News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by JCM9 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:18AM (#44592478)
For those around for the .com bust it does feel very similar. In both cases the tech is amazing and isn’t going away, but the business models of many/most companies “innovating” with the tech is simply unsustainable. A lot of “AI” currently looks like a dry forest waiting for lighting to strike and burn it to the ground. The latest round of PR puff from CEOs saying they’re doing layoffs because of AI (vs their poor performance or prior bad business decisions) is fueling the perception that the hype is a mile wide and a millimeter thick, just waiting for the moment when it all comes crashing down.

This is a longstanding predictable pattern in tech. Most of these “AI companies” will go bust or become a shell of their former self and sold off for parts. The tech will be commoditized and become pretty ubiquitous across the board but not a profit center in its own right.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by windexh8er on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:27AM (#44592541)
In most implementations of generative AI, as of today, the use case is as a feature. People don't buy features, they buy products. If your company is built solely on this hot button you better be sure you either have some IP backing it up, are building and own it (models), or are the best mouse trap for your target market. Because, I'm watching an entire industry segment all show up with slight iterations of the exact same thing and those things are not great. They're unreliable and mostly mediocre.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by nancyminusone on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:35AM (#44593240)
"Thank god <insert every service> added an AI chatbot to their site! It makes it much faster and easier to use!" - things no living soul has ever said
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by dinfinity on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:39AM (#44593943)
Actually, compared to the non-AI chatbots they are incredibly good.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Yizahi on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:36AM (#44594511)
Considering that the only purpose of chat-bots is to bullshit customers and filter out as much as they can before redirecting to the human support, then yeah - LLM chat-bots are good. Just not good for the the customers. I recently had to call my telco and they had a temerity to demand that I have(!) to speak to the fucking bot. And then bot declared it doesn't understand me and hang up the call. I have no idea if that bot was neural network powered, but the only improvements LLM bot may have achieved is to keep me in the hamster loop longer and delay transfering to the support even more.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Sharlin on Thursday July 17, 2025 @03:11PM (#44596992)
Compared to being tortured to death, merely being waterboarded is incredibly good.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by sheepscreek on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:48AM (#44593405)
Yes. But those feature companies are not IPO’d and listed on the exchanges. That is the key distinction with the markets this time. Most public companies in this space are actually growing their bottom lines. I’m not talking about just Nvidia here. You can see this effect in the entire food-chain. Everyone is benefitting.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by rented_mule on Thursday July 17, 2025 @02:40PM (#44596625)
I have inside knowledge (that I'm not trading on) of multiple publicly listed companies with "every feature is AI powered or it doesn't ship" policies that are being applied to their entire product or major parts of their product. Those policies come from execs who are primarily informed by science fiction and FOMO, not by an understanding of the available tools.

AI is great when it's the right tool. But the rate at which features are shipping at these companies is plummeting because so many features would be cheaper, easier, and better without AI. It feels like self-gaslighting on a scale that I haven't seen since the dot com days. And I see engineers and their managers struggling to maintain their sanity as they try to improve their products within the constraints of these policies.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Sharlin on Thursday July 17, 2025 @03:14PM (#44597014)
So… where is the money coming from? Where is the value added?
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Workaccount2 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:28AM (#44592557)
CEOs are doing layoffs because Elon dumped 80% of Twitter staff and it didn't collapse.

Those layoffs were a make or break moment for tech.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by sealeck on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:43AM (#44593338)
> Elon dumped 80% of Twitter staff and it didn't collapse.

Have you looked at a graph of Twitter revenue and profit recently (hint: it is very low). Nobody has ever claimed that you cannot fire all the employees and keep Twitter online with a skeleton crew; the claim has always been that you can't do that _and remain a viable business_.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Workaccount2 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:49AM (#44593412)
Twitter is now a private company and doesn't share financial numbers. The only insight we have is that the banks that were stuck with the debt from the purchase (the banks who loaned Elon money) were recently able to find buyers for that debt. That is not a sign of bad financial health or diminishing value.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by sealeck on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:07AM (#44593616)
Have you considered why investors were bidding something like 60 cents on the dollar right until Trump's election? (Hint: because Elon has been using the US government to press companies into buying his ad product, despite the fact that it is materially worse than Google or Facebook's).

> The only insight we have

This is untrue. There's fairly credible reporting (e.g. in the FT) that Twitter's reveue numbers have bottomed and they are not making money. Of course, a lot of these problems are being disguised by the fact that Elon Musk has merged in xAI (and investors are very happy to pile money into AI without even the slightest due diligence).

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by ekianjo on Thursday July 17, 2025 @12:02PM (#44594819)
credible reporting based on what exactly?
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by sealeck on Thursday July 17, 2025 @02:19PM (#44596387)
Credible reporting based on what institutions the banks have tried to offload the Twitter debt to have said.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by furyofantares on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:35AM (#44593896)
> Nobody has ever claimed that you cannot fire all the employees and keep Twitter online with a skeleton crew

Lots of people claimed that, it was a common claim, even on HN, which was odd to me because I felt it had been common for 10 years on HN to wonder what the heck these companies are doing with 80% of their employees.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by dgfitz on Thursday July 17, 2025 @12:29PM (#44595099)
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by AIPedant on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:47AM (#44593375)
It didn't "collapse" but it lost a ton of users and stopped being a public service where anyone could freely read most tweets. The load on Twitter's servers and the scope of its services have gone down dramatically, and it's childish to conclude "Twitter was overstaffed." Musk made Twitter into a much smaller service.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by apercu on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:01AM (#44592897)
I don’t think most (non social companies) were as overstaffed as twitter because most companies have valuations based on revenue/profit rather than “it’s internet/social so 1000x”. Many “traditional” companies have been running leaner since the 90s and can’t function at all with even a 25% headcount reduction.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by dreamcompiler on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:37AM (#44592645)
It didn't collapse in the sense of ceasing to exist. It did collapse as a place where decent human beings cared to gather, and it lost over 75% of its market value.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by lenkite on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:47AM (#44593380)
> it lost over 75% of its market value.

No longer true. In March 2025, X Corp. was acquired by xAI, Musk's artificial intelligence company. The deal, an all-stock transaction, valued X at $33 billion, with a full valuation of $45 billion when factoring in $12 billion in debt.

Investor sentiment through secondary share trades still prices the company at $44 billion.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:53AM (#44593457)
Well sure, but that was an inter-party transaction so basically valuations are irrelevant (unless they get sued, which probably won't happen unless the AI stuff collapses).

To be fair, the banks did offload the debt at par (two years later) so some people think X/Twitter is worth some money.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by ern_ave on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:59AM (#44592877)
> it lost over 75% of its market value

I'm not sure what you mean by this. Twitter went private. It's no longer "on the market." Its market value is $0.

> It did collapse as a place where decent human beings cared to gather

That's your personal opinion, and though you're welcome to it, I think it's heavily colored by your personal politics, and doesn't reflect reality.

Before its purchase by Musk, Twitter was absolutely full of speech that I personally consider bad ...but apparently you think is okay.

I consider every tweet in this image[1] to be pretty bad. Most of them are by verified accounts. None of them were banned. And apparently you thought this was okay, and that these were """decent human beings"""

[1] https://i.imgur.com/802gCWz.jpeg

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by epistasis on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:17AM (#44593079)
You are the one bringing politics into this, not the comment that you are falsely accusing of being politically motivated, with some sort of "free speech" nonsense and an image that has been filled with so many tweets that it's not even legible. Even collecting that image is odd and strange and shows highly politically motivated behavior on your part!

Twitter's valuation with investors was based on the idea of heavy growth. It wasn't even profitable when purchased, and when it did make a profit, it was on the order of $1B/year, nothing that would validate it's market cap.

Musk squashed all potential for growth. Twitter advertisers, users, and the hope of a brighter future are all gone now. A well-established brand has been abandoned for an amorphous X, on which it's pretty much impossible to establish a new brand.

Musk has destroyed so value much from Twitter with bone-headed moves that if he had to answer to investors, he'd be out in a second.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by blockmarker on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:47AM (#44593384)
>Even collecting that image is odd and strange and shows highly politically motivated behavior on your part!

"If you care about what I say you are weird, and you care because you are an evil person". The first comment was obviously political, pretending otherwise is only because you are disingenuous, or because you are so polarized that you are unable to understand that your beliefs are politics and not universally accepted facts. You can zoom on the image and see the tweets. These are tweets from verified people before Musk, which were people that Twitter employees personally verified and thought deserved a recognition. Tell me, do you think "Kill all the White People!" and "white genocide is good", are things that good people say?

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by epistasis on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:27AM (#44593831)
> You can zoom on the image and see the tweets.

No, I literally can not. The interface of imgur does not allow zooming in to see what is in the Tweets! Collecting that many tweets into such a massive image is the behavior of a crazy person, likely motivated by crazy politics. I do not know what's in the Tweets that's supposed to be objectionable, but the obsessive collection of stuff like that, and spending the time to create such an unreadable way.

> "If you care about what I say you are weird, and you care because you are an evil person"

Who are you quoting? Who brought evil into this? Very weird thing to start your comment with, what is your point?

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by blockmarker on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:27AM (#44594403)
>It did collapse as a place where decent human beings cared to gather

If it's no longer fit for decent humans, the meaning is that only evil people stay there. You understand this, you only pretend not to.

>the behavior of a crazy person, likely motivated by crazy politics. >Very weird thing

You don't even bother to refute the argument, you only insult.

>No, I literally can not. The interface of imgur does not allow zooming in to see what is in the Tweets!

I zoomed on pc, Firefox, and just did it too on my smartphone, Firefox. Your argument now depends on outright lies.

But I also quoted two tweets for your benefit, both allowed and enabled by Old Twitter.

Does a decent human being say "Kill all the White People!" and "genocide white people"? Yes or no.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by 123yawaworht456 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @12:20PM (#44594999)
>No, I literally can not. The interface of imgur does not allow zooming in to see what is in the Tweets!

https://i.imgur.com/agUcw7R.png

here's a similar compilation of verified "decent human beings", in much higher resolution.

and before you try cop out again by saying "imgur does not allow zooming": right click > open image in new tab > ctrl+wheel up to zoom in, arrows to scroll ;)

>Collecting that many tweets into such a massive image is the behavior of a crazy person, likely motivated by crazy politics.

literally "stop noticing things!", lmao

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by ern_ave on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:06AM (#44593608)
In my opinion, if I had said anything that you could demonstrate to be false, you would quote what I said and present an explanation for why it's false. I believe you're not doing that because you cannot do it.

> You are the one bringing politics into this

No, that's not true. The person I responded to characterized the old, pre-musk twitter as "a place where decent human beings cared to gather" and contrasted that with the current twitter.

What possible non-political interpretation of that viewpoint is there? He is clearly saying that when twitter was run by people on the political-left, and (for example) Trump was banned, that was "decent human beings."

My rebuttal is to show a large list of verified accounts making hateful statements. My point is, those statements were allowed under pre-musk twitter. Hate was allowed before, and it's allowed now.

The only difference is that the person I responded to finds the former brand of it acceptable.

Which part of this analysis is incorrect?

> Even collecting that image is odd and strange

It's odd and strange to pretend that you believe I personally collected those examples. You're well aware of how the internet works. You know that someone else created that image.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by DonHopkins on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:07AM (#44594207)
Of course pre-Musk twitter had horrible people posting to it, just like Hacker News has horrible people like you posting to it. But dang doesn't fancy himself MechaHitler and post antisemitic white supremacist hate speech, or donate hundreds of millions of dollars to elect somebody he knows is a pedophile.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by ern_ave on Thursday July 17, 2025 @03:45PM (#44597365)
> horrible people like you posting to it.

I challenge you to quote anything I've said that you can argue constitutes a "horrible person"

Why do you believe things that you cannot defend?

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by DonHopkins on Thursday July 17, 2025 @06:14PM (#44598865)
If you're not a horrible person, then why are you too embarrassed to post under your real name or at least your normal account, and why are you carrying the water for fascists?
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by brookst on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:16AM (#44593067)
Private companies have valuations. Your can pedant on whether it’s appropriate to use the word “market”, but the fact is pretty well known.

Musk paid $44B and it is generally considered to be worth less than $10B today[1], though his open participation in political corruption has resulted in valuations all over the map, including $44B[2].

It’s kind of Schroedinger’s valuation; if he and Trump are having a spat it’s worth less because there’s a risk Trump orders it shut down or seized or whatever, if he and Trump make up the company is a a part of the ruling party’s government apparatus.

But as far as actual product value, outside of a clubhouse for red hats, it’s pretty close to zero. They have to literally sue companies to force them to advertise[3], which would be laughable if creeping fascism wasn’t so bad that it’s actually a successful strategy. Any attempt to claim free speech high ground while suing companies for declining to advertise is incredibly disingenuous.

1. https://www.theverge.com/2024/9/30/24258129/musks-44-billion...

2. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/mar/19/value-elo...

3. https://www.npr.org/2025/02/01/nx-s1-5283271/elon-musk-lawsu...

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by ekianjo on Thursday July 17, 2025 @12:07PM (#44594864)
> Private companies have valuations

and they are usually massively off.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by DonHopkins on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:23AM (#44593132)
If you think someone's personal politics of not liking fascists and white supremacists and companies run by and platforming them don't reflect reality, I'd hate to know what your personal politics are.

You created your account just to post that, so you obviously don't want your real name associated with your own personal politics, which is understandable, but cowardly, and undermines the nakedly partisan political points you're trying to score by carrying the water for fascists. How about finding some personal politics to believe that you're not embarrassed to put your real name by?

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by ern_ave on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:55AM (#44593475)
> you think someone's personal politics of not liking fascists and white supremacists and companies run by and platforming them don't reflect reality

No, I'm sorry. That's not true. You have misunderstood the comment you replied to.

Should I explain it or would you prefer to figure it out for yourself?

Hint: the guy I replied to said, in essence, "it used to be a place for descent people, but now it's not" ...and I showed a large list of verified users being bad. Conclusion: his position doesn't reflect reality.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by DonHopkins on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:59AM (#44594139)
So what's your real name if you're not ashamed to have it associated with your pro fascist white supremacist politics, water carrying, and apologetics, Mr. Single Use Throwaway Worthless Opinion Green Account Who Will Never Post Again Because You Just Wanted To Bring Politics Into Hacker News Then Run Away?
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by 123yawaworht456 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @03:47PM (#44597394)
YWNBAW
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by nancyminusone on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:40AM (#44593288)
I think you'll find Twitter to be completely dead to many more people than it was in 2021.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by ponector on Thursday July 17, 2025 @04:32PM (#44597852)
You can say the same about Facebook, but they had small layoff.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by graemep on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:49AM (#44592781)
> Elon dumped 80% of Twitter staff and it didn't collapse.

That was because Twitter was massively overstaffed. Are all these other businesses also overstaffed? The result of cheap money? Are they all atu

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by bentt on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:00AM (#44592892)
They are all overstaffed because they were financially incentivized to overstaff, both for valuation and defensive talent hoarding reasons. This was a positive feedback loop which unwound in tech and will unwind in AI too.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by c16 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:24AM (#44593133)
Definitely feels like since AI there's been a shift and it's gone from total head count as a measure of success to revenue per employee as a measure of success. The fewer employees the better.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by bentt on Thursday July 17, 2025 @12:16PM (#44594964)
Probably because they need to burn all their investment money on compute.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by surgical_fire on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:35PM (#44595881)
> The fewer employees the better.

This has always been true for any mature companies.

The conundrum is that tech companies in particular are really averse to be perceived as mature companies, because their valuations have to be more grounded in reality.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by moomin on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:24AM (#44593144)
The thing is, you need those staff to implement expansion plans. Twitter, famously, didn’t make the kind of money people expected a site with that many loyal users to make. Give up on your ambitions and you can lose people. Meta did the same thing.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by FirmwareBurner on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:06AM (#44592939)
>That was because Twitter was massively overstaffed.

What's the proof it was the only tech company being overstaffed?

For example Meta doubled its headcount during the pandemic without any increase in market share or new products. How do you explain that not being overstaffed?

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by xnx on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:19AM (#44593091)
> For example Meta doubled its headcount during the pandemic without any increase in market share or new products.

Meta probably overhired, but if the overall market grows immensely due to even more commerce moving online because of the pandemic, it would make sense to hire a lot more people even without a change in market share or new products.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by graemep on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:08AM (#44592975)
I think it very likely a lot of big tech companies are overstaffed. However a lot of companies in many industries are cutting back.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by FirmwareBurner on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:33AM (#44593219)
That's what I said.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by gatinsama on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:45AM (#44592730)
Exactly this. Everyone else is doing what everyone else does. There's no direct relationship between AI adoption and layoffs, except for inflated board/CEO expectations.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by moomin on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:22AM (#44593123)
He definitely started a trend, but the takeaway was a mess. The company makes less money, the technology/UX is objectively getting worse. Yes, some parts of the audience have proven sticky, but I don’t think that was ever a huge revelation. It’s always been possible to take some seeds off the bun.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Traubenfuchs on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:04AM (#44592917)
What were all those people doing all day long?
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by kalleboo on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:03AM (#44593567)
Twitter was a whole media company. They had staff in every country writing news summaries for trending hash tags, etc.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by FirmwareBurner on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:08AM (#44592976)
Search on youtube "A day in the life of a Twitter/$FAANG employee".
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by junga on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:00AM (#44593529)
Did so. According to Josh and Katie most of the day was spent eating.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by carlosjobim on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:22PM (#44595718)
Planning their holidays, their kid's birth day parties and who's going to pick up the ice cream for the barbecue with the aunts and uncles, planning the kitchen renovation or house renovation, negotiating with the realtor for their investment property they are buying to rent out on AirBnB, buying cool stuff on Amazon and buying some cute clothes on Temu, planning a fishing trip or skiing trip, raging on social media against fascist who are oppressing them, arguing with lawyers over inheritance, complaining about their boss, thinking about what they're going to have for lunch.

Only complete idiots actually work for a living in this day and age. A job is first and foremost a tool to get approved for a nice/nicer mortgage so that you can focus on your real career which is getting rich from real estate appreciation. Secondly a job is a tool for getting exposed to the right people so you can get an even better job and thus an even nicer mortgage. You can't waste your time at the office by actually working.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by nyarlathotep_ on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:43PM (#44595979)
This is a juvenile take that seems brash but ironically I can't disagree with at this point in my life. Well played.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by nyarlathotep_ on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:41PM (#44595964)
I'm the first to attack "useless busywork" employees, but my experience at a large, uh, software firm at this time was there were loads of "promo doc"/pet projects going on.

There were plenty of people working very hard on things that had no path to profitability/utility (beyond the attempt to get higher-ups promoted for "showing impact" or "ownership") or whatever. This was paired with incentives at this time for managers to have more underlings.

I have no idea of the ratio of this to "day in the life" TikToks, but there were lots of people working on things that had no utility or time horizon to be "valuable" in the business sense.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by mock-possum on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:56AM (#44592847)
Are you still using twitter?
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by exe34 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:40AM (#44592669)
Twitter produced mechahitler and didn't collapse. I don't like this timeline.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by surgical_fire on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:28PM (#44595803)
> CEOs are doing layoffs because Elon dumped 80% of Twitter staff and it didn't collapse.

Anyone that ever worked in a sufficiently large tech company knows that it can keep the lights on with a skeleton crew. It doesn't mean the results will be good or desirable, but it can be done.

Over time cracks will start to show. New featurs are seldom delivered and half-assed. Bugs will take a long time to fix or just become part of the landscape. That sort of thing.

Twitter is a special case that Musk did not buy it to make it into a profitable company, or to make it more valuable, or to improve it in any way. He just bought it because he wanted to rid it of the "woke mind virus" (and factually tried to get out of the deal and was sued into actually buying it).

CEOs are doing layoffs for a variety of reasons, but mostly to improve profits by reducing costs. These cycles happen, and what it actually points to is that those companies are not seeing a viable path for growth at the moment that justifies their valuation. Layoffs with some vague gestures towards AI is a good smokescreen for the time being.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by weinzierl on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:40AM (#44592675)
"For those around for the .com bust it does feel very similar."

I was around for the .com boom and it feels very different. I experienced the boom as exuberant without limits, the current situation is much more nuanced.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by apercu on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:58AM (#44592864)
I was around as well and while tech financing is more sophisticated and mainstream, it feels like a similar cliff in regards to valuations - what are some of the nuances you see that separate these too time periods?
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by noosphr on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:42AM (#44593313)
My grandmother wasn't using altavista in 2000. She is using chatgpt in 2025.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by arevno on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:41AM (#44593307)
I was also around, and I concur.

NVDA has a P/E of 55, which is definitely elevated, but nowhere near the 230+ that CSCO had at that time. TO say nothing of SUNW.

The big AI labs are definitely losing money, but they're doing it on the back of tens of (rapidly growing) billions of dollars in ARR, versus the dot com e-commerce and portal flameouts who would go public on (maybe) a million in revenue, at best.

We also have large AI teams at FAANG who are being funded directly by the fat margins of these companies, whose funding is not dependent on the whims of VC, PE or public markets.

These times are not really comparable.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by potatototoo99 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:46AM (#44593363)
Tesla's P/E is at 177.04, a lot of other AI companies are private so we can't really say.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by kasey_junk on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:53AM (#44593453)
Teslas pe imbalance long predates the ai cycle so is not relevant.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by AIPedant on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:44AM (#44593340)
I don't think Mark Zuckerberg salivating about data centers bigger than Manhattan is "nuanced." People gleefully predicting a 30% increase in national energy consumption strikes me as pretty darn exuberant.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by pjmlp on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:32AM (#44593210)
I did as well, and then we had a few layoff rounds after having "positive" results when the VC money dried out, and those that stayed like myself, had several months of delayed salaries.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Applejinx on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:03AM (#44592908)
Maybe you were in the handbasket for the .com boom, and more of an outsider this time around?
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by weinzierl on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:17AM (#44593075)
I am certainly much older now;-)

So my question to the youngsters in the handbasket:

Do you feel pure and completely untroubled for being part of something big that is certainly not going away anymore? Do you look into your future and see bright skies without the slightest hint of a cloud?

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by chrisweekly on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:55AM (#44593466)
The .com bubble casualties were companies acting like "the internet means we don't need a viable business model". I see echoes of that in today's "AI means we don't need (m)any human experts anymore, now everyone is a 10x engineer".

Unless it's leveraged by skilled experts, AI-generated code is the payday loan / high-interest credit card of tech debt.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Sharlin on Thursday July 17, 2025 @03:20PM (#44597096)
"The AI means we don't need a viable business model" seems to describe the current reality quite closely.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by pfisherman on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:11AM (#44593660)
I was around for the dot com boom and bust, and this does not feel similar. The issue with the internet was that much of the value came from network effects that were not there in the late 90s and early aughts when personal computing was desktop boxes with 56k dial up connections. Very much, “if you build it, they will come.” It was the mass rollout of cable modems and then smart phones that changed the math.

There is no cart before the horse here. AI is coming for you, not the other way around. The pessimistic takes are underestimating the impact by at least a couple orders of magnitude. Think smart phones as a lower bound.

I have no idea what capacity people here work with AI, but given my view and experience the pessimistic takes I commonly see on here do not seem realistic.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by ZephyrBlu on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:25AM (#44593811)
Smartphones as a lower bound is crazy
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by pfisherman on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:44AM (#44593989)
Karpathy’s talk about computing 3.0 was spot on. Look at what is going on with pydantic and langchain. “LLM programming” is about to be a thing.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Yizahi on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:42AM (#44594579)
Wait, there was computing 2.0? Damn, I missed whole revolution again...
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by danaris on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:27AM (#44593827)
I would say exactly the opposite, frankly.

With the internet, there was a clear value proposition for the vast majority of use cases. Even if some of the specific businesses were poorly-conceived or overly optimistic, the underlying technology was very obviously a) growing organically, b) going to be something everyone used & wanted, and c) a commodity.

All three of those parts are vital for a massive boom like that.

Generative AI is growing some, yes, but a lot of the growth is being pushed by the companies creating or otherwise massively invested in gen-AI. And yes, many people try out ChatGPT's webapp, but that's mostly a gimmick—and frankly, many of the cases where people are attempting to use it for more are fairly awful cautionary tales (eg, the people trying to use it as a therapist, and instead getting a cheerleader that confirms their worst impulses).

Gen-AI may be useful to some people, but it's not going to be a central feature of most people's lives—at least not in the forms it exists in today, or what can be clearly extrapolated from them. Yes, it can help some with coding—with mixed results—but not everyone's a programmer. Not everyone's even an office worker. The internet has obvious useful applications for a plumber or a lawyer; if I hired one of those and they said they were using generative AI to help them in their work, I'd fire them instantly. There are already a bunch of (both amusing and harrowing) stories of lawyers getting reamed out in court for using gen-AI to help them write legal filings.

OpenAI may or may not have a robust moat—I've seen people arguing both ways; personally I suspect lean slightly toward the "not" side—but generative AI as a whole is not something that's an interchangeable commodity the way internet access, or even hosting, is. First of all, in order to use the models that are touted as being advanced enough to actually look like more than spicy autocorrect, you need a serious GPU farm. Second of all, AFAIK, those models are being kept private by the big players like Google and OpenAI. That means that if you build your business on generative AI, unless you're able to both fork out for a massive hardware investment and do your own training to match what the big boys are already doing, you're going to be 100% dependent on another specific for-profit company for your entire business model. That's not a sound business decision, especially during this time where both the technology and the legal aspect of generative AI are still so much in flux.

Generative AI may be here to stay, but it's not going to take over the world the way the internet did.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by pfisherman on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:41AM (#44593962)
Hindsight is 20/20. The company I worked at went under because people questioned whether enough people would ever buy stuff over the internet to make the business viable. It was very much not obvious then.

> Gen-AI may be useful to some people, but it's not going to be a central feature of most people's lives—at least not in the forms it exists in today, or what can be clearly extrapolated from them…

The problem is that you are going to have to compete with people who are using AI. There is a learning curve, and some people are better at using it than others. Some people know how to use it really well.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by dgfitz on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:04PM (#44595519)
> There is a learning curve, and some people are better at using it than others. Some people know how to use it really well.

It's just google-fu 2.0. It isn't hard at all. There isn't really a trick to it. I daresay learning google-fu was harder.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by surgical_fire on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:18PM (#44595666)
> The problem is that you are going to have to compete with people who are using AI.

This doesn't sound as much of a game changer as you seem to think.

Generative AI is a productivity tool, that can help (to an extent) in certain professional settings. It's usage will never be as ubiquitous as the internet (unless you want to build an economy out of users generating memes using AI).

While I find it somewhat useful (although pretty far of how hyped it is) the economics of it are still super unclear. Right now companies are willing to dump money into this because it is fashionable with the investor class, but I don't know how long it will take for it to lose steam.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by bwfan123 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:44AM (#44593988)
- internet & ecommerce & online changed the way we shopped.

- smartphones in every pocket changed behaviors around entertainment, communication, and commerce

what behaviors of people will gen-ai change ? perhaps the way we learn (instead of google, we head over to a chatbot), perhaps coding .. all up in the air, and unclear at the moment.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by arbitrary_name on Thursday July 17, 2025 @02:58PM (#44596821)
I know lawyers using it, plumbers using it. My sweet little ol grandma uses it. I depend on it as an office worker.

My belief is that it is similarly transformative as the Internet. The bubble will burst, some use cars will never materialize, others will emerge as costs come down, and as value chains adapt.

Your belief is opposite to mine. Time will tell who is right.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by npalli on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:34AM (#44593889)
>For those around for the .com bust it does feel very similar.

Not it doesn't. I was around and we didn't have an entire group of GenX gang warning about the .com crash everywhere, everytime. Compared to nonsense metrics like eyeballs, this time we have real revenue and the biggest companies are tech. It might end in some crash but nothing like the .com one.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by 4b11b4 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:07AM (#44594215)
I keep coming back to this thought that the ability for computation itself sets the stage for speculation.. or rather, widely available and cheap computation.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by xnx on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:24AM (#44593143)
It's interesting how both of those period have their tech stock flagship. dotcom: Cisco ai: Nvidia
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by chii on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:28AM (#44593172)
on the other hand, it's easier to "copy" telecommunications equipment than state of the art chips. Not saying there won't be competitions to nvidia's dominance, but so far, not a pip from anyone (realistically that is).
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by xnx on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:30AM (#44593847)
> Not saying there won't be competitions to nvidia's dominance, but so far, not a pip from anyone (realistically that is).

It's so surprising. So much money at stake and there is zero competition for hardware purchase. Google's Tensor chips are excellent, but can only be rented.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by esafak on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:29AM (#44593184)
I think Cisco imploded because people moved to the cloud. But even cloud providers are stuck with nvidia; they have a software moat.

Curiously, nvidia's P/E ratio is lower than it was two years ago!

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by high_na_euv on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:17AM (#44593719)
Cloud is 2010+ thing
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by ParanoidShroom on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:42AM (#44593310)
Do you think FANG companies inflate AI on purpose in order to create a scenario for a bust to happen, they can survive it given their vast warchest of cash
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by Spooky23 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:45AM (#44593354)
It’s one of those scenarios where the high level value prop is obvious and compelling, just like the dotcom bubble.

80% of the hype is about 20% of the bullshit. And the bullshit attracts 80% of the dollars. The current cohort of leaders are Jedi at separating sovereign wealth and markets from their treasure.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by jstummbillig on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:59AM (#44592875)
Disagree, because the very few very big AI players are (in contrast to the 90s) very solid. Yes, there is a breadth of absolute bullshit built on top of current AI, but if it were only ChatGPT-alikes and LLMs for coding from here on out, that in itself is enough real value, that requires very little imagination, a lot of implementation and there's more demand than can easily be satisfied right now for both.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by dontlaugh on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:32AM (#44593206)
You can’t be serious, surely?

Most of the LLM applications are either entirely useless or trivially reproduced with much simpler free models (or even entirely non-“AI” methods).

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by petesergeant on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:12AM (#44593016)
I’m an AI enthusiast, and it’s not clear to me that selling inference to a prop model is a winning business model, which is what Anthropic and OpenAI are doing. The open models are good enough today for many things, and are likely to only get better. Feels like inference is a commodity, and not clear how much money there is in it.

I would love to know how much of the inference I pay for is being paid for by VC cash: I suspect a lot of it.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by jstummbillig on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:22AM (#44593125)
To be fair though though, the "open" models are fairly sketchy as well, from a business standpoint, because somebody is paying for a lot of GPUs and expensive talent. It's probably the least obviously sustainable open source product of all time, and it's not at all clear to me why that would change going forward.

Right now there seem to be roughly two paths, when it comes to frontier-level LLMs: Meta just not giving a fuck, spending instagram money and pretending it's a business, and whatever Deepseek is doing that might make it both good and also super cost-effective (and there it's even less clear, how much of it is real and what the actual costs are).

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by xnx on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:21AM (#44593110)
> I would love to know how much of the inference I pay for is being paid for by VC cash: I suspect a lot of it.

Definitely a lot of VC subsidies for OpenAI and Anthropic, none for Google.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by petesergeant on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:07AM (#44594211)
Sure, that doesn’t mean we’re not getting subsidised tokens from Google though
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by optimlayer on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:49AM (#44593414)
yeah, most of it
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by digitcatphd on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:47AM (#44592758)
If I’m not mistaken they are using high valuations of top companies to conclude AI is overhyped?

Sorry, but weren’t these valuations escalated because of low interest rates and quantitative easing? Perhaps combined with increased concentration in Top 10 by investors navigating uncertainty?

Typical BS coming from a mega fund only supported by management fees. not saying AI isn’t hyped but this is laughable.

Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by thunky on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:58AM (#44592870)
Exactly. Their chart even shows that these companies were more overvalued in 2020, before the AI "bubble" even started.
Re:The AI bubble today is bigger than the IT bubble in the 1... by zcw100 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:08PM (#44595565)
Some of the most valuable companies in the world right now are remnants of the dot com crash, Facebook (Meta), Google, Microsoft, Oracle, etc. By this logic the "AI companies" will go bust and coalesce into a few winners who will go on to become the worlds first multi trillion dollar companies and dominate the economic landscape for the next couple of decades.