iPhone use WhatsApp too.

The user experience of iMessage used to be subpar and now everyone has WhatsApp installed anyway, the feature set is the same and it works on all phone brands so nobody feels like switching.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by discomrobertul8 on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @05:40AM (#45179731)
Same in the UK. The fact that iMessage only works for iOS devices means it's a complete non-starter. What's the point in using a messaging app if you can't add all your contacts to a group? And if you're using a different app for group chats for this reason, then why not use it for 1-1 messaging, too?
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by OJFord on Monday September 08, 2025 @11:33PM (#45177098)
I'm in the UK, I don't even know what 'the blue bubble alternative' is (Signal? Telegram?), everyone's on WhatsApp.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by serial_dev on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @12:48AM (#45177529)
I guess that it’s the iPhone’s messenger app? I heard that in that app, fellow iOS users have blue bubble messages and Android / other users have green bubble messages, and all the teens in the US /maybe Canada think it’s lame if you don’t have blue bubbles.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by OJFord on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @06:20AM (#45180029)
Oh. I remember hearing about that about 15y ago, didn't realise it was still a thing. I suppose because I haven't heard of anyone using iMessage for almost as long!
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by thaumasiotes on Monday September 08, 2025 @11:14PM (#45176970)
I would have thought he meant "inside of the West". Outside of the West you have other channels.

Russia: Telegram

Taiwan: Line

Japan: Line

By contrast, WhatsApp is best known to me for being used in Europe, Australia, and India.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by N19PEDL2 on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @01:47AM (#45177881)
I think the most used messaging app in Russia now is Max.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by throwaway290 on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @02:03AM (#45178003)
According to official statistics it is the most used app since 1 september 2025 /s
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by throwaway290 on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @01:57AM (#45177957)
Telegram is degraded/blocked in russia depending where you are and how authorities feel today
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by RyJones on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @03:34AM (#45178705)
Japan is mostly Instagram, line, WhatsApp, telegram, in that order, for me.

For business comms drop instagram and move WhatsApp to first.

For Singapore it seems LinkedIn messages are the go to IM for business.

Europe p2p: telegram number one by a huge margin, then WhatsApp. B2b: WhatsApp, period.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by jjani on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @12:59PM (#45184886)
Central Asia is Telegram as well.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by guappa on Thursday September 11, 2025 @09:42AM (#45211562)
I think in italy telegram is 2nd to whatsapp
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by crypto_throwa on Monday September 08, 2025 @06:19PM (#45174792)
Without open source, end to end encryption is useless. It's not hard to hide a piece of code that defeats the encryption in closed source code.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by __spooky__ on Monday September 08, 2025 @06:30PM (#45174923)
iMessage is end to end encrypted. Although Apple says it secure and the courts and FBI seem to not be able to get it in, it is still closed source.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by bigiain on Monday September 08, 2025 @06:55PM (#45175185)
I can't tell if I'm being paranoid or just realistic, when I suspect that FBI/Apple fights over decrypting/unlocking iPhones or iMessage are just part of Apple's security theater.

If I were Evil-Tim-Cook, I'd have a deal with the FBI (and other agencies) where I'd hand over some user's data, in return for them keeping that secret and occasionally very publicly taking Apple to court demanding they expose a specific user and intentionally losing - to bolster Apple's privacy reputation.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by throw0101a on Monday September 08, 2025 @07:05PM (#45175292)
> If I were Evil-Tim-Cook, I'd have a deal with the FBI (and other agencies) where I'd hand over some user's data, in return for them keeping that secret and occasionally very publicly taking Apple to court demanding they expose a specific user and intentionally losing - to bolster Apple's privacy reputation.

The FBI wants its investigations to go to court and lead to convictions. Any evidence gained in this way would be exposed as coming form Apple; notwithstanding parallel construction:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction

As for other agencies, I'm sure many have exploits to attack these devices and get spyware on them, and so may not need Apple's assistance.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by 14 on Monday September 08, 2025 @08:33PM (#45175976)
I imagine if you have the information parallel construction becomes trivial.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by worthless-trash on Monday September 08, 2025 @10:40PM (#45176770)
The killers app for ai.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by nkrisc on Monday September 08, 2025 @07:53PM (#45175667)
Wouldn’t it be easier to just not do that and have the same thing happen, but for real?
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by MangoToupe on Monday September 08, 2025 @07:08PM (#45175318)
Maybe. I think they'd have a hard time keeping that under wraps—governments aren't typically very careful (and the FBI is about as careful as a bull in a china shop) about not showing their hand when it comes to charging people. If you're strict about keeping certain info on certain channels, smart observers would notice if someone were snooping.

For instance, if someone shared something incriminating in a group chat and got arrested, and that info was only shared in the group chat, they'd have to silence everyone in that group chat to ensure that the channel still seemed secure. I don't think at least our government is that competent or careful.

But also, people wayyyy overhype how much apple tries to come off as privacy-forward. They sell ads and don't even allow you to deny apps access to the internet, and for the most part their phone security seems more focused on denying you control over your own phone rather than denying a third party access to it. I think they just don't want the hassle of complying with warrants. Stuff like pegasus would only be so easy to sell if you couldn't lean on the company to gain access, and I think it'd be difficult for hundreds of countries to conspire to obscure legal pressure. Finally Apple generally has little to gain from reading your data, unlike other tech giants with perverse incentives.

Of course this is all speculation, but I do trust imessages much more than I trust anything coming out of meta, and most of what comes out of google.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by Terr_ on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @01:43AM (#45177848)
> For instance, if someone shared something incriminating in a group chat and got arrested, and that info was only shared in the group chat, they'd have to silence everyone in that group chat to ensure that the channel still seemed secure.

Corrupt investigators can use parallel construction to pretend that the key breakthrough in the case was actually something legal.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by MangoToupe on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @06:57AM (#45180309)
See the sibling comment. The odds of nobody noticing still don't make any sense.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by const_cast on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @10:20AM (#45182315)
PRISM went undetected for a long, long time and it's essentially a wiretapping of the entire internet.

Clearly, you are underestimating the intelligence and capabilities of the US government. They have a lot of money. Like... A lot of money.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by MangoToupe on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @02:43PM (#45186635)
What do you think I based this analysis on?
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by sokoloff on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @05:16AM (#45179536)
> someone shared something incriminating in a group chat and got arrested, and that info was only shared in the group chat

“Only” is doing an incredible amount of work there.

Unless you concoct something incriminating solely for the purpose of testing this, the something incriminating being discussed in group chat previously happened in the real world. Ripples of information were created there and can be found (parallel construction).

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by MangoToupe on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @06:55AM (#45180294)
Right, but parallel construction only works if opsec fails. Good luck with repeating that feat forever. You clearly have far more faith in the FBI than I do. Now repeat this feat for every dumbass in intelligence in every country.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by sokoloff on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @07:30AM (#45180521)
My position doesn’t require a lot of faith in the FBI. If they fail in parallel construction, they always have the option to continue.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by MangoToupe on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @02:43PM (#45186630)
It requires faith that they prioritize keeping such abilities a secret rather than prosecuting, and again, I do not share this faith.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by somenameforme on Monday September 08, 2025 @10:48PM (#45176823)
It's possible for it to be a facade, but also real.

Apple is a part of PRISM so there's approximately a 100% chance that anything you send to Apple via message, cloud, or whatever else, gets sent onto the NSA and consequently any agency that wants it. But the entire mass data collection they are doing is probably unconstitutional and thus illegal. But anytime it gets challenged in courts it gets thrown out on a lack of standing - nobody can prove it was used against them, so they don't have the legal standing to sue.

And the reason this is, is because its usage is never acknowledged in court. Instead there is parallel construction. [1] For instance imagine the NSA finds out somebody is e.g. muling some drugs. They tip off the police and then the police find the car in question and create some reason to pull it over - perhaps it was 'driving recklessly.' They coincidentally find the cache of drugs after doing a search of the car because the driver was 'behaving erratically', and then this 'coincidence' is how the evidence is introduced into court.

----

So getting back to Apple they probably want to have their cake and eat it too. By giving the NSA et al all they want behind the scenes they maintain those positive relations (and compensatory $$$ from the government), but then by genuinely fighting its normalization (which would allow it to be directly introduced) in court, they implicitly lie to their users that they're keeping their data protected. So it's this sort of strange thing where it's a facade, but simultaneously also real.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @01:46AM (#45177878)
> the entire mass data collection they are doing is probably unconstitutional and thus illegal. But anytime it gets challenged in courts it gets thrown out on a lack of standing

It's kind of wild that this is the part of the deep state MAGA just forgot about.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by paulryanrogers on Monday September 08, 2025 @07:56PM (#45175687)
iMessage backups in the cloud are subject to warrants. Even if you don't use iCloud backups, can you be sure everyone you communicate with also abstains?
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by stingraycharles on Monday September 08, 2025 @08:04PM (#45175748)
Aren’t those encrypted with a key that lives on your device only?
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by ants_everywhere on Monday September 08, 2025 @08:14PM (#45175823)
how would you restore if you lost your device?
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by bri3d on Monday September 08, 2025 @09:02PM (#45176163)
Backups with Advanced Data Protection also enroll:

* Recovery Keys

* Recovery Contact (someone who holds your recovery key in key escrow)

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by ants_everywhere on Monday September 08, 2025 @11:04PM (#45176914)
right, the ability to recover implies keys exist outside the device. even if they gossip keys to other devices you control, there are lots of people with only a single apple device.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by bri3d on Monday September 08, 2025 @09:02PM (#45176168)
Only if you enable Advanced Data Protection, but in that case, yes, absolutely
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by rpdillon on Monday September 08, 2025 @06:46PM (#45175106)
Just don't back it up to iCloud!
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by yamazakiwi on Monday September 08, 2025 @06:50PM (#45175152)
Not able to get into it legally or without consequence, it is not infallible.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by another_twist on Monday September 08, 2025 @06:29PM (#45174908)
Curious, is there a poc somewhere demonstrating an attack like this ?
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by joaomacp on Monday September 08, 2025 @06:32PM (#45174955)
Sure:

  plain_msg = decrypt(encrypted_msg)
  send_to_nsa(plain_msg)
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by saagarjha on Monday September 08, 2025 @08:33PM (#45175972)
It is actually quite difficult.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by thewebguyd on Monday September 08, 2025 @06:58PM (#45175212)
Makes you wonder if Meta got one or more of those secret national security letters, or foreign equivalents.

Also makes me wonder about Google's change wrt android security patches - under the guise of "making it easier for OEMs" by moving to quarterly is actually just so that Paragon and other nation state spyware has access to the vulnerabilities for at least 4 months before they get patched.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by saagarjha on Monday September 08, 2025 @08:32PM (#45175966)
Ok, what do you suggest instead?
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by realz on Monday September 08, 2025 @08:36PM (#45176003)
I think Signal is the safest choice. If you want to be absolutely sure, host your own service, and hope you know how to make it have airtight security.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by dontlaugh on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @03:05PM (#45187086)
Signal got US state department funding, if you’re not American you should be sceptical.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by johnisgood on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @04:14AM (#45179034)
Ricochet (Refresh), Briar, Session, SimpleX, IRC with OTR, Matrix...

We have alternatives. Not all of them support all features you might want. It might lack stickers, for one, but it is not a huge deal to me. To many people, it actually is. :| Do not get me wrong, I use stickers on WhatsApp, but still.

If I am really paranoid, I would use Ricochet or my own self-hosted SimpleX onion service. If I am not so paranoid but still paranoid, I would use Matrix (e.g. Element). Ricochet still uses onion v2 services, that is why we have Ricochet Refresh with v3 but they have big dreams. They should really focus on the basics first.

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by dijit on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @03:20AM (#45178609)
> End to end encryption is useless if the "ends" are fully controlled by a (..) third party.

YES!

Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by sulandor on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @03:40AM (#45178745)
although e2ee does raise the cost for an attacker, the perceived gain in trustworthiness of the system is unjustified
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @04:14AM (#45179036)
E2EE is likely the reason why this supposedly includes "contact information, IP addresses and profile photos" and not message content.
Re:Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billi... by achrono on Tuesday September 09, 2025 @10:25AM (#45182379)
From the article:

> According to the 115-page complaint, Baig discovered through

> internal security testing that WhatsApp engineers could “move

> or steal user data” including contact information, IP addresses

> and profile photos “without detection or audit trail”.

That isn't really the breach you're making it out to be. Profile photos, unless made private/contacts only, are already publicly visible, and so is "contact information".

Of course these are useful to intelligence services, but this doesn't mean that Baig found they don't have true end-to-end encryption.