On the other hand, I could image some more narrow uses where an LLM could help.
For example, in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, there are different methods that are pretty prescriptive, like identifying cognitive distortions in negative thoughts. It's not too hard to imagine an app where you enter a negative thought on your own and exercise finding distortions in it, and a specifically trained LLM helps you find more distortions, or offer clearer/more convincing versions of thoughts that you entered yourself.
I don't have a WaPo subscription, so I cannot tell which of these two very different things have been banned.
It would still need a therapist to set you on the right track for independent work, and has huge disadvantages compared to the current state-of-the-art, a paper worksheet that you fill out with a pen.
Yes?
If you go looking to psychopaths and LLMs for empathy, you're touching a hot stove. At some point, you're going to get burned.
Expert system. You want an expert system. For example, a database mapping "what patients write" to "what patients need to hear", a fuzzy search tool with properly-chosen thresholding, and a conversational interface (repeats back to you, paraphrased – i.e., the match target –, and if you say "yes", provides the advice).
We've had the tech to do this for years. Maybe nobody had the idea, maybe they tried it and it didn't work, but training an LLM to even approach competence at this task would be way more effort than just making an expert system, and wouldn't work as well.
I can't imagine some therapists, especially remote only, aren't already just acting as a human interface to chatgtp as well.
Are you joking? Any medical professional caught doing this should lose their license.
I would be incensed if I was a patient in this situation, and would litigate. What you're describing is literal malpractice.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1xrNaTO1bI
and given price of proper therapy is skyrocketing.
The more you tell an AI not to obsess about a thing, the more they obsess about it. So trying to make a model that will never tell people to self harm is futile.
Though maybe we are just doing in wrong, and the self-filtering should be external filtering - one model to censor results that do not fit, and one to generate results with lighter self-censorship.
[1] https://futurism.com/former-ceo-uber-ai
[2] If you need /s here to be sure, perhaps it's time for some introspection
And frankly, it's not even clear to me that a human therapist is any better. Yeah, maybe the guard-rails are in place but I'm not convinced that if those are crossed it'd result in some sociately consequences. Let people explorer their mind and experience--at the end of the day, I suspect they'd be healthier for it.
A big point of therapy is helping the patient better ascertain reality and deal with it. Hopefully, the patient learns how to reckon with their mind better and deceive themselves less. But this requires an entity that actually exists in the world and can bear witness. LLMs, frankly, don’t deal with reality.
I’ll concede that LLMs can give people what they think therapy is about: lying on a couch unpacking what’s in their head. But this is not at all the same as actual therapeutic modalities. That requires another person that knows what they’re doing and can act as an outside observer with an interest in bettering the patient.
People were able to write about their feelings and experiences before the invention of a chat bot that tells you everything that you wrote is true. Like you could do that in notepad or on a piece of paper and it was free
They want to schedule something weekly. Cool, that's 800$ a month which the vast majority of people can't afford.
Medicare has a 1 year waiting list, and that's going away for a ton of people very soon.
The thing that stresses most people out is money. If money is so bountiful in your life 800$ isn't a lot then you're doing pretty good.
Where's a therapist when you're laid off, behind on rent and can't keep the lights on ?
That statement doesn't make any sense.
Water is still necessary for the body whether I can acquire it or not. Therapy, or any healthcare in general, is still useful whether or not you can afford it.
They are really paying $800 / month to have their feelings validated and receive a diagnosis that absolves them from taking ownership over their emotions and actions.
Remember, we're talking about a country where people skip insulin.
Back during my second eviction I had a friend listen to me whine on the phone for hours. That's a debt I can never repay, I definitely didn't have health insurance or a spare 800$ a month back then.
Or to flip this around, 800$ a month would be a fantastic treatment for most stressed out lower income people.
I really hate how therapy is promoted as some kind of miracle, when;
A) It's completely inaccessible to those who need it most.
B) Can actually make things significantly worse.
C) You probably just need to do less of whatever your doing.
But if slow down you might get fired. If you get fired you won't be able to afford 800$ a month!
Ah, I'm in the Netherlands. I didn't realise we were only talking about the US. I know the story is about Illinois but I thought the critique of therapy was intended to be broader.
It goes without saying that basic necessities like food and housing come first for health, mental and otherwise, I'm sorry that they're so uncertain in America.
Or the health insurance company will outright refuse to cover what your doctor prescribes so you need to materialize a spare 1000$.
Too sick to work, time to cut off your medicare because you failed the work requirements.
Even if you find a therapist that works, they can move out if your insurance network. Or you switch to a new job that offers different insurance your therapist can't accept.
I know during my second eviction I didn't have 800$ a month. So what use is it. Do only upper middle class people have problems worthy of consideration?
Here in The Netherlands people with less money can get access to therapy with assistance from the state. I've had to do it myself and it cost me around 300 euros per year to see 3 different providers for 3 kinds of therapy; the rest of the costs were covered by the state.
I wouldn't call it a magical utopia as it works via a system of mutual social support, not magic, but it does seem relatively utopic in comparison to what you describe.
My first reply was flagged for pointing out an unaffordable treatment has no real use.
I forgot this is a forum where 800$ a month is a trivial amount of money.
No snark intended. I've been to Europe a few times, as far as I'm concerned The Netherlands, Belgium, and the UK are essentially utopias.
Not having to play the health insurance game, significantly lower crime rates, actual worker rights. No place is perfect, but try being poor in America. Nothing is closer to hell.
It suggests that shared values may predict more positive outcomes, and therapists should develop ethical sensitivity regarding value conflict.
Many patients are encouraged to shop around for therapists and typically wind up with someone they are comfortable with whos value system aligns with theirs.
AKA a private echo chamber financially incentivized to cultivate recurring revenue via emotionally dependent patients.