News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by glimshe on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @12:02PM (#45104882)
Sometimes I'm just happy to avoid the worst engineers. They do exist. Bad work ethic, poor foundational skills, hard to work with. I feel that if I can weed them out, I've done 75% of my job as a hiring manager.
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by foobarian on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @12:16PM (#45105086)
So much this. As I've been changing teams at my company (which by and large has awesome people) there is the occasional person in the team that just drags down the rest so much, they are probably a net negative. And it's such a breath of fresh air when the whole team is excellent.
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by j45 on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @12:25PM (#45105253)
So true. Anyone who isn't wanting to be a self-directed learner misses the essence of working and growing with technology.
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by pbronez on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @12:28PM (#45105302)
Yes, essential to protect the broader team from low performance and toxic colleagues. The trick is to get the disruptive folks off the team quickly without causing the productive folks to doubt their job security.

Clear communication and transparent accountability are the way.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by Centigonal on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @12:40PM (#45105508)
Reed Hastings and Erin Meyer talk about this right at the start of No Rules Rules. Netflix had to lay off a big chunk of of their staff because of a funding crunch early in their history. Despite the negative emotional toll that took on everyone, productivity actually improved.

The authors reference a Will Felps experiment[1] that showed that introducing just one pessimistic, lazy, or mean actor into a group of professionals cut the entire group's productivity by 30-40%.

As a result of this lesson, Netflix now only hires "A-players" and is pretty aggressive about letting go of "B-players" and "C-Players."

[1] https://www.thisamericanlife.org/370/transcript

This has been borne out in real-world observational studies, too: https://www.washington.edu/news/2007/02/12/rotten-to-the-cor...

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by hobs on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @01:06PM (#45105893)
I think the hard part to figure out is how to fire those people without causing a lot of unintended consequences. I have been through layoffs 6 times now, and what I have seen often times they are high up in the food chain with a lot of power, and lay offs are pretty random because they are not telegraphed to everyone so you lose good people.

The people in power circle the wagons around their preferred cliques, because they don't care about the business succeeding nearly as much as their buddies (because there's always the next job.)

Then often the folks are left to do more work with the same pay and the impression that a random draw occurred and they lucked out, nothing more. It really can sour previously hard working folks and have them become that employee that you then think you need to get rid of.

The truth is that most companies are not made of "only A-Players" and that its basically impossible to staff such a company, so you need to limit the damage anyone can do, create systems of checks and balances, reward brilliance and have clear objective levels of work people need to meet to keep their jobs.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by bluGill on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @01:26PM (#45106213)
Right, what you need are a, b, and c players- and no d or f players.
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by sokoloff on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @01:40PM (#45106437)
I think most significant sized operations are built and succeed or fail based on the quality and leadership of the B players. You just can't find enough A players to build an entire [large] company of them and hopefully the C players contribute in a steady, no-drama fashion, leaving the B players* as the differentiating aspect of your particular company.

* - and the focus/determination/consistency with which you part ways with the D and F players.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by mrandish on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @04:18PM (#45108444)
> You just can't find enough A players to build an entire [large] company of them

The corollary to this is that too many real super star players can hurt a large company, especially if they're too close to each other. They need to be spaced out and inserted into the right places at the key moments when there are critical challenges they are uniquely suited to solve. Super heroes generally make lousy mayors.

Super heroes are able to conquer insurmountable Cthulu-grade existential threats. But that often involves doing things you wouldn't normally do and can cause collateral damage. Fortunately, such threats are fairly rare. Of course, many people who use the term "A players" are really just referring to "good people" not true super stars.

A wise F500 CEO once told me there were only about 20 such super stars in his >10,000 person organization but he shared it more with a tone of "thank goodness there's only about 20 of them" because identifying them and getting them onto the right problems was a constant challenge. He didn't think the organization needed more of them, it just needed to better manage and direct the energies of ones it had - and by direct, he meant "direct it outward" on a massive, high-value problem - not inward laying waste to the day-to-day structures that keep the org running.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by questionableans on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @11:00PM (#45111846)
That’s an unusual definition of superstars. It sounds like you’re talking about very lopsided people who are experts at one thing?
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by Jensson on Wednesday September 03, 2025 @05:58AM (#45113979)
That is what people typically mean with superstar, a person exceptionally good at a thing. A superstar basketball player doesn't necessarily come with a good attitude, same with movie stars, they don't always deliver great results if they are unhappy with their role.

What do you think superstar means? That they are good at everything? Nobody is good at everything. A superstar programmer is probably not a superstar manager etc, not is he a superstar football player.

Also the more sought after you are the harder it is to stand bullshit, so generally superstars are more fickle than average workers. They don't get more irritated, they just don't hide it as much because they have less reasons to.

This means if your job involves a lot of bullshit then a superstar will likely perform worse than an average worker and will quit soon, since superstars tolerate less bullshit. That doesn't mean they are not a superstar, tolerating bullshit is generally not a part of being a superstar in most peoples definitions.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by VirusNewbie on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @01:09PM (#45105938)
Anecdotal comment here, Netflix had the best interview process of any company I’ve applied to in my ~20 year career.

Very challenging, but no tricky questions, it felt collaborative and low pressure (comparatively at least) and everyone seemed like someone I would enjoy as a coworker.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by alexchantavy on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @03:39PM (#45108028)
What kind of process was it?
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by VirusNewbie on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @05:02PM (#45109005)
Pretty typical big tech process, just done in a very good way.

I had an initial screening where I had to write some code, write a test case, run it, then discuss how i'd parallelize the algorithm (didn't have to write this part). The code wasn't tricky, but I was glad I had practiced writing code quickly as general interview prep.

After the screen was an algorithmic coding round, but it was enjoyable and nothing that couldn't have been solved with some basic data structures and recursion. The interviewer was talkative and was happy to brainstorm as I talked through my solution, it felt like pair programming where I was driving, not just me being watched while I coded.

Then I did two system design interviews and an "HR" type interview/culture fit one.

I also had a 'practical' coding interview that again was challenging but really just some basic data munging. They gave me some (simplified) data structures and a simple version of a problem Netflix has to deal with, then I had to rearrange the data to the right format.

Again, not tricky, but needed lots of thought, they made me run code, and I was glad I had done practice interviews.

Finally, I was scheduled to the final round of the senior manager team interview, but by then I had accepted an offer for a team I liked at Google.

Google also had a really nice interview process except it took 4x as long.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by Gud on Wednesday September 03, 2025 @12:26AM (#45112246)
Ironic considering Netflix content is mostly F-level junk these days.
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by pydry on Wednesday September 03, 2025 @04:22AM (#45113436)
Not really. The quality of engineering has little to do with the quality of content.

Their problem is that the quality of engineering started off being critical (who cares how good the content is if you get endless streaming failures?) and is now not so important.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by jonmc12 on Wednesday September 03, 2025 @05:22PM (#45120553)
Maybe an investment in "A-players" for streaming stifled cultural diversity and kept engineers from being able to innovate on novel media formats where they are losing engagement of the younger demographic to TikTok and other social media video formats.

The same corporate strategy and culture that hired "A-player" engineers for streaming is hiring "A-player" studios for content.

Defining A-players as such means you've set the rules of the game instead of building a culture of adaptive success criteria to meet customer opportunities. The label itself is a function of organizational ossification. This is the likely legacy of our tech giants; innovative in only one direction and not able to change fast enough to avoid becoming a brittle, mediocre institution over time.

As consumers, we can all feel this ossified mediocrity every day.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by tom_m on Thursday September 04, 2025 @12:27AM (#45123582)
I think this is an important distinction too. It's not skill level or how fast you can code something. It's attitude. How you work with others. How you communicate (at all? Because many people don't raise their hand for help or clarification like at all). How motivated you are to learn and grow. How well you follow a process. Etc.

That's what makes an A player. I manage a bunch of programmers and I'll always hire and keep those who want to be there and want to learn over those with "skill." In fact, I find many junior engineers who outperform senior engineers. All the time. Because they're present. They're there. They care. They're careful. They learn. They're dependable and accountable.

I know it may sound silly, but it's really true and I think a lot of people are surprised.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by osullivj on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @12:49PM (#45105651)
One consistent red flag I look for after the hire is a refusal to learn anything outside their own narrowly defined scope.
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by goopypoop on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @01:20PM (#45106099)
Do you mean outside their job description?
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by sokoloff on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @01:44PM (#45106506)
Most job descriptions contain some version of "other duties as assigned", IMO with good reason.

No job description can realistically capture every responsibility; this language helps prevent bad-faith disputes when new tasks or responsibilities arise that aren’t explicitly mentioned but are 5 millimeters away from those mentioned and entirely reasonable to be considered as in-scope for an existing employee.

Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by desolate_muffin on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @03:29PM (#45107898)
I think also it's the reality in most engineering roles that you will often have to pivot to new technologies, help out on unfamiliar projects using different technologies (e.g., work on the front-end for a bit when you're a backend engineer), etc. Some engineers aren't comfortable with this and it shows. This is how I understood the original comment, anyway.
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by Sammi on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @05:47PM (#45109530)
Anecdotally: People who aren't flexible about their job description are some of the worst people to work with. They always leave the tough unforeseen challenges to their colleagues to handle. Kinda the definition of "not a team player".
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by dehrmann on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:55AM (#45135098)
As an engineer, I had a job at a small company where I sat by the office phone, answered it sometimes, and had to get the door for deliveries. Not in my job description, but it needed to be done.
Re:You don't want to hire "the best engineers" by sokoloff on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @01:37PM (#45106385)
This is under-appreciated, very rarely talked about, and spot on!

I am personally guilty of being far too lenient and tolerant in overlooking "hard to work with". Bluntly, as an engineer, I enjoyed working with a few particular "brilliant assholes" (as their brilliance was often but their AH nature rarely directed at me) and so I tended to tolerate them too much when I transitioned into leadership roles. I don't know if that was biggest mistake as a leader, but it was for sure in the top five.